Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

This broad cast was full of, IF, POSSIBLE, MAYBE, and NOT IS and ARE.

And there is NO CREDIBLE EVIDENCE Aliens have visted here.

You missed that too.

He is speculating. not stating any facts.

You obviously did not listen to what he said.

Once again you have failed to misrepresent what Dr Sagan was acutally saying
 
Last edited:
While riding by on a galloping horse.

I researched his interviews, documentaries and biographies. He was a very public figure and was video taped extensively. His work is now a library of public record.
 
Last edited:
I researched his interviews, documentaries and biographies. He was a very public figure and was video taped extensively. He work is now a library of public record.

When researching, did you do any actual reading?

That might explain your comprehension issues.

Only here to help.
 
This broad cast was full of, IF, POSSIBLE, MAYBE, and NOT IS and ARE.

You obviously did not listen to what he said.

Yes, that only proves Carl Sagan was never sure of anything and that comes across clearly in most of his videos. If you add all the IF, POSSIBLE, MAYBE, and NOT IS and ARE. You will understand why he struggled to articulate a true position even near the conclusion of his life.

This is why people are suspicious of scientist. They have more disclaimers than actual facts in their research.
 
you really don't have a clue how big the universe is, do you?

Someone has to do it!

'"Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mindbogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist's, but that's just peanuts to space,"
 
Yes, that only proves Carl Sagan was never sure of anything and that comes across clearly in most of his videos.

That's what made him a skeptic.

Looks like you answered your question from the thread title. Carl Sagan was a skeptic.
 
Carl sagan never claimed he was absoultuly certain of everything he would have been a poor scientist if he did go around labouring under that delusion.

Now cease misrepresenting him in your ill judge and totally ignornace driven assessment of him.

You have stated you have not read any of his books so you do know nothing about him in real terms.
 
This broad cast was full of, IF, POSSIBLE, MAYBE, and NOT IS and ARE.

And there is NO CREDIBLE EVIDENCE Aliens have visted here.

You missed that too.

He is speculating. not stating any facts.

You obviously did not listen to what he said.

Once again you have failed to misrepresent what Dr Sagan was acutally saying

I did not misrepresent what Carl Sagan said. I gave you the actual Carl Sagan video.
Here it is again.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOcfCkUBsdc
 
Last edited:
From his biography.
To the general public, he is mainly recalled as a television personality— in particular, as a suave commentator on the possibility of extraterrestrial life and on the robotic exploration of the solar system.
I changed the highlighting to emphasize the relevant point: your cherry-picking of one statement of one facet of the popular impression of his work.

From his biography - as in the biography in his obituary from his final employer, Cornell University:
Cornell University said:
Sagan has published more than 600 scientific papers and popular articles and is author, co-author or editor of more than 20 books, including The Dragons of Eden (1977), for which he won the Pulitzer Prize in 1978.

...At Cornell since 1968, Sagan received a bachelor's degree in 1955 and a master's degree in 1956, both in physics, and a doctorate in astronomy and astrophysics in 1960, all from the University of Chicago. He taught at Harvard University in the early 1960s before coming to Cornell, where he became a full professor in 1971.

Sagan played a leading role in NASA's Mariner, Viking, Voyager and Galileo expeditions to other planets. He has received NASA Medals for Exceptional Scientific Achievement and twice for Distinguished Public Service and the NASA Apollo Achievement Award.

His research has focused on topics such as the greenhouse effect on Venus; windblown dust as an explanation for the seasonal changes on Mars; organic aerosols on Titan, Saturn's moon; the long-term environmental consequences of nuclear war; and the origin of life on Earth. A pioneer in the field of exobiology, he continued to teach graduate and undergraduate students in courses in astronomy and space sciences and in critical thinking at Cornell.

The breadth of his interests were made evident in October 1994, at a Cornell-sponsored symposium in honor of Sagan's 60th birthday. The two-day event featured speakers in areas of planetary exploration, life in the cosmos, science education, public policy and government regulation of science and the environment -- all fields in which Sagan had worked or had a strong interest.

Sagan was the recipient of numerous of awards in addition to his NASA recognition. He has received 22 honorary degrees from American colleges and universities for his contributions to science, literature, education and the preservation of the environment and many awards for his work on the long-term consequences of nuclear war and reversing the nuclear arms race.

Among his other awards have been: the John F. Kennedy Astronautics Award of the American Astronautical Society; the Explorers Club 75th Anniversary Award; the Konstantin Tsiolkovsky Medal of the Soviet Cosmonauts Federation and the Masursky Award of the American Astronomical Society. He also was the recipient of the Public Welfare Medal, the highest award of the National Academy of Sciences, "for distinguished contributions in the application of science to the public welfare."

Sagan was elected chairman of the Division of Planetary Sciences of the American Astronomical Society, president of the Planetology Section of the American Geophysical Union and chairman of the Astronomy Section of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. For 12 years he was editor of Icarus, the leading professional journal devoted to planetary research.

He is co-founder of The Planetary Society, a 100,000-member organization and the largest space-interest group in the world. The society supports major research programs in the radio search for extraterrestrial intelligence, the investigation of near-Earth asteroids and, with the French and Russian space agencies, the development and testing of balloon and mobile robotic exploration of Mars. Sagan also was Distinguished Visiting Scientist at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in California and was contributing editor of Parade magazine, where he published many articles about science and, most recently, about the disease that he has battled for the past two years.
Yes, this biography did mention SETI. Did you notice anything else in there? Anything at all? Hey, I'm envious too, but I don't need to trash the man in a transparently dishonest and incompetent way.

justintime, you have no idea what you're talking about, the sources to which you appeal regularly contradict you, you can't even put together a coherent argument. I've read most of this thread, and I get that you don't like Carl Sagan, which is a right you have vigorously exercised. You also have a right to make a fool of yourself, and you have made liberal use of that right as well with your parade of misrepresentations, straw men, ludicrously broken analogies, cherry-picking, and nearly innumerable errors of fact. My advice to you - my parting advice, mind you, because I don't feel like indulging you again - is not to pat yourself on the back for getting attention in this thread, because, as another poster once said, people aren't laughing with you. It's the other thing.
 
I did watch the video and in at NO POINT does he state that aiens, ETI exist as proved fact.

And I recall watching that clip the first time it was broadcast on TV well before youtube was ever thoguth up.

he never claimed in his professiaonl working life that they did, he only ever posited a possibility, he actually says in that clip and I have watched it, THERE IS NO CREDIBLE EVIDENCE ALIENS HAVE VISITED.

You have totally misunderstood what he was sying, you have no credible arguments based on anything he actually did do to back up your assertion.
 
Last edited:
Why don't you watch and enjoy the video.

As I have patiently explained to you before, (although perhaps not, as I think of it, on this forum), I do not like to watch videos for information. Above and beyond the fact that people speak so much more slowly than I read, there is a personal consideration...with the deterioration of my hearing, I find it impractical to set the volume of my computer high enough to for me to hear it--and at that volume, it is disturbing to my partner while my partner is working...not to mention being fuzzy and distorted (the audio, not my partner).
So, no thank you; I will read Dr, Sagan's words instead. Perhaps you know of a location where the transcript of the video might be found?

Why he constantly refers to ETI as advanced civilizations. What evidence did he have they even existed let alone they were intelligent?

The simple act of reading any of Dr., Sagan's explanations would demonstrate that the attribution of "advanced civilization" to extra-terrestrial intelligences that it would be possible for us to detect on Earth is due to the fact that a "primitive civilization" (such as Earth's) is capable of doing very little that is, in fact, detectable, or perceptible, at intergalactic distances.

We do not have "evidence" that extraterrestrial intelligences exist, which is why privately-funded organizations are looking for them. If we had hard evidence of the existence of extraterrestrial intelligences; if we knew they were there, we would not be looking for them, but trying to figure out how (and whether) to contact them.

All his work was just based on conjectures.

Not having read "(all) his work" (or, for that matter, according to your own report, any of his work, how do you think you know this?
Further, developing and investigating conjecture is a real, and vital, part of the nature of this enterprise we call "science" (along with, for instance, skeptical thought).

He was obsessed with flying saucers and aliens

It has been pointed out to you, patiently and repeatedly, that Dr, Sagan's interest in debunking unsupported tales of UFO visits" and "alien abductions", even coupled with his fascination with the possibility of the existence, somewhere in the universe, of intelligent life, does not constitute an "obsession". Might I ask why you persist in the straw-man characterization?
If you are of the unshakable opinion, in the face of contrary evidence, that Dr. Sagan's interest constituted an "obsession", consider phrasing it as such...an opinion. Your own opinion.

and attributed the same advanced technology to extraterrestrial beings.

Carl Sagan on advanced civilizations visting Earth
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOcfCkUBsdc
 
So it's not just Carl Segan and 'Skeptics' you have a problem with it's all scientists?

Try to explain why so few scientists are employed.

(February 2012) Scientists and engineers make up only about 5 percent of the U.S. labor force.

This is part of a series of PRB articles about the science and engineering workforce in the United States, funded by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. Data for this article are based on the Population Reference Bureau's analysis of the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom