Meteor over Moscow

That's a huge upgrade in size.

An earlier report said only 10 tons and 2 meters across. Looks like that was off by a factor of 1,000. Wow.

Still, the one that missed us was 13 times bigger yet: 130,000 tons and 50 meters across.

I'm glad this didn't happen during the cold war, say, during the Cuban missile crisis.
Offhand, can anyone give a plausible account of what would have been the effect, if it had been the larger one that struck the Ural region?
 
Offhand, can anyone give a plausible account of what would have been the effect, if it had been the larger one that struck the Ural region?

I can't give you an account but if the one that hit was half a megaton and the other was 13 times more .....then the damage a 6 megaton nuclear device would do.
The Hiroshima explosion was 12 ± 1 kilotons and the Nagasaki explosion was 22 ± 2 kilotons.

Russian Meteor Blast Bigger Than Thought, NASA Says | Space.com
►►
www.space.com/19838-russian-meteor-blast-bigger-siz...
14 hours ago
The energy estimate was later increased to 470 kilotons. Map of the Russian meteor explosion of Feb. 15 ...

serious amount of blast damage in BOTH cases.

Now that assumes a similar speed which I have no idea about. Do we even know the incoming velocity yet?
 
I meant the near miss asteroid. The yield was already in on the meteor. To get a proper comparison would need the velocity of the asteroid as well as the mass but thanks for that info.
 
I meant the near miss asteroid. The yield was already in on the meteor. To get a proper comparison would need the velocity of the asteroid as well as the mass but thanks for that info.

http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2013/02/15/asteroid-2012-da14-passes-by-earth_n_2697559.html

An 150-metre wide asteroid has passed by Earth just 27,700km (17,200 miles) closer than many communication satellites, and just one tenth the distance between the Moon and Earth.

The flyby of 2012 DA14 was the closest-ever approach to Earth by an object this large, passing at 18,641 mph, eight times the speed of a bullet.

Not sure how reliable these numbers are though. I read elsewhere that the asteroid 2012 DA14 was 50 meters wide, not 150.
 
Something occurs to me as a possible reason why nobody saw the Russia meteor coming:

Since it was headed directly toward Earth, it would be hard to see it moving against the background. Also it was smaller than the other one, but usually these things are discovered because they move relative to the stars, but something coming straight at us would not move relative to the background.
 
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2013/02/15/asteroid-2012-da14-passes-by-earth_n_2697559.html


Quote:
An 150-metre wide asteroid has passed by Earth just 27,700km (17,200 miles) closer than many communication satellites, and just one tenth the distance between the Moon and Earth.
Not sure how reliable these numbers are though. I read elsewhere that the asteroid 2012 DA14 was 50 meters wide, not 150.

I think they meant 150 feet. Everyone was calling it as big as half a football field.
 
Last edited:
NASA's update on the Russian meteor from the Space.Com link.

The reference to "infrasound stations" in Alaska was new to me. No word of seismic readings yet though. I read also that the burst at 15 to 20 miles altitude essentially lessened the impact of the explosion, as the atmosphere absorbed most of the energy. If I remember correctly, the ideal air burst altitude, for nuclear devices, is around 10,000 feet for most efficient devastation of ground structures. Also, there were several reports of intense warmth from the infrared component of the explosion, nothing near what Hiroshima victims experienced even though this burst was equivalent to 500 kilotons of TNT, much greater than the early atom bombs. It is likely that the nuclear events create much higher temperatures, I would think.


But late Friday, NASA revised its estimates on the size and power of the devastating meteor explosion. The meteor's size is now thought to be slightly larger — about 55 feet (17 m) wide — with the power of the blast estimate of about 500 kilotons, 30 kilotons higher than before, NASA officials said in a statement. [See video of the intense meteor explosion]


The meteor was also substantially more massive than thought as well. Initial estimated pegged the space rock's mass at about 7,000 tons. Scientists at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, Calif., now say the meteor weighed about 10,000 tons and was travelling 40,000 mph (64,373 km/h) when it exploded.



"These new estimates were generated using new data that had been collected by five additional infrasound stations located around the world - the first recording of the event being in Alaska, over 6,500 kilometers away from Chelyabinsk," JPL officials explained in the statement. The infrasound stations detect low-frequency sound waves that accompany exploding meteors, known as bolides.

​
 
I think they meant 150 feet. Everyone was calling it as big as half a football field.

That's about the same size as the object that made the mile-wide Barringer crater in Arizona. It could wipe out a major city. The shock wave and falling debris would destroy everything for tens of miles in every direction.

Steve S
 
I meant the near miss asteroid. The yield was already in on the meteor. To get a proper comparison would need the velocity of the asteroid as well as the mass but thanks for that info.
7.8 km/sec WAS the velocity of the asteroid, not of the Urals impactor.
 
My non-expert veiew: too high, too big and too fast for a successful intercept. Compare with the ABM trial results, or Patriot missiles against Scuds.

ETA: also I haven't seen any missile contrails in the videos I've seen - on a phone so can't easily watch them st the moment.

Sounds like nationalistic bluster.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone have an explanation for what is going on in this video?

Claims - 'meteor was shot down'

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qzKhPIArIKQ

Yes.

If you look at the well publicised original video that closeup is taken from you'll see that the anomalous glinting 'object' is actually stationary with respect to the car's windscreen (compare it with dirt specks nearby). It's just a small scratch on the glass catching the light and glinting.
 
SG

The contrail clearly indicated multiple tracks - that might not indicate an "airburst" but it certainly indicated a break up and multiple contrails to go with it.
I was talking in that sentence about the Peruvian meteorite strike in case that wasn't clear.


Also something caused the post shock wave "pops" that sounded like muffled gun fire. Smaller bits with different velocities would have their own shock fronts.

I'm curious on the hole as well but it looks reasonable, the edges look almost lasered and there is almost no ice in the hole at all but lots around it.
Cannot see how that hole could be anything but.

Water slows objects very quickly ( think bullets ) but this one is likely buried in the mud at the bottom which is why the divers did not locate it. It would be very unlikely for the water to have been deep enough to slow it enough to end up "on" the bottom.

Thinking about it.....it may not have been a very large object ( does not need to be the diameter of the hole ) due to the the way a shock wave propagates outwards which the ice pattern shows.....as if the explosion was from underwater

The pink images here show the effect

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/05/09/article-1385073-0BF8B6FE00000578-904_634x342.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/05/09/article-1385073-0BF8B6EE00000578-314_634x346.jpg

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNI-LIVs-to&feature=player_embedded
I think it's possible some pieces were not slowed. I've been trying to find out more, you think you know stuff then some new question comes up and you realize you don't.

Back to speculating. :)

That lake is much bigger than it looks in those images, therefore it is probably very deep. It might be harder to search the bottom than it looks. I agree the surrounding ice looks like an impact crater pattern.
 
Last edited:
That's about the same size as the object that made the mile-wide Barringer crater in Arizona. It could wipe out a major city. The shock wave and falling debris would destroy everything for tens of miles in every direction.

Steve S
From your link:
object that excavated the crater was a nickel–iron meteorite about 50 meters (54 yards) across
That's 3 times bigger than this one (55 feet) and probably made of denser material.

If you scroll down on this page to the NEO list, objects of the size of the one that made meteor crater are often detected. Currently there are 5 NEOs on the list that are 50m or less.

Almost all very large objects that are near the Earth, say a km or greater have been found. If you look at the name of the object, the year it was discovered is the first number. You can see the larger rocks are rarely new discoveries, though occasionally one does turn up.

Here's the data on the NEO website. It should make people feel safer, or not. ;)
 
Last edited:
From your link:That's 3 times bigger than this one (55 feet) and probably made of denser material.


From NASA's website...
http://www.nasa.gov/topics/solarsystem/features/asteroidflyby.html

Q: What is asteroid DA14

A: Asteroid 2012 DA14 is a small near-Earth object – approximately 150 feet (45 meters) in diameter. On Feb. 15, 2013, the asteroid will pass by our planet at a remarkably close distance, but the asteroid’s path is understood well enough that there is no chance of a collision with the Earth.


The Barringer object is estimated at 50 meters. They're pretty close in size.

Steve S
 
Interesting. I have no real expertise other than the little I have read about these things. I realize small pieces would be cooled in their fall, since they land on the ice of Antarctica without penetrating. Fairly large chunks fall through roofs without causing a fire.

I'm having trouble picturing the sequence of events though. I imagined a large superheated chunk of something making it to the ground.

Reports were that the temperature was, 40,000 degrees? I found that a bit much, (more like 4,000?) but it certainly was bright. I never actually understood what produced the explosive sounds, including the many smaller ones after the initial shock wave. Was it the explosion of the bolide (bright flash) at 20 - 30 miles altitude, or the sonic boom? Then smaller pieces producing sonic booms?

http://www.amsmeteors.org/fireballs/faqf/
9. Are meteorites “glowing” hot when they reach the ground?
Probably not. The ablation process, which occurs over the majority of the meteorite’s path, is a very efficient heat removal method, and was effectively copied for use during the early manned space flights for re-entry into the atmosphere. During the final free-fall portion of their flight, meteorites undergo very little frictional heating, and probably reach the ground at only slightly above ambient temperature.

For the obvious reason, however, exact data on meteorite impact temperatures is rather scarce and prone to hearsay. Therefore, we are only able to give you an educated guess based upon our current knowledge of these events.
Observed meteorite falls have occasionally been near people and the recovered rocks reported to be only warm to the touch. And despite the myths that abound, meteorites have not been known to start fires.


If I understand correctly, the explosion is just due to dynamic forces on the exterior, which essentially tear it apart, and not from the entire thing being molten. The trailing burning parts are visible after the flash. Also, what was the huge "vapor trail" due to? Was that vaporizing of the moisture in the air, or some sort of combustion product from the meteorite?
The vapor trail is before the airburst. Also, people are confusing the sonic boom and the pressure wave with the explosion. That's not exactly what's happening. The pressure wave is altered with the break up of the meteor, but it existed before the airburst.

What's amazing is just how much energy is stored in the compressed air mass that the meteor is creating.

At the same time, the meteoroid will also rapidly lose mass due to ablation. In this process, the outer layer of the meteoroid is continuously vaporized and stripped away due to high speed collision with air molecules. Particles from dust size to a few kilograms mass are usually completely consumed in the atmosphere.
The ablation is what results in the vapor trail.

Due to atmospheric drag, most meteorites, ranging from a few kilograms up to about 8 tons (7,000 kg), will lose all of their cosmic velocity while still several miles up. At that point, called the retardation point, the meteorite begins to accelerate again, under the influence of the Earth’s gravity, at the familiar 9.8 meters per second squared. The meteorite then quickly reaches its terminal velocity of 200 to 400 miles per hour (90 to 180 meters per second). The terminal velocity occurs at the point where the acceleration due to gravity is exactly offset by the deceleration due to atmospheric drag.
Not every meteor explodes in the air. Smaller ones may break apart, you see that with a fireball that looks to be 'dripping' pieces off.

So reaching the point of falling at terminal velocity is one thing, breaking up in an airburst is a separate thing. I never thought about it before so I'm looking into what happens when the airburst occurs before maximum drag is reached. It has to slow the meteor and the pieces probably fall at TV from there anyway. And from the appearance of the vapor trail here, I don't think any pieces of this meteorite were going at supersonic speeds after the airburst.


I have not seen any videos that show the bright flash and the explosion, though one of them (the one taken with the automated camera showing the traffic) actually included more than 2 minutes after the flash. This means that the distance to the meteorite had to have been greater than 24 miles. Is there enough atmosphere to transmit such amplitude at this altitude? ETA: there was no audio on this video, but I was looking for any reaction caused by the blast, and never saw any.
The bright flash I think you are talking about is merely the fireball passing overhead in those videos. If you look at the vapor trail, you'll see it just disappears, it does not show some big blast at the end of it. It's because after the airburst, nothing left is going fast enough anymore to leave a vapor trail.

True. Very likely not metallic.
With extremely rare exception, all meteorites have a considerable amount of metal. But nickel-irons are almost all metal. The come from the core of a planetary body where the heaviest metals sank to the core (like our own planet) as the planet formed.


I'm not sure I understand what relevance "terminal velocity" has in this case though. I think of that as the limiting velocity due to air resistance of an object (like a skydiver) starting out at zero, and accelerated by the earth's gravity. This stuff was already moving at hypersonic speed, so would not most of it hit the ground at very high speed?
See above.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom