Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

I also provided links to Mayan Alien encounter claims.

Your acceptance of this nonsense shows how you are anything but skeptical. No genuine skeptic would accept this without question as you apparently have.
 
The defining characteristic of sceptics is that they look at the evidence before deciding what to (provisionally) believe. A creationist could describe himself as an evolution sceptic, but that wouldn't make him one. Likewise climate change "sceptics" are people who deny overwhelming evidence in order to continue to believe what they want to believe - the very opposite of sceptics.

Justin needs to distinguish between pseudosceptics and genuine sceptics. Some of what he says may well be true of pseudosceptics, but it certainly isn't true of real sceptics.
 
The defining characteristic of sceptics is that they look at the evidence before deciding what to (provisionally) believe. A creationist could describe himself as an evolution sceptic, but that wouldn't make him one. Likewise climate change "sceptics" are people who deny overwhelming evidence in order to continue to believe what they want to believe - the very opposite of sceptics.

Justin needs to distinguish between pseudosceptics and genuine sceptics. Some of what he says may well be true of pseudosceptics, but it certainly isn't true of real sceptics.

People believe only what they want to believe and that goes for skeptics too.
 
Maybe you should read the link about Mayan encounters with Aliens.
http://weeklyworldnews.com/aliens/38913/mayans-had-contact-with-aliens/

So are you claiming that Mayans did encounter "Aliens"?

How do you separate Carl Sagan fascination with aliens and flying saucers at 17 and his continued interest in looking for them for the next 50 years. That by any definition is an obsession. Whether it was alien visiting earth or aliens in some remote planet. It was aliens all the same.

"aliens all the same" indeed, but "flying saucers" where exactly was he looking for them "for the next 50 years"? Why do you equate the two?

If he switched his career to looking for gold instead we can say he got over his obsession. But he did not.

Wouldn't just spending his entire "career to looking for gold instead" be "his obsession" then?

We are not talking about evidence of UFOs or aliens because neither have been found. We are talking about his obsession with them because he carried it throughout his life. All he ever talked about were aliens.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Sagan#Education_and_scientific_career

PhD in astronomy and astrophysics in 1960 and a thesis on the origins of life with physical chemist H. C. Urey after working in the laboratory of the geneticist H. J. Muller, surely "UFOs or aliens" must have been "All he ever talked about".
 
Last edited:
People believe only what they want to believe and that goes for skeptics too.
I'd love to believe in the paranormal, an afterlife, all sorts of things, but I don't because there's no evidence for them.

Sceptics have the same human needs as everyone else but they make a conscious effort to recognise and allow for their own biases in order to find out what's really true. It's hard, and we all fail occasionally, but at least we try.
 
Why do you have to make up things? Carl Sagan was obsessed with flying saucers and aliens. Read his biography. It is well documented. Proof of his obsession. He spent 50 years looking for them. The program was called SETI.

Here is what Carl Sagan said about UFOs

Or take UFOS, the contention that beings in spaceships from other worlds are visiting us all the time. I find that a thrilling idea. It's at least a break from the ordinary. I've spent a fair amount of time in my scientific life working on the issue of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Think how much effort I could save if those guys are coming here.


You can clearly see he wished they had so he could stop looking for them.


Go to a dictionary, and look up the meaning of the word "if".
 
It is beginning to look as if it is you, not Sagan, who believes we have been visited by alien spacecraft.


Not true.


If you're going to claim that you don't believe that we've been visited by aliens, you really shouldn't claim that we've been visited by aliens. Especially not in the same thread.
Maybe you should read the link about Mayan encounters with Aliens.
http://weeklyworldnews.com/aliens/38913/mayans-had-contact-with-aliens/
 
I first defined the Skeptic...


The "Skeptic" you defined was a strawman.

...and then provided cause for his fears (doubts, uncertainty and insecurity) which built the case for panic and fear. For good measure I even located the seat of fear in the Skeptic brain.


But you didn't manage to link the two because your claim about skeptics wasn't included in your source, although you pretended it was.
 
Get another mechanic. Why pay for a total analysis of the problem when all you only want it to have your car fixed and a mechanic who knows how to fix it. I am sure a scientist can also fix your car using his scientific method. How much are you willing to pay him to get it fixed.


...and the "why are there no alternative car mechanics" analogy that people sometimes use when arguing with CAMsters fails, because there really is someone who believes in alternative car mechanics.
 
...and the "why are there no alternative car mechanics" analogy that people sometimes use when arguing with CAMsters fails, because there really is someone who believes in alternative car mechanics.

They sprinkle special herbs in my fuel tank that increases my mileage! As long as I drive at 56mph on long journeys, they work like magic.
 
I get the impression that he thinks the scientific method can't be accomplished without lab coats, flasks,beakers and lots of colorful fluids and smoke.
 
Foster Zygote you are disappointing me.
Let us try again.

Definition of Scientist: A person having expert knowledge of one or more sciences, especially a natural or physical science.

Scientific method : Mathematical and experimental techniques employed in the natural sciences.

Natural science definition:A branch of science that deals with the physical world, e.g., physics, chemistry, geology, and biology.

Is a mechanic a scientist. I don`t think so by that definition.

Is this the application of logic that philosophers are proud to tell us achieves something or other?
 
Maybe you should read the link about Mayan encounters with Aliens.
http://weeklyworldnews.com/aliens/38913/mayans-had-contact-with-aliens/

I said a scholarly source (such as New Scientist, Scientific American, the American Journal of Archaeology, Nature, the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, Proceedings of the Royal Society, Science; even the Christian Science Monitor); genuine, reliable and trustworthy sources that carry "peer-reviewed" articles not the unbridled speculation and fabricated pseudo-science that is prevalent in the sensationalist gutter press you have cited here.

How do you separate Carl Sagan fascination with aliens and flying saucers at 17 and his continued interest in looking for them for the next 50 years.
I had a fascination with aliens when I was 17, and now I'm 57 and I have my computers (all 10 of them) signed up to BOINC programmes; SETI@Home, Rosetta and Einstein. I guess you would regard me as obsessed with aliens, the human genome and gravitational waves.

That by any definition is an obsession. Whether it was alien visiting earth or aliens in some remote planet. It was aliens all the same.
No, by YOUR definition, that is obsession. I prefer to use definitions that are well understood among the remaining members of humanity

"OBSESSION: a persistent, disturbing, single-minded preoccupation with an unreasonable idea, to the exclusion of everything else"


If he switched his career to looking for gold instead we can say he got over his obsession. But he did not.

We are not talking about evidence of UFOs or aliens because neither have been found. We are talking about his obsession with them because he carried it throughout his life.
So he carried an interest throughout his life, but that doesn't mean he was obsessed with it. You appear to be more obsessed with him, that he was with UFO's

If he had any obsession at all, it was that he was worried that we were heading down the path to self destruction. The "Pale Blue Dot" was not just a catchphrase, it had real meaning for him.

All he ever talked about were aliens.
How little you have read of his works if that is what you think?


If you're going to claim that you don't believe that we've been visited by aliens, you really shouldn't claim that we've been visited by aliens. Especially not in the same thread.

Ooohh, that exposed him somewhat cruelly.

Wait for the handwave now!!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom