Meteor over Moscow

Makes you wonder how many blinding flashes happen over Russia in any given amount of time. :eek:

Indeed.
None of my Russian colleagues wanted to discuss the event with me.
Odd.
They're usually a garrulous lot when it comes to current events in Mother Russia.
 
What the heck does "wormwood" have to do with anything? The Russian word is not even close to "hole in the ice".:D

Somehow, the hole looks precisely like what I would imagine a 7,000 ton 20 foot diameter red hot hunk of iron traveling at hypersonic speed would do.
A few corrections:

Meteorites that explode in the air are only warm when they reach the ground. Despite what seems logical, only about a millimeter or less is molten on the surface before the airburst, and by the time the object falls at terminal velocity, it has cooled.

I doubt this was a nickel-iron because an object that size made of nickel-iron probably wouldn't have exploded.

A meteorite that does not explode before reaching the surface can impact with incredible force and the heat generated melts rock.


If the hole in the ice was new, as it appears to be, then I'll be curious as to what they find in the lake. That ice is thick enough people are walking on it. But if you drop a big rock and it falls at terminal velocity, it would have to be really big to make such a hole.

I visited this crater on the Peru-Bolivia border a year after the meteorite hit. The crater while it looked big in the news images, was 4.5 m (15 ft) deep, 13 m (43 ft) wide and only small fragments were recovered. (Skeptigirl's Magical Mythery Tour of Peru :D)

BTW, that Wiki article has a number of first hand reports that are full of inaccuracies, the scientists discredited later in the article so be careful what conclusions you draw reading about it. The article claims the water boiled and the ground was scorched around the crater, both local folk reports that are not consistent with the facts and likely resulted from falsely interpreting what they actually saw.

Because the impact site is at a high altitude of more than 3,800 m (12,467 ft), the meteoroid may not have been slowed down as much as it ordinarily would have been by passage through the Earth’s denser lower atmosphere, and kinetic energy at impact may have been unusually high for a terrestrial impact of an object of this size and mass. Most larger meteorites are cold in their bulk mass when they land on Earth, since their heated outer layers ablate from the objects before impacting.[14]
That's followed by a claim I don't think is scientific:
It was later confirmed that the meteorite contained a large amount of iron and possessed magnetic properties common to similar metallic objects, which contributed to its capacity to retain heat during atmospheric entry.[21]

The source is a news report and Chondrites do not have that much iron relative to their whole. And the reports of illness from arsenic stirred up in the air were also highly suspect. I think someone wanted to make the locals feel better about their stories, or more likely, people hearing the reports just couldn't believe it could simply be hysteria. The location was isolated and the town was miles away. By the time anyone got near the crater anything in the air would have dissipated. But all that's beside the point.

The bottom line is, I don't think there was an airburst and the object hit with considerable force. But had there been an airburst, this crater would simply not have been created. So I'm very curious about this hole in the ice in Russia, but I'm beginning to be less convinced the meteorite caused it.


Here are some images of the Tagish Lake meteorites recovered from a frozen lake after an airburst. While who knows the depth of the ice, you can see how shallow the fragments penetrated before the ice around them refroze.
 
Last edited:
What the heck does "wormwood" have to do with anything? The Russian word is not even close to "hole in the ice".:D

Somehow, the hole looks precisely like what I would imagine a 7,000 ton 20 foot diameter red hot hunk of iron traveling at hypersonic speed would do.

I disagree (not that I've seen a meteorite hole in the ice before).

1. Surely if a metorite had hit there then the divers would find it relatively easy?
2. I would have thought that a rock that size and speed would break up a hell of a lot of ice round the hole due to the water pressure, even if the ice was 5 foot thick.

:confused:
 
Not if the bottom of the lake is soft mud and the meteorite could be buried in it several feet deep.
The evidence is still equivocal.

The hole is so round, something going straight down?

But then all you have is terminal velocity. It would have to be one big rock.

The water would slow the object more.

So, big enough to make the crater, unlikely to be completely under the mud.

Small enough to fit the evidence, unlikely to have made that hole.

But on the other side, the image of the hole does show impact evidence. Note the ice thrown out around the hole. From the one picture I've seen, that is what you would expect from an impact crater.


I'm leaning back toward, it's real and maybe they even found the meteorite fragment but the news media does not yet know. CNN just had a reporter in Russia try to get to the crater and the police would not let him close.


Then I lean back toward, nope. It could also be a fishing hole someone used explosives to open.
 
Fragments or myth. :)

I saw it on one of the videos, a guy films the trail of the meteor, you hear the blasts and very shortly afterwards points his camera down to the snow to show the black ash falling.

As it is 'ash' then surely it has come from quite a low altitude, and to be reaching the ground so soon after the blasts.

:confused:
 
This image shows a good view of the ice thrown out in a pattern you'd see with an impact (or an explosion if you used dynamite to make a fishing hole).

One thing I learned from visiting the Carancas impact eventWP, the rumors and misinformation are rampant after one of these events, even info from some of the scientists is not always reliable, though certainly more trustworthy than the news and all the eye-witness accounts.

And the picture of a crater with a person in the background looks way bigger than the thing does in person due to how the camera deals with background and foreground perspective distortions.
 
Last edited:
I saw it on one of the videos, a guy films the trail of the meteor, you hear the blasts and very shortly afterwards points his camera down to the snow to show the black ash falling.

As it is 'ash' then surely it has come from quite a low altitude, and to be reaching the ground so soon after the blasts.

:confused:
Linky? If you're too new to post them, just put a few spaces in the address and we can figure it out. I can't comment without seeing it.

It's more likely building debris, but I can't guess without a visual. :)
 
Last edited:
I saw it on one of the videos, a guy films the trail of the meteor, you hear the blasts and very shortly afterwards points his camera down to the snow to show the black ash falling.

As it is 'ash' then surely it has come from quite a low altitude, and to be reaching the ground so soon after the blasts.

:confused:

I didn't see that one, but I suppose it could be a local effect like, say, soot shaken loose from a nearby chimney by the shock of the blast, or just accumulated dirt blown off a roof.
 
A few corrections:

Meteorites that explode in the air are only warm when they reach the ground. Despite what seems logical, only about a millimeter or less is molten on the surface before the airburst, and by the time the object falls at terminal velocity, it has cooled.

Interesting. I have no real expertise other than the little I have read about these things. I realize small pieces would be cooled in their fall, since they land on the ice of Antarctica without penetrating. Fairly large chunks fall through roofs without causing a fire.

I'm having trouble picturing the sequence of events though. I imagined a large superheated chunk of something making it to the ground.

Reports were that the temperature was, 40,000 degrees? I found that a bit much, (more like 4,000?) but it certainly was bright. I never actually understood what produced the explosive sounds, including the many smaller ones after the initial shock wave. Was it the explosion of the bolide (bright flash) at 20 - 30 miles altitude, or the sonic boom? Then smaller pieces producing sonic booms?

If I understand correctly, the explosion is just due to dynamic forces on the exterior, which essentially tear it apart, and not from the entire thing being molten. The trailing burning parts are visible after the flash. Also, what was the huge "vapor trail" due to? Was that vaporizing of the moisture in the air, or some sort of combustion product from the meteorite?

I have not seen any videos that show the bright flash and the explosion, though one of them (the one taken with the automated camera showing the traffic) actually included more than 2 minutes after the flash. This means that the distance to the meteorite had to have been greater than 24 miles. Is there enough atmosphere to transmit such amplitude at this altitude? ETA: there was no audio on this video, but I was looking for any reaction caused by the blast, and never saw any.

I doubt this was a nickel-iron because an object that size made of nickel-iron probably wouldn't have exploded.

A meteorite that does not explode before reaching the surface can impact with incredible force and the heat generated melts rock.
True. Very likely not metallic.
If the hole in the ice was new, as it appears to be, then I'll be curious as to what they find in the lake. That ice is thick enough people are walking on it. But if you drop a big rock and it falls at terminal velocity, it would have to be really big to make such a hole.
I'm not sure I understand what relevance "terminal velocity" has in this case though. I think of that as the limiting velocity due to air resistance of an object (like a skydiver) starting out at zero, and accelerated by the earth's gravity. This stuff was already moving at hypersonic speed, so would not most of it hit the ground at very high speed?
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure I understand what relevance "terminal velocity" has in this case though. I think of that as the limiting velocity due to air resistance of an object (like a skydiver) starting out at zero, and accelerated by the earth's gravity. This stuff was already moving at hypersonic speed, so would not most of it hit the ground at very high speed?

I don't think a meteorite hits the earth at anything other than terminal velocity because it's already been slowed way down by the atmosphere from its initial hypersonic speed (perhaps it depends on the mass?). So it's nowhere close to that anymore. That's my understanding, anyway. :) I may be wrong.
 
Last edited:
According to this blogger, a trajectory computed using the shadows of objects of known height in a couple of the videos happens to intersect with the lake where the supposed meteor ice-hole was discovered.
 
Was it the explosion of the bolide (bright flash) at 20 - 30 miles altitude, or the sonic boom? Then smaller pieces producing sonic booms?

I was trying to sort the post shock wave bangs as well - must be smaller chunks that are moving slightly slower so the sonic booms get there after the first shock wave. Only thing I could come up with

•••

I don't think a meteorite hits the earth at anything other than terminal velocity

It's entirely dependent on, mass, shape and initial velocity plus the angle of entry so there is no way you could make that statement.

A sizeable chunk of say nickel iron coming in at 55,000 mph vertically is not going to hit at terminal velocity.
It's not going to lose much velocity at all if it stays intact.
Chicxlub did NOT hit at terminal velocity ;)

I have seen earth grazers come in - slow right down and tumble - those would land, if they do at terminal velocity.
But it will be different for every bolide.
 
It's entirely dependent on, mass, shape and initial velocity plus the angle of entry so there is no way you could make that statement.

A sizeable chunk of say nickel iron coming in at 55,000 mph vertically is not going to hit at terminal velocity.
It's not going to lose much velocity at all if it stays intact.
Chicxlub did NOT hit at terminal velocity ;)

I have seen earth grazers come in - slow right down and tumble - those would land, if they do at terminal velocity.
But it will be different for every bolide.

Yes, of course this makes sense. Of course velocity at impact depends on a number of factors. Thanks for clarifying.
 
SG
The bottom line is, I don't think there was an airburst and the object hit with considerable force. But had there been an airburst, this crater would simply not have been created. So I'm very curious about this hole in the ice in Russia, but I'm beginning to be less convinced the meteorite caused it.

The contrail clearly indicated multiple tracks - that might not indicate an "airburst" but it certainly indicated a break up and multiple contrails to go with it.
Also something caused the post shock wave "pops" that sounded like muffled gun fire. Smaller bits with different velocities would have their own shock fronts.

I'm curious on the hole as well but it looks reasonable, the edges look almost lasered and there is almost no ice in the hole at all but lots around it.
Cannot see how that hole could be anything but.

Water slows objects very quickly ( think bullets ) but this one is likely buried in the mud at the bottom which is why the divers did not locate it. It would be very unlikely for the water to have been deep enough to slow it enough to end up "on" the bottom.

Thinking about it.....it may not have been a very large object ( does not need to be the diameter of the hole ) due to the the way a shock wave propagates outwards which the ice pattern shows.....as if the explosion was from underwater

The pink images here show the effect

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/05/09/article-1385073-0BF8B6FE00000578-904_634x342.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/05/09/article-1385073-0BF8B6EE00000578-314_634x346.jpg

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cNI-LIVs-to&feature=player_embedded
 
Last edited:
NASA has updated it's estimate of the size of the meteor and energy released.

55 feet diameter
10,000 tons mass
500 Kilotons of energy

That's a huge upgrade in size.

An earlier report said only 10 tons and 2 meters across. Looks like that was off by a factor of 1,000. Wow.

Still, the one that missed us was 13 times bigger yet: 130,000 tons and 50 meters across.

I'm glad this didn't happen during the cold war, say, during the Cuban missile crisis.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom