Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

In short Skeptics also end up believing in Ghosts and religion.
Some sceptics, having assessed the available evidence, choose to come down on the other side of the fence to the majority of sceptics on some subjects. Ghosts and religion are amongst the beliefs most likely to be considered plausible by the otherwise sceptical because, unlike things like paranormal powers and "alternative" medicines, they are not testable. I don't believe in either myself, but I can understand why some sceptics find themselves able to do so, even after applying their critical thinking skills. And as I said in the post you quoted:

It's hard, and we all fail occasionally, but at least we try
 
justin seems to be of the opinion that having googled the definitions of a few items and spending a few minutes reading he now can opine informatively and heroically on a subject many of us have studied for decades.

Yes a mechanic knowingly or unknowingly uses the scientific method in diagnosing and repairing a vehicle. As an electronic tech so do I. I am handed a piece of equipment, say a TV Camera, that the operator simply says "it doesn't work". I then investigate and find for instance, that the camera is working but for some reason no power is getting to the lens and CCD section of the camera. I hypothesize that there is an interruption in the delivery of power to that section. A secondary hypothesis would be that the DC power converter for that supply is dead but this is considered secondary since the rest of the camera IS operating. I then pull out the schematics for the camera and find that there is a soldered in fuse on the cct board lead that supplies power to the lens and this bolsters my hypothesis. Next I pull the camera apart and locate that fuse, then use an ohm meter to further test my hypothysis. Finding the fuse to be an open I replace said fuse and test again with the ohm meter (did the fuse survive being soldered in) and put the camera back together and turn it on and find that all is well again.

What I DO NOT DO, is tear the camera apart and start changing parts will nilly with no thought whatsoever as to what may or may not be causing the problem which is what would be the case if one were not using a logical method to solve this.

Mechanics, good ones , certainly do the same as I do. Yes some bad ones may just start swapping out parts because they have no clue as to what may be the problem and thus no way to form a hypothesis. I would submit that in such a case calling them mechanics is a bit of a misnomer since they are about as effective as a TV chef inasmuch as forming a hypothesis about the vehicle.
 
True mechanics are born knowing what the problem is.

Not really all that far from the truth. One must have an innate sense of the relationship between connected mechanical and electrical/electronic systems. However to be an actual automobile mechanic one must study the specific mechanical and electrical/electronic systems that are used in an automobile.

My son is a ticketed heavy equipment mechanic and is good at his job. He would be less effective in repairing a gasoline powered passenger sedan, and even less effective if I handed him the camera in my above example. (He may however discover that the camera body has power and that the viewfinder displays a greyish glow and deduce that whatever system converts light to electronic signals is the problem. Doing so would be application of the scientific method.

In university I took History as my arts ellective in first year. In that class we were taught to use the, and I quote both my prof and the textbook, "scientifc method of history" when writing on a historical subject. In such a case one was to restrict personal opinion and instead use historical fact to bolster a conclusion. For instance there are two lines of thought on the effect of the Spanish conquest of the Americas. These were termed the "White" and "Black" history of the conquests. One line states that it was good and civilising operation in which the population was delivered from human sacrifice and crushing oppression by supposedly divine rulers, while the other states that the conquest was a horrible affliction that sent the population, those that survived the warfare and pestilence brought by the invaders, into slavery to the Spanish.
However the preponderance of the historical evidence does weigh heavily on the side of the "Black" history that has the invasion and conquest as a morally reprehensible event, and THAT is application of 'scientific method" wrt to history.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe in UFOs and I don't believe in Carl Sagan or his ETI. There are better ways to spend research grants and better research projects than looking of smarter people millions of miles away.


So which UFOs do you believe in? I mean, you keep talking about them and posting links to newspaper articles about them, so you clearly have an obsessive belief in them, right?
 
So which UFOs do you believe in? I mean, you keep talking about them and posting links to newspaper articles about them, so you clearly have an obsessive belief in them, right?

That is to support my position with citations and subject material. I would not need them if the Skeptics were better informed and just debated the issues.
 
So first you claim you don't believe in interstellar travel nor ETI yet you follow that up with this:

I won't be satisfied till we get intergalactic travel. And this is one way to pressure NASA. Make those demands in public.

which claims that all we need to achieve interstellar travel is to put some pressure on NASA?

Your lack of comprehension of the vastness of space would be breathtaking were it not such obvious trolling.
 
So far J has failed to prove Carl Sagan was not a skeptic and now he appears to be demonstrating ignorance of astrophysics too
 
Justintime, you need not put science in so formal a category to claim skeptics are using philosophy more than science to draw their conclusions. And it seems you make the same mistake when you narrow the category this way, as those that think all of philosophy is either common sense or nonsense. Its the fallacy of the excluded middle, and you're really just playing a game of definitions. Its no use to anyone to argue semantics.
I have a biology textbook that uses as an example of the scientific method a person trying to figure out why their flashlight doesn't work. While this is not a formal use of The Scientific Method™ It is the same thinking process that scientists, and actually, everyone with a brain uses, because it works. The textbook goes on to say that it not such a formal method as people think, but rather a process for testing one variable at a time, to verify or not, a hypothesis. Amazing, so simple an idea and yet it has changed so much of our lives.
 
The textbook goes on to say that it not such a formal method as people think, but rather a process for testing one variable at a time, to verify or not, a hypothesis. Amazing, so simple an idea and yet it has changed so much of our lives.

Not to mention that the method predates the nomenclature. people used the scientific method before they knew it was called "the scientific method". (heck there is evidence of the method written on a 1600BC piece of Egyptian papyrus)
 
Today after 50 years of SETI. The number of planets scientist think are capable is reduced to a little over hundred tops.

Complete nonsense, no extrasolar planet was confirmed until 1992 and that had nothing to do with SETI. The number of detected planets has been steadily increasing over the years and with it the number of potentially habitable worlds. Given the relatively greater difficulty of detecting small rocky planets close to their star like Earth it may well be that such planets are currently under represented, though with Kepler approaching the three year mark that may well change.

To put it simply you have things totally backwards.
 
So first you claim you don't believe in interstellar travel nor ETI yet you follow that up with this:



which claims that all we need to achieve interstellar travel is to put some pressure on NASA?

Your lack of comprehension of the vastness of space would be breathtaking were it not such obvious trolling.
He read teh quote somewhere and forgot the first part, ending up with
"Consistency is the sign of a small mind"
 
That is to support my position with citations and subject material. I would not need them if the Skeptics were better informed and just debated the issues.

About what exactly do you feel skeptics need to be better informed?

And better informed than whom?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom