Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

making unsupported claims against a dead man is pretty low on the totem pole of "anti skepticism" (somewhere above Holocaust deniers and Truthers, but somewhere below AGW deniers and Bigfooters)
 
Can we see those plans for the trans-galactic rocket?

Yes I'd like to see them too, particularly as the Galactic escape velocity at the Solar System's radial position is about 1000 km/s, and the fastest we have ever accelerated a rocket to is 16.26 km/s (New Horizons mission to Pluto launched January 2006). By my math, that makes it over 60 times too slow.

justintime's "next generation of rockets" will have to be light-years (literally) ahead of what we have now. Even a spacecraft travelling at 90% of C will take something like 40,000 years just to reach the edge
 
I think looking at the dates Roswell 1947 and around 1951 Carl Sagan at 17 talking about flying saucers and aliens makes me feel he made that connection. He developed an early obsession and tried to fulfill it by searching for them for the rest of his life.
~~~

Something seemed wonky with this speculation to me, because I was under the impression that 'The Roswell Incident' did not become known outside Roswell until the late 50s/early 60s.

I was wrong. It was the late 70s, when Stanton Friedman dug up Jesse Marcell in 1978.

So Sagan and the Green Bank Conference(SETI) had no connexion to Roswell.
 
There are plans to build the next generation of rockets that will push us past our own galaxy. NASA does not have that capability yet. Sort of if they won`t come to us we just have to go to them.

I feel sorry for you, that you think this is something you could get away with saying. You have gone from pathetic to bathetic--you have three, and only three, reasonable options:
1. Provide a reliable source for these magical intergalactic rockets. Book, chapter, verse, or it didn't happen.
2. Throw yourself on the mercy of the forum, and admit that your braggadocio and hubris led your ego to write a check reality can't cash. Admit it was a fabrication out of thin air, or remarkable carelessness, and hope that the forum is in a forgiving mood.
3. Try to pretend we did not understand what you meant. Blame your claim on our lack of comprehension. Pretend we just don't get it. Try to lie your way out of it, and change the subject...and live with the fact that you have exposed your true colors for all to see.

Ooops--there is one more option. You could just go away.

I'm curious to see upon which one you will settle.
 
Something seemed wonky with this speculation to me, because I was under the impression that 'The Roswell Incident' did not become known outside Roswell until the late 50s/early 60s.

I was wrong. It was the late 70s, when Stanton Friedman dug up Jesse Marcell in 1978.

So Sagan and the Green Bank Conference(SETI) had no connexion to Roswell.

Which simple proves his early obsession with flying saucers and aliens were even less founded because Roswell was what gave an impetus to UFOs. Maybe he got his impressions from early Mayan readings about UFOs and aliens which makes him even less credible than his public records.
 
Which simple proves his early obsession with flying saucers and aliens were even less founded because Roswell was what gave an impetus to UFOs. Maybe he got his impressions from early Mayan readings about UFOs and aliens which makes him even less credible than his public records.

Okay, come clean. This is some kind of class assignment right? See what kind of outrageous illogical, non-sensical drivel you can post until everyone figures out that there's no way you could be serious? After all, there's no way anyone could possibly be as obtuse as your postings make you out to be. Not a bad attempt, but really, did you think anyone was going to take you seriously, ragging on Sagan with such ludicrous accusations. You should have made it at least plausible.
 
Which simple proves his early obsession with flying saucers and aliens were even less founded because Roswell was what gave an impetus to UFOs. Maybe he got his impressions from early Mayan readings about UFOs and aliens which makes him even less credible than his public records.

Ever hear of, I dunno, War of the Worlds? The original radio broadcast? In 1938? Orson Welles? From the H.G. Wells novel?

Impetus to UFOs?

WTF are you talking about?
 
Okay, come clean. This is some kind of class assignment right? See what kind of outrageous illogical, non-sensical drivel you can post until everyone figures out that there's no way you could be serious? After all, there's no way anyone could possibly be as obtuse as your postings make you out to be. Not a bad attempt, but really, did you think anyone was going to take you seriously, ragging on Sagan with such ludicrous accusations. You should have made it at least plausible.


Yep. Everyone has figured out by now that this is just gratuitous trolling. All that's left is batting his silly comments around like a cat toy. Oh, and I think there's a betting pool going for how long it goes before the ban.
 
Maybe he got his impressions from early Mayan readings about UFOs and aliens which makes him even less credible than his public records.


So you are ignorant about the Mayans too. What's next?
 
Last edited:
Ever hear of, I dunno, War of the Worlds? The original radio broadcast? In 1938? Orson Welles? From the H.G. Wells novel?

Impetus to UFOs?

WTF are you talking about?

"1938?" What about 1898? Naturally though H.G. Wells believed or must have had some 'obsession' with UFO's and invading aliens, vengeful submariners, invisible men, changing animals to be almost human, time travel, and a world war dominated by air power, since he evidently wrote fictional stories about them.
 
Last edited:
Maybe he got his impressions from early Mayan readings about UFOs and aliens which makes him even less credible than his public records.


Maybe he was an alien. Maybe that's Jesus on your toast. Maybe cats and dogs should get married. Maybe I'm petting a unicorn and you are under a bridge, demanding people pay a toll.
 
Which simple proves his early obsession with flying saucers and aliens were even less founded because Roswell was what gave an impetus to UFOs. Maybe he got his impressions from early Mayan readings about UFOs and aliens which makes him even less credible than his public records.

Where's your source for those magical intergalactic rockets, Rocket-Boy? Changing the subject will not make the gaffe go away...
 
Carl Sagan was challenged about the two way communication even if it was possible would take hundreds of years to get the messages across. The entire project was a scam.
1. First the ETI had to be contacted.
2. We would never know if they responded to our signal because it would take way longer than a lifetime.
3. It would take another lifetime for the ETI to receive out reply.
You cannot get more irrational that this.


When I earlier said that, among other things, you did not understand the meaning of 'hypocrisy', and that 'fiction' was also a thing you did not understand, I should have added 'irrational' because you don't know what that means either. Oh, and 'scam'.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom