Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

In other words, having had it handed to you on a number of forums and having had your ignorance expounded in a most disconcerting manner, you've decided that the fault cannot lie with yourself, and therefor must reside with those who have pointed out the numerous, often egregious, errors in the claims and statements that you have presented. Rather than address the deficiencies in your knowledge, you've chosen to project the feeling that your encounters has inspired in yourself onto those who have shown you your errors.

I have never lost a debate on any forum. I have been censured by moderators because of the inordinate amount of complaints made by my detractors who lack the education or rhetorical skills and would rather have the moderator assist them, which is cowardly and despicable. It is not a perfect world.

So it is of little surprise I am generating so much traffic. My posts draw strong emotions and is a better substitute than mind expanding drugs. But I always caution. If the headache persist........that is as expanded as it gets. :)
 
Justintime already admitted Sagan was as skeptic a couple pages ago, so I guess we could call the thread done since that was the question in the OP.
 
Not good enough. If you want to discuss what Carl Sagan said, you need to read what he actually said, not what other people think about what he said.

Of course, that assumes you're interested in honest discussion about the man's work.

That is why I only used what he actually said and not all the stuff he passed off as fiction.
 
I have never lost a debate on any forum. I have been censured by moderators because of the inordinate amount of complaints made by my detractors who lack the education or rhetorical skills and would rather have the moderator assist them, which is cowardly and despicable.
You'd be amazed how many people just like you have posted here over the years.
 
I have never lost a debate on any forum. I have been censured by moderators because of the inordinate amount of complaints made by my detractors who lack the education or rhetorical skills and would rather have the moderator assist them, which is cowardly and despicable. It is not a perfect world.

So it is of little surprise I am generating so much traffic. My posts draw strong emotions and is a better substitute than mind expanding drugs. But I always caution. If the headache persist........that is as expanded as it gets. :)

Which twin wrote this?

By the way, your perfect forum debating record is crashing in flames; you're failing in a number of threads, and rather badly.

Not a perfect world, nor record, huh?
 
How many Skeptics know that Carl Sagan also suffered from an inferiority complex.


Quote:
From a biography: “Why is Carl Sagan so lonely?” asked the novelist Walker Percy. He answered that to Sagan, the cosmos was nothing but “matter in interaction, [and] there is no one left to talk to except other transcending intelligences from other worlds.”

Carl Sagan appears to have an inferiority complex. He believes as the quote suggest there are more transcending intelligence in other worlds.

Is that the only hint of his inferiority complex and insecurity in himself and disdain for the entire human race? We know he searched for Extraterrestrial intelligence through his SETI program which just celebrated its 50th Anniversary.

In his own words he describes just how tiny and insignificant we are in the vastness of the cosmos. How he believes there are older and wiser civilizations out there and justifies searching for them. He also holds in contempt human intelligence and the self destructive nature of man borne out of ignorance and misguided purpose. That we might be spared our self destruction by seeking those distant planets of older and wiser civilizations.

Space Engine: A Cosmic Voyage (Feat. Carl Sagan) in his own words.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UU0e_J31tcc&feature=youtu.be

Did he go beyond the definition of Skeptic? Was it scientific skepticism or his inferiority complex that made him a lonely man. Did his complex force him to over compensate for his feelings of inadequacy as is often with those suffering from an IC. Does his words and life provide us the clues? I leave that to the readers.
 
Last edited:
That is why I only used what he actually said and not all the stuff he passed off as fiction.

I think you've passed over a great deal of his work. I'm certain of it in fact.

Your homework assignment for this weekend is to read, cover to cover, The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark. It's a primer to your understanding of the man, skepticism, science, and a whole bunch of stuff.

Go on now.
 
I think you've passed over a great deal of his work. I'm certain of it in fact.

Your homework assignment for this weekend is to read, cover to cover, The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark. It's a primer to your understanding of the man, skepticism, science, and a whole bunch of stuff.

Go on now.

To read Carl Sagans works like the one you mentioned is to go back into the past Carl was lost in that was full of Ghost, Demons and irrational superstitions. Carl Sagan was concerned these irrational superstitions should be rejected so we can allow science to triumphant. That made a lot of sense till the public found out what he was doing with science. Looking for extraterrestrial intelligence.

It was noble of him to write that book The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark. to help people overcome their irrational beliefs and sacrificed himself to his own demons and obsession with aliens.

Do you have something for forward thinkers like me ?
 
Last edited:
To read Carl Sagans works like the one you mentioned is to go back into the past Carl was lost in that was full of Ghost, Demons and irrational superstitions. Carl Sagan was concerned these irrational superstitions should be rejected so we can allow science to triumphant. That made a lot of sense till the public found out what he was doing with science. Looking for extraterrestrial intelligence.

It was noble of him to write that book The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark. to help people overcome their irrational beliefs and sacrificed himself to his own demons and obsession with aliens.

Do you have something for forward thinkers like me ?

You, more than anyone with whom I'm currently acquainted, need to read that book.
 
Carl Sagan, Stephen Hawking and Arthur C. Clarke - God, The Universe and Everything Else (1988)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKQQAv5svkk

THAT is the panel discussion I referred to earlier in the thread.

Great find.

He wrote a fiction book Contact. to cash in on the rave.


That is so wrong it beggars belief. Sagan actually wrote "Contact" because he wanted a portrayal of First Contact that didn't involve laser blasters and photon torpedoes. Ann Druyan is clear about what Carl wanted. They wanted to write something that would be a fictional representation of what contact would actually be like, in a manner that was within the technology of today, but would also show the tension between religion and science.

Your posts started out as unlikely, and have evolved through the preposterous and outright stupid to end up actually insulting a great man who is unable to speak for himself.

You make me sick!.
 
Last edited:
To read Carl Sagans works like the one you mentioned is to go back into the past Carl was lost in that was full of Ghost, Demons and irrational superstitions. Carl Sagan was concerned these irrational superstitions should be rejected so we can allow science to triumphant. That made a lot of sense till the public found out what he was doing with science. Looking for extraterrestrial intelligence.

It was noble of him to write that book The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark. to help people overcome their irrational beliefs and sacrificed himself to his own demons and obsession with aliens.

Do you have something for forward thinkers like me ?

Try this as a resource.
 
@justintime

Nah, I got nothin', why don't you ask the guy with the plans for the INTERGALACTIC rockets? LOL
 
Last edited:
To read Carl Sagans works like the one you mentioned is to go back into the past Carl was lost in that was full of Ghost, Demons and irrational superstitions.

How would you know? You haven't read any of them.
 
How many Skeptics know that Carl Sagan also suffered from an inferiority complex.
So saying, "I wonder if there might be other beings in the universe far, far older than us, with far greater knowledge and technology?" indicates an inferiority complex? I'd bet 10,000 internets that had he concluded that humans are probably the smartest beings in the universe, you'd accuse him of arrogance. By your logic, unless you are convinced that you are the smartest person alive today, you too must have a terrible inferiority complex. Are you the smartest person alive today?

Carl Sagan appears to have an inferiority complex. He believes as the quote suggest there are more transcending intelligence in other worlds.
I haven't read Percy's book, but given that he described it as "An obnoxious and abusive book. And it's going to make a lot of people mad. It's going to irritate North Carolina more than any other state, because North Carolina has more fundamentalist Christians in it than any other state", it seems to me that it might be a satyrical work. And one would have to have appallingly poor reading comprehension to declare that Sagan believed that there were other civilizations to communicate with. He simply speculated that there might be, and that it was worth investigating.

Is that the only hint of his inferiority complex and insecurity in himself and disdain for the entire human race?
Now you're really just making **** up. One would have to be tragically ignorant to think that his speculation that we might not be the smartest things in the universe was an expression of "disdain for the entire human race".

We know he searched for Extraterrestrial intelligence through his SETI program which just celebrated its 50th Anniversary.
Very good! Yes, we do know that. Only a small percentage of the galaxy has been searched so far.

In his own words he describes just how tiny and insignificant we are in the vastness of the cosmos.
Yes. The universe is humbling, isn't it? Here are my own words on the same subject:

Our anthropomorphic conceits are exposed by the unanticipated truth of nature; that complexity is generated from the bottom up rather than from the top down. We are confronted by an incomprehensibly vast and dangerous, yet beautiful and awesome universe that was not made for us and does not care if we exist or not. We are left to explore this universe without a guide. We are utterly alone... all 6.87 billion of us.

Would anyone else care to add their own thoughts?

How he believes there are older and wiser civilizations out there and justifies searching for them.
You've been told so many times that Sagan never said that he had a positive belief that there were alien civilizations, that at this point you are simply telling a bald-faced lie. Repeating it ad infinitum will not make it true, it will only solidify the perception of you as a liar.

He also holds in contempt human intelligence and the self destructive nature of man borne out of ignorance and misguided purpose.
This is where your admitted ignorance of Sagan's own writing reveals you as utterly inept to those of us who have read his works. Sagan had great admiration of human achievements. He had great concern for the welfare of humanity. He was disappointed by humanity's tendency toward cruelty, waste and war. Are you suggesting that we shouldn't all aspire to this same standard?

That we might be spared our self destruction by seeking those distant planets of older and wiser civilizations.
No, he didn't think that the aliens would save us. He did hope that if we learned that we are not alone in the universe, it might give us hope that we could avoid destroying ourselves, because we would know that others had avoided destroying themselves.

It's too bad you've never actually read the man you are attempting to discredit. You might learn something. But first, you'll need to bone-up on your reading comprehension.

Did he go beyond the definition of Skeptic? Was it scientific skepticism or his inferiority complex that made him a lonely man. Did his complex force him to over compensate for his feelings of inadequacy as is often with those suffering from an IC.
I'm starting to think that you may be a lonely, insecure and inadequate man, desperately trying to convince yourself that it's others who have the problem.

Does his words and life provide us the clues? I leave that to the readers.
Do his words... And no.
 
Never lost a debate in a forum?? ...you have totally crashed in the flames of failure in the Carl Sagan thread
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom