Evolved Wookie
A rigidly defined area of doubt and uncertainty
- Joined
- Aug 25, 2008
- Messages
- 601
Not again…
I am fed up with this tactic of quoting a dictionary definition and then deriving a dogmatic argument from it. Years ago, had you asked me, I would have held up the OED definition of a word as being correct, but I have now seen just how wrong one can be if you accept such a definition without any exterior knowledge of the subject and no intention of admitting your ignorance.
A dictionary does NOT define the only and correct use of language, it reflects the proper use of words. If the proper use of words and the dictionary disagree, it’s the dictionary that’s wrong!
As for science; both my wife and I were educated as scientists (applied and pure physics, respectively). My first job was as a metrologist – about the purest form of science you can get – the practice of measuring things. After that, I went to work in the RF plant of a particle accelerator – about the most mechanical end of the spectrum I can think of. I work every day with mechanics, engineers and pure scientists. I have a VERY good idea of what the scientific method entails and how to apply it, but I would not claim any more to be a “professional scientist”…so do I have any authority to speak on the subject or not? I’m sure you have a view…
A “professional scientist” is merely someone who makes his or her living from the application of the scientific method. Everybody applies the scientific method to most of their lives most of the time. If you have something real to say or a point to make then go ahead, but all you’re doing right now is demonstrating how very far you are from having the slightest idea about how the scientific community works.
I am fed up with this tactic of quoting a dictionary definition and then deriving a dogmatic argument from it. Years ago, had you asked me, I would have held up the OED definition of a word as being correct, but I have now seen just how wrong one can be if you accept such a definition without any exterior knowledge of the subject and no intention of admitting your ignorance.
A dictionary does NOT define the only and correct use of language, it reflects the proper use of words. If the proper use of words and the dictionary disagree, it’s the dictionary that’s wrong!
As for science; both my wife and I were educated as scientists (applied and pure physics, respectively). My first job was as a metrologist – about the purest form of science you can get – the practice of measuring things. After that, I went to work in the RF plant of a particle accelerator – about the most mechanical end of the spectrum I can think of. I work every day with mechanics, engineers and pure scientists. I have a VERY good idea of what the scientific method entails and how to apply it, but I would not claim any more to be a “professional scientist”…so do I have any authority to speak on the subject or not? I’m sure you have a view…
A “professional scientist” is merely someone who makes his or her living from the application of the scientific method. Everybody applies the scientific method to most of their lives most of the time. If you have something real to say or a point to make then go ahead, but all you’re doing right now is demonstrating how very far you are from having the slightest idea about how the scientific community works.
Last edited: