Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Not again…

I am fed up with this tactic of quoting a dictionary definition and then deriving a dogmatic argument from it. Years ago, had you asked me, I would have held up the OED definition of a word as being correct, but I have now seen just how wrong one can be if you accept such a definition without any exterior knowledge of the subject and no intention of admitting your ignorance.

A dictionary does NOT define the only and correct use of language, it reflects the proper use of words. If the proper use of words and the dictionary disagree, it’s the dictionary that’s wrong!

As for science; both my wife and I were educated as scientists (applied and pure physics, respectively). My first job was as a metrologist – about the purest form of science you can get – the practice of measuring things. After that, I went to work in the RF plant of a particle accelerator – about the most mechanical end of the spectrum I can think of. I work every day with mechanics, engineers and pure scientists. I have a VERY good idea of what the scientific method entails and how to apply it, but I would not claim any more to be a “professional scientist”…so do I have any authority to speak on the subject or not? I’m sure you have a view…

A “professional scientist” is merely someone who makes his or her living from the application of the scientific method. Everybody applies the scientific method to most of their lives most of the time. If you have something real to say or a point to make then go ahead, but all you’re doing right now is demonstrating how very far you are from having the slightest idea about how the scientific community works.
 
Last edited:
His biography mentions the balancing act he had to maintain between his public and private beliefs. UFOs enthusiast could not understand why he was looking for aliens everywhere but HERE.

Consider providing support for this speculation, or learn the useful phrase, "In my opinion, for which I can offer no actual support..."

He never said anything in the affirmative. So one could take it either way.
.

He also never said he was not the lost Dauphin. Your point?

Example. He would go into great details about UFOs but then conclude there was no evidence and therefore not believable. It is best to read his biographies and draw your own conclusions.

I challenge you to find a single instance of Dr. Sagan going into "great details about UFOs" except for the express purpose of debunking the credulous craze of UFO sightings. comparing them to other credulous superstitions. Were you aware, for instance, that some people who mock Dr. Sagan for being "obsessed" with "aliens", and for believing in aliens, credulously accept tabloid rags as evidence, and believe that ancient mesoamerican civilizations actually did have contact with "aliens" in "UFOs"? SO many people make so many unsupported silly claims that the work or spreading reason and teaching skeptical thinking skills is never-ending. We are, as I used to tell school boards, never more than one generation away from barbarism. Dealing with the superstitious and the credulous on a daily basis, some say we are already there.
 
Last edited:
Get another mechanic. Why pay for a total analysis of the problem when all you only want it to have your car fixed and a mechanic who knows how to fix it. I am sure a scientist can also fix your car using his scientific method. How much are you willing to pay him to get it fixed.

What method do you claim that a mechanic should use to discover which of the multiple ways in which a car can fail is the reason your car won't start?

9th graders get this. Why don't you?
 
I know they use mathematical modelling as part of the scientific method in experimental sciences (chemistry, biology and physics)

Is it possible,in your opinion, to use a scientific method without "mathematical modeling"?
In your opinion, is there more than one "scientific method"?
Who, in your opinion, developed "scientific methodology"?
Where, in your opinion, does the polymath fit in?
What do you suppose the world claim to exist would be like,. if "scientific methodology" were limited to "scientists", and everyone else had to depend upon divine revelation or blind luck?
 
5. Analysis

Car still won't start. Dead battery is not cause of failure to start.

6. Go back to step 2

----------

2. Hypothesis

Car will not start because coil is burned out.

And so on.

...remembering as you continue the experiment to always keep in the back of your mind the nagging suspicion that the test battery was also dead.
 
Justintime please tell us how long this solar-sail-ship needs for travelling with constant speed over the distance of one light year.

The rated speed is 100,000 MPH. One light year is 5,879,000,000,000
So do the math. It is roughly 6711 years. Because it is solar powered it can travel large distances. They might have to be launched closer to the destination if you are in a hurry. :)
 
Today after 50 years of SETI. The number of planets scientist think are capable is reduced to a little over hundred tops. And even there is could be microbial and not the ETI Carl Sagan envisioned. Please don`t ask for link. I did not save it.

There is no link, because what you posted is not true.
 
I said a scholarly source (such as New Scientist, Scientific American, the American Journal of Archaeology, Nature, the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Proceedings of the Royal Society, Science; even the Christian Science Monitor); genuine, reliable and trustworthy sources that carry "peer-reviewed" articles not the unbridled speculation and fabricated pseudo-science that is prevalent in the sensationalist gutter press you have cited here.

I had a fascination with aliens when I was 17, and now I'm 57 and I have my computers (all 10 of them) signed up to BOINC programmes; SETI@Home, Rosetta and Einstein. I guess you would regard me as obsessed with aliens, the human genome and gravitational waves.

No, by YOUR definition, that is obsession. I prefer to use definitions that are well understood among the remaining members of humanity

"OBSESSION: a persistent, disturbing, single-minded preoccupation with an unreasonable idea, to the exclusion of everything else"


So he carried an interest throughout his life, but that doesn't mean he was obsessed with it. You appear to be more obsessed with him, that he was with UFO's

If he had any obsession at all, it was that he was worried that we were heading down the path to self destruction. The "Pale Blue Dot" was not just a catchphrase, it had real meaning for him.

How little you have read of his works if that is what you think?




Ooohh, that exposed him somewhat cruelly.

Wait for the handwave now!!

I understand the frustrations you guys are going through. I too am disappointed he was so wrong and no ETI were found. But we should not be apologizing for him. He made a lot of money by getting in on a hot idea and marketing it.

When his search was turning futile he even began to interview alien abductees to keep the interest alive and stay in the public eye. But he was careful to discredit them so his funding would not be affected.

There is only so much the public will take after years of watching a blank screen on a monitor supposed to contact ETI with radio signals and hope they signal back. Not a blimp on the screen for 50 years.

He said many things in his lifetime. But is known mainly for his "billions and billions" and SETI. and his serious fascination with aliens.

I used to watch Cosmos but stopped when he started talking about Extraterrestrial intelligent. It was bad enough we have UFO whack whacks but to have to listen to his nonsense was a bit much.

Maybe I missed something. But it sure wasn't ETI. :)
 
Last edited:
His biography mentions the balancing act he had to maintain between his public and private beliefs. UFOs enthusiast could not understand why he was looking for aliens everywhere but HERE.
Could you cite the passage in question?

If UFO believers (you're one, aren't you?) couldn't understand why he would conclude that there is no evidence of alien visitation, yet still consider the possibility that life has evolved on other worlds, then the failure is theirs.

He never said anything in the affirmative. So one could take it either way.
So, like a scientist, he refused to make declarations about things that are epistemologically unknowable, preferring to say things like, "It's possible that aliens are visiting Earth, but there is no evidence that they are and no justification for claiming certainty that UFOs are of alien origin".

Example. He would go into great details about UFOs but then conclude there was no evidence and therefore not believable. It is best to read his biographies and draw your own conclusions.
In other words, he examined UFO claims in detail and considered them from every angle he could think of before concluding that there was no empirical evidence that UFO sightings and alien abduction accounts were most likely not the result of actual alien visitations.

I have read his biographies. Even better, I've read his own words. Your inability to understand his positions would seem to derive from a deficiency in reading comprehension.
 
There is no link, because what you posted is not true.

Last time I checked. There are several theories on how intergalactic travel can be possible. But I did say NASA does not have that capability yet. I am the eternal optimist. I am confident it will be possible in the future maybe distant future or very distant future. This is not something that can be rushed.
 
Crap!
yes, we both know that a light-year is a distance, not a time

Yes, a dog light year is how far light travels in a vacuum in one dog year. Which is the same as seven human years. Why else do you think the Russians sent up Laika first? It gave them much more data. ;)
 
I understand the frustrations you guys are going through. I too am disappointed he was so wrong and no ETI were found. But we should not be apologizing for him. He made a lot of money by getting in on a hot idea and marketing it.

Evidence, please.

There is only so much the public will take after years of watching a blank screen on a monitor supposed to contact ETI with radio signals and hope they signal back. Not a blimp on the screen for 50 years.

Only 50 years? Do you not understand how large the universe is? 50 years of searching is not nearly enough time to say there is, or was, no intelligent, radio-using life out there.
 
The rated speed is 100,000 MPH. One light year is 5,879,000,000,000
So do the math. It is roughly 6711 years. Because it is solar powered it can travel large distances. They might have to be launched closer to the destination if you are in a hurry. :)

I know better than this...

<snip> do you realize that a "solar sail" only works near a "solar source" i.e. a "sun"?

It is possible, of course, to boost power to a "solar sail" with a ground-based laser (see, e.g., The Mote in God's Eye by Niven/Pournelle), but radiant power (sun or laser) decreases by the inverse cube of the distance from the source. My ninth graders could figure out that a "solar sail" could not accelerate in interstellar space, much less intergalactic space.

And, of course, you fail to explain how one could get "closer to the destination" (is that where your "launching pads based on distant planets" idea comes from? Did you read your link; what it says about "launching" solar-sail-powered craft?)

And you may not have figured this out, yet, but a "solar sail" is not a "rocket". Did you ever provide a source for your claim about the "next generation" of "long distance (sic) rockets"?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I was just idly considering the prospects of manned interstellar flight using solar sails.

I wonder how large and heavy a craft would need to be to sustain a human population (you couldn't really call it a crew) for thousands of years. It would have to contain a self-sustaining biosphere and energy source (nuclear presumably).

Then you need a sail. A really big one. You only get an accelerative force of 9N per square km of sail on departure, and by the time you pass Mars that's fallen to about 3N. By the time you pass Jupiter it's fallen to 0.3N.

Instead of working out how long it takes to coast to the next star at it's cruising speed, I'm wondering how long this craft would take just to get out of the car park.
 
Last time I checked. There are several theories on how intergalactic travel can be possible. But I did say NASA does not have that capability yet. I am the eternal optimist. I am confident it will be possible in the future maybe distant future or very distant future. This is not something that can be rushed.

I know better than this...

<snip> you did not claim that "intergalactic travel" could be possible. Many of us here have understood, and hoped for, that, for years.

The claim you made was that plans for the next generation of long distance rockets, capable of intergalactic travel, exist. When asked to provide evidence, you put up a link to a sensationalist article about the possibility of "solar sails".

Par for your course...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I understand the frustrations you guys are going through. I too am disappointed he was so wrong and no ETI were found. But we should not be apologizing for him. He made a lot of money by getting in on a hot idea and marketing it.
You seem to have a child's concept of the universe and the scientific method. You claim to have an interest in science, yet nothing you've said so far supports this claim. Do you understand how big just the Milky Way galaxy is? We've barely begun to search. It's like we're searching a football field for a lost wedding ring of great value, and we've only searched a few square yards so far.

When his search was turning futile he even began to interview alien abductees to keep the interest alive and stay in the public eye. But he was careful to discredit them so his funding would not be affected.
You'd be right at home in the Conspiracy Theories sub-forum.

There is only so much the public will take after years of watching a blank screen on a monitor supposed to contact ETI with radio signals and hope they signal back. Not a blimp on the screen for 50 years.
The same public that has an appallingly deficient understanding of science? I'm sorry that some people have a simple-minded expectation based on Michael Bay movies. But only a fool would expect scientists to tailor their research to the expectations of the ignorant.

By the way, even when SETI (actually HRMS) was publicly funded, the cost amounted to about 5¢ per taxpayer per year. But since 1993 it has been privately funded. So what are you complaining about?

He said many things in his lifetime. But is known mainly for his "billions and billions" and SETI. and his serious fascination with aliens.
You mean the "billions and billions" that he never actually said? There sure is a lot that you don't know about Carl Sagan. And you do realize that virtually every cosmologist, astronomer, biologist and chemist, as well as millions of other people in the world, have exactly the same serious fascination with the question of extraterrestrial biology that Carl Sagan had, yes?

I used to watch Cosmos but stopped when he started talking about Extraterrestrial intelligent. It was bad enough we had UFO whack whacks but to have to listen to his nonsense was a bit much.
"I know it was stupid because I didn't watch it."

Please don't get banned too soon. You're very entertaining.

Maybe I missed something. But it sure wasn't ETI. :)
Yeah, maybe you've missed something.
 
I was just idly considering the prospects of manned interstellar flight using solar sails.

I wonder how large and heavy a craft would need to be to sustain a human population (you couldn't really call it a crew) for thousands of years. It would have to contain a self-sustaining biosphere and energy source (nuclear presumably).

Then you need a sail. A really big one. You only get an accelerative force of 9N per square km of sail on departure, and by the time you pass Mars that's fallen to about 3N. By the time you pass Jupiter it's fallen to 0.3N.

Instead of working out how long it takes to coast to the next star at it's cruising speed, I'm wondering how long this craft would take just to get out of the car park.

Jack:

The article justintime posted speculated that with advances in materials and construction, a solar-sail-powered craft might, possibly, be capable of leaving our solar system within 8 years of being launched...
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom