Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

So the OPs sum total of knowledge about Carl Sagan is stuff dredged up on the internet and not based on any reading of his books, or any first hand knowledge at all about his life and work.

How bogus can you get.....
 
I get the impression that you are well intentioned. You seem to be arguing for something you have strong convictions for, and I respect that.

Unfortunately, you've painted a picture of skeptics with a rather broad brush and as a result you've sacrificed accuracy in favor of generalizations. Yes there are participants on skeptical forums who match with your descriptions, if not always, at least some of the time. That in itself does not mean that all skeptics match these descriptions and I contend that the vast majority do not.

As well intentioned as your crusade may be, it is unlikely to bear fruit because the misdirected war you've waged is on the wrong enemy. To truly have an impact of the sort you're hoping for will require far more diligence and specificity than you're currently employing. You'll need to target and dismantle the arguments of individuals instead of lackadaisically poisoning the well. In doing so you can expose the weakness of cynicism, which is what I think you really want to do.

Even then you've got a hard road ahead of you if you want to be effective. Do yourself a favor though, and don't create enemies where there were none in the first place. Who knows, you may even come to appreciate some of the skeptical perspectives offered by many participants on forums like these.

Cheers.

I hope to be more diligent and provide more specificity to bring home my message. Why you might not be a Skeptic but a very insecure individual.

I begin with the best known Skeptic of our times Carl Sagan. He advocated scientific skepticism and denounced the irrational beliefs of those who were buried in superstitions. I am basing my research on Carl Sagans biographies and using his own words to support my conclusions. Your comments are welcomed.

Was Carl Sagan a Skeptic or just an insecure individual.

From a biography: “Why is Carl Sagan so lonely?” asked the novelist Walker Percy. He answered that to Sagan, the cosmos was nothing but “matter in interaction, [and] there is no one left to talk to except other transcending intelligences from other worlds.”

Carl Sagan appears to have an inferiority complex. He believes as the quote suggest there are more transcending intelligence in other worlds.

Is that the only hint of his inferiority complex and insecurity in himself and the entire human race? We know he searched for Extraterrestrial intelligence through his SETI program which just celebrated its 50th Anniversary.

In his own words he describes just how tiny and insignificant we are in the vastness of the cosmos. How he believes there are older and wiser civilizations out there and justifies searching for them. He also holds in contempt human intelligence and the self destructive nature of man borne out of ignorance and misguided purpose. That we might be spared our self destruction by seeking those distant planets of older and wiser civilizations.
Space Engine: A Cosmic Voyage (Feat. Carl Sagan) in his own words.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UU0e_J31tcc&feature=youtu.be

There is that possibility that Carl Sagan was truly a Skeptic and that might be true of many here. I have considered that as well and am working on my next OP. Why you might be a Skeptics and an insecure individual too.
 
Last edited:
There is that possibility that Carl Sagan was truly a Skeptic and that might be true of many here. I have considered that as well and am working on my next OP. Why you might be a Skeptics and an insecure individual too.

Do you think it's wise to start another thread? You haven't adequately defended those you've already started, or your position in this one.
 
The Arecibo message sent by the Arecibo radio telescope in 1974

http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1975Icar...26..462.

The Arecibo message of November, 1974
Icarus, vol. 26, Dec. 1975, p. 462-466.

On November 16, 1974, the Arecibo Observatory transmitted at 2380 MHz at an effective bandwidth of 10 Hz a message directed at the globular cluster M13. The message consists of a 1679-bit picture portraying a counting scheme, five biologically significant atoms (H, C, O, N, and P), the generic structure of the four purines and pyrimidine bases of DNA; a schematic of the DNA double helix with an order-of-magnitude estimate of the number of base pairs; a representation of a human being and his or her dimensions; a depiction of the solar system with an indication that human beings inhabit the third planet and an estimate of the human population of the earth; and finally, a schematic representation of the Arecibo Observatory and a description of its dimensions.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...bo_message.svg/1000px-Arecibo_message.svg.png
 
I hope to be more diligent and provide more specificity to bring home my message. Why you might not be a Skeptic but a very insecure individual.

I begin with the best known Skeptic of our times Carl Sagan. He advocated scientific skepticism and denounced the irrational beliefs of those who were buried in superstitions. I am basing my research on Carl Sagans biographies and using his own words to support my conclusions. Your comments are welcomed.
Was Carl Sagan a Skeptic or just and insecure individual.



Carl Sagan appears to have an inferiority complex. He believes as the quote suggest there are more transcending intelligence in other worlds.

Is that the only hint of his inferiority complex and insecurity in himself and the entire human race? We know he searched for Extraterrestrial intelligence through his SETI program which just celebrated its 50th Anniversary.

In his own words he describes just how tiny and insignificant we are in the vastness of the cosmos. How he believes there are older and wiser civilizations out there and justifies searching for them. He also holds in contempt human intelligence and the self destructive nature of man borne out of ignorance and misguided purpose. That we might be spared our self destruction by seeking those distant planets of older and wiser civilizations.
Space Engine: A Cosmic Voyage (Feat. Carl Sagan) in his own words.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UU0e_J31tcc&feature=youtu.be

There is that possibility that Carl Sagan was truly a Skeptic and that might be true of many here. I have considered that as well and am working on my next OP. Why you might be a Skeptics and an insecure individual too.

Two things:

1. You really ought to read Dr. Sagan's own writings before you pretend to be able to analyze, or criticize, what Dr. Sagan said...that way you do not look as if you are so insecure that you have to raise up a second-hand hearsay strawman imitation of him in order to be able to pretend to smite it...

2. As a clarification, in your opinion, are there differences among "being a Skeptic", "being a skeptic", "being skeptical", and "applying skeptical reasoning to scientific thought"? Or is this another place where you will deny nuance in order to escape the actual meaning of the things you say?
 
Last edited:
So the OPs sum total of knowledge about Carl Sagan is stuff dredged up on the internet and not based on any reading of his books, or any first hand knowledge at all about his life and work.

How bogus can you get.....

I relied not only on Carl Sagan's biographies but also researched what he actually said. He had several positions on UFOs and offered several explanations while making sure we all understood that only the credible evidence was lacking. Just as his SETI project was to look for ETI. It would be the evidence that would finally prove they exist. For all his billions and billions of possibilities and probabilities he still had to deliver the evidence for the billions or rational people and billions of believers (as in religious believers).

Michael Shermer cites only 55,000 skeptic subscribers for his Skeptics Magazine. Skeptic movement claims only 1 million skeptics. But there are billions of rational people and billions of believers (religious) who were not convinced Carl Sagan would find ETI and were proven right.

Carl Sagan on advanced civilizations visting Earth (Carl Sagan at one point suggest they might even be HERE and hiding).
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOcfCkUBsdc
 
Last edited:
Carl Sagan's main work and focus of his career WAS NOT the search for ETI, again you ignore this, his main focus was space exploration, ETI was jut one strand of his work and NOT the CORE one.

Ad again you ignore the fact thathe only ever saw it as a POSSIBILITY and NOT A FACT, he never stated it was proved fact during his professional life.
 
Last edited:
In his own words he describes just how tiny and insignificant we are in the vastness of the cosmos. How he believes there are older and wiser civilizations out there and justifies searching for them. He also holds in contempt human intelligence and the self destructive nature of man borne out of ignorance and misguided purpose. That we might be spared our self destruction by seeking those distant planets of older and wiser civilizations.
Space Engine: A Cosmic Voyage (Feat. Carl Sagan) in his own words.

I can categorically state that my penis is tiny and insignificant in the vastness of the cosmos. Doesn't make me insecure though.

All of the above and the rest of your post is completely irrelevant though because you can't use ONE person to draw conclusions about the group they belong to. That's not me telling you you can't, it's all the forces of logic and reason.

You can only continue your battle against these forces by moving further away from Right and deeper into the pit of Wrong.
 
I relied not only on Carl Sagan's biographies but also researched what he actually said. He had several positions on UFOs and offered several explanations while making sure we all understood that only the credible evidence was lacking. Just as his SETI project was to look for ETI. It would be the evidence that would finally prove they exist. For all his billions and billions of possibilities and probabilities he still had to deliver the evidence for the billions or rational people and billions of believers (as in religious believers).

Michael Shermer cites only 55,000 skeptic subscribers for his Skeptics Magazine. Skeptic movement claims only 1 million skeptics. But there are billions of rational people and billions of believers (religious) who were not convinced Carl Sagan would find ETI and were proven right.

Carl Sagan on advanced civilizations visting Earth (Carl Sagan at one point suggest they might even be HERE and hiding).
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOcfCkUBsdc

Perhaps a reading comprehension course would help you?
 
Carl Sagan's main work and focus of his career WAS NOT the search for ETI, again you ignore this, his main focus was space exploration, ETI was jut one strand of his work and NOT the CORE one.

Ad again you ignore the fact thathe only ever saw it as a POSSIBILITY and NOT A FACT, he never stated it was proved fact during his professional life.

From his biography.

To the general public, he is mainly recalled as a television personality— in particular, as a suave commentator on the possibility of extraterrestrial life and on the robotic exploration of the solar system.
 
Last edited:
I relied not only on Carl Sagan's biographies but also researched what he actually said. He had several positions on UFOs and offered several explanations while making sure we all understood that only the credible evidence was lacking. Just as his SETI project was to look for ETI. It would be the evidence that would finally prove they exist. For all his billions and billions of possibilities and probabilities he still had to deliver the evidence for the billions or rational people and billions of believers (as in religious believers).

Michael Shermer cites only 55,000 skeptic subscribers for his Skeptics Magazine. Skeptic movement claims only 1 million skeptics. But there are billions of rational people and billions of believers (religious) who were not convinced Carl Sagan would find ETI and were proven right.

Carl Sagan on advanced civilizations visting Earth (Carl Sagan at one point suggest they might even be HERE and hiding).
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOcfCkUBsdc

How can the highlighted statement be harmonized with your statement that you have never read Dr. Sagans' work?
 
There is that possibility that Carl Sagan was truly a Skeptic and that might be true of many here. I have considered that as well and am working on my next OP. Why you might be a Skeptics and an insecure individual too.

What makes you think that being insecure and sceptic is at most improbable? You seem annoyed to have found counterexamples preventing you to claim that it is impossible for those to coexist in the same person. What's your real point here? If "true" sceptics don't exist then evolution is a myth? The insecurity that makes you believe in a god is better than alleged Sagan's (which makes him believe in.... nothing)? Why?
 
Why don't you watch and enjoy the video. Why he constantly refers to ETI as advanced civilizations. What evidence did he have they even existed let alone they were intelligent? All his work was just based on conjectures. He was obsessed with flying saucers and aliens and attributed the same advanced technology to extraterrestrial beings.

Carl Sagan on advanced civilizations visting Earth
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bOcfCkUBsdc
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom