Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

No one has come forward with the same depth and referenceable material on Carl Sagan on this forum before me.
Cherry picking search engine results on the fly hardly qualifies as a "depth of referenceable material".

I am not an expert on Carl Sagan.
We've noticed.

But I am a pioneer in seeking the truth behind the iconic skeptic Carl Sagan.
No, you are attempting to advance your ignorant prejudices in the face of contradictory evidence. You have made clear your willingness to ignore truth should it controvert your preconceived notions.

You can challenge my claim by directing me to an OP where Carl Sagan was discussed at even greater length and depth on this forum before. All that is available are snippets of him and the largest OP discusses his religion. We know he claimed to be an agnostic.
What do you expect that will prove. Do you really think that an argument with more words beats any argument with fewer words? That's interesting.

My OP is drawing such interest that in just 3 days it has surpassed all other threads on Carl Sagan...
Again, go look up DavidJayJordan. That guy's threads were very busy.

...in views counted except on the subject of his religious beliefs. And that just reflects the real interest Skeptics have......RELIGION!!!!

In fact all Skeptics sites suffer the same problem. It is Skeptics struggling with religion or the obsession with refuting religion. And in doing so are neglecting so many other areas of their development.
Looks like that wall of inscrutability may be cracking. Might we soon find out why you're really here?

I am the only one here highlighting these issues by using Carl Sagan as the best understood example of the dichotomy Skeptics suffer from.
What dichotomy? Seriously, what dichotomy do you believe you are highlighting? You aren't just parroting another word you've seen here without really understanding what it means, are you?
 
Last edited:
Try to explain why so few scientists are employed.

As of 2008, approximately 2-3 percent of the population is directly employed in agriculture.[6]

Agriculture in the United StatesWP

Do you realize the fundamental difference between the statement "Scientists and engineers make up only 5% of the labor force". and the statement, "Only 5% of scientists and engineers are employed"?

I am truly curious...

Ouch, I really hope that's not what he meant. Though either way it's dumb and dumber.
 
Why he constantly refers to ETI as advanced civilizations. What evidence did he have they even existed let alone they were intelligent?

You still appear to be confused.

See if you can't work it out for yourself. Why might Sagan have said SETI was a project looking for signs of "advanced civilizations"?

Here's a clue: If he had said they were looking for radio transmissions from aliens more primitive than ourselves you might have a point in criticizing him.
 
What's clear, having watched the video (it's from Cosmos), is that Justinian needs to learn to listen as well as learn to read.
 
No one has come forward with the same depth and referenceable material on Carl Sagan on this forum before me.

********. When I asked you for your references you told me to Google him.


<edit> Regarding my opening remark, I hope it's not considered to be an evasion of the autocensor to recall that waggish people used to say of the Isle of Wight ferry that it is brown, it steams and it comes out of Cowes backwards.
 
Last edited:
Try to explain why so few scientists are employed.

(February 2012) Scientists and engineers make up only about 5 percent of the U.S. labor force.

This is part of a series of PRB articles about the science and engineering workforce in the United States, funded by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. Data for this article are based on the Population Reference Bureau's analysis of the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey.


It might be a good idea if you don't post here again until you have read this book.
 
What makes you think that being insecure and sceptic is at most improbable? You seem annoyed to have found counterexamples preventing you to claim that it is impossible for those to coexist in the same person. What's your real point here? If "true" sceptics don't exist then evolution is a myth? The insecurity that makes you believe in a god is better than alleged Sagan's (which makes him believe in.... nothing)? Why?

I am trying to be as analytically correct as possible and that is why I use definitions so there is little room for semantic errors.

I said I never met skeptics outside of Skeptic forums. I met and know many insecure people who are full of doubts, uncertain and generally fearful about security, appearance or social status. But they are not self declared skeptics and admit they are just insecure.

Definition of insecure. A person who is not confident or assured; uncertain or anxious.

You can see by definition not all insecure people are skeptics. So I applied that to the members of this forum claiming to be skeptics on a Skeptic Forum.
That They might not be skeptics but just insecure individuals.

Now having analyzed a sufficient number of skeptics on several Skeptic forums. I am of discovering that Skeptics are insecure too. So it is possible for one to be both a skeptic and insecure too.

Because by definition a Skeptic is: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

So there is little doubt that Skeptics are insecure people.

So what is Skepticism?
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php
 
Last edited:
so your research is analyzing internet forums.....tells me all I need to know.

Applies baloney Detection Kit.......Baloney detected.
 
so your research is analyzing internet forums.....tells me all I need to know.

Applies baloney Detection Kit.......Baloney detected.

It is called rational thinking. Critical thinking only invites critics who are offended by the persons critical attitude or critical comments. I try to stay on the rational side so the discussions are more civil and actually advances peoples logic.
 
As the basis of your assertisons about other people is totally based on trawling internet forums I see no credible evidential base for your views and therefore and complete lack of a rational thought out research project.
 
In my experience people who are insecure tend to seek security by subscribing to beliefs (especially, but not excusively, religious beliefs) which claim to be able to offer certainties where none actually exist. It takes someone who is pretty secure in most areas of their life - emotionally, professionally etc - to accept that no such certainties are possible, that everything must be questioned, and to be all right with that.
 
I am trying to be as analytically correct as possible and that is why I use definitions so there is little room for semantic errors.

Sigh.
Using definitions, especially current definitions, is good--particularly when you provede accurate citations for those definitions, so that your presentation of a definition can be assessed for completeness and accuracy.

Pretending that one definition in one general dictionary represents an accurate definition of the way a word is used in practice, particularly words that are jargon terms, is not so good (particularly when your error is pointed out to you). Charitably, this practice demonstrates a certain laziness; a certain disregard for reality. When it is continually and continuously repeated, this practice looks dishonest.

I said I never met skeptics outside of Skeptic forums. I met and know many insecure people who are full of doubts, uncertain and generally fearful about security, appearance or social status. But they are not self declared skeptics and admit they are just insecure.

So you have never met skeptics in TRW, yet you feel qualified to declare that "insecure people full of doubt" = "skeptics on this forum"?
Fascinating.
Odd, and incorrect, but fascinating.

Definition of insecure. A person who is not confident or assured; uncertain or anxious.

What is your citation for this "definition"? It has certain characteristics that make it suspect as an accurate quote. Be so kind as to provide for me its source...

You can see by definition not all insecure people are skeptics. So I applied that to the members of this forum claiming to be skeptics on a Skeptic Forum.
That They might not be skeptics but just insecure individuals.

I will address "claiming to be skeptics" another time.

Now having analyzed a sufficient number of skeptics on several Skeptic forums. I am of discovering that Skeptics are insecure too. So it is possible for one to be both a skeptic and insecure too.

In what way is your adversarial, dishonest, and contentious reaction with skeptics on this forum (not to mention other fora from which you have been banned) "analysis"?
In what way is pointing out errors in your logic, discrepancies in your claims, inconsistencies in your "facts", and the pellucid paucity of your preparation a demonstration of "insecurity"? Where did you get your certification in Psychology?

Because by definition a Skeptic is: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

Be so good as to provide a citation for this "definition".
I have offered you multiple actual definitions, with complete citations, from multiple sources, developed by skeptical thinkers, that refute your "definition". Be so kind as to explain why your contentious, adversarial, incorrect "definition" is supposed to be more accurate than actual definitions attested by actual skeptical thinkers.

So there is little doubt that Skeptics are insecure people.

1. Be so kind as to stop capitalizing "Skeptics" at least unless and until you answer my question about differences among "Skeptics", "skeptics", and "skeptical thinkers".
2. You may, in fact, have little doubt. You have done nothing to address the doubts of reasonable, rational, skeptical posters on this or any other forum. You are, quite simply, assuming your conclusion


From your link:
"The true meaning of the word skepticism has nothing to do with doubt, disbelief, or negativity. Skepticism is the process of applying reason and critical thinking to determine validity. It's the process of finding a supported conclusion, not the justification of a preconceived conclusion."

and

"Skepticism is, or should be, an extraordinarily powerful and positive influence on the world. Skepticism is not simply about "debunking" as is commonly charged. Skepticism is about redirecting attention, influence, and funding away from worthless superstitions and toward projects and ideas that are evidenced to be beneficial to humanity and to the world."

and

"The scientific method is central to skepticism. The scientific method requires evidence, preferably derived from validated testing. Anecdotal evidence and personal testimonies generally don't meet the qualifications for scientific evidence, and thus won't often be accepted by a responsible skeptic; which often explains why skeptics get such a bad rap for being negative or disbelieving people. They're simply following the scientific method."

...there seems to be very little* there about fear, or insecurity...

This is why I always ask you for your sources.

(*for sufficiently nonexistent values of "very little")
 
Last edited:
It is called rational thinking. Critical thinking only invites critics who are offended by the persons critical attitude or critical comments. I try to stay on the rational side so the discussions are more civil and actually advances peoples logic.

These sentences of yours . . . perhaps you could assemble them in such a manner that they express something.

Thanks in advance.
 
I am trying to be as analytically correct as possible and that is why I use definitions so there is little room for semantic errors.

I said I never met skeptics outside of Skeptic forums. I met and know many insecure people who are full of doubts, uncertain and generally fearful about security, appearance or social status. But they are not self declared skeptics and admit they are just insecure.

Definition of insecure. A person who is not confident or assured; uncertain or anxious.

You can see by definition not all insecure people are skeptics. So I applied that to the members of this forum claiming to be skeptics on a Skeptic Forum.That They might not be skeptics but just insecure individuals.

Now having analyzed a sufficient number of skeptics on several Skeptic forums. I am of discovering that Skeptics are insecure too. So it is possible for one to be both a skeptic and insecure too.

Because by definition a Skeptic is: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

So there is little doubt that Skeptics are insecure people.

So what is Skepticism?
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php

I don't get why you quoted me as you don't address any of my points. Why is your own insecurity worthier than the one you attribute to sceptics?

Highlighted part: if you don't see where the logic flaws are I recommend you take Logic 101 and then come back, for a regular discussion can't take place in such circumstances.
 
Yes, that only proves Carl Sagan was never sure of anything and that comes across clearly in most of his videos. If you add all the IF, POSSIBLE, MAYBE, and NOT IS and ARE. You will understand why he struggled to articulate a true position even near the conclusion of his life.

This is why people are suspicious of scientist. They have more disclaimers than actual facts in their research.

One thing you can never accuse him of is struggling to be articulate. He was the most clear and concise science presenter of his generation. IMO, that mantle has now been handed over to Professor Brian Cox.

Please do not confuse the way Sagan speaks with "not knowing" or "not understanding", because these are the positions from which ALL science proceeds; we don't understand something, and we want to, so we postulate, theorise, research, study, experiment, reassess and conclude until we do understand. The problem in science is that often, when he get an answer, it raises many more questions.

After reading the many posts you have posted here, and the many contradictions you have written, I have come to the conclusion that you are a LGM obsessed teenager with a poor grasp of language almost zero ability at comprehension and you have utterly no idea what you are talking about.
 
No one has come forward with the same depth and referenceable material on Carl Sagan on this forum before me. I am not an expert on Carl Sagan. But I am a pioneer in seeking the truth behind the iconic skeptic Carl Sagan.

Now where the hell is that laughing dog?


Oh wait, here it is...

:dl:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom