And he also wrote Contact which was all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters. Here he is pandering to the so called irrational and trying to profit from it after he claimed to be a Skeptic of UFOs. It is hard to be a scientist and not indulge in some wild speculations or vicariously live in fiction, what the real world cannot provide, except in fantasy land.
I am not erecting a strawman. I am relating what Carl Sagan actually did.
No. Many skeptics are driven to seek knowledge. So much so that they are prone to ask "but what if this claim is wrong?" regarding a great many things. So skeptics simply hold claims to a higher standard of evidence than the more credulous.
Your analogy does not seem relevant. The whole idea behind innocence until proof of guilt is derived from the moral position that it is better that a guilty person go unpunished than an innocent person be punished. Thus, in legal systems that make such a moral judgement, skepticism is applied to the charges leveled against a defendant.
Examples?
That is where it belongs. If you claim that a '67 Dodge Dart is orbiting a star in the Andromeda galaxy, that your god has given you supernatural powers, or that the sparkly rocks that you sell for $500 will cure all forms of cancer, then the burden of proof lies with you.
Yes, it is a challenge to provide sound evidence of a claim. Many extraordinary claims have met that challenge: Heliocentricism, relativity, metric expansion of space, continental drift.
But you seem to be conflating this challenge with a mean-spirited aggression. Are you, perhaps, an exponent of some hypothesis or claim that has failed the challenge?
More often than not, those discussing any subject are not experts in the field being deliberated. This does not invalidate any consensus reached by those who are experts in the field.
That sounds an awful lot like an excuse to dismiss anyone who does not accept your ideas. Do you suggest seeking out the company of the credulous when attempting to deduce the truth of a claim?
Subject to what?
Ah, the 'poisoning the well' fallacy.
Skeptics are not experts in the field they criticize.
Your logic is totally flawed.
1. If he did not think aliens were a threat why did he write to the Sectary of State concerned if they were prepared for an alien attack.
It would be even more dumb if you went looking for evidence of something you didn't believe in.3. It is dumb to say he was looking for the evidence of ETI but did not believe in them. In fact you got it backwards. He had to know what he was looking for. He had to tell people who were funding him what he was looking for and also convince them of the chance/probability of finding them after he convinced himself.
Your logic is totally flawed.
1. If he did not think aliens were a threat why did he write to the Sectary of State concerned if they were prepared for an alien attack.
In fact he is not alone in thinking aliens are threatening. Stephen Hawkins is another scientist who warns of making contact with aliens because they might not have altruistic intentions.
2. Nothing has been explained to me. You are the one asking the questions.
3. It is dumb to say he was looking for the evidence of ETI but did not believe in them. In fact you got it backwards. He had to know what he was looking for. He had to tell people who were funding him what he was looking for and also convince them of the chance/probability of finding them after he convinced himself. He had to make them believe they exists. All this even before he started looking for them or as you like to say evidence of them. The evidence of ETI would go a long way to validate his beliefs and convictions of their existence. Just like the results of a scientific research can confirm or invalidate the hypothesis.
Which brings us to extraordinary claims and extraordinary evidence. How many Skeptics can even raise to the level of understanding extraordinary evidence when they are barley coping with ordinary problems. I cited an example of a skeptic scientist Richard Muller who rejected climate change results because he was skeptical of its results even though it was peer reviewed research. He conducted his own research and came to the same conclusion. His research was denied peer review but Richard Muller announced he was now a climate change believer based on his own research which was a peer rejected study versus a peer reviewed one that he earlier denounced.
So Skepticism is really a state of mind a psychological attribute of insecure individuals.
Which brings us to extraordinary claims and extraordinary evidence. How many Skeptics can even raise to the level of understanding extraordinary evidence when they are barley coping with ordinary problems. I cited an example of a skeptic scientist Richard Muller who rejected climate change results because he was skeptical of its results even though it was peer reviewed research. He conducted his own research and came to the same conclusion. His research was denied peer review but Richard Muller announced he was now a climate change believer based on his own research which was a peer rejected study versus a peer reviewed one that he earlier denounced.
So Skepticism is really a state of mind a psychological attribute of insecure individuals.
BTW, Sagan was 17 when he wrote that letter to the DOD about aliens. But you probably knew that and hoped we wouldn't....
He stated clearly that he found it very possible for ETI to exist, but he did not say that he "believed hey existed". He clearly states in one of his books that he thinks that UFO's were a construct of The Cold War, and that both sides used this fear as a tool of propaganda.
so, in other words, you have nothing but accusations, and no evidence to back it up. (except trying to wash over an esteemed scientists entire career with the fact that when he was 17 he was interested in UFOs enough to write a letter to the Gubbmint.)
And he also wrote Contact which was all about UFOs, alien spacecraft and alien encounters. Here he is pandering to the so called irrational and trying to profit from it after he claimed to be a Skeptic of UFOs. It is hard to be a scientist and not indulge in some wild speculations or vicariously live in fiction, what the real world cannot provide, except in fantasy land.
But that is exactly the point. At 17 Carl Sagan believe in flying saucers and aliens. And took it seriously enough to write to the Sectary of State. Later he became a skeptic of UFOs as it is mentioned in his biographies. But he did not lose his obsession with aliens. He spend the rest of his life looking for extraterrestrial intelligent life or aliens. That is a super sized obsession.
If I spend time researching whether there is nitrogen in the atmosphere of Mars does it mean that I believe nitrogen exists in the atmosphere of Mars?
Your logic is totally flawed.
1. If he did not think aliens were a threat why did he write to the Sectary of State concerned if they were prepared for an alien attack.