Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

It is like I am denouncing pornography as a social evil and at the same time making a phonographic movie with fictitious characters. Of course it is a fiction. The characters are not real so where is the connection. How is that hypocrisy?


Wow. That analogy is quite a leap from Carl Sagan writing a piece of fiction about exploring alien contact and being a skeptic on the issue of alien visitation. So distant a leap in fact that either could best be described as irrelevant to the other.

That is the problem with Skepticism. Skepticism is not a position (has no moral conviction), it is a process. The process is only as good as the person processing it.


Aha! That could be the crux of the problem right there. It appears you don't understand what skepticism is and how it's applied. No wonder your arguments seem filled with confusion and misunderstanding.
 
It is like I am denouncing pornography as a social evil and at the same time making a phonographic movie with fictitious characters. Of course it is a fiction. The characters are not real so where is the connection. How is that hypocrisy?
That is the problem with Skepticism. Skepticism is not a position (has no moral conviction), it is a process. The process is only as good as the person processing it.

Perhaps you could remind me in what way Contact is "about" credulous "UFO" "sightings", or about "alien abductions"? Have you ever read Contact? Did you even see the movie?
 
Too many points to deal with in one post. The point raise in the legal system was the play on the line "beyond a reasonable doubt." So Skeptics are entitled to their doubts but are they reasonable and what is their threshold for accepting evidence because it appears very subjective from one Skeptic to another.
First off, in this context, the word "skeptic" is not a proper noun, so I'm not sure why you've begun to capitalize it.

You appear to be conflating skepticism with cynicism. They are not the same. Many skeptics I've encountered are among the least cynical people I've met. Skepticism isn't about saying, "I refuse to believe it". Rather, it is about saying, "I need to be convinced".

And guess what? Skepticism is subjective. It's a method employed by people. I'm not sure why you would expect all skeptics to agree completely about standards of acceptable evidence, or why it would surprise you that some people can be skeptical regarding certain issues, yet also believe in ghosts or gods.

Skeptics are about debunking claims.
No, skeptics are about looking into claims in detail to see if they stack up against known reality. Everything we've learned through the application of the scientific method has been confirmed by skeptics.

According to Brian Dunning Skeptics are also Ghost believers and many are deeply religious. So what have they debunked?
You think that selective choices by certain individuals not to apply skepticism to certain areas invalidates the value of skepticism?

Skeptics are not experts in the field they criticize.
Really? Every skeptical peer review of a scientific publication is criticized by experts in the field. On this very forum I've seen crackpot claims about biology addressed by people with Ph.D.s in biology. I've seen an astrophysicist criticize statements regarding astronomy. I've seen engineers tear apart 9/11 conspiracy theories made by people who know nothing of engineering. I've seen geologists point out the fatal flaws in crazy theories about the Earth.

This was a follow up to the notion that Skeptics are critical thinkers and evidence based directed. But critical thinking is a university level course often introduced in undergraduate courses and most Skeptics are not at that level of education on Skeptics forums (no offense intended). So much that is debated by Skeptics are really outside their scope.
So you've taken university courses in critical thinking, and you assume that no self-described skeptics have?

Which brings us to extraordinary claims and extraordinary evidence. How many Skeptics can even raise to the level of understanding extraordinary evidence when they are barley coping with ordinary problems. I cited an example of a skeptic scientist Richard Muller who rejected climate change results because he was skeptical of its results even though it was peer reviewed research. He conducted his own research and came to the same conclusion. His research was denied peer review but Richard Muller announced he was now a climate change believer based on his own research which was a peer rejected study versus a peer reviewed one that he earlier denounced.
Could you cite a source for this, particularly of the part about Muller being denied peer review? Richard Muller supported the criticism leveled by two other scientists, Stephen McIntyre and Ross McKitrick, who pointed out flaws in the statistical analysis of a study led by Michael E. Mann. This very criticism that they were engaged in is the peer review process. Muller did not deny global warming. He wasn't saying that global warming wasn't real, and he never later "announced he was now a climate change believer".

So Skepticism is really a state of mind a psychological attribute of insecure individuals.
So you think that it is an attribute of insecurity to want to look at evidence in detail before deciding the merits of a claim? Is it a mark of a secure individual to simply believe whatever they are told?

Here's what I think. I think that you have a belief in something that you can't justify with facts or reason, and you've encountered many skeptics who have pointed out the logical flaws your arguments. But rather than address those flaws you've decided to poison the well by characterizing skeptics as as suffering from insecurity. Ironic, isn't it?
 
Wow. That analogy is quite a leap from Carl Sagan writing a piece of fiction about exploring alien contact and being a skeptic on the issue of alien visitation. So distant a leap in fact that either could best be described as irrelevant to the other.




Aha! That could be the crux of the problem right there. It appears you don't understand what skepticism is and how it's applied. No wonder your arguments seem filled with confusion and misunderstanding.

That was a quote by Dr. Shermer: Skepticism is not a position; it's a process.
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php

How would a Skeptic know who he is? :jaw-dropp

Dr. Michael Shermer is Founding Publisher of Skeptic magazine, Executive Director of the Skeptics Society, and columnist for Scientific American.

Guess who said this." When I am good I am really good. When I am bad I am even better. " :)
 
Skepticism: 1. A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety synonyms with uncertainty.

What problem do you have with this? Are you conflating doubt with refusal to believe? Do you question the value of thoroughly investigating claims of a scientific nature?
 
That was a quote by Dr. Shermer: Skepticism is not a position; it's a process.


The problem you seem to have here is some severe disconnect between your perception of skeptics and skepticism and how the process is actually applied, what sorts of results might be expected, and how to work those results into our understanding of the universe we live in.

What is your agenda, anyway? Are you a ghost believer? UFOs = aliens? Climate change isn't man made? You think you can see people's kidneys through their clothes and skin, and some skeptics were mean to you when you couldn't actually do it? Really, why all the anger and resentment toward skeptics? What is your unsupportable belief, and why are you reluctant to just start a thread about it and make your best case?
 
And he also wrote Contact which was all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters. Here he is pandering to the so called irrational and trying to profit from it after he claimed to be a Skeptic of UFOs. It is hard to be a scientist and not indulge in some wild speculations or vicariously live in fiction, what the real world cannot provide, except in fantasy land.

1. Contact is a work of fiction. It was Sagan imagining what it might be like if humans did detect a signal from an extraterrestrial civilization.

2. Being a skeptic of UFOs does not mean that one must also believe that life cannot exist elsewhere in the universe. That's as silly as thinking that if life exists elsewhere in the universe, then it must be visiting us here in UFOs.

3. Being skeptical about something is not the same as denying its possibility. When asked, Sagan generally stated that he was very doubtful about the legitimacy of UFO claims, but he never claimed to have epistemological certainty that they were not alien visitors.
 
What problem do you have with this? Are you conflating doubt with refusal to believe? Do you question the value of thoroughly investigating claims of a scientific nature?

Skepticism appears to match the definition of insecurity.
Compare.

Skepticism: 1. A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety synonyms with uncertainty.

Insecurity definition: 1. Not sure or certain; doubtful:

That is what I said in the OP. What is a Skeptic?

Why they might not be Skeptics but just very insecure individuals.

Link: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=248789
 
Last edited:
Skepticism appears to match the definition of insecurity.
Compare.

Skepticism: 1. A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety synonyms with uncertainty.

Insecurity definition: 1. Not sure or certain; doubtful:

That is what I said in the OP. What is a Skeptic?

Why they might not be Skeptics but just very insecure individuals.

Link: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=248789

So, if skeptics are supposed to accept your adversarial definition of what "skeptical thought" or a "skeptical approach" "really is", does it follow that you accept the adversarial characterization of "religion" as "superstition", since the Random House Webster's Unabridged Dictionary (2nd ed) defines "superstition" as "any belief held without evidence"?
 
But that is exactly the point. At 17 Carl Sagan believe in flying saucers and aliens. And took it seriously enough to write to the Sectary of State.
So what? As a child I believed in Jesus and UFOs.

Later he became a skeptic of UFOs as it is mentioned in his biographies.
So, let me get this straight: As he grew up and gained more knowledge, he revised his position to "UFOs are most likely a construct of human imagination". And?

But he did not lose his obsession with aliens. He spend the rest of his life looking for extraterrestrial intelligent life or aliens. That is a super sized obsession.
You continuing to call it an obsession is a transparently obvious attempt to discredit the man.

Definition of Extraterrestrial: originating, existing, or occurring outside the earth or its atmosphere.
Aliens as everyone knows are extraterrestrial.
Could you please explain why belief in UFOs must go hand in hand with the conclusion that it is possible for life to arise on another world through the same natural processes that resulted in life evolving on this world? I'd really like to know, because your entire argument hinges on this premise. Why can't someone conclude that there isn't any evidence that extraterrestrial life is visiting us here on Earth, but that it is still possible, even likely, that biology has evolved on other worlds?
 
Here's what I think. I think that you have a belief in something that you can't justify with facts or reason, and you've encountered many skeptics who have pointed out the logical flaws your arguments. But rather than address those flaws you've decided to poison the well by characterizing skeptics as as suffering from insecurity. Ironic, isn't it?

So Skepticism is really a state of mind a psychological attribute of insecure individuals.

Skeptics psychological attributes.

The Pyrrhonians, in contrast, did not claim that knowledge is impossible; rather, they suspended judgment on all such theoretical questions, thereby avoiding the mental discomfort that comes from taxing one's brain with insoluble problems. For them, skepticism was a mental attitude and a way of life, not an abstract philosophical position. The Pyrrhonist refused to judge or criticize the laws and customs of his society, resolving instead to accept things as they appear to be, without committing himself to any judgment about them. In this way he attained the psychological tranquillity of ataraxia.

ataraxia definition:
a state of tranquility free from anxiety and emotional disturbance.
Why a Skeptic seeks ataraxia or a stress free state to pacify his insecurity, uncertainty or doubting attitude.
 
What is your agenda, anyway? Are you a ghost believer? UFOs = aliens? Climate change isn't man made? You think you can see people's kidneys through their clothes and skin, and some skeptics were mean to you when you couldn't actually do it? Really, why all the anger and resentment toward skeptics? What is your unsupportable belief, and why are you reluctant to just start a thread about it and make your best case?

It would be quite nice if he/she would drop the other shoe and just spill the beans.

Then we could have a discussion.
 
Skeptics psychological attributes.



ataraxia definition:
a state of tranquility free from anxiety and emotional disturbance.
Why a Skeptic seeks ataraxia or a stress free state to pacify his insecurity, uncertainty or doubting attitude.

C'mon, spill the beans.

What woo do you do?
 
Skeptics psychological attributes.

ataraxia definition:
a state of tranquility free from anxiety and emotional disturbance.
Why a Skeptic seeks ataraxia or a stress free state to pacify his insecurity, uncertainty or doubting attitude.

Please don't smoke around all that straw.
 
That's why God invented paragraphs.



As I said above, your courtroom comparison is invalid. It doesn't become more valid through repetition.



Sceptics are about scepticism, critical thinking. Sometimes this involves debunking claims.



I don't know who Brian Dunning is, nor do I know why I should care. What I do know is that Brian Dunning should speak for himself.

That's assuming that you're accurately reporting what he's said, that is. I'm a little sceptical of your claim.



Which field is that? I'd love for you to tell me what I criticise.



I wonder if you thought about that paragraph critically before posting it? My guess would be not, but I'm willing to be persuaded, if evidence comes to light.



Where and when did you cite this example, what's it supposed to be an example of, and what point do you think that it proves?

Brian Dunning/ What is Skepticism?
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php

Brian Dunning: The true meaning of the word skepticism has nothing to do with doubt, disbelief, or negativity.
So where do we get the meaning of Skepticism?

I don't meet skeptics outside of Skeptic forums. So I am trying to understand what drives a Skeptic.
Skeptic definition: 1. One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.
How does a Skeptic communicate if he disagrees with generally accepted conclusions. There are millions of generally accepted conclusion a cumulative buildup of knowledge over the generations. How does a Skeptic go about validating every one of those assertions before accepting them.
I went through 10 pages of debating because the Skeptic member (on another forum) refused to believe what he said and wanted me to show him the evidence. And when I did he refused to accept that was what he meant.
Here was a single parent on welfare, a school dropout living in a crummy apartment making it through the month a bus token at a time refusing to believe not only what he said but also the dire conditions of his existence.
It is this troubling experience that drives me to reach out to Skeptics and get them to recognize most times the evidence is self evident.
I apologize for sounding off. And I agree not everyone here is a Skeptic, they might just be very insecure individuals.
 
Last edited:
Skeptics psychological attributes.



ataraxia definition:
a state of tranquility free from anxiety and emotional disturbance.
Why a Skeptic seeks ataraxia or a stress free state to pacify his insecurity, uncertainty or doubting attitude.

Do you consider yourself to be skeptical justintime?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom