Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Again stop proejecting what YOU think Carl Sagan said and did not say.

He and many other scientists have carried out SCIENTIFIC research into the POSSIBIITY of Exterterestial life, and it has largely been prvatly funded not state funded.


Now have you actually read any of his books?
 
And the first solar sail was deployed by NASA in 2011

http://www.nasa.gov/connect/chat/nanosail_chat2.html

NASA is now one step closer to sailing among the stars! In a historic milestone on Jan. 21, 2011, NASA engineers confirmed that the NanoSail-D nanosatellite deployed its 100-square-foot polymer sail in low-Earth orbit and is operating as planned. The deployment was confirmed with beacon packets data received from NanoSail-D and additional ground-based satellite tracking assets.

Looks like NASA is way ahead of you

http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20110007225_2011006130.pdf
 
Last edited:
Get another mechanic. Why pay for a total analysis of the problem when all you only want it to have your car fixed and a mechanic who knows how to fix it. I am sure a scientist can also fix your car using his scientific method. How much are you willing to pay him to get it fixed.

The problem, which you'd realize if you thought about it for five seconds, is that sometimes neither you nor the mechanic knows what the problem IS. The SM is a method of discovering the unknown. If there's an obvious problem, yeah, no need to go through the SM--my dome light is busted in my car, and it's fairly obvious (it's sitting in the back seat for one thing). But if my car won't start, how do you fix it? Most people--my wife included--think it's the battery, the alternator, I didn't put gas in it, that type of thing. I saw an ignition cylender go bad once, which was only obvious after we'd removed it. But none of those were the issue for my car when it died. It required a fair bit of research and experimentation to figure out what was going on, because it was an unknown.

aggle-rithm said:
...remembering as you continue the experiment to always keep in the back of your mind the nagging suspicion that the test battery was also dead.
My family learned early on to side-step THAT issue. We hook the battery up to something (usually another car, but sometimes a tool, and once a wrench [I don't recommend it]). We know the thing works with the old battery, so if it doesn't work with the new one the battery is the problem.

That's an example of a particular twist on the SM called Strong Inferrence. You establish mutually-exclusive working hypotheses and devise a test that will disprove one. H1=the battery works. H2=the battery is fried. The test is hooking it up to something you know works. If the thing works, H2 is disproven. If not, H1 is.

Evolved Wookie said:
A dictionary does NOT define the only and correct use of language, it reflects the proper use of words.
It's actually even worse than that. The majority of dictionaries don't actually attempt to define jargon; they define commonly-used terms. If you look up "character" in any common dictionary you won't find "a trait or feature of an organism used in cladistic analysis". I've looked in enough to be fairly confident in that statement. And this discussion includes a great deal of jargon, despite the fact that it doesn't look that way. The scientific method means something different to scientists than to non-scientists, and dictionaries simply won't include that because there aren't enough scientists to make our definition common.

StankApe said:
I get the impression that he thinks the scientific method can't be accomplished without lab coats, flasks,beakers and lots of colorful fluids and smoke.
I call it physics envy. People have this view that physics is science as such, and everything needs to comply with the way physics is done. A fantastic application of the scientific method is making a geological map, but it takes forever for people to realize that--they don't think hiking and drawing and coloring are science.
 
Again stop proejecting what YOU think Carl Sagan said and did not say.

He and many other scientists have carried out SCIENTIFIC research into the POSSIBIITY of Exterterestial life, and it has largely been prvatly funded not state funded.


Now have you actually read any of his books?

No I have not read any of his books. I just stated I am not interested in UFOs or ETI or aliens or ghost or religion or the superstitions he considers irrational beliefs. I was way ahead of him. I did not suffer his obsessions. Not because I was skeptical. It was because I was rational and that made the difference.

But I read a lot of biographical material for my research.
 
I haven't been long enough on this site to grade it. But I can say Skeptics appear to like what I am saying because they are responding to my posts with feverish enthusiasm even when they disagree with me. Maybe it is because I think out of the box and Skeptics are craving for some original ideas.

I don't believe in UFOs and I don't believe in Carl Sagan or his ETI. There are better ways to spend research grants and better research projects than looking of smarter people millions of miles away.

It is only insecure people that look for intelligence in other beings. And it is strange, that is how I described skeptics.

<snip>

How odd to contrast this:
"I don't believe in UFOs and I don't believe in Carl Sagan or his ETI. There are better ways to spend research grants and better research projects than looking of smarter people millions of miles away"

with this:
Where Carl Sagan failed my ideas will succeed. If aliens won't come to us, we will go to them. :)

It is also funny to see you act so insecure, and so desperate for attention, while you pretend that skeptics are insecure, and emit "fear signals".

Do you ever read your own stuff?

BTW: Do you ever intend to provide the sources for what you claim are accurate quotes about Dr. Sagan? Because, as you know, the accuracy of your sources has been demonstrably spotty, even just on this forum...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No I have not read any of his books. I just stated I am not interested in UFOs or ETI or aliens or ghost or religion or the superstitions he considers irrational beliefs. I was way ahead of him. I did not suffer his obsessions. Not because I was skeptical. It was because I was rational and that made the difference.

But I read a lot of biographical material for my research.

Game, set, match.
 
Carl sagan did not beleive in ghosts, or UFOs either in his professianal Adult life.

He may have done in his youth, I certainly did when I was a teenager and when I reached adulthood turned my back on that rubbish just like Carl sagan did.

You would know that if you read his books instead of projecting your views onto him.
 
And the first solar sail was deployed by NASA in 2011

http://www.nasa.gov/connect/chat/nanosail_chat2.html

NASA is now one step closer to sailing among the stars! In a historic milestone on Jan. 21, 2011, NASA engineers confirmed that the NanoSail-D nanosatellite deployed its 100-square-foot polymer sail in low-Earth orbit and is operating as planned. The deployment was confirmed with beacon packets data received from NanoSail-D and additional ground-based satellite tracking assets.

Looks like NASA is way ahead of you

http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20110007225_2011006130.pdf

I won't be satisfied till we get intergalactic travel. And this is one way to pressure NASA. Make those demands in public.
 
Carl sagan did not beleive in ghosts, or UFOs either in his professianal Adult life.

He may have done in his youth, I certainly did when I was a teenager and when I reached adulthood turned my back on that rubbish just like Carl sagan did.

You would know that if you read his books instead of projecting your views onto him.

I did not read his books because they were on subjects I had no interest in. He came across to me as a salesman. In fact he was recognized for that talent in the scientific community.

Carl Sagan was probably the best salesman science ever had
 
JT you have not read any of Carl Sagan's books or works so you actually know nothing about his views and work you are not qulaified to comment on his life and work.


And if you are hoping for interglactic travel its not happening in your lifetime nor mine so do not hold your breath.
 
Before you knock a man and claim you know what his views are you should at least familiarise yourself with their actual writings and works, before you even try to pass jsudgement.

Start here:

Intelligent Life in the Universe (1966) (with L S Shklovskii)
Planets (1966) (with Jonathan Norton Leonard)
The Cosmic Connection: An Extraterrestrail Perspective (1973)
Communicaton with Extraterrestrial Intelligence (1973)
Other Worlds (1975)
The Dragons of Eden: Speculations on the Evolution of Human Intelligence (1977)
Broca's Brain: The Romance of Science (1979)
Cosmos: The Story of Cosmic Evolution, Science and Civilization (1980) (with Gentry Lee)
Murmurs of Earth: The Voyager Interstellar Record (1983)
Comet (1985) (with Ann Druyan)
Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors (1992) (with Ann Druyan)
Pale Blue Dot: A Vision of the Human Future in Space (1994)
The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark (1995)
Billions and Billions: Thoughts on Life and Death at the Brink of the Millennium (1997)
The Varieties of Scientific Experience: A Personal View of the Search for God (2006)
 
Last edited:
Before you knock a man abd clain you know what his views are you should at least familairsie yourself with their actual writings and works, before you even try to pass jsudgement.

Start here:

Intelligent Life in the Universe (1966) (with L S Shklovskii)
Planets (1966) (with Jonathan Norton Leonard)
The Cosmic Connection: An Extraterrestrail Perspective (1973)
Communicaton with Extraterrestrial Intelligence (1973)
Other Worlds (1975)
The Dragons of Eden: Speculations on the Evolution of Human Intelligence (1977)
Broca's Brain: The Romance of Science (1979)
Cosmos: The Story of Cosmic Evolution, Science and Civilization (1980) (with Gentry Lee)
Murmurs of Earth: The Voyager Interstellar Record (1983)
Comet (1985) (with Ann Druyan)
Shadows of Forgotten Ancestors (1992) (with Ann Druyan)
Pale Blue Dot: A Vision of the Human Future in Space (1994)
The Demon Haunted World: Science as a Candle in the Dark (1995)
Billions and Billions: Thoughts on Life and Death at the Brink of the Millennium (1997)
The Varieties of Scientific Experience: A Personal View of the Search for God (2006)

I was already familiar with all the stuff he wrote about. Religion, UFOs, Ghosts, Aliens etc. I was only interested in him as a skeptic and what he did to back that claim. His attacks on religion, UFOs and Ghosts are not new. It is only new on Skeptic forums. Those arguments have been around for a very long time. I am happy I did not read any of them because they were not literary best sellers just popular reading.

There comes a time when you have to ask. Show me the beef? Where are the ETI?
 
The rated speed is 100,000 MPH. One light year is 5,879,000,000,000
So do the math. It is roughly 6711 years. Because it is solar powered it can travel large distances. They might have to be launched closer to the destination if you are in a hurry. :)
Now, there's quite the trick, and here we've been missing it all along, when it was a plain as the nose on our faces.
Takes too long to get from LA to NYC? Well, start in Chicago instead of LA!
Brilliant!
 
I was already familiar with all the stuff he wrote about. Religion, UFOs, Ghosts, Aliens etc. I was only interested in him as a skeptic and what he did to back that claim. His attacks on religion, UFOs and Ghosts are not new. It is only new on Skeptic forums. Those arguments have been around for a very long time. I am happy I did not read any of them because they were not literary best sellers just popular reading.

There comes a time when you have to ask. Show me the beef? Where are the ETI?

You have stated you ahve not read hos books therefore you knwo nothing about the man nor his views other than second hand information, that is not good enough.

Carl Sagan never in his adult professional life claimed that aliens and ETI absolutly exist as a FACT, he did argue for the POSSIBIITY of their existance and set out as did many others to try to find evidence, he died before he could finsih his search, and it ws not his CORE work just one part of many strands.

But you do not knwo that as you have not even had the basic courtesy to read his books and works academic and non academic before condeming him.

You might want to read this:

http://www.csicop.org/si/show/carl_sagans_life_and_legacy_as_scientist_teacher_and_skeptic

Sagan was a founding member of the Committee for Scientific Investigation of Claims of the Paranormal.
 
I'd love to believe in the paranormal, an afterlife, all sorts of things, but I don't because there's no evidence for them.

Sceptics have the same human needs as everyone else but they make a conscious effort to recognise and allow for their own biases in order to find out what's really true. It's hard, and we all fail occasionally, but at least we try.

I raised the same questions. If Skeptics as many claim apply critical thinking and adhere to credible evidence directed scrutiny, should this then lead to conclusions different from those who do not apply such processes.

The answer was found in What is Skepticism:
http://skeptoid.com/skeptic.php

It's thus inaccurate to say "Skeptics don't believe in ghosts." Some do. Many skeptics are deeply religious, and are satisfied with the reasoning process that led them there.

In short Skeptics also end up believing in Ghosts and religion. So those processes Skeptics think they are applying is not as reliable as they are making it out to be.

Emanuel Kant said. "We believe in things that are useful to us."

Id rather a man took up religion because it helped him avoid a life of crime than the same man starts believing he is from a monkey, therefor quite helpless to avoid his criminal behavior.

Or the man wants to be the fastest tree climber where believing he is from a monkey might actually help him psychologically.

"Man believes in things because it is useful to him.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom