Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Justintime, did you actually post a link to the Weekly World News with a straight face?

Some of the headlines recently on their site, for those who might be unfamiliar with that esteemed publication:

"Mitt Romney Wins Powerball Lottery" (they also report in separate articles that Romney was made Secretary of the Treasury and "President of Disneyland," whatever that is)
"Obama on New Dollar Bill"
"Vampires on the Loose in Chicago"
"Bigfoot has Three Wives"
 
Last edited:
Could you cite the passage in question?

If UFO believers (you're one, aren't you?) couldn't understand why he would conclude that there is no evidence of alien visitation, yet still consider the possibility that life has evolved on other worlds, then the failure is theirs.


So, like a scientist, he refused to make declarations about things that are epistemologically unknowable, preferring to say things like, "It's possible that aliens are visiting Earth, but there is no evidence that they are and no justification for claiming certainty that UFOs are of alien origin".


In other words, he examined UFO claims in detail and considered them from every angle he could think of before concluding that there was no empirical evidence that UFO sightings and alien abduction accounts were most likely not the result of actual alien visitations.

I have read his biographies. Even better, I've read his own words. Your inability to understand his positions would seem to derive from a deficiency in reading comprehension.

I just said in my earlier post I stopped listening to Carl Sagan after he started talking about Extraterrestrial Intelligence. It is bad enough we have UFO whack whacks. That should have suggested to you I am not a UFO believer.

As for his contradictory positions on UFOs and aliens.

By that time he was an outspoken skeptic of the “saucers,” although he evidently was not skeptical enough for Menzel, who privately complained that Sagan expressed his skepticism in artfully convoluted sentences that others might misinterpret. Meanwhile, Urey grumbled that Sagan speculated wildly about the possible molecular constituents of other planets.

Pioneer 10 and Pioneer 11 space probes that were scheduled to visit the outer planets and (because their speed exceeded solar escape velocity) would eventually leave the solar system. Sagan argued that extraterrestrials might eventually recover the spaceships millions of years from now, though he acknowledged the probability was extremely low.

Sagan’s role is especially interesting because he himself was accused of straying beyond the limits of proper science in his pursuit of evidence for life on other planets and his defense of SETI. As Achenbach argues, it was precisely because of his apparent open-minded attitude toward fringe topics that many on the fringe became so bitter when Sagan turned against them.
 
Sagan never turned agaisnt them hewas never with them.

Also there is key word in one of those paragrpahs "MIGHT"
 
I know better than this...

Rocket-Boy, you did not claim that "intergalactic travel" could be possible. Many of us here have understood, and hoped for, that, for years.

The claim you made was that plans for the next generation of long distance rockets, capable of intergalactic travel, exist. When asked to provide evidence, you put up a link to a sensationalist article about the possibility of "solar sails".

Par for your course...

Yes I did say NASA did not have that capability, yet. I also said I was ahead of the times even NASA. Now that is not something to scoff at. It is obvious NASA has to catchup with my futuristic vision of intergalactic travel.

Where Carl Sagan failed my ideas will succeed. If aliens won't come to us, we will go to them. :)
 
I just said in my earlier post I stopped listening to Carl Sagan after he started talking about Extraterrestrial Intelligence. It is bad enough we have UFO whack whacks. That should have suggested to you I am not a UFO believer.

As for his contradictory positions on UFOs and aliens.

<snip>--please provide sources for your quotes,so that they can be checked for aptness, accuracy, reliability of source, and context.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Justintime, did you actually post a link to the Weekly World News with a straight face?

Some of the headlines recently on their site, for those who might be unfamiliar with that esteemed publication:

"Mitt Romney Wins Powerball Lottery" (they also report in separate articles that Romney was made Secretary of the Treasury and "President of Disneyland," whatever that is)
"Obama on New Dollar Bill"
"Vampires on the Loose in Chicago"
"Bigfoot has Three Wives"
Sorry to disappoint you. I am not a member of the Weekly World News. But I correctly predicted Obamas win on The Daily Beast.
 
Jack:

The article Rocket-Boy posted speculated that with advances in materials and construction, a solar-sail-powered craft might, possibly, be capable of leaving our solar system within 8 years of being launched...

Yes, I followed the link. I liked the worked example of a craft accelerating at almost 1g. It had a kilometer wide sail and an all-up mass of 1kg. Not much crew space.
 
Yes I did say NASA did not have that capability, yet. I also said I was ahead of the times even NASA. Now that is not something to scoff at. It is obvious NASA has to catchup with my futuristic vision of intergalactic travel.

Where Carl Sagan failed my ideas will succeed. If aliens won't come to us, we will go to them. :)

I know better than this--

<snip> what you originally said was:
There are plans to build the next generation of rockets that will push us past our own galaxy. NASA does not have that capability yet. Sort of if they won`t come to us we just have to go to them.

...and...

You forget. The long range rockets combined with launching pad based on distant planets will enable us to get beyond our Milky Way.

Pressed for support, or corroboration, you provided a link to a sensationalist article about the theoretical possibility of solar-sail-powered interstellar flight. Do you ever intend to provide the source of your claim about the "next generation" of "long range (sic) rockets"?

This tendency of yours is why it is important for you to provide sources for your quotes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
MR Intime you are barking up the wrong tree completely about Carl Sagan,

read Cosmos and The Demon Haunted World cover to cover then come to a conclusion.
 
Yes, I followed the link. I liked the worked example of a craft accelerating at almost 1g. It had a kilometer wide sail and an all-up mass of 1kg. Not much crew space.

I know, right? But that's the "next generation" of "long range rockets", according to justintime...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Where Carl Sagan failed my ideas will succeed. If aliens won't come to us, we will go to them. :)

Volunteers wanted: You and all your descendants for the next hundred generations wanted urgently to sign up for a space mission. You get to spend the rest of your life in a spaceship. That's about it. Please note you are signing up on behalf of all future children and grandchildren etc too. Same deal for them. Your great100 grandchild might get to meet an alien. Maybe.
 
This was a good read too

http://www.skeptic.com/magazine/archives/vol04n04.html

Skeptisc Magazines tribute to Carl Sagan

http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/sagan-leaves-us/

In Memory of Carl Sagan 1934–1996:
Carl Leaves Us

by James Randi

My heroes are few. Martin Gardner, Dick Feynman, Isaac Asimov, Carl Sagan. With all that brilliance, my starry zodiac was more than adequate. Dick, Isaac, and now Carl are gone.

I’m glad that I last saw him in person in Seattle, looking well, and to all appearances recovering from his ailment. We sat and spoke for a long time. The last time.

Up until the end, he was confident, cheery, optimistic. Despite the ravages of his illness and the obvious, visible effects of the therapy he was undergoing, he made every public appearance he could in his last weeks. He was brave in the face of his demise, and went like the warrior he was.
 
Last edited:
Slowvehicle is a couple of years behind which is just the opposite of me. I am so far ahead. :)
Check it out.
Japan launches Venus probe and solar sail
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/3726475...launches-venus-probe-solar-sail/#.UL9le3cfq_1

t is probable, given your demonstrated degree of science literacy, that you do not realize your link talks about an interplanetary solar sail, not an intergalactic "next-generation rocket".

But don't worry-you can, in fact, catch up, if you try hard enough. I believe nearly anyone is teachable.
 
Last edited:
We already know why cheese turn green. It is the mold that causes it to turn green. If you knew that and was less of a Skeptic. You might have ended checking her out for suspect mold instead of being directed to a dead cow.

Next time someone shows you a picture of udders, Be less skeptical.

So I gave you an example of scepticism that was outside of your narrow definition and you respond by whiffling?

Can you understand why these statements are wrong in exactly the same way your statement is wrong?

Christians are stupid.

Arabs are fundamentalists.

Women are bad drivers.
 

I haven't been long enough on this site to grade it. But I can say Skeptics appear to like what I am saying because they are responding to my posts with feverish enthusiasm even when they disagree with me. Maybe it is because I think out of the box and Skeptics are craving for some original ideas.

I don't believe in UFOs and I don't believe in Carl Sagan or his ETI. There are better ways to spend research grants and better research projects than looking of smarter people millions of miles away.

It is only insecure people that look for intelligence in other beings. And it is strange, that is how I described skeptics.
 
I just said in my earlier post I stopped listening to Carl Sagan after he started talking about Extraterrestrial Intelligence. It is bad enough we have UFO whack whacks. That should have suggested to you I am not a UFO believer.
Then what was that stuff about the Mayans?

Again, I have to ask: What is it about the concept of concluding that extraterrestrial life might exist elsewhere, but that there is no evidence that it is traveling here to visit us, that eludes you? It's like you are saying "If you believe that giant squid exist in the deep ocean, then you have to believe that they live between your front door and your mailbox". I'm afraid that the only two possibilities that I can see are that you are being deliberately obtuse, or that this very simple concept is genuinely beyond your intellect. Which is it?

As for his contradictory positions on UFOs and aliens.
What contradictions do you think that you are demonstrating? Seriously.

If I'm a juror who votes "not guilty" because I haven't seen evidence to prove the guilt of the defendant, and a friend later asks me if I think that the defendant was innocent and I say "I don't know. It's possible that he committed the crime", it is not a contradiction. You seem to think that one either has to say "I'm certain that UFOs are alien craft" or "I'm certain the UFOs are not alien craft", that these are the only two legitimate positions. This is binary thinking. It's a false dichotomy. Saying, "Based on the available evidence, I feel that UFOs are very unlikely to be alien craft", is actually the most logically justifiable position to take.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom