Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

What method do you claim that a mechanic should use to discover which of the multiple ways in which a car can fail is the reason your car won't start?

9th graders get this. Why don't you?

True mechanics are born knowing what the problem is.
 
ON THE VIEW OF EARTH FROM 3.7 BILLION MILES AWAY AS A PALE BLUE DOT:

"Look again at that dot. That's here. That's home, That's us. On it everyone you love, everyone you know, everyone you ever heard of, every human being who ever was, lived out their lives. The aggregate of our joy and suffering, thousands of confident religions, ideologies, and economic doctrines, every hunter and forager, every hero and coward, every creator and destroyer of civilization, every king and peasant, every young couple in love, every mother and father, hopeful child, inventor and explorer, every teacher of morals, every corrupt politician, every 'superstar,' every 'supreme leader,' every saint and sinner in the history of our species lived there-on a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam. ... There is perhaps no better demonstration of the folly of human conceits than this distant image of our tiny world. To me, it underscores our responsibility to deal more kindly with one another, and to preserve and cherish the pale blue dot, the only home we've ever known."

-"You Are Here," Pale Blue Dot, pp. 8-9.
 
If Skeptics as many claim apply critical thinking and adhere to credible evidence directed scrutiny, should this then lead to conclusions different from those who do not apply such processes.

It usually does. This is why few sceptics know so little about evolution that they think that anybody believes "he is from a monkey".

Here's an idea, rather than making these sweeping generalisations on subjects that you evidently know very little about, why don't you try picking up a book and educating yourself? You'll be amazed at what a difference it can make. Even just learning a little about what you're trying to discuss would be a start.
 
ON THE VIEW OF EARTH FROM 3.7 BILLION MILES AWAY AS A PALE BLUE DOT:

"Look again at that dot. That's here. That's home, That's us. On it everyone you love, everyone you know, everyone you ever heard of, every human being who ever was, lived out their lives. The aggregate of our joy and suffering, thousands of confident religions, ideologies, and economic doctrines, every hunter and forager, every hero and coward, every creator and destroyer of civilization, every king and peasant, every young couple in love, every mother and father, hopeful child, inventor and explorer, every teacher of morals, every corrupt politician, every 'superstar,' every 'supreme leader,' every saint and sinner in the history of our species lived there-on a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam. ... There is perhaps no better demonstration of the folly of human conceits than this distant image of our tiny world. To me, it underscores our responsibility to deal more kindly with one another, and to preserve and cherish the pale blue dot, the only home we've ever known."

-"You Are Here," Pale Blue Dot, pp. 8-9.
 
I was already familiar with all the stuff he wrote about. Religion, UFOs, Ghosts, Aliens etc. I was only interested in him as a skeptic and what he did to back that claim. His attacks on religion, UFOs and Ghosts are not new. It is only new on Skeptic forums. Those arguments have been around for a very long time. I am happy I did not read any of them because they were not literary best sellers just popular reading.

There comes a time when you have to ask. Show me the beef? Where are the ETI?


The highlighted text is odd, becfause you claim never to have read Dr. Sagan's work.
Depending upon secondary sources, when the primary sources are reaily available, is as dishonest as quote-mining; as dishonest as pretending a quote is from a provided source when it is not; as dishonest as presenting a quotation without a citation or source.

Nice trifecta.

The problem with spin-doctoring the life work of someone like Dr. Sagan on a forum full of scientifically literate rational people is that many here have, in fact, read Dr. Sagan's actual words, nor the slurs of his detractors. Your "arguments" are not new; they are simply false. It is to be hop;ed you are not this careless with your other superstitions unsupported beliefs...

Do you plan to provide sources for your quotes above? Or are you content with dishonesty?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
http://www.csicop.org/si/show/does_truth_matter_science_pseudoscience_and_civilization/

Does Truth Matter? Science, Pseudoscience, and Civilization

Volume 20.2, March / April 1996
Carl Sagan

Science has beauty, power, and majesty that can provide spiritual as well as practical fulfillment. But superstition and pseudoscience keep getting in the way providing easy answers, casually pressing our awe buttons, and cheapening the experience.
 
I haven't been long enough on this site to grade it. But I can say Skeptics appear to like what I am saying because they are responding to my posts with feverish enthusiasm even when they disagree with me. Maybe it is because I think out of the box and Skeptics are craving for some original ideas.

I don't believe in UFOs and I don't believe in Carl Sagan or his ETI. There are better ways to spend research grants and better research projects than looking of smarter people millions of miles away.

It is only insecure people that look for intelligence in other beings. And it is strange, that is how I described skeptics.

There was a point where I thought you might be well intentioned. Apparently I was mistaken.
 
I haven't been long enough on this site to grade it. But I can say Skeptics appear to like what I am saying because they are responding to my posts with feverish enthusiasm even when they disagree with me. Maybe it is because I think out of the box and Skeptics are craving for some original ideas.
No, no, no... No... God, no.

Tell you what, do a search for DavidJayJordan and peruse some of his threads. See how active they were.

I thought that the belief that thread traffic somehow positively correlated with the quality of the arguments presented by the OP was unique to DOC. Seriously, go type "stupid stunt" into the Youtube search engine and see how many views some of those videos have attracted.

I don't believe in UFOs and I don't believe in Carl Sagan or his ETI.
I can assure you that Carl Sagan really existed.

There are better ways to spend research grants and better research projects than looking of smarter people millions of miles away.
Millions? you really don't have a clue how big the universe is, do you? The nearest star to Sol is around 25 trillion miles away.

It is only insecure people that look for intelligence in other beings. And it is strange, that is how I described skeptics.
That is absolutely one of the stupidest statements I've ever read.
 
Not because I was skeptical. It was because I was rational and that made the difference.

Could you explain how you can be rational without being skeptical?

If someone came to you and claimed to have discovered the cure for cancer in the back of his refrigerator, would you believe him without question, or would you ask to see evidence to support his claim? If you say "I would reserve judgment regarding the claim until I'd seen some evidence of its veracity", then you are a skeptic. If you are not a skeptic, then you might say something like, "Wonderful! Here's all my life savings to invest in your company".

You clearly did a quick Google search for the word "epistemology" after seeing it in one of my earlier posts, then used it without any real understanding of what it means. This is transparently obvious because the above statement shows a gross lack of knowledge of a simple epistemological concept. It's as though you overheard someone working on a '62 Chevrolet pickup talking about replacing and gapping the points and re-jetting the carburetor, then walked over to someone working on a 2011 Honda Accord and told him, "Be sure to replace and gap the points and re-jet the carburetor". You clearly don't know what "skeptic" or "rational" mean.
 
I understand the frustrations you guys are going through. I too am disappointed he was so wrong and no ETI were found. But we should not be apologizing for him. He made a lot of money by getting in on a hot idea and marketing it.

When his search was turning futile he even began to interview alien abductees to keep the interest alive and stay in the public eye. But he was careful to discredit them so his funding would not be affected.

There is only so much the public will take after years of watching a blank screen on a monitor supposed to contact ETI with radio signals and hope they signal back. Not a blimp on the screen for 50 years.

He said many things in his lifetime. But is known mainly for his "billions and billions" and SETI. and his serious fascination with aliens.

I used to watch Cosmos but stopped when he started talking about Extraterrestrial intelligent. It was bad enough we have UFO whack whacks but to have to listen to his nonsense was a bit much.

Maybe I missed something. But it sure wasn't ETI. :)

You appear to be very good at quoting things that you cannot back up with reliable sources.

And as far as SETI goes, and its failure so far to pick up signals from extra-terrestrials for 50 years, well, I think it shows that you have no understanding of what is involved. I'm guessing you think they just point some dishes towards the sky and listen? Well, it is a LOT more complicated than that. They listen almost exclusively in one, narrow band of frequencies (bracketing the 1421 mHz hydrogen line and the 1650 MHz by hydroxyl ion line), in one direction defined by a width of only a few minutes of arc. Yes, there are wide field searches done too, but these are far less likely to pick up signals because they are low-resolution searches

In point of fact, if you were a member of a SETI program run by an intelligent species living on a planet circling Alpha Centauri, and you pointed your dish at us and listened on that frequency, the chances are that you would hear nothing, because we don't happen to broadcast anything on 1421 mHz powerful enough to be heard that far away.

SETI isn't listening for incidental broadcasts of alien TV or Radio signals. Those are too weak to be detected because they fall into the noisy cosmic background within a far less distance than that to the nearest star, they are listening for ET's broadcasting signals in our general direction. Those signals would have to be hugely powerful for us to receive them.

Another point about the 50 years, well, how long have physicists been looking for a unified field theory and how long have they been trying to explain the origin of the Universe.....about a hundred years, While we are a lot closer than we were, we aren't there yet, but there is no sign of them giving up.
 
Last edited:
I did not read his books because they were on subjects I had no interest in. He came across to me as a salesman. In fact he was recognized for that talent in the scientific community.

"Carl Sagan was probably the best salesman science ever had."

That comes from here. Did you think that by excluding the source that we wouldn't discover that these are the words of a single person who isn't even identified as a scientist, or were you just being sloppy? And it is clear that the author is talking about Carl Sagan as a popularizer of science, as someone who was dedicated to making science accessible to everyone.

Sorry, but your sloppy cherry-picking doesn't support your assertion.
 
ahead of NASA eh?

design me a spacecraft capable of traveling to Venus and back (with applicable flight path trajectories and burn times)

I'll give you a few days (and no high detail blueprints required, just a rough sketch with applicable notes)


I'll give you part of the answer:

A six second course correction burn at T+68:15:24:35-41.

The rest you're going to have to figure out on your own.
 
Last edited:
I was already familiar with all the stuff he wrote about. Religion, UFOs, Ghosts, Aliens etc. I was only interested in him as a skeptic and what he did to back that claim. His attacks on religion, UFOs and Ghosts are not new. It is only new on Skeptic forums. Those arguments have been around for a very long time.
Ii is clear that you haven't read Sagan, or you would know that he never attacked religion, UFO claims or ghosts. He simply doubted them.

I am happy I did not read any of them because they were not literary best sellers just popular reading.
It's sad to see someone so defiantly proud of his own ignorance.

There comes a time when you have to ask. Show me the beef? Where are the ETI?
We don't know. They may not be out there. They may not be using technology we can detect. They may be too far away. They may be where we haven't looked yet. Remember that analogy about looking for a ring on a football field and only having searched a few square yards so far? The ring may not be there, but looking for 30 seconds and then declaring it is not there is the act of a fool.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom