Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

I don't know how you can even make a comparison. Carl Sagan was talking about radio signal contact. I am talking about intergalactic travel. We are visions apart.


You have made some pretty idiotic statements about what you believe in this thread, and they have been related to space travel and the existence of extraterrestrial life. If you don't see the relation to your statements on Carl Sagan, then your posts are even more worthless.
 
I think they do the scientific method in mathematics as well:

confront problem, form hypothesis of equation to solve problem, test hypothesis by completing equation, analyze results to see why the answer does or does not solve the problem.

so neener

I know they use mathematical modelling as part of the scientific method in experimental sciences (chemistry, biology and physics)
 
Get another mechanic. Why pay for a total analysis of the problem when all you only want it to have your car fixed and a mechanic who knows how to fix it. I am sure a scientist can also fix your car using his scientific method. How much are you willing to pay him to get it fixed.

Yes, I agree. Like you, I also prefer to use either magic or machine psychic mechanics who just know what's wrong without having to waste time with all that pesky examination and testing. I can then also save money by paying them with magic beans.
 
If you are trying to say that Sagan believed in alien flying saucers visiting Earth right now, then I have no "difficulity" calling you a bald faced LIAR.


Do yourself a "favor" and stop being stupid.

Why do you have to make up things? Carl Sagan was obsessed with flying saucers and aliens. Read his biography. It is well documented. Proof of his obsession. He spent 50 years looking for them. The program was called SETI.

Here is what Carl Sagan said about UFOs
Or take UFOS, the contention that beings in spaceships from other worlds are visiting us all the time. I find that a thrilling idea. It's at least a break from the ordinary. I've spent a fair amount of time in my scientific life working on the issue of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Think how much effort I could save if those guys are coming here.

You can clearly see he wished they had so he could stop looking for them.
 
Why do you have to make up things? Carl Sagan was obsessed with flying saucers and aliens. Read his biography. It is well documented. Proof of his obsession. He spent 50 years looking for them. The program was called SETI.

Here is what Carl Sagan said about UFOs


You can clearly see he wished they had so he could stop looking for them.


You should do some more reading. Reposting again, since you obviously missed it.

Another quote from Sagan--this time from Cosmos--showing how wrong you are (highlight added):

In the Milky Way Galaxy there must be many planets millions of years older than Earth, and some that are billions of years older. Should we not have been visited? In all the billions of years since the origin of our planet, has there not been even once a strange craft from a distant civilization surveying our world from above, and slowly settling down to the surface to be observed by iridescent dragonflies, incurious reptiles, screeching primates or wondering humans? The idea is natural enough. It has occurred to everyone who has contemplated, even casually, the question of intelligent life in the universe. But has it happened in fact? The critical issue is the quality of the purported evidence, rigorously and skeptically scrutinized - not what sounds plausible, not the unsubstantiated testimony of one or two self-professed eyewitnesses. By this standard there are no compelling cases of extraterrestrial visitation, despite all the claims about UFOs and ancient astronauts which sometimes make it seem that our planet is awash in uninvited guests.


By the way, can you tell us more about those Mayan encounters with aliens you believe happened?
 
What if Carl Sagan misrepresented himself?

He's dead, I expect such a further misrepresentation, much as a further representation, can't be enacted by him other than already done.

What if you have simply misrepresented him? Perhaps you expect to take the mantle of representing him? Either way he's still just dead and all that's enacted here is still just you. Do with that what you will.
 
I have moved a bunch of posts to Abandon All Hope. Please, stop the personalization, bickering, and name-calling. Be civil, and stick to the topic of the thread - which is not other members. Also, do not import arguments from other forums. Thank you advance for your anticipated cooperation.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
Last edited:
Thats around 10.5 post per day. What a madman!

Of course, justintime started posting around 33 hours ago and is up to 59 posts as I type this. Even if he stopped now he'd have an average of 43 posts per day.

I don't generally post that much. I took on a dead thread and made something out of it.
 
justintime

The Mayans did not report encounters with extraterrestrials. It was the fraudster Erich von Daniken who proposed this, based on his somewhat unique and misguided interpretation of certain Mayan artefacts.

As far as Carl Sagan goes, I challenge you to find (name/link) any reference material from a reliable, scholarly source that he was obsessed with UFOs beyond his teenage and young adult years.
 
If he did, how did Carl Sagan misrepresent himself, justin?

His biography mentions the balancing act he had to maintain between his public and private beliefs. UFOs enthusiast could not understand why he was looking for aliens everywhere but HERE.

He never said anything in the affirmative. So one could take it either way. Example. He would go into great details about UFOs but then conclude there was no evidence and therefore not believable. It is best to read his biographies and draw your own conclusions.
 
He never said anything in the affirmative. So one could take it either way. Example. He would go into great details about UFOs but then conclude there was no evidence and therefore not believable. It is best to read his biographies and draw your own conclusions.


Yeah, right... citation, please. Have you actually read Sagan's quotes above?

I call BS.

And I may remind everyone that justintime has no credibility. He doesn't understand interstellar travel and thinks the Mayans were visited by aliens.
 
justintime

The Mayans did not report encounters with extraterrestrials. It was the fraudster Erich von Daniken who proposed this, based on his somewhat unique and misguided interpretation of certain Mayan artefacts.

As far as Carl Sagan goes, I challenge you to find (name/link) any reference material from a reliable, scholarly source that he was obsessed with UFOs beyond his teenage and young adult years.

Maybe you should read the link about Mayan encounters with Aliens.
http://weeklyworldnews.com/aliens/38913/mayans-had-contact-with-aliens/

How do you separate Carl Sagan fascination with aliens and flying saucers at 17 and his continued interest in looking for them for the next 50 years. That by any definition is an obsession. Whether it was alien visiting earth or aliens in some remote planet. It was aliens all the same.

If he switched his career to looking for gold instead we can say he got over his obsession. But he did not.

We are not talking about evidence of UFOs or aliens because neither have been found. We are talking about his obsession with them because he carried it throughout his life. All he ever talked about were aliens.
 
Yeah, right... citation, please. Have you actually read Sagan's quotes above?

I call BS.

And I may remind everyone that justintime has no credibility. He doesn't understand interstellar travel and thinks the Mayans were visited by aliens.

Then you must have missed it. Someone posted a link to his quotes. I also provided links to Mayan Alien encounter claims. You can even google for both.
 
Maybe you should read the link about Mayan encounters with Aliens.
http://weeklyworldnews.com/aliens/38913/mayans-had-contact-with-aliens/

How do you separate Carl Sagan fascination with aliens and flying saucers at 17 and his continued interest in looking for them for the next 50 years. That by any definition is an obsession. Whether it was alien visiting earth or aliens in some remote planet. It was aliens all the same.

If he switched his career to looking for gold instead we can say he got over his obsession. But he did not.

We are not talking about evidence of UFOs or aliens because neither have been found. We are talking about his obsession with them because he carried it throughout his life. All he ever talked about were aliens.

You don't know what you are talking about and you have absolutely no credibility in this thread.

Or have you given up you belief in intergalactic rocketships and Mayans being visited by aliens?

You know virtually nothing of the universe compared to Carl Sagan. Your opinion is crap, as demonstrated in this thread.

Prove me wrong. :)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom