Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

I don't get why you quoted me as you don't address any of my points. Why is your own insecurity worthier than the one you attribute to sceptics?

Highlighted part: if you don't see where the logic flaws are I recommend you take Logic 101 and then come back, for a regular discussion can't take place in such circumstances.

I am basing my reply to your points.

You asked:
Q: 1. What makes you think that being insecure and sceptic is at most improbable?
A: I did not say it was improbable. I listed my real-life experience with insecure people and nothing from those experiences led me to any assumption they were skeptics too. They said they were just insecure people.

Q: 2. You seem annoyed to have found counterexamples preventing you to claim that it is impossible for those to coexist in the same person.
A: Nowhere in any of my post did I exhibit any annoyance. I only suggested the members who thought they were skeptics might just be insecure people.

Q: 3. What's your real point here?
A: This suggest it was you that did not understand what my post was about.

Q: 4. If "true" sceptics don't exist then evolution is a myth?
A: I did not suggest there were no skeptics, all I was suggesting was they might just be insecure individuals. And it is incorrect to think skeptics are a separate branch of evolution.

Q: 4. The insecurity that makes you believe in a god is better than alleged Sagan's (which makes him believe in.... nothing)?
There is no mention of god in my post. It is not a choice between god or Sagan's. I was merely point to Sagan's inferiority complex and insecurity and the fact he is a skeptic.

You question on this post.
Q: 5. Why is your own insecurity worthier than the one you attribute to sceptics?
A: I never mentioned I had any insecurities. And if I had maybe I could make a comparison for you.
 
Last edited:
One thing you can never accuse him of is struggling to be articulate.

Reading the transcripts of the question and answer sessions following his Gifford lectures at the end of The Varieties of Scientific Experience, I'm amazed that he could be every bit as articulate, his syntax every bit as perfectly formulated in spontaneous conversation as he was in his written compositions. There are certainly others who fall into that same category: Stephen J. Gould, Christopher Hitchens, Richard Feynman etcetera, but it's inspiring to behold.
 
Try to explain why so few scientists are employed.

Because a formal science education is a very difficult, expensive and time consuming process.

Why do you think there are so few brain surgeons compared to, say McDonald's employees?
 
Please do not confuse the way Sagan speaks with "not knowing" or "not understanding", because these are the positions from which ALL science proceeds; we don't understand something, and we want to, so we postulate, theorise, research, study, experiment, reassess and conclude until we do understand. The problem in science is that often, when he get an answer, it raises many more questions.

I'm reminded of the smug "Scientists think they know it all" retort too often issued by the ignorant. I reply that if scientists thought they knew everything there would be no reason to continue science. Science thrives on the three words "we don't know". As such, the scientific method is driven by the acknowledgement of one's own ignorance. Scientists, as a general rule, are bored by what they already know. When a mystery is resolved there are some high fives passed around, but then everyone quickly turns their attentions to the new "But then what the hell is that?".
 

I saw that as a three part series. There are plenty of contradictions to highlight in those videos.

1. Carl Sagan is not against all the good things that religion has done for mankind. He even list many commendable contributions. What he is against is the institution of religion that profits from the weakness of it believers. That is no different from his own pandering to the publics fascination with UFOs and alien encounters. He wrote a fiction book Contact. to cash in on the rave.

2. He was asked if he was not using double standards insisting on evidence before believing and yet maintaining. Just because we don't know if they are out there and there is no evidence they exist does not preclude that we should not be looking for them.

3. When asked why he rejected his friend Dr John Mack's professional opinion as a doctor and psychiatrist. Dr Mack said the strong emotions exhibited by alien abductees and witnesses of UFOs had to be taken as proof that there was something to those sightings and experiences. Dr John Mack was a doctor, a scientist. He went back to his position the lack of evidence.

Carl Sagan then uses an experience he had as an example. He heard his dead fathers voice calling out Carl. He recognized the voice of his dead father and was drawn with emotions. But explained it away as a auditory hallucination without any supported evidence. Ironically using a medical explanation to explain away the incident. So what is good for the goose is not good for the gander in Carls case.

4. Carl is concerned we now live in a scientific age and old superstitions and beliefs are really a hindrance. I suppose in a world searching for a cure and solutions for cancer, AIDS, autism, climate change, global destruction etc. etc. We should take scientist like him seriously. Scientist who are looking for aliens, black holes and flights into fantasy land.

Scientist like to blame their failures on the public. How can the public take scientist seriously when most of the major discovers were discovered by accident and not by design or scientific method.
Some Examples.
http://listverse.com/2008/02/24/top-10-accidental-discoveries/

http://science.discovery.com/brink/top-ten/accidental-inventions/inventions-01.html

http://www.oddee.com/item_97879.aspx
 
Now having analyzed a sufficient number of skeptics on several Skeptic forums. I am of discovering that Skeptics are insecure too. So it is possible for one to be both a skeptic and insecure too.

In other words, having had it handed to you on a number of forums and having had your ignorance expounded in a most disconcerting manner, you've decided that the fault cannot lie with yourself, and therefor must reside with those who have pointed out the numerous, often egregious, errors in the claims and statements that you have presented. Rather than address the deficiencies in your knowledge, you've chosen to project the feeling that your encounters has inspired in yourself onto those who have shown you your errors.
 
Now having analyzed a sufficient number of skeptics on several Skeptic forums. I am of discovering that Skeptics are insecure too. So it is possible for one to be both a skeptic and insecure too.
According to whom? Youm?

Because by definition a Skeptic is: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.
Crap definition; I've highlighted the crappiest part.

So there is little doubt that Skeptics are insecure people.

Does not follow.
 
One thing you can never accuse him of is struggling to be articulate. He was the most clear and concise science presenter of his generation. IMO, that mantle has now been handed over to Professor Brian Cox.

Please do not confuse the way Sagan speaks with "not knowing" or "not understanding", because these are the positions from which ALL science proceeds; we don't understand something, and we want to, so we postulate, theorise, research, study, experiment, reassess and conclude until we do understand. The problem in science is that often, when he get an answer, it raises many more questions.

After reading the many posts you have posted here, and the many contradictions you have written, I have come to the conclusion that you are a LGM obsessed teenager with a poor grasp of language almost zero ability at comprehension and you have utterly no idea what you are talking about.

Please read my post again. You are missing the preciseness of the language when you rush through the reading because you are too eager to post a reply.

I wrote: Yes, that only proves Carl Sagan was never sure of anything and that comes across clearly in most of his videos. If you add all the IF, POSSIBLE, MAYBE, and NOT IS and ARE. You will understand why he struggled to articulate a true position even near the conclusion of his life.

This is why people are suspicious of scientist. They have more disclaimers than actual facts in their research.

Note I said "articulate a true position".
 
The only insecure person in this discussion is you justintime. You who feel like since people don't accept things on face value that they aren't being rational, but rather fearful. (which is total baloney)

I think some skeptic just kicked your butt up and down the street in a debate sometime and you are still coming to grips with it. You can tell us, we will havd you a hanky and help you get through it.

Cuz dude, all you are doing right now is getting your butt kicked again, just in slow motion this time....
 
Why is "I don't know" not a true position? And why don't you read Sagan's books?
 
Why don't you read Carl Sagan's books, justintime?

If you saw Carl Sagan's "Last interview" you will get the picture. Carl Sagan openly says whahever he said about religion, ghost and irrational beliefs in superstitions etc are not new. They have been around since the beginning of time. I just happen to have read them from other sources.

I enjoyed his Cosmos series but once he got into his obsession with aliens and the search for them. It just turned me off. It was just too much listening to someone talking about a remote chance of contacting aliens in distant space when there was a regular supply of whacky alien sightings right HERE on earth.
You don't replace one whacky sighting with another just because they show you a formula they used to calculate the probability, which sounded like a very long story even then. I was right.. The story is still going on after 50 years.
 
I saw that as a three part series. There are plenty of contradictions to highlight in those videos.

1. Carl Sagan is not against all the good things that religion has done for mankind. He even list many commendable contributions. What he is against is the institution of religion that profits from the weakness of it believers. That is no different from his own pandering to the publics fascination with UFOs and alien encounters. He wrote a fiction book Contact. to cash in on the rave.

Contact wasn't about UFOs.

2. He was asked if he was not using double standards insisting on evidence before believing and yet maintaining. Just because we don't know if they are out there and there is no evidence they exist does not preclude that we should not be looking for them.

Exactly. Very rational.

3. When asked why he rejected his friend Dr John Mack's professional opinion as a doctor and psychiatrist. Dr Mack said the strong emotions exhibited by alien abductees and witnesses of UFOs had to be taken as proof that there was something to those sightings and experiences. Dr John Mack was a doctor, a scientist. He went back to his position the lack of evidence.

4. Carl is concerned we now live in a scientific age and old superstitions and beliefs are really a hindrance. I suppose in a world searching for a cure and solutions for cancer, AIDS, autism, climate change, global destruction etc. etc. We should take scientist like him seriously. Scientist who are looking for aliens, black holes and flights into fantasy land.

You know black holes are real, right?
 
All I saw in your last psots is your complete lack of an ability to understand and analyse Sagan did not say anything you claim he did and most major discoveries HAVE NOT BEEN accidents.

All that shows is you have little knowledge of the history of scientific discovery either.
 
If you saw Carl Sagan's "Last interview" you will get the picture. Carl Sagan openly says whahever he said about religion, ghost and irrational beliefs in superstitions etc are not new. They have been around since the beginning of time. I just happen to have read them from other sources.
Not good enough. If you want to discuss what Carl Sagan said, you need to read what he actually said, not what other people think about what he said.

Of course, that assumes you're interested in honest discussion about the man's work.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom