Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

I feel sorry for you, that you think this is something you could get away with saying. You have gone from pathetic to bathetic--you have three, and only three, reasonable options:
1. Provide a reliable source for these magical intergalactic rockets. Book, chapter, verse, or it didn't happen.
2. Throw yourself on the mercy of the forum, and admit that your braggadocio and hubris led your ego to write a check reality can't cash. Admit it was a fabrication out of thin air, or remarkable carelessness, and hope that the forum is in a forgiving mood.
3. Try to pretend we did not understand what you meant. Blame your claim on our lack of comprehension. Pretend we just don't get it. Try to lie your way out of it, and change the subject...and live with the fact that you have exposed your true colors for all to see.

Ooops--there is one more option. You could just go away.

I'm curious to see upon which one you will settle.

If you can read properly. It says NASA does not have that capability yet. Duh!
There are plans to build the next generation of rockets that will push us past our own galaxy. NASA does not have that capability yet. Sort of if they won`t come to us we just have to go to them.
 
A speculative article on possible future means of propulsion for spacecraft. Did you even understand it?

How long do you think it will take such a craft to reach another galaxy, justintime, as you believe the "next generation" of rockets will?

I said there are plans to make the next generation rockets. But NASA does not have that capability yet. How much simpler can I get.

There are plans to build the next generation of rockets that will push us past our own galaxy. NASA does not have that capability yet. Sort of if they won`t come to us we just have to go to them.
 
A speculative article on possible future means of propulsion for spacecraft. Did you even understand it?

How long do you think it will take such a craft to reach another galaxy, justintime, as you believe the "next generation" of rockets will?

The Sagittarius Dwarf Elliptical Galaxy is only some 70,000 light years from us. So as long as this next generation can travel at a large percentage of the speed of light, it's only an incredibly long trip. Of course, the Sagittarius Dwarf Elliptical Galaxy is kind of rinky dink, so if you want to go to a cool galaxy like M31 you'll have to hang in there for almost three million years. Better bring something to read.
 

<snip>

As per usual, your cite does not support your claims.

You said:
There are plans to build the next generation of rockets that will push us past our own galaxy. NASA does not have that capability yet. Sort of if they won`t come to us we just have to go to them.
And compounded the silliness with:
You forget. The long range rockets combined with launching pad based on distant planets will enable us to get beyond our Milky Way.

The link you provided,

...is a speculative, sensationalist article about "solar sails". Not "rockets". Certainly not "intergalactic rockets" with "launching pad (sic) based on distant planets".

Did you even read the article? The "solar sail" concept has been around a long time. At its most effective, a solar-sail-powered craft might reach up to "5 times the speed of a conventional rocket"(notice that "solar sail craft are not"rockets")...and that only within a solar system. In interstellar space, the solar sail would not develop any significant power. I know maths can be confusing, but that means a solar-sail-powered craft would still only reach about 1/12 of galactic escape velocity.

So, do you have the plans for the intergalactic rockets you claimed, or was this just another...((what's a polite word?) "exaggeration" of reality, with no basis in fact?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I hear Mitch McConnell has plans to build his own Death Star. He just doesn't have that capability yet.
 
Rocket-Boy:

As per usual, your cite does not support your claims.

You said:

And compounded the silliness with:


The link you provided,


...is a speculative, sensationalist article about "solar sails". Not "rockets". Certainly not "intergalactic rockets" with "launching pad (sic) based on distant planets".

Did you even read the article? The "solar sail" concept has been around a long time. At its most effective, a solar-sail-powered craft might reach up to "5 times the speed of a conventional rocket (notice that "solar sail craft are not"rockets")...and that only within a solar system. In interstellar space, the solar sail would not develop any significant power. I know maths can be confusing, but that means a solar-sail-powered craft would still only reach about 1/12 of galactic escape velocity.

So, do you have the plans for the intergalactic rockets you claimed, or was this just another...((what's a polite word?) "exaggeration" of reality, with no basis in fact?

I am a bit ahead of NASA. Hey what can I say.
 
I am a bit ahead of NASA. Hey what can I say.


No, you simply don't know what you are talking about. And the fact that you think you can criticize Carl Sagan, who definitely did know what he was talking about, is laughable.

You have no credibility.
 
I am a bit ahead of NASA. Hey what can I say.

You can say, "I got caught in a lie--there are no plans for 'intergalactic rockets', I just hoped that no one on a forum full of space-happy science fiction fans would know that".

Instead of pretending that you are "ahead of NASA".

...not that you need to admit the obvious, Rocket-Boy.
 
ahead of NASA eh?

design me a spacecraft capable of traveling to Venus and back (with applicable flight path trajectories and burn times)

I'll give you a few days (and no high detail blueprints required, just a rough sketch with applicable notes)

should be a piece of cake for an engineering genius such as yourself eh?



ETA: 3 man crew, no lander, just an orbiter is required thanx!
 
You can say, "I got caught in a lie--there are no plans for 'intergalactic rockets', I just hoped that no one on a forum full of space-happy science fiction fans would know that".

Instead of pretending that you are "ahead of NASA".

...not that you need to admit the obvious, Rocket-Boy.

With all the Carl Sagan material I have been researching. I might have caught his bug. I should be consider a cosmic visionary. Intergalactic travel. If they won't come to us, we will go to them. My new slogan. :)
 
With all the Carl Sagan material I have been researching. I might have caught his bug. I should be consider a cosmic visionary. Intergalactic travel. If they won't come to us, we will go to them. My new slogan. :)

So this is your new tack? Caper, and jape, and play the jackanape, hoping to be winsome enough to distract from your fundamental dishonesty?

How's that working out for you?
 
Which simple proves his early obsession with flying saucers and aliens were even less founded because Roswell was what gave an impetus to UFOs. Maybe he got his impressions from early Mayan readings about UFOs and aliens which makes him even less credible than his public records.

What a load of crap....does it make you feel "important" to lie about someone who can't "fight back" because they are dead?

You should be ashamed of yourself.
 
Last edited:
Two questions, justintime, which you may understandably prefer not to answer: a) how old are you; and b) is English your first language (I'm guessing not)?
 
The Sagittarius Dwarf Elliptical Galaxy is only some 70,000 light years from us. So as long as this next generation can travel at a large percentage of the speed of light, it's only an incredibly long trip. Of course, the Sagittarius Dwarf Elliptical Galaxy is kind of rinky dink, so if you want to go to a cool galaxy like M31 you'll have to hang in there for almost three million years. Better bring something to read.

No one said it was going to be easy.
 
It is well documented his obsession with flying sauces and aliens in his biographies. But it does not mention where he got his information from. I am guessing it was from Roswell or Mayan literature. What is there to be ashamed of. I am sure he wants us to continue talking about his legacy....ETI, aliens and flying saucers.


You have shown you are ignorant on these subjects. Perhaps you should move on.
 
No, you simply don't know what you are talking about. And the fact that you think you can criticize Carl Sagan, who definitely did know what he was talking about, is laughable.

You have no credibility.

I don't know how you can even make a comparison. Carl Sagan was talking about radio signal contact. I am talking about intergalactic travel. We are visions apart.
 
It is well documented his obsession with flying sauces and aliens in his biographies.

If you are trying to say that Sagan believed in alien flying saucers visiting Earth right now, then I have no "difficulity" calling you a bald faced LIAR.


Do yourself a "favor" and stop being stupid.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom