Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Just too many points to deal with in one post.
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums. I have never been asked for citations or even questioned about my faith. There is a lot less paranoia outside Skeptic forums.
I have to protect the individuals privacy because it is really my concern. I knew the person and his dire situation before we entered the world of social media. But after joining a few Skeptic Forums I have noticed the drastic changes. He now denies not only what he knows which is little considering he is a school dropout, but who he is which is an unemployed welfare recipient for the last 10 years, but also where he is which is a failed single parent living is a dump.
But the biggest concern I have is his obsession engaging in endless arguments on forums hiding behind his anonymity. And the reason he can do that is because Skeptics are not very astute at seeing through the facade and reward doubt, a questioning attitude and uncertainty as evidence of critical thinking and evidence directed validation. But all the person is doing is putting the burden of proof on the other person and expecting to be educated about the subject in the process.
This can become tedious because you cannot raise a school drop-out to graduate level with a few well placed arguments. He needs the whole enchilada and months of your time. I haven`t seen him progress over the years because he cannot get an education debating on Skeptic forums. The smarts ones quit or are banned and the ones that remain share the same level of doubts and uncertainty that drew them to the forums in the first place.
I appreciate your interest in what I am attempting which is to understand why Skeptics are such disagreeable people. In an information age the more you know the better your chances are to succeed. And a Skeptic on welfare is not the success expected from applying critical thinking and simultaneously ignoring what is self evident.

It's OK, "Justin", aka "Justintime", aka "justinrapper", aka "jamalrapper"--most of the posters here understand how frustrating it is to deal with a habitual nym-shifter; especially one who tries to deny his identities...
 
"If the galaxy is teeming with intelligent life, then why haven't at least some of them been here"

I remember Sagan answering this question with something like this

"First, its long way here. What is there about us that makes us worth spending the time and effort to visit? Even if that civilisation was physically close to us, say, at Alpha Centauri, and somewhere near our level of technological development, a trip here would take them many thousands of years. If they were significantly more advanced that us, why would they even bother to visit us"

"Second, we have only just attained the technology to make our presence known, We have only been broadcasting for a hundred years, and only with enough power to be obvious in the last 70. We may not have even been noticed yet!"
 
Skepticism is simply the process by which someone can determine whether a given claim is true or not.

For example, if I walk up to someone in the street and tell them that I have a green cat in my pocket, they will be skeptical. If I suggest to you that I can flap my arms and fly, you will be skeptical. If I tell Mr Joe Random that my brain is made of blue vein cheese, he will be skeptical.

Similarly, when someone walks up to me and tells me that their Miracle Mineral Solution can cure cancer, I am skeptical. When someone tells me that they were brought aboard an alien ship and given a tour of the Andromeda galaxy, I am skeptical. When someone says that they can talk to my dead grandmother, I am skeptical.

This is all that skepticism is - a rubbish detector. Those of us who have been practising for a while have our rubbish detectors quite finely tuned. It's easier for us to tell when someone is talking rubbish because we have a lot of experience in working out what differentiates rubbish from non-rubbish.

All the rest is just baggage. We're human beings, after all, with all that being a human entails. We have emotions, relationships, likes and dislikes, different upbringings, different attitudes and different ways of looking at things. That's why we like to get together - so that we can compare and contrast our different styles. Sometimes we get into arguments. Sometimes we disagree. But we all agree that some claims are rubbish, and everybody ought to be able to tell what's rubbish and what isn't, in order to minimise the amount of unnecessary harm that these claims cause.
 
Skepticism is simply the process by which someone can determine whether a given claim is true or not.

For example, if I walk up to someone in the street and tell them that I have a green cat in my pocket, they will be skeptical. If I suggest to you that I can flap my arms and fly, you will be skeptical. If I tell Mr Joe Random that my brain is made of blue vein cheese, he will be skeptical.

Similarly, when someone walks up to me and tells me that their Miracle Mineral Solution can cure cancer, I am skeptical. When someone tells me that they were brought aboard an alien ship and given a tour of the Andromeda galaxy, I am skeptical. When someone says that they can talk to my dead grandmother, I am skeptical.

This is all that skepticism is - a rubbish detector. Those of us who have been practising for a while have our rubbish detectors quite finely tuned. It's easier for us to tell when someone is talking rubbish because we have a lot of experience in working out what differentiates rubbish from non-rubbish.

All the rest is just baggage. We're human beings, after all, with all that being a human entails. We have emotions, relationships, likes and dislikes, different upbringings, different attitudes and different ways of looking at things. That's why we like to get together - so that we can compare and contrast our different styles. Sometimes we get into arguments. Sometimes we disagree. But we all agree that some claims are rubbish, and everybody ought to be able to tell what's rubbish and what isn't, in order to minimise the amount of unnecessary harm that these claims cause.

Goddammit, man, you've left me nothing to say.

That's pretty much it, right there in a nutshell.
 
I know there are no skeptics outside skeptic forums.
No, you don't. You may or may not legitimately think that you know, but you're wrong.

I have never been asked for citations or even questioned about my faith.
So, what you're saying is, when you visit a forum that is specifically about skeptical inquiry, you encounter skeptical inquiry regarding claims you've made. Funny how that works.

Over in the religion and philosophy sub-forum, I've questioned a great many people about a great many claims. I've challenged them to produce evidence, pointed out flaws and fallacies in their arguments, etcetera. Know what I say when a nice old lady says "Thank you. God bless you" after I hold the door open for her at a store? I say "Thanks, you too".

There is a lot less paranoia outside Skeptic forums.
How did we get on the subject of paranoia?

I have to protect the individuals privacy because it is really my concern. I knew the person and his dire situation before we entered the world of social media. But after joining a few Skeptic Forums I have noticed the drastic changes. He now denies not only what he knows which is little considering he is a school dropout, but who he is which is an unemployed welfare recipient for the last 10 years, but also where he is which is a failed single parent living is a dump.
But the biggest concern I have is his obsession engaging in endless arguments on forums hiding behind his anonymity. And the reason he can do that is because Skeptics are not very astute at seeing through the facade and reward doubt, a questioning attitude and uncertainty as evidence of critical thinking and evidence directed validation. But all the person is doing is putting the burden of proof on the other person and expecting to be educated about the subject in the process.
This can become tedious because you cannot raise a school drop-out to graduate level with a few well placed arguments. He needs the whole enchilada and months of your time. I haven`t seen him progress over the years because he cannot get an education debating on Skeptic forums. The smarts ones quit or are banned and the ones that remain share the same level of doubts and uncertainty that drew them to the forums in the first place.
I appreciate your interest in what I am attempting which is to understand why Skeptics are such disagreeable people. In an information age the more you know the better your chances are to succeed. And a Skeptic on welfare is not the success expected from applying critical thinking and simultaneously ignoring what is self evident.
Even if I believed the above tale, what would it tell me about you?
 
It's OK, "Justin", aka "Justintime", aka "justinrapper", aka "jamalrapper"--most of the posters here understand how frustrating it is to deal with a habitual nym-shifter; especially one who tries to deny his identities...

Thanks, that led to some quick but informative search results. The analogy that often comes to my mind in situations like this is wondering whether someone is pooping his pants on a crowded bus because he doesn't know any better, or because he just likes the commotion it causes. I think I have my answer.
 
I was hoping that by posting my OP in the philosophy section someone could frame the difference between scientific skepticism and classical Hume, Descartes, Pyrrho and address the problems of the One and Many.

If you understand the scientific method you pretty well grasp scientific skepticism.
 
Skepticism is simply the process by which someone can determine whether a given claim is true or not.

For example, if I walk up to someone in the street and tell them that I have a green cat in my pocket, they will be skeptical. If I suggest to you that I can flap my arms and fly, you will be skeptical. If I tell Mr Joe Random that my brain is made of blue vein cheese, he will be skeptical.

Similarly, when someone walks up to me and tells me that their Miracle Mineral Solution can cure cancer, I am skeptical. When someone tells me that they were brought aboard an alien ship and given a tour of the Andromeda galaxy, I am skeptical. When someone says that they can talk to my dead grandmother, I am skeptical.

This is all that skepticism is - a rubbish detector. Those of us who have been practising for a while have our rubbish detectors quite finely tuned. It's easier for us to tell when someone is talking rubbish because we have a lot of experience in working out what differentiates rubbish from non-rubbish.

All the rest is just baggage. We're human beings, after all, with all that being a human entails. We have emotions, relationships, likes and dislikes, different upbringings, different attitudes and different ways of looking at things. That's why we like to get together - so that we can compare and contrast our different styles. Sometimes we get into arguments. Sometimes we disagree. But we all agree that some claims are rubbish, and everybody ought to be able to tell what's rubbish and what isn't, in order to minimise the amount of unnecessary harm that these claims cause.

:bigclap :bigclap
 
The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.
You clearly do not know, among other things('fiction' would probably be included in the other things), the meaning of 'hypocritical'
 
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, particularly in claims that are far fetched or that violate physical laws.

Carl Sagan did not need extraordinary evidence to spend his adult life searching for ETI (aliens). He just followed his early obsessions with flying saucers and aliens to fuel his scientific curiosity and a rather weak statistical probability based on arbitrary assumptions, hardly scientific by any definition or even scientifically skeptical.

:dl:
 
No kiddin puppycow, they are gonna have to change the definition of Obtuse to "see justintime" if he keeps this up
 
Just too many points to deal with in one post.

That is still why God invented paragraphs.

As far as the rest of your post goes, it seems to be a bunch of irrelevant nonsense about some guy you know, which you're then extrapolating to be true about every single sceptic on the internet. Do I really have to explain why this isn't a well thought out proposition?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom