Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

As I have patiently explained to you before, (although perhaps not, as I think of it, on this forum), I do not like to watch videos for information. Above and beyond the fact that people speak so much more slowly than I read, there is a personal consideration...with the deterioration of my hearing, I find it impractical to set the volume of my computer high enough to for me to hear it--and at that volume, it is disturbing to my partner while my partner is working...not to mention being fuzzy and distorted (the audio, not my partner).
So, no thank you; I will read Dr, Sagan's words instead. Perhaps you know of a location where the transcript of the video might be found?



The simple act of reading any of Dr., Sagan's explanations would demonstrate that the attribution of "advanced civilization" to extra-terrestrial intelligences that it would be possible for us to detect on Earth is due to the fact that a "primitive civilization" (such as Earth's) is capable of doing very little that is, in fact, detectable, or perceptible, at intergalactic distances.

We do not have "evidence" that extraterrestrial intelligences exist, which is why privately-funded organizations are looking for them. If we had hard evidence of the existence of extraterrestrial intelligences; if we knew they were there, we would not be looking for them, but trying to figure out how (and whether) to contact them.



Not having read "(all) his work" (or, for that matter, according to your own report, any of his work, how do you think you know this?
Further, developing and investigating conjecture is a real, and vital, part of the nature of this enterprise we call "science" (along with, for instance, skeptical thought).



It has been pointed out to you, patiently and repeatedly, that Dr, Sagan's interest in debunking unsupported tales of UFO visits" and "alien abductions", even coupled with his fascination with the possibility of the existence, somewhere in the universe, of intelligent life, does not constitute an "obsession". Might I ask why you persist in the straw-man characterization?
If you are of the unshakable opinion, in the face of contrary evidence, that Dr. Sagan's interest constituted an "obsession", consider phrasing it as such...an opinion. Your own opinion.

and an opinion based on total ignorance of what Carl Sagan acutally siad and did in his working life.
 
So few scientists are employed simply becasue very few people are scientists.
 
It is my opinion that if there were more scientists than say priests or looney radio hosts the world would have a chance of being a better place.
 
Try to explain why so few scientists are employed.

What? That doesn't even make sense!

Scientists are employed as scientists, not everyone in the workforce is a scientist.

What percentage of the labour force are Dentists? What percentage are Lumberjacks?
 
And Carl Sagan was a thorough scientist which would be proved by even a cursory reading of jsut some of his books....

oh wait justin has not read those..
 
There's nothing quite as funny as using a global computer network as a medium to criticize scientists.
 
Especailly dead ones who cannot reply to the inane comments made about them
 
Next you will be saying my brilliant twin wrote all this. Get real. :)

I'll say that there does appear to be a difference between your posts in the first few pages of this thread on those on the latter pages.

Whether any of them are brilliant or not . . .
 
I relied not only on Carl Sagan's biographies but also researched what he actually said.
But never bothered to actually read any of his books. Doing quick Google searches in order to cherry pick phrases that you think will support your prejudicial opinion isn't research.

He had several positions on UFOs...
List some of them.

...and offered several explanations...
Thats what smart people do. They consider every possibility that they can conceive of and then evaluate them to see how they conform to known reality. Forming quick opinions based on little evidence and then clinging obstinately to those opinions in the face of all contradictory evidence out of the belief that admitting error, or acknowledging one's own ignorance, is a sign of weakness, is what stupid people do.

...while making sure we all understood that only the credible evidence was lacking.
So he looked at the explanations offered, offered some speculative possibilities of his own, then noted that there is no credible evidence supporting the hypothesis that UFO sightings are the result of alien visitation. Then he concluded that, while it was possible that evidence might be presented in the future, there is no logical reason to believe that UFOs are alien craft.

The fact that you think Sagan's approach was unreasonable says more about you than it does him.

Just as his SETI project was to look for ETI. It would be the evidence that would finally prove they exist.
No, it is a test of an hypothesis. SETI researchers wondered (and still do) if other civilizations might broadcast radiation that we can detect. So they are listening to see if they can detect anything. If they can't, then SETI is not a failure, because it isn't intended to prove that alien civilizations exist. It is a test to answer a question: Can we detect broadcasts from other civilizations? Yes/No. There are no wrong answers in science. The fact that you seem to think that scientists only investigate things that they are already convinced exist only serves to establish your own profound ignorance of the scientific method.

Michael Shermer cites only 55,000 skeptic subscribers for his Skeptics Magazine. Skeptic movement claims only 1 million skeptics.
And you think that every skeptic subscribes to Skeptic Magazine or belongs to a skeptical "movement"?

But there are billions of rational people and billions of believers (religious) who were not convinced Carl Sagan would find ETI and were proven right.
Making up statistics again?

Carl Sagan on advanced civilizations visting Earth (Carl Sagan at one point suggest they might even be HERE and hiding).
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOcfCkUBsdc
Again, considering all the possibilities you can think of and then evaluating them logically to determine if they are confirmed, disproved or undetermined, is what smart people do.
 
No one has come forward with the same depth and referenceable material on Carl Sagan on this forum before me. I am not an expert on Carl Sagan. But I am a pioneer in seeking the truth behind the iconic skeptic Carl Sagan. You can challenge my claim by directing me to an OP where Carl Sagan was discussed at even greater length and depth on this forum before. All that is available are snippets of him and the largest OP discusses his religion. We know he claimed to be an agnostic.

My OP is drawing such interest that in just 3 days it has surpassed all other threads on Carl Sagan in views counted except on the subject of his religious beliefs. And that just reflects the real interest Skeptics have......RELIGION!!!!

In fact all Skeptics sites suffer the same problem. It is Skeptics struggling with religion or the obsession with refuting religion. And in doing so are neglecting so many other areas of their development.

I am the only one here highlighting these issues by using Carl Sagan as the best understood example of the dichotomy Skeptics suffer from.
 
From his biography.

As Mashuna suggested, you should probably invest in a course on reading comprehension. It might have helped you to comprehend that, just because Sagan was best know to the general public for commenting on the possibility of extraterrestrial life, it doesn't follow that this was the focus of his career.
 
No one has come forward with the same depth and referenceable material on Carl Sagan on this forum before me. I am not an expert on Carl Sagan. But I am a pioneer in seeking the truth behind the iconic skeptic Carl Sagan. You can challenge my claim by directing me to an OP where Carl Sagan was discussed at even greater length and depth on this forum before. All that is available are snippets of him and the largest OP discusses his religion. We know he claimed to be an agnostic.

My OP is drawing such interest that in just 3 days it has surpassed all other threads on Carl Sagan in views counted except on the subject of his religious beliefs. And that just reflects the real interest Skeptics have......RELIGION!!!!

In fact all Skeptics sites suffer the same problem. It is Skeptics struggling with religion or the obsession with refuting religion. And in doing so are neglecting so many other areas of their development.

I am the only one here highlighting these issues by using Carl Sagan as the best understood example of the dichotomy Skeptics suffer from.

Quit capitalizing the word skeptic(s) already.

And quit diagnosing.
 
No one has come forward with the same depth and referenceable material on Carl Sagan on this forum before me. I am not an expert on Carl Sagan. But I am a pioneer in seeking the truth behind the iconic skeptic Carl Sagan. You can challenge my claim by directing me to an OP where Carl Sagan was discussed at even greater length and depth on this forum before. All that is available are snippets of him and the largest OP discusses his religion. We know he claimed to be an agnostic.

My OP is drawing such interest that in just 3 days it has surpassed all other threads on Carl Sagan in views counted except on the subject of his religious beliefs. And that just reflects the real interest Skeptics have......RELIGION!!!!

In fact all Skeptics sites suffer the same problem. It is Skeptics struggling with religion or the obsession with refuting religion. And in doing so are neglecting so many other areas of their development.

I am the only one here highlighting these issues by using Carl Sagan as the best understood example of the dichotomy Skeptics suffer from.

In all your referencing, all you've done is confirm that Carl Sagan was, in fact, a skeptic.
 
You have been given an extensive bibliography and you are no pioneer, you ahve chosoen to ignore it.

And again you present a FALSE dichotomy, Carl Sagan was a scientist, scientists deal with hypotheses which are then tested and become theories if any credible evidence is found to support the original hypothesis. THAT is waht Carl Sagan DID, all you ahve done is misrepresent him while openly declaring you know nothing about his work becasue you have openly stated you HAVE NOT read any of his books.
 
No one has come forward with the same depth and referenceable material on Carl Sagan on this forum before me.

...you mean, no one has stooped to your level of innuendo, preferring, as is the wont of good thinkers, to use Dr. Sagan's own work to judge the man...contentious, second-hand sources do not constitute "depth". You really, really ought to read Dr. Sagan's own words.

I am not an expert on Carl Sagan.

Really?

But I am a pioneer in seeking the truth behind the iconic skeptic Carl Sagan. You can challenge my claim by directing me to an OP where Carl Sagan was discussed at even greater length and depth on this forum before. All that is available are snippets of him and the largest OP discusses his religion. We know he claimed to be an agnostic.

Or, as has been suggested repeatedly, you could read the majority of his corpus before you judge him on second-hand, contentious "analyses"...
You could even consider litening to those who have, in fact, read Dr. Sagan's work.

My OP is drawing such interest that in just 3 days it has surpassed all other threads on Carl Sagan in views counted except on the subject of his religious beliefs. And that just reflects the real interest Skeptics have......RELIGION!!!!

Of course, you are completely missing the groupo dynamic of the fascination with a train wreck. Consider the actions of T-cells...

In fact all Skeptics sites suffer the same problem. It is Skeptics struggling with religion or the obsession with refuting religion. And in doing so are neglecting so many other areas of their development.

Evidence?

I am the only one here highlighting these issues by using Carl Sagan as the best understood example of the dichotomy Skeptics suffer from.

Thank you for finally revealing your true agenda.

Moderators, might we get these three threads merged, perhaps in R&P, perhaps elsewhere?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom