Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

The rated speed is 100,000 MPH. One light year is 5,879,000,000,000
So do the math. It is roughly 6711 years. Because it is solar powered it can travel large distances. They might have to be launched closer to the destination if you are in a hurry. :)

Now I know why my road trips always take so long! I am beginning from where I am rather than closer to, or even in, the city I intend to go to.
 
That is to support my position with citations and subject material. I would not need them if the Skeptics were better informed and just debated the issues.

So you presuppose that there should be a class of skeptics out there that have read exactly what you have read and thus the need to cite those works would be moot?
 
Now, there's quite the trick, and here we've been missing it all along, when it was a plain as the nose on our faces.
Takes too long to get from LA to NYC? Well, start in Chicago instead of LA!
Brilliant!

Worse... Chicago doesn't exist yet. First, you have to go there and build it. :D


I'm laughing so hard at Justin's troll failings, but this really gets me...

A SS ship rated to cover a light year in ~6000 years (if he did his math right).

The next star system is ~4 LY.
The edge of the Milky Way is tens of thousands of LYs away.
The nearest (dwarf) galaxy is tens of thousands of LYs beyond that (if it's even along that path)
And the nearest major spiral galaxy (Andromeda) is a bit over 2 million LY away.

Then the distances start to get really large. :p

Justin... you're so far ahead of the actual scientists, you better come up with something impressive real quick.
 
I raised the same questions. If Skeptics as many claim apply critical thinking and adhere to credible evidence directed scrutiny, should this then lead to conclusions different from those who do not apply such processes.

The answer was found in What is Skepticism:
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php



In short Skeptics also end up believing in Ghosts and religion. So those processes Skeptics think they are applying is not as reliable as they are making it out to be.

Emanuel Kant said. "We believe in things that are useful to us."

Id rather a man took up religion because it helped him avoid a life of crime than the same man starts believing he is from a monkey, therefor quite helpless to avoid his criminal behavior.
Or the man wants to be the fastest tree climber where believing he is from a monkey might actually help him psychologically.

Hilited shows your true colours.

I'm curious. Have you ever heard of Lynne McTaggart?
 
Not to mention that the method predates the nomenclature. people used the scientific method before they knew it was called "the scientific method". (heck there is evidence of the method written on a 1600BC piece of Egyptian papyrus)

Excellent find, have a ref, I can use that.
 
Justintime

You really have utterly no idea about Carl Sagan. The fact that you state that you couldn't watch Cosmos all the way though says more about your lack of attention span that it does about Sagan and an obsession that you imagine he might have

As for his biography, there is only the official one on his website http://www.carlsagan.com/

"Biography CARL SAGAN was the David Duncan Professor of Astronomy and Space Sciences and Director of the Laboratory for Planetary Studies at Cornell University. He played a leading role in the American space program since its inception. He was a consultant and adviser to NASA since the 1950's, briefed the Apollo astronauts before their flights to the Moon, and was an experimenter on the Mariner, Viking, Voyager, and Galileo expeditions to the planets. He helped solve the mysteries of the high temperatures of Venus (answer: massive greenhouse effect), the seasonal changes on Mars (answer: windblown dust), and the reddish haze of Titan (answer: complex organic molecules).
For his work, Dr. Sagan received the NASA medals for Exceptional Scientific Achievement and (twice) for Distinguished Public Service, as well as the NASA Apollo Achievement Award. Asteroid 2709 Sagan is named after him. He was also awarded the John F. Kennedy Astronautics Award of the American Astronautical Society, the Explorers Club 75th Anniversary Award, the Konstantin Tsiolkovsky Medal of the Soviet Cosmonauts Federation, and the Masursky Award of the American Astronomical Society, ( "for his extraordinary contributions to the development of planetary science…As a scientist trained in both astronomy and biology, Dr. Sagan has made seminal contributions to the study of planetary atmospheres, planetary surfaces, the history of the Earth, and exobiology. Many of the most productive planetary scientists working today are his present and former students and associates").
He was also a recipient of the Public Welfare Medal, the highest award of the National Academy of Sciences (for "distinguished contributions in the application of science to the public welfare…Carl Sagan has been enormously successful in communicating the wonder and importance of science. His ability to capture the imagination of millions and to explain difficult concepts in understandable terms is a magnificent achievement").
Dr. Sagan was elected Chairman of the Division of Planetary Sciences of the American Astronomical Society, President of the Planetology Section of the American Geophysical Union, and Chairman of the Astronomy Section of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. For twelve years he was the editor-in-chief of Icarus, the leading professional journal devoted to planetary research. He was cofounder and President of the Planetary Society, a 100,000-member organization that is the largest space-interest group in the world; and Distinguished Visiting Scientist, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology.
A Pulitzer Prize winner for the book The Dragons of Eden: Speculations of the Evolution of Human Intelligence, Dr. Sagan was the author of many bestsellers, including Cosmos, which became the bestselling science book ever published in English. The accompanying Emmy and Peabody award-winning television series has been seen by a billion people in sixty countries. He received twenty-two honorary degrees from American colleges and universities for his contributions to science, literature, education, and the preservation of the environment, and many awards for his work on the long-term consequences of nuclear war and reversing the nuclear arms race. His novel, Contact, is now a major motion picture.
In their posthumous award to Dr. Sagan of their highest honor, the National Science Foundation declared that his "research transformed planetary science… his gifts to mankind were infinite."
Dr. Sagan's surviving family includes his wife and collaborator of twenty years, Ann Druyan; his children, Dorion, Jeremy, Nicholas, Sasha, and Sam; and grandchildren.

Not a mention of UFO's or SETI or extra terrestrials. He discussed these things but they did not take up a great amount of his life
 
Excellent find, have a ref, I can use that.

My boss and I once had a discussion on survival in the Mojave, after a particularly memorable incident drove home the fact that I don't know how to do it. He's paleo/archaeo, so he had a very good background in the topic. One of the things he mentioned is that in the ancient past, people ate pretty much anything they could get their hands on in these regions--and when someone die, they were smart enough to say "You know, I'm not gonna try that".

It's extremely brutal, but it IS the scientific method in action. Hypothesis: This is edible. Test: Eat it. Results: live, get sick, or die. The interpretation phase is, of course, left to those how opted to not engage in the experiment in one of those cases.
 
Our latest troll has no use for facts, but I, and many others here, appreciate your post.

I knew surprisingly little about Sagan's impressive body of work prior to reading several postings in this thread. He is certainly a candidate for the, "if you could invite any 3 people from history to dinner..." question.
 
Perhaps the misunderstanding comes from the name SETI chose for itself. Search implies doing something active; all SETI actually does is listen, which is a pretty passive activity. It would be like "searching" for your misplaced keys by sitting on your couch and looking around.
 
Perhaps the misunderstanding comes from the name SETI chose for itself. Search implies doing something active; all SETI actually does is listen, which is a pretty passive activity. It would be like "searching" for your misplaced keys by sitting on your couch and looking around.

It would be more like looking for your misplaced keys by sitting on the couch and looking around through the hole down the centre of a syringe needle and only looking in random directions for half a second at a time at two hour intervals.
 
Our latest troll has no use for facts, but I, and many others here, appreciate your post.

I knew surprisingly little about Sagan's impressive body of work prior to reading several postings in this thread. He is certainly a candidate for the, "if you could invite any 3 people from history to dinner..." question.

Some years ago I saw a TV panel discussion hosted by Magnus Magnussen. The three panelists were Carl Sagan, Stephen Hawking and Arthur C. Clarke. These would be my three dinner guests.

PS: The discussion was recorded back in the 1990's I think, but looking back at those three, who would have thought that Stephen Hawking would be the only one still living today.
 
That is a theory for intergalactic travel. Unfortunately you still need a faster rocket than what NASA has.

Ad nauseum, it has been explained why "intergalactic" travel is plain foolish as a concept, and where are your "faster rockets"? That's been explained also.

Where are the plans for these "faster rockets", capable of intergalactic travel please.
 
Our latest troll has no use for facts, but I, and many others here, appreciate your post.

I knew surprisingly little about Sagan's impressive body of work prior to reading several postings in this thread. He is certainly a candidate for the, "if you could invite any 3 people from history to dinner..." question.

Agreed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom