Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

That should be of grave concern that science has no moral convictions.
Why? Engineering has no moral convictions either. Science doesn't tell us what is right or wrong, but it can help us to understand why we think things are right or wrong.

I have tried to accept Science as an amoral discipline. I also considered those scientist who help build the nuclear bomb. If scientist cannot be responsible for how it is used. Then their scientific curiosity should be subject to some restraint because of consequences they have not considered.
So we should limit free inquiry because it might lead to some things that you don't like?

Which brings to mind Stephen Hawking's warnings that we should avoid making contact with aliens because they might not have altruistic intentions.
How did the above bring that to mind?

Now try communicating that to a scientist like Carl Sagan who was obsessed with contacting aliens...
I tire of addressing this silliness. Your "argument" isn't getting any less dumb with repetition.

and supported by Skeptics who have yet to articulate the wisdom behind his obsession.
It's called scientific inquiry. It's about human curiosity. You've expressed an interest in learning about humanity. Wouldn't you like to know how unique or common life in the universe is?

Stephen Hawking Warns Over Making Contact with Aliens
https://www.commondreams.org/headline/2010/04/25
Thank you. We've actually heard of Stephen Hawking.
 
Why would he? He was profiting from it.
He wrote a book and people purchased it? What an appalling human being!

Why he targeted Skeptics is the focus of my inquiry.
I think his intended audience was anyone who was curious about what it might be like to detect a signal from an extraterrestrial civilization.
 
Please read Plot summary for Contact. I have the same reaction with every Skeptic who claimed they read Contact. They all missed that part. This is why we group them as Skeptics. They all arrive at the same conclusion with different facts.

Smartcooky's observation in no way contradicts the plot of Contact. As he (she?) observed, there are no UFOs or alien visitors in the story and the only spacecraft is built by humans.
 
The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.

Why the aggressive banter? the smugness, the defensiveness? insecurity maybe? are you 14? your argument sounds like that of an angry teenager who's been shown to be wrong, so he trolls the forum-verse hoping to either find one place where people agree with his goofy ideas, or to try and make everybody else's life miserable whilst they grapple with the sheer denseness of his thinking.
 
Last edited:
How do you know this? Do you ask everyone you meet? Most people apply skepticism to one degree or another, so I suspect you've met more than you realize.


So far, you seem more determined to tell skeptics what you want them to believe.


There are no doubt people who fit that definition, but on a forum such as this you are more likely to encounter people who define skepticism as an unwillingness to accept claims that have not met a certain scientific standard of empirical evidence. This isn't to say that such skeptics won't acknowledge the possibility of a claim.


Generally with words.


It depends on the standard of evidence that they require of a given situation. Around here, most rely on the scientific method for claims about the natural universe.


Can you link to this discussion? It's just impossible to evaluate an exchange that we know nothing about.


How do you know this? Did he tell you this, or is it something you've assumed?


What evidence? What claim did you make?


Or they may simply be people with higher than average educations who have learned a thing or two about critical thinking and the scientific method.
Just too many points to deal with in one post.
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums. I have never been asked for citations or even questioned about my faith. There is a lot less paranoia outside Skeptic forums.
I have to protect the individuals privacy because it is really my concern. I knew the person and his dire situation before we entered the world of social media. But after joining a few Skeptic Forums I have noticed the drastic changes. He now denies not only what he knows which is little considering he is a school dropout, but who he is which is an unemployed welfare recipient for the last 10 years, but also where he is which is a failed single parent living is a dump.
But the biggest concern I have is his obsession engaging in endless arguments on forums hiding behind his anonymity. And the reason he can do that is because Skeptics are not very astute at seeing through the facade and reward doubt, a questioning attitude and uncertainty as evidence of critical thinking and evidence directed validation. But all the person is doing is putting the burden of proof on the other person and expecting to be educated about the subject in the process.
This can become tedious because you cannot raise a school drop-out to graduate level with a few well placed arguments. He needs the whole enchilada and months of your time. I haven`t seen him progress over the years because he cannot get an education debating on Skeptic forums. The smarts ones quit or are banned and the ones that remain share the same level of doubts and uncertainty that drew them to the forums in the first place.
I appreciate your interest in what I am attempting which is to understand why Skeptics are such disagreeable people. In an information age the more you know the better your chances are to succeed. And a Skeptic on welfare is not the success expected from applying critical thinking and simultaneously ignoring what is self evident.
 
Why can't you seem to understand that one can accept the possibility that life exists elsewhere in the universe, but also conclude that there isn't any convincing evidence that it is visiting us here on Earth with the purpose of anally probing any idiot in a pickup truck?

.

Yeah that's totally true.... I burned three weekends laying in the back of that truck.... nothin. :boxedin:




as far as the OP goes, why do I get the sneaking suspicion that Jesus is going to be making an appearance soon?
 
Just too many points to deal with in one post.
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums. I have never been asked for citations or even questioned about my faith. There is a lot less paranoia outside Skeptic forums.
I have to protect the individuals privacy because it is really my concern. I knew the person and his dire situation before we entered the world of social media. But after joining a few Skeptic Forums I have noticed the drastic changes. He now denies not only what he knows which is little considering he is a school dropout, but who he is which is an unemployed welfare recipient for the last 10 years, but also where he is which is a failed single parent living is a dump.
But the biggest concern I have is his obsession engaging in endless arguments on forums hiding behind his anonymity. And the reason he can do that is because Skeptics are not very astute at seeing through the facade and reward doubt, a questioning attitude and uncertainty as evidence of critical thinking and evidence directed validation. But all the person is doing is putting the burden of proof on the other person and expecting to be educated about the subject in the process.
This can become tedious because you cannot raise a school drop-out to graduate level with a few well placed arguments. He needs the whole enchilada and months of your time. I haven`t seen him progress over the years because he cannot get an education debating on Skeptic forums. The smarts ones quit or are banned and the ones that remain share the same level of doubts and uncertainty that drew them to the forums in the first place.
I appreciate your interest in what I am attempting which is to understand why Skeptics are such disagreeable people. In an information age the more you know the better your chances are to succeed. And a Skeptic on welfare is not the success expected from applying critical thinking and simultaneously ignoring what is self evident.

So, you apparently don't understand skepticism, critical thinking, burden of proof . . . and probably a bunch of other stuff.

Did Carl Sagan or some other skeptic piss on your corn flakes?

Inquiring minds don't you know.
 
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums.


You should get out of your mom's basement a little more often.

Admit, it, you're just trolling now, aren't you? Or do you really believe the nonsense you post?
 
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums

You don't know any such thing. This is the most preposterous claim I've seen this week.

You may not have met any, but there certainly are skeptics outside of skeptic fora.
 
The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.


You still don't get it do you?

1. I believe that the cosmos is swarming with intelligent life.

2. I believe that UFO's DO NOT have any connection whatever with the intelligent life in the cosmos.

These two belief are NOT mutually exclusive; I can argue in support of BOTH beliefs without any contradiction and without any hypocrisy.
 
Just too many points to deal with in one post.
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums.

What an odd claim to make. Were there skeptics before the days of forums, message boards, newsgroups, and even the internet?

I'd say yes, but what about you?

That said, I know many skeptical people who don't participate in forums.



I have never been asked for citations or even questioned about my faith. There is a lot less paranoia outside Skeptic forums.

There are far fewer credulous claims made outside of forums these days as well. Do you wander around various places and start proclaiming your faith to all who are within earshot? If yes, have you noticed any people who look at you weird and then politely walk away? These people are also skeptics, but they are less likely to engage you in discussion face to face because let's be honest... there are some real crazy nuts out there and who knows what they might do if you try to take away their candy.



I have to protect the individuals privacy because it is really my concern. I knew the person and his dire situation before we entered the world of social media. But after joining a few Skeptic Forums I have noticed the drastic changes. He now denies not only what he knows which is little considering he is a school dropout, but who he is which is an unemployed welfare recipient for the last 10 years, but also where he is which is a failed single parent living is a dump.
But the biggest concern I have is his obsession engaging in endless arguments on forums hiding behind his anonymity.

So this bout of Skeptiphobia* that you've come to is out of concern for a friend of yours? Your concern is commendable, but perhaps his issues have nothing to do with skepticism in general.



And the reason he can do that is because Skeptics are not very astute at seeing through the facade and reward doubt, a questioning attitude and uncertainty as evidence of critical thinking and evidence directed validation.

My you're quick to generalize aren't you? Have you considered the possibility that your friend who is sadly failing at life (in your opinion) may not necessarily be representative of skepticism and skeptics in general?



But all the person is doing is putting the burden of proof on the other person and expecting to be educated about the subject in the process.

If someone makes a claim, is it not their burden to prove the claim? If not, what would you propose as a general rule of thumb?



This can become tedious because you cannot raise a school drop-out to graduate level with a few well placed arguments. He needs the whole enchilada and months of your time. I haven`t seen him progress over the years because he cannot get an education debating on Skeptic forums. The smarts ones quit or are banned and the ones that remain share the same level of doubts and uncertainty that drew them to the forums in the first place.

It can also become tedious to deal with skeptiphobics who are seemingly obsessed with undermining critical thinking while professing otherwise.



I appreciate your interest in what I am attempting which is to understand why Skeptics are such disagreeable people. In an information age the more you know the better your chances are to succeed. And a Skeptic on welfare is not the success expected from applying critical thinking and simultaneously ignoring what is self evident.

May I suggest that you focus more on your friend than on skeptics in general if your actual concern is your friend?



*read this as 'credulity'
 
Last edited:
Just too many points to deal with in one post.
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums. I have never been asked for citations or even questioned about my faith. There is a lot less paranoia outside Skeptic forums.
I have to protect the individuals privacy because it is really my concern. I knew the person and his dire situation before we entered the world of social media. But after joining a few Skeptic Forums I have noticed the drastic changes. He now denies not only what he knows which is little considering he is a school dropout, but who he is which is an unemployed welfare recipient for the last 10 years, but also where he is which is a failed single parent living is a dump.
But the biggest concern I have is his obsession engaging in endless arguments on forums hiding behind his anonymity. And the reason he can do that is because Skeptics are not very astute at seeing through the facade and reward doubt, a questioning attitude and uncertainty as evidence of critical thinking and evidence directed validation. But all the person is doing is putting the burden of proof on the other person and expecting to be educated about the subject in the process.
This can become tedious because you cannot raise a school drop-out to graduate level with a few well placed arguments. He needs the whole enchilada and months of your time. I haven`t seen him progress over the years because he cannot get an education debating on Skeptic forums. The smarts ones quit or are banned and the ones that remain share the same level of doubts and uncertainty that drew them to the forums in the first place.
I appreciate your interest in what I am attempting which is to understand why Skeptics are such disagreeable people. In an information age the more you know the better your chances are to succeed. And a Skeptic on welfare is not the success expected from applying critical thinking and simultaneously ignoring what is self evident.

Is this post autobiographical?
 
You still don't get it do you?

1. I believe that the cosmos is swarming with intelligent life.

2. I believe that UFO's DO NOT have any connection whatever with the intelligent life in the cosmos.

These two belief are NOT mutually exclusive; I can argue in support of BOTH beliefs without any contradiction and without any hypocrisy.


I agree with and share your beliefs. I don't think it's going to have much impact on justintime's position though. The only hypocrisy taking place here is justin's condemnation of skepticism by being skeptical of skeptics; the painful and hypocritical conundrum of all skeptiphobics.
 
I am not a religious person but I do believe in defending the religious rights of people. And with 0ver 3 billion believers. It would take a lot of hating to hold all of them in contempt. I have made the effort to study comparative religion and many secular philosophies. And they all teach us about our humanity.
As for your question. There are many religions and then there are superstitions. So learn "The difference between religion and superstition".
http://mikio.hubpages.com/hub/The-difference-between-religion-and-superstition

And you learn the difference between your silly, disproven, adversarial., inaccurate, unsourced "definition" of "skepticism" and what skeptics actually are.

http://youngausskeptics.com/what-is-a-skeptic/
"A skeptic is an individual who approaches every claim with a degree of scepticism proportional to its plausibility. They use the basis of science, the scientific method, to analyse objectively each issue they encounter so as to come to a conclusion that is most supported by the evidence."

http://oxford.skepticsinthepub.org/Default.aspx/19/What-is-a-Skeptic
"A skeptic is one who prefers beliefs and conclusions that are reliable and valid to ones that are comforting or convenient, and therefore rigorously and openly applies the methods of science and reason to all empirical claims, especially their own.
A skeptic provisionally proportions acceptance of any claim to valid logic and a fair and thorough assessment of available evidence, and studies the pitfalls of human reason and the mechanisms of deception so as to avoid being deceived by others or themselves.
Skepticism values method over any particular conclusion."

and, from a link you provided, but did not read:
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php
"The true meaning of the word skepticism has nothing to do with doubt, disbelief, or negativity. Skepticism is the process of applying reason and critical thinking to determine validity. It's the process of finding a supported conclusion, not the justification of a preconceived conclusion."

It is odd to see you claim not to be "religious" in this forum...
I believe that people have the right to be "religious" in whatever way gives them comfort, as 3 billion credulous people pursuing numberless different "truths" attest. And as the warm feelings of love and unity expressed by all of the "3 billion" attest.

If I might be so bold, may I ask why you caution against contempt for the credulous, when you yourself are so dismissively contemptuous of "skeptics"?

Adhere to whatever bronze-age superstition you choose--but do not pretend that gives you the right to spread calumny, disingenuous calumny, about anyone, credulous or skeptic, who does not share your superstition.

...but I, and others, have already pointed these things out to you...
 
Last edited:
I don't have a problem with Carl Sagan's criticism of superstitions and other irrational beliefs. But to attack them with skepticism and at the same time believe in aliens, flying saucers and ETI is a contradiction.

What evidence do you have that Sagan had any such belief?

Here's what Sagan himself had to say:

=========

"I'm frequently asked, "Do you believe there's extraterrestrial intelligence?" I give the standard arguments -- there are a lot of places out there, the molecules of life are everywhere, I use the word billions, and so on. Then I say it would be astonishing to me if there weren't extraterrestrial intelligence, but of course there is as yet no compelling evidence for it.

Often, I'm asked next, "What do you really think?"
I say, "I just told you what I really think."
"Yes, but what's your gut feeling?"
But I try not to think with my gut. If I'm serious about understanding the world, thinking with anything besides my brain, as tempting as that might be, is likely to get me into trouble. Really, it's okay to reserve judgment until the evidence is in." -- Carl Sagan, from his 1997 book The Demon-Haunted World - Science as a Candle in the Dark, page 180.

=========

Have you read the book?

RayG
 
Please read Plot summary for Contact. I have the same reaction with every Skeptic who claimed they read Contact. They all missed that part. This is why we group them as Skeptics. They all arrive at the same conclusion with different facts.
Quote:
Wiki: A third message is discovered containing over 30,000 pages describing plans for a machine that appears to be a kind of highly advanced vehicle, with seats for five human beings. But they cannot understand the third message until they find the fourth message, a primer hidden in phase modulation.[2] The primer allows them to translate the alien language to human language.

Ultimately, a machine is successfully built and activated, transporting five passengers

The above is purportedly your "response" to:
What a load of tosh! There wasn't a single UFO anywhere in the FICTION NOVEL Contact, and the only alien spacecraft was built by humans.

You might actually want to read Contact, instead of just the wikki summary, because (in case you missed it) there were no UFOs in Contact. The only "alien" spaceship in Contact was built by humans.
What point did you think you were making?
 
Last edited:
You obviously haven't read Sagan.

He wanted to find EVIDENCE they existed. He never said he was 100% certain they were out there.

How is this not skeptical? If anything he thought it was highly likely, but he never said they existed for sure, as he never had any evidence.
 
What evidence do you have that Sagan had any such belief?

Here's what Sagan himself had to say:

=========

"I'm frequently asked, "Do you believe there's extraterrestrial intelligence?" I give the standard arguments -- there are a lot of places out there, the molecules of life are everywhere, I use the word billions, and so on. Then I say it would be astonishing to me if there weren't extraterrestrial intelligence, but of course there is as yet no compelling evidence for it.

Often, I'm asked next, "What do you really think?"
I say, "I just told you what I really think."
"Yes, but what's your gut feeling?"
But I try not to think with my gut. If I'm serious about understanding the world, thinking with anything besides my brain, as tempting as that might be, is likely to get me into trouble. Really, it's okay to reserve judgment until the evidence is in." -- Carl Sagan, from his 1997 book The Demon-Haunted World - Science as a Candle in the Dark, page 180.

=========

Have you read the book?

RayG

But Ray--what do you really think?
 
I don't have a problem with Carl Sagan's criticism of superstitions and other irrational beliefs. But to attack them with skepticism and at the same time believe in aliens, flying saucers and ETI is a contradiction.


Another quote from Sagan--this time from Cosmos--showing how wrong you are (highlight added):

In the Milky Way Galaxy there must be many planets millions of years older than Earth, and some that are billions of years older. Should we not have been visited? In all the billions of years since the origin of our planet, has there not been even once a strange craft from a distant civilization surveying our world from above, and slowly settling down to the surface to be observed by iridescent dragonflies, incurious reptiles, screeching primates or wondering humans? The idea is natural enough. It has occurred to everyone who has contemplated, even casually, the question of intelligent life in the universe. But has it happened in fact? The critical issue is the quality of the purported evidence, rigorously and skeptically scrutinized - not what sounds plausible, not the unsubstantiated testimony of one or two self-professed eyewitnesses. By this standard there are no compelling cases of extraterrestrial visitation, despite all the claims about UFOs and ancient astronauts which sometimes make it seem that our planet is awash in uninvited guests.

Not skeptical, huh? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom