Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

It is this troubling experience that drives me to reach out to Skeptics and get them to recognize most times the evidence is self evident.


Pardon me if I don't buy that.

Why don't you come out and say what woo you believe in, rather than presume to tell skeptics what you think they believe?
 
So, if skeptics are supposed to accept your adversarial definition of what "skeptical thought" or a "skeptical approach" "really is", does it follow that you accept the adversarial characterization of "religion" as "superstition", since the Random House Webster's Unabridged Dictionary (2nd ed) defines "superstition" as "any belief held without evidence"?

I am not a religious person but I do believe in defending the religious rights of people. And with 0ver 3 billion believers. It would take a lot of hating to hold all of them in contempt. I have made the effort to study comparative religion and many secular philosophies. And they all teach us about our humanity.
As for your question. There are many religions and then there are superstitions. So learn "The difference between religion and superstition".
http://mikio.hubpages.com/hub/The-difference-between-religion-and-superstition
 
I don't meet skeptics outside of Skeptic forums.
How do you know this? Do you ask everyone you meet? Most people apply skepticism to one degree or another, so I suspect you've met more than you realize.

So I am trying to understand what drives a Skeptic.
So far, you seem more determined to tell skeptics what you want them to believe.

Skeptic definition: 1. One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.
There are no doubt people who fit that definition, but on a forum such as this you are more likely to encounter people who define skepticism as an unwillingness to accept claims that have not met a certain scientific standard of empirical evidence. This isn't to say that such skeptics won't acknowledge the possibility of a claim.

How does a Skeptic communicate if he disagrees with generally accepted conclusions.
Generally with words.

There are millions of generally accepted conclusion a cumulative buildup of knowledge over the generations. How does a Skeptic go about validating every one of those assertions before accepting them.
It depends on the standard of evidence that they require of a given situation. Around here, most rely on the scientific method for claims about the natural universe.

I went through 10 pages of debating because the Skeptic member (on another forum) refused to believe what he said and wanted me to show him the evidence. And when I did he refused to accept that was what he meant.
Can you link to this discussion? It's just impossible to evaluate an exchange that we know nothing about.

Here was a single parent on welfare, a school dropout living in a crummy apartment making it through the month a bus token at a time refusing to believe not only what he said but also the dire conditions of his existence.
How do you know this? Did he tell you this, or is it something you've assumed?

It is this troubling experience that drives me to reach out to Skeptics and get them to recognize most times the evidence is self evident.
What evidence? What claim did you make?

I apologize for sounding off. And I agree not everyone here is a Skeptic, they might just be very insecure individuals.
Or they may simply be people with higher than average educations who have learned a thing or two about critical thinking and the scientific method.
 
I am not a religious person but I do believe in defending the religious rights of people.
And you think this makes you different from skeptics?

And with 0ver 3 billion believers. It would take a lot of hating to hold all of them in contempt.
I think there are more than three billion. And again, do you think that holding the religious in contempt is a defining characteristic of skeptics?

I have made the effort to study comparative religion and many secular philosophies. And they all teach us about our humanity.
You'll find a lot of skeptics on this forum who have also studied religion in great depth because it is so important to understanding humanity.

As for your question. There are many religions and then there are superstitions. So learn "The difference between religion and superstition".
http://mikio.hubpages.com/hub/The-difference-between-religion-and-superstition
Hardly an authoritative source. Looks an awful lot like special pleading to me.
 
Definition of Obsession: 1: a persistent disturbing preoccupation with an often unreasonable idea or feeling.

Well, Sagan's interest in the possibility of extraterrestrial life wasn't disturbing and the idea wasn't unreasonable. So I guess it wasn't an obsession.
 
It is like I am denouncing pornography as a social evil and at the same time making a phonographic movie with fictitious characters.
That's one of the worst analogies I've ever seen.

Why can't you seem to understand that one can accept the possibility that life exists elsewhere in the universe, but also conclude that there isn't any convincing evidence that it is visiting us here on Earth with the purpose of anally probing any idiot in a pickup truck?

Skepticism is not a position (has no moral conviction), it is a process. The process is only as good as the person processing it.
Duh.

Science has no moral convictions either. Morality is subjective and varies from person to person.
 
And he also wrote Contact which was all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters. Here he is pandering to the so called irrational and trying to profit from it after he claimed to be a Skeptic of UFOs. It is hard to be a scientist and not indulge in some wild speculations or vicariously live in fiction, what the real world cannot provide, except in fantasy land.

What a load of tosh! There wasn't a single UFO anywhere in the FICTION NOVEL Contact, and the only alien spacecraft was built by humans.

Also, it is not unusual for scientists and engineers to "cross over" to be science fiction authors and vice-versa.

You may have heard of Isaac Asimov, a prolific science fiction writer, but what you may not realise is that he also wrote over 60 books of non-fiction including textbooks on particle physics, astrophysics and chemistry. So wide ranging was his writings that his works have been published in all ten major categories of the Dewey Decimal system!

Fred Hoyle also comes to mind (the Black Cloud), and Gentry Lee, who is the chief engineer for the Planetary Flight Systems Directorate at JPL, co-wrote the "Rama" sequels with Arthur C. Clarke. Interestingly, Lee was also a series producer on Carl Sagan's "Cosmos".
 
That's one of the worst analogies I've ever seen.

Why can't you seem to understand that one can accept the possibility that life exists elsewhere in the universe, but also conclude that there isn't any convincing evidence that it is visiting us here on Earth with the purpose of anally probing any idiot in a pickup truck?


Duh.

Science has no moral convictions either. Morality is subjective and varies from person to person.

That should be of grave concern that science has no moral convictions. I have tried to accept Science as an amoral discipline. I also considered those scientist who help build the nuclear bomb. If scientist cannot be responsible for how it is used. Then their scientific curiosity should be subject to some restraint because of consequences they have not considered. Which brings to mind Stephen Hawking's warnings that we should avoid making contact with aliens because they might not have altruistic intentions.
Now try communicating that to a scientist like Carl Sagan who was obsessed with contacting aliens and supported by Skeptics who have yet to articulate the wisdom behind his obsession.
Stephen Hawking Warns Over Making Contact with Aliens
https://www.commondreams.org/headline/2010/04/25
 
But Sagan never denounced science fiction as a social evil.

Why would he? He was profiting from it. Alimony for 2 wives and married to the third. Any one gifted with critical thinking knows there are bills to be paid and suckers to pander to. Why he targeted Skeptics is the focus of my inquiry.
 
What a load of tosh! There wasn't a single UFO anywhere in the FICTION NOVEL Contact, and the only alien spacecraft was built by humans.

Also, it is not unusual for scientists and engineers to "cross over" to be science fiction authors and vice-versa.

You may have heard of Isaac Asimov, a prolific science fiction writer, but what you may not realise is that he also wrote over 60 books of non-fiction including textbooks on particle physics, astrophysics and chemistry. So wide ranging was his writings that his works have been published in all ten major categories of the Dewey Decimal system!

Fred Hoyle also comes to mind (the Black Cloud), and Gentry Lee, who is the chief engineer for the Planetary Flight Systems Directorate at JPL, co-wrote the "Rama" sequels with Arthur C. Clarke. Interestingly, Lee was also a series producer on Carl Sagan's "Cosmos".

Please read Plot summary for Contact. I have the same reaction with every Skeptic who claimed they read Contact. They all missed that part. This is why we group them as Skeptics. They all arrive at the same conclusion with different facts.

Wiki: A third message is discovered containing over 30,000 pages describing plans for a machine that appears to be a kind of highly advanced vehicle, with seats for five human beings. But they cannot understand the third message until they find the fourth message, a primer hidden in phase modulation.[2] The primer allows them to translate the alien language to human language.

Ultimately, a machine is successfully built and activated, transporting five passengers
 
Now try communicating that to a scientist like Carl Sagan who was obsessed with contacting aliens and supported by Skeptics who have yet to articulate the wisdom behind his obsession.

You keep making this claim, but you haven't established it (his purported obsession) as a fact.

In fact, I don't think he was obsessed with ETS and UFOs.
 
Last edited:
Please read Plot summary for Contact. I have the same reaction with every Skeptic who claimed they read Contact. They all missed that part. This is why we group them as Skeptics. They all arrive at the same conclusion with different facts.


It's fiction! And what's more, the plot summary you quoted actually supports smartcookie's comment that "there wasn't a single UFO anywhere in the FICTION NOVEL Contact, and the only alien spacecraft was built by humans".

But basically, it's fiction.
 
That should be of grave concern that science has no moral convictions. I have tried to accept Science as an amoral discipline. I also considered those scientist who help build the nuclear bomb. If scientist cannot be responsible for how it is used. Then their scientific curiosity should be subject to some restraint because of consequences they have not considered.

Who do you propose should subject this restraint, and what qualifies them for the task?


Which brings to mind Stephen Hawking's warnings that we should avoid making contact with aliens because they might not have altruistic intentions.

I fail to see the relevance. This suggestion is simply prudent in light of our presumed technological inferiority to an extraterrestrial race capable of interstellar travel. It really has nothing to do with skepticism, but rather self preservation.


Now try communicating that to a scientist like Carl Sagan who was obsessed with contacting aliens and supported by Skeptics who have yet to articulate the wisdom behind his obsession.

Being that you haven't established that Carl Sagan was actually obsessed with contacting aliens, why do you continue to accuse him of it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom