Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

I don't seem to recall the UFO's or alien spacecraft in Contact. I DO seem to recall that it was speculative fiction about HOW an actual contact with ETI MIGHT go down, if it ever occurred.

Plus, it was, as you said,FICTION

The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.
 
But that is exactly the point. At 17 Carl Sagan believe in considered the possibility that flying saucers and aliens exist. And took it seriously enough to write to the Sectary of State and ask a question about a hypothetical situation. Later he became a skeptic of UFOs as it is mentioned in his biographies. But he did not lose his obsession with interest in the possibility of aliens. He spend the rest of his life looking for evidence that extraterrestrial intelligent life or aliens exist. That is a super sized obsession an avid interest.


Fixed that for you.
 
The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.

How is that hypocritical?
 
The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.

lol, how? Even if I don't believe in vampires I can still write a fictional story about vampires. Come on, this is just silly.
 
Last edited:
The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.


Please notice those words you wrote. Yeah, the ones I made into big red words. Right there. Yes, those are the words. Do you see what they say? Do you know what they mean?
 
And he also wrote Contact which was all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters. Here he is pandering to the so called irrational and trying to profit from it after he claimed to be a Skeptic of UFOs. It is hard to be a scientist and not indulge in some wild speculations or vicariously live in fiction, what the real world cannot provide, except in fantasy land.

As I,and others, have pointed out to you in several threads on other fora, Contact is a novel. A novel of speculative fiction. A novel written for entertainment. But please, feel free continue to claim that writing the novel is somehow a failing of Dr. Sagan's. Evidence would be nice...
 
Definition of Obsession: 1: a persistent disturbing preoccupation with an often unreasonable idea or feeling.


Like if someone had a persistent preoccupation with badmouthing skeptics and skepticism on various forums on the internet, disturbing to the extent that it manifests itself in expressing unreasonable ideas or feelings in a way that gets him banned from some of those forums? Like is that a fair description of an obsession? :p

No, Carl Sagan's interest was not an obsession.
 
Last edited:
Definition of Obsession: 1: a persistent disturbing preoccupation with an often unreasonable idea or feeling.

...You may have missed godless dave's question, so I am posting it again for you:
"Do you or do you not agree that looking for things is how you find out if things exist?"

I am also interested in your answer...
 
Evidently Sagan was so obsessed that he barely found time to earn two bachelor's degrees, a master's degree, and a doctorate; to write twenty best-selling works, some fiction but mostly nonfiction; to cowrite and host Cosmos, an extraordinarily popular award-winning TV series on the nature of science and the universe; to serve as a Professor of Astronomy at Cornell University and to direct the Laboratory for Planetary Studies there; to work as a consultant and advisor for NASA; to serve as a contributing editor/technology officer of the journal Icarus for more than a decade; to cofound the Planetary Society; to chair a division of the American Astronomical Society and become the President of the Planetologicy division of the American Geophysical Union; to marry (three times) and to father three children; to win thirty important awards, ranging from two Emmies to a Pulitzer Prize.

Sad that his consuming obsession prevented him from doing anything really worthwhile. Who knows what a brilliant career he might have had?
 
Last edited:
Clearly you take exception to the fact that many people here do not believe something you believe in. Would you care to share what it is that you believe in that you think we should? As you posted this in Religion and Philosophy I have a pretty good idea what it was but I won't put words in your mouth.

I was hoping that by posting my OP in the philosophy section someone could frame the difference between scientific skepticism and classical Hume, Descartes, Pyrrho and address the problems of the One and Many.
 
The information received contained the blueprint for a spacecraft. The spacecraft was built from that blueprint and used to contact the aliens.
Yes, it was a piece of fiction written and marketed at the same time he was also denouncing UFOs and alien encounters. Sounds hypocritical.

Was Walt Disney hypocritical because he knew mice can't talk and walk on two legs?
 
I was hoping that by posting my OP in the philosophy section someone could frame the difference between scientific skepticism and classical Hume, Descartes, Pyrrho and address the problems of the One and Many.

One is by itself and many is a lot.
 
I don't seem to recall the UFO's or alien spacecraft in Contact. I DO seem to recall that it was speculative fiction about HOW an actual contact with ETI MIGHT go down, if it ever occurred.

Plus, it was, as you said,FICTION

As a First Contact story Contact was not a patch on Dragon's Egg, which was "all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters"

scientists! why don't they stick to science (whatever that is) instead of writing FICTION (which is just an euphemism for "lies").
 
I was hoping that by posting my OP in the philosophy section someone could frame the difference between scientific skepticism and classical Hume, Descartes, Pyrrho and address the problems of the One and Many.

I hope you will take this as a friendly hint, "mate", but by starting your post with an erroneous, and argumentative, and incomplete, and adversarial, definition, you almost guaranteed the kind of response you are, in fact. getting.
If you want to discuss the "difference between scientific skepticism and classical Hume, Descartes, Pyrrho" and "address the problems of the One and Many", you might consider a post along these lines:

"I am hoping that someone here will be willing to frame for me the differences among what I shall call "scientific skepticism", Hume, Descartes, and Pyrrho; and, in addition, perhaps address the problems of the "One and Many"."

That way, it does not look as if you are simply pursuing an "obsession" with insulting and denigrating skeptics and skeptical thinkers into a new forum from which you have not been banned.

YMMV
 
How is that hypocritical?

It is like I am denouncing pornography as a social evil and at the same time making a phonographic movie with fictitious characters. Of course it is a fiction. The characters are not real so where is the connection. How is that hypocrisy?
That is the problem with Skepticism. Skepticism is not a position (has no moral conviction), it is a process. The process is only as good as the person processing it.
 
Too many points to deal with in one post.

That's why God invented paragraphs.

The point raise in the legal system was the play on the line "beyond a reasonable doubt." So Skeptics are entitled to their doubts but are they reasonable and what is their threshold for accepting evidence because it appears very subjective from one Skeptic to another.

As I said above, your courtroom comparison is invalid. It doesn't become more valid through repetition.

Skeptics are about debunking claims.

Sceptics are about scepticism, critical thinking. Sometimes this involves debunking claims.

According to Brian Dunning Skeptics are also Ghost believers and many are deeply religious. So what have they debunked?

I don't know who Brian Dunning is, nor do I know why I should care. What I do know is that Brian Dunning should speak for himself.

That's assuming that you're accurately reporting what he's said, that is. I'm a little sceptical of your claim.

Skeptics are not experts in the field they criticize.

Which field is that? I'd love for you to tell me what I criticise.

This was a follow up to the notion that Skeptics are critical thinkers and evidence based directed. But critical thinking is a university level course often introduced in undergraduate courses and most Skeptics are not at that level of education on Skeptics forums (no offense intended). So much that is debated by Skeptics are really outside their scope.

I wonder if you thought about that paragraph critically before posting it? My guess would be not, but I'm willing to be persuaded, if evidence comes to light.

Which brings us to extraordinary claims and extraordinary evidence. How many Skeptics can even raise to the level of understanding extraordinary evidence when they are barley coping with ordinary problems. I cited an example of a skeptic scientist Richard Muller who rejected climate change results because he was skeptical of its results even though it was peer reviewed research. He conducted his own research and came to the same conclusion. His research was denied peer review but Richard Muller announced he was now a climate change believer based on his own research which was a peer rejected study versus a peer reviewed one that he earlier denounced.
So Skepticism is really a state of mind a psychological attribute of insecure individuals.

Where and when did you cite this example, what's it supposed to be an example of, and what point do you think that it proves?
 
As a First Contact story Contact was not a patch on Dragon's Egg, which was "all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters"

scientists! why don't they stick to science (whatever that is) instead of writing FICTION (which is just an euphemism for "lies").

Thank you for reminding me of Dragon's Egg. It's been too long...
 
It is like I am denouncing pornography as a social evil and at the same time making a phonographic movie with fictitious characters. Of course it is a fiction. The characters are not real so where is the connection. How is that hypocrisy?
That is the problem with Skepticism. Skepticism is not a position (has no moral conviction), it is a process. The process is only as good as the person processing it.

It's true! Vinyl is only as sexy as the lady wearing it.
 
As a First Contact story Contact was not a patch on Dragon's Egg, which was "all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters"

scientists! why don't they stick to science (whatever that is) instead of writing FICTION (which is just an euphemism for "lies").

Contact Movie: Plot summary:

Wiki: A third message is discovered containing over 30,000 pages describing plans for a machine that appears to be a kind of highly advanced vehicle, with seats for five human beings.
Ultimately, a machine is successfully built and activated, transporting five passengers
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom