And he also wrote Contact which was all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters. Here he is pandering to the so called irrational and trying to profit from it after he claimed to be a Skeptic of UFOs. It is hard to be a scientist and not indulge in some wild speculations or vicariously live in fiction, what the real world cannot provide, except in fantasy land.
So what? As a child I believed in Jesus and UFOs.
E.g., even die-hard wooists, typically believe only a small number of woo things, and are very sceptical of those which aren't on their list. My favourite quote (and evidence) about it is from the second edition to Martin Gardner's "In The Name Of Science", one of the first who did a systematic job of collecting and debunking pseudoscience woo. It starts with the words:
"THE FIRST EDITION of this book prompted many curious letters from irate readers. The most violent letters came from Reichians, furious because the book considered orgonomy alongside such (to them) outlandish cults as dianetics. Dianeticians, of course, felt the same about orgonomy. I heard from homeopaths who were insulted to find themselves in company with such frauds as osteopathy and chiropractic, and one chiropractor in Kentucky "pitied" me because I had turned my spine on God's greatest gift to suffering humanity. Several admirers of Dr. Bates favoured me with letters so badly typed that I suspect the writers were in urgent need of strong spectacles. Oddly enough, most of these correspondents objected to one chapter only, thinking all the others excellent."
E.g., even the most brain-dead apologists of religion, usually are uncritical of only one religion. If I'm to pick one flavour as the most brain-dead it would be presuppositionalism, but even those are only presuppositionalist about the Bible, and will cheerfully pick at holes in Buddhism, Islam, Hinduism, etc.
Land, distant lands separated by wide expanses of water (ocean) are tangible just as rocks and dirt are on other planets. But aliens? Superior advanced intelligent aliens.
Will you be proving some evidence for the beliefs that you claim Sagan held were actually held by him?I am not erecting a strawman. I am relating what Carl Sagan actually did.
To the claim I haven't encountered any Skeptics outside of Skeptic forums. There are more important things that affect you directly in the real world. Your job, customers, patients, transactions, interactions, trust and social encounters. You don't have Skeptics out there demanding citations or criticizing your beliefs. It is a live and let live attitude out there. All the nit pickers are cesspooling on Skeptic forums.What an odd claim to make. Were there skeptics before the days of forums, message boards, newsgroups, and even the internet?
I'd say yes, but what about you?
That said, I know many skeptical people who don't participate in forums.
There are far fewer credulous claims made outside of forums these days as well. Do you wander around various places and start proclaiming your faith to all who are within earshot? If yes, have you noticed any people who look at you weird and then politely walk away? These people are also skeptics, but they are less likely to engage you in discussion face to face because let's be honest... there are some real crazy nuts out there and who knows what they might do if you try to take away their candy.
So this bout of Skeptiphobia* that you've come to is out of concern for a friend of yours? Your concern is commendable, but perhaps his issues have nothing to do with skepticism in general.
My you're quick to generalize aren't you? Have you considered the possibility that your friend who is sadly failing at life (in your opinion) may not necessarily be representative of skepticism and skeptics in general?
If someone makes a claim, is it not their burden to prove the claim? If not, what would you propose as a general rule of thumb?
It can also become tedious to deal with skeptiphobics who are seemingly obsessed with undermining critical thinking while professing otherwise.
May I suggest that you focus more on your friend than on skeptics in general if your actual concern is your friend?
*read this as 'credulity'
To the claim I haven't encountered any Skeptics outside of Skeptic forums. There are more important things that affect you directly in the real world. Your job, customers, patients, transactions, interactions, trust and social encounters. You don't have Skeptics out there demanding citations or criticizing your beliefs. It is a live and let live attitude out there. All the nit pickers are cesspooling on Skeptic forums.
My own approach to critical thinking is to look beyond the Skeptic and Skepticism and see the treatable person. Here are some examples.
1. I noticed a very poor contributor on another Skeptic Forum. He had his one line quarterbacking comments and the usual smiley faces. He also had 11,600 post in 3 years. I asked him how did he get away posting that many post and not being challenged on a Skeptic Forum full of critical thinkers for basically not saying anything substantive. I also asked him why would someone spend so much time on a Skeptic Forum and post that many inconsequential post. Below his avatar the caption read "Has No Life". So I suggested make it a new year resolution to get a life. You have to see beyond the Skeptic and Skepticism and get to the treatable person.
2. And close behind him was someone claiming he was from an English village. I noticed he kept bobbing in and out of my OP quitting and returning like he could not stick with his decisions. Typical habitual doubter with a condition. I figured the austerity program in the UK was not working for this bugger. Cutting back on medication is never a good idea.
But it is our civic duty to sometimes protect the inept even on Skeptic forums.
On the evidence of this thread, he doesn't even understand the difference between fiction and non-fiction.
Or take UFOS, the contention that beings in spaceships from other worlds are visiting us all the time. I find that a thrilling idea. It's at least a break from the ordinary. I've spent a fair amount of time in my scientific life working on the issue of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Think how much effort I could save if those guys are coming here.
There is more to skepticism than just demanding citations. Prior knowledge is also important.
If I know that zero point energy is pretty much impossible, and somebody suddenly tells me that they have discovered zero point energy, I will be a skeptic about it.
If someone tells me they have won the lottery, I will be more likely to believe them, because although it's not very likely, it is still possible.
Probability is a big part of it.
A skeptic forum is not the proper place to go to for facts. It is the place you go to when you have doubts about something and you are looking for other doubters. For example if you want to learn something about climate change or religion/god You go to a climate research/study site or a church to be with religious people.
Now having met more doubters that agree with you on a skeptic forum, you can either end your search and stop learning anything more about the subject or search for other doubts that doubters have to add to the list of doubts you have accumulated. You might then reach a saturation point full of only doubts and that is where the panic and fear creeps in.
Tragically, Skeptic brains 'emit fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought'
The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749
Yes, because that's a much more interesting story to tell. I'm not sure I would go see a movie called "Invasion of the barely recognizeable balloons from New Mexico"Skeptics argue UFOs are unidentified flying objects. Most literature on UFOs associate them with alien spacecraft. Even moves dipict them as alien spacecraft.
That is a silly definition. It already disregards certain kinds of explanations for an unexplained observation, and includes the (by this very definition unfounded) opinion of some unnamed persons.UFO definition:
1. A mysterious object seen in the sky for which it is claimed no orthodox scientific explanation can be found, often supposed to be a vehicle carrying extraterrestrials.
If so, what of it? In what way would it not be awesome if alien spacecraft were actually visiting us?Even Carl Sagan knew people associated UFOs with alien spacecraft and wished they were real.
Skeptics argue UFOs are unidentified flying objects. Most literature on UFOs associate them with alien spacecraft. Even moves dipict them as alien spacecraft.
UFO definition:
1. A mysterious object seen in the sky for which it is claimed no orthodox scientific explanation can be found, often supposed to be a vehicle carrying extraterrestrials.
Even Carl Sagan knew people associated UFOs with alien spacecraft and wished they were real. He saw aliens and his search for extraterrestrial intelligence and the same "those guys".
Skeptics argue UFOs are unidentified flying objects.
Most literature on UFOs associate them with alien spacecraft. Even moves dipict them as alien spacecraft.
UFO definition:
1. A mysterious object seen in the sky for which it is claimed no orthodox scientific explanation can be found, often supposed to be a vehicle carrying extraterrestrials.
Even Carl Sagan knew people associated UFOs with alien spacecraft and wished they were real. He saw aliens and his search for extraterrestrial intelligence and the same "those guys".
Skepticism is simply the process by which someone can determine whether a given claim is true or not.
For example, if I walk up to someone in the street and tell them that I have a green cat in my pocket, they will be skeptical. If I suggest to you that I can flap my arms and fly, you will be skeptical. If I tell Mr Joe Random that my brain is made of blue vein cheese, he will be skeptical.
2. And close behind him was someone claiming he was from an English village. I noticed he kept bobbing in and out of my OP quitting and returning like he could not stick with his decisions. Typical habitual doubter with a condition. I figured the austerity program in the UK was not working for this bugger. Cutting back on medication is never a good idea.
Isn't that the point I am making. Where would you in the real world have a person ask you about zero point energy. It is even rare to debate Big Bang and Dark matter unless you know you are conversing with another credible person in that field of study.
Skeptics pretend to be members of some kind of academia. The truth is there are legitimate groups already fulfilling that role. Science, religion, philosophy, climate change, politics, commerce, etc. etc.
A skeptic forum is not the proper place to go to for facts. It is the place you go to when you have doubts about something and you are looking for other doubters. For example if you want to learn something about climate change or religion/god You go to a climate research/study site or a church to be with religious people.
Now having met more doubters that agree with you on a skeptic forum, you can either end your search and stop learning anything more about the subject or search for other doubts that doubters have to add to the list of doubts you have accumulated. You might then reach a saturation point full of only doubts and that is where the panic and fear creeps in.
Tragically, Skeptic brains 'emit fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought'
The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749
Isn't that the point I am making. Where would you in the real world have a person ask you about zero point energy. It is even rare to debate Big Bang and Dark matter unless you know you are conversing with another credible person in that field of study.
Skeptics pretend to be members of some kind of academia. The truth is there are legitimate groups already fulfilling that role. Science, religion, philosophy, climate change, politics, commerce, etc. etc.
Looking beyond the Skeptic and Skepticism and finding that treatable person is what drives me to these Skeptic Forums. I have seen what happens when people get addicted to anonymity and forget they are real people with real problems they have to face like education, job, responsibility and social consciousness. There is no cure for their stupidity. But it is our civic duty to sometimes protect the inept even on Skeptic forums.
Just because Skepticism is not a position, it is a process. We have to take a position against such human carnage.