Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

I would have looked for ETI if I was a scientist in the trained field. But I would not have done so if I were skeptical of their existence(did not believe). Carl Sagan was a Skeptic he denounced irrational beliefs.
What a sadly simple-minded misconception. Skepticism is not a refusal to believe. It is a reservation of judgement pending solid evidence. SETI researchers didn't believe or disbelieve in the existence of extraterrestrial civilizations. They wondered if they might be detectable and made observations.


1. What can be more irrational than looking for aliens without a spacecraft that could reach them.
Why is this irrational?

2. What could be more irrational than assuming aliens could be contacted using radio telescope.
Why is this irrational?

3, What can be more irrational than using a statistical probability equation with arbitrary assumptions to arrive at a probable number.
Why is speculation about what might exist irrational?

4. What could be more irrational than writing a book on alien contact when even the remotest possibility of finding any was never realized.
You have misplaced the woo.
I can think of a whole hell of a lot of things, including the OP of this thread.
 
Sagan didn't do that.

The thing about the Drake Equation is that it primarily demonstrates that even if each of the values inserted is extremely low, the odds are pretty good that there have been/are/will be lots of civilizations that develop to the point, and survive long enough, to be able to broadcast for at least a little while.

Maybe such civilizations, if they exist, would be so rare that they would arise so far apart in time, and so separated by distance, that they have no chance of detecting the emissions of previous civilizations. But maybe they are much more common. Or maybe some are able to survive for a very long time, and thus are able to wait around until another infant civilization evolves and emits some artificial radiation that will eventually reach them and be recognized as a sigh of intelligent life.
 
and the odds are the distances are so extreme, that even if the moment you heard a transmission and pinpointed it's source ,AND had a near light speed rocket standing by, by the time you reached your destination, the civilization would have perished either by natural or self destructive means.
 
I would have looked for ETI if I was a scientist in the trained field. But I would not have done so if I were skeptical of their existence(did not believe). Carl Sagan was a Skeptic he denounced irrational beliefs.
there's your problem right there.
Being skeptical is not a belief. It is actually reserving judgement until evidence comes in.
If you don't search because you don't believe, then you're not a skeptic, you are a closed-minded believer
ETA:
The justintime argument is identical to the ones the Creationalsits use--"Since I don't believe in evolution, there is no point in searching for evidence of it, and since I don'tbelieve in it any way, any evidence for it is wrong"
1. What can be more irrational than looking for aliens without a spacecraft that could reach them.
2. What could be more irrational than assuming aliens could be contacted using radio telescope.
What the hell is irational about knowing that a Radio Telescope can recieve Radio Transmissions?
3, What can be more irrational than using a statistical probability equation with arbitrary assumptions to arrive at a probable number.
Intersetingly enough, 1.0x1099times 10-99=1.0
4. What could be more irrational than writing a book on alien contact when even the remotest possibility of finding any was never realized.
You have misplaced the woo.
Even scientists and other skeptics like to suspend disbelief once in a while. Hell, read The Bad Astronomer's critique of Men In Black (the first one, not the sequels)
 
Last edited:
I see. You are going to repeat your dodge of not standing behind what you post.

Follow:

Here is your original formatting, quoted directly form your post #66:



It is a common convention of honest scholarship that, when one purports to quote material, one provides a source for the quote (to avoid, among other things: on the one hand, the charge of plagiarism, by demonstrating that the words quoted are, in fact, another's work; and on the other hand, the charge of quote-mining, that is, taking a snippet of text out of context in order to change the clear meaning intended by the actual offer).

Your formatting, above, appears to make the claim that the text from "A skeptic forum..." to "...rational thought." is, in fact, an actual direct, and unedited quote from "The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749".

The truth is that "The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749" does not, in fact, mention, even by colorable implication, "skeptic forums", the "agreement" among "doubters" on such fora, "accumulated doubt", "saturation points", or "fear signals" tragically emitted by "Skeptic brain' (sic)", that can "disrupt attempts at rational thought".

In fact, the article articulately discusses the role of the amygdala, with the rest of the limbic system, in conditioned rats in laboratory settings. There is an interesting, and useful, distinction suggested between the "feeling" of fear and the "emotion" of fear; there is also a brief paragraph on methods of "reducing fear and inhibiting the fear response".

In other words, the text you provided is not from the article you referenced.
The text you provided is not a description, precis, abstract, or development of the information in the article you cited.

Your pretense that I did not read, or understand, the citation is incorrect.
Your post, as formatted, looks dishonest.

Logically, there are several possibilities, among them being:
1. You made an honest formatting mistake, but tried to cover it up by pretending I was not applying "logic" (as per your habit of blaming the reader for reading what you say, not what you claim, you meant); or,
2. You posted a link to an article you did not understand, hoping that no one would check your source and notice that your quote is not, in fact, described, contained, reference, or implied, much less present verbatim, in the citation you provided; or,
3. You knowingly provided a citation to an article that does not in any way support the quote you presented as coming from that article.

I anticipate your explanation. Do be so good as to notice that simply repeating your accusation that I did not read, or understand, the article has been dealt with--the issue is not my comprehension, but your use or abuse of the way material is honestly and accurately quoted.
You are one confused person.
I made a statement explaining how the Skeptics accumulated doubts reach a saturation point then panic and fear creeps in.

I then posted a link to show The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
The amygdala deals with fear and panic. It is the part of the brain that responds to fear.
 
justintime said:
In short, only the professionals can apply scientific method.
Horseapples. I've got a few publications on my shelf right now written by firefighters, engineers, quarry workers, and other non-scientists. I once called a member of the juvenile justice system to get his opinion on a scientific question, because frankly he knew more than me about that topic. Scientific publications have been written by grade schoolers. In short, this idea is nonsensical and demonstrates that you have very little involvement with the scientific community.

Only the professionals can tackle complex phenomena for verifiability.
What "complex phenomena"? What "verifiability"? I know a number of scientific questions that could be solved by five-year-olds under proper supervision--all that's needed is someone finding a fossil at the right location. An ameture adult could easily do so.

Science isn't all hugely expensive particle accelorators and multi-billion dollar labs. A lot of it is still a bunch of people walking around looking at stuff.

And none of that addresses how your average person-in-the-street is restricted from applying the scientific method. They do it all the time. Let's say your break lights are out. You realize that your headlights work. You also realize that your car starts. That rules out the electrical system, battery, alternator, etc. You look at the light, and it appears fine. Then you find the wire that's loose. That's the scientific method at work. You've formulated a few hypotheses, and tested them. Eventually, you got the right one. It's a simple version of the SM, but accurate none the less. And it's something everyone with a car problem has done.

As for skepticism, I'm astounded by your inconsistency, justintime. You say skepticism doubts everything, but you implicitely exhempt that doubt from doubt! Not all doubt is reasonable or rational. Some doubt is manufactured, and some is self-serving rationalizations. And a skeptic that doubts their own doubt must necessarily come to SOME conclusions.

From the responses it is obvious none of the participants are philosophy majors and unfortunately Skeptics lack an understanding of Epistemology.
Considering your inability to look beyond dictionary definitions, this is funny. Seriously, anyone who uses a dictionary to define jargon has no business telling others they don't understand epistemology.
 
The article you linked to in no way supports your statement that "Skeptic brains 'emit fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought'."

And you took that last bit from a book on climate change that is not referring to "skeptic brains":



http://www.straight.com/article-604...-incapable-recognizing-reality-climate-change

Yes that was the article I read but went further and located the actual seat of fear in the brain the amygdala. Author William Marsden was using climate change as one example. There are other reasons for Skeptic fears as well.
 
ahh, but in that article, they aren't referring to skeptics are they? No they are referring to people who deny AGM based on political and/or ideological reasons (or claim that AGW is promoted for those reasons) NOT because they have evaluated the scientific evidence and come to that conclusion.

So your attempt to pigeonhole skeptics has been smited. care to try again?
 
The thing about the Drake Equation is that it primarily demonstrates that even if each of the values inserted is extremely low, the odds are pretty good that there have been/are/will be lots of civilizations that develop to the point, and survive long enough, to be able to broadcast for at least a little while.
Maybe such civilizations, if they exist, would be so rare that they would arise so far apart in time, and so separated by distance, that they have no chance of detecting the emissions of previous civilizations. But maybe they are much more common. Or maybe some are able to survive for a very long time, and thus are able to wait around until another infant civilization evolves and emits some artificial radiation that will eventually reach them and be recognized as a sigh of intelligent life.

I agree. Of course, that doesn't mean that we should just not bother looking for them.

It is not irrational to believe that intelligent, technologically advanced life exists elsewhere in the galaxy, but while there is no direct evidence to support this, the building blocks of life do exist throughout the universe no matter where we look.

It is now thought that gravitationally captured planets outnumber stars in our galaxy by several to one. Even conservative estimates are that there are an average of four planets for every star, meaning that the are some 800 billion planets in the galaxy. Even if only, say one in 100,000 are the right composition and size and in the "Goldilocks" zone, that is still 8 million potentially life-bearing planets in the Galaxy. IMO it would be absurd to believe that we were the only ones to develop advanced technology.

Assuming that to be correct we can make a couple of scratchy calculations to show how close they might be. Ignoring depth, our galaxy has an "area" of about 8 billion square light years. With 8 million potential life bearing planets, that comes out to about 1000 square light years per planet, giving us about 18 light years between planets. The chances are reasonable that a technological civilisation might be quite close, and on that basis, it is not irrational to listen for them (note I said "listen for" not "communicate with") in order to find some direct evidence.
 
So, what we've established here isn't that justintime didn't cite his sources properly because he made an honest mistake or didn't know any better, rather that he didn't cite his sources properly because he was attempting to be dishonest about what they actually say. And that his dishonesty didn't work due to the critical thinking of some of the sceptics in this thread.
 
So, what we've established here isn't that justintime didn't cite his sources properly because he made an honest mistake or didn't know any better, rather that he didn't cite his sources properly because he was attempting to be dishonest about what they actually say. And that his dishonesty didn't work due to the critical thinking of some of the sceptics in this thread.

The amusing thing is the insinuation that we're somehow afraid of his intellectual prowess.
 
I agree. Of course, that doesn't mean that we should just not bother looking for them.

Full agreement from me. But counter to justintime's baseless assertion that Sagan claimed to be certain of the existence of alien civilizations (or his fallacious assertion that a true skeptic is a disbeliever who would claim certainty that they don't exist and thus never conduct the search) is the fact that SETI researchers fully acknowledge the possibility that we won't be able to detect anything, for any number of reasons.
 
Horseapples. I've got a few publications on my shelf right now written by firefighters, engineers, quarry workers, and other non-scientists. I once called a member of the juvenile justice system to get his opinion on a scientific question, because frankly he knew more than me about that topic. Scientific publications have been written by grade schoolers. In short, this idea is nonsensical and demonstrates that you have very little involvement with the scientific community.

What "complex phenomena"? What "verifiability"? I know a number of scientific questions that could be solved by five-year-olds under proper supervision--all that's needed is someone finding a fossil at the right location. An ameture adult could easily do so.

Science isn't all hugely expensive particle accelorators and multi-billion dollar labs. A lot of it is still a bunch of people walking around looking at stuff.

And none of that addresses how your average person-in-the-street is restricted from applying the scientific method. They do it all the time. Let's say your break lights are out. You realize that your headlights work. You also realize that your car starts. That rules out the electrical system, battery, alternator, etc. You look at the light, and it appears fine. Then you find the wire that's loose. That's the scientific method at work. You've formulated a few hypotheses, and tested them. Eventually, you got the right one. It's a simple version of the SM, but accurate none the less. And it's something everyone with a car problem has done.

As for skepticism, I'm astounded by your inconsistency, justintime. You say skepticism doubts everything, but you implicitely exhempt that doubt from doubt! Not all doubt is reasonable or rational. Some doubt is manufactured, and some is self-serving rationalizations. And a skeptic that doubts their own doubt must necessarily come to SOME conclusions.

Considering your inability to look beyond dictionary definitions, this is funny. Seriously, anyone who uses a dictionary to define jargon has no business telling others they don't understand epistemology.

The scientific method is primarily used in the natural sciences. The scientific method is subject to peer-review for possible mistakes before publication. Mechanics are not subject to scientific scrutiny. You are confusing a logical approach, the mechanics experience and other task with that of the strict discipline scientist are bound to to maintain the integrity of the scientific method.
I have never seen a mechanic apply scientific method. He knows what is wrong and without even thinking fixes it. He relies on his knowledge and experience. Unlike a scientist who has to build a hypothesis and verify with frequent test if his hypothesis is correct at the same time following some strict guidelines so the results can be repeated.
 
Justintime, could we have your thoughts on the following questions:

1. Why is it irrational to think that life may have evolved elsewhere in the universe?

2. Why is it irrational to investigate the possibility that some of that life might, like us, evolve to the point that it develops the technology to broadcast communications using radiation emissions?
 
justintime said:
The scientific method is primarily used in the natural sciences.
True, in the same way that wrenches are primarily used by mechanics.

The scientific method is subject to peer-review for possible mistakes before publication.
Not technically, no. The SM doesn't actually include peer review; that's another issue entirely.

Mechanics are not subject to scientific scrutiny.
Well, since you've arbitrarily and improperly defined "scientific scrutiny" as "peer review", then yeah, I suppose that's true--but it's a cheap rhetorical trick, not a reflection of reality in any way.

You are confusing a logical approach, the mechanics experience and other task with that of the strict discipline scientist are bound to to maintain the integrity of the scientific method.
No. You're arbitrarily limiting the scientific method by redefining it to fit your terms to make yourself right by definition.

have never seen a mechanic apply scientific method.
I just described how they do, constantly. The reason you reject it is because you equivocate between the SM and peer review.

He knows what is wrong and without even thinking fixes it.
Dear Lord, I hope I never use your mechanic! Your car must be a death trap!

He relies on his knowledge and experience.
You know no scientists, I take it. Scientists relly HEAVILY on their knowledge and experience.

Unlike a scientist who has to build a hypothesis and verify with frequent test if his hypothesis is correct at the same time following some strict guidelines so the results can be repeated.
You know no scientists, I take it. Scientists relly HEAVILY on their knowledge and experience.

It's amazing. Nearly every single sentence you've typed is wrong.
 
You don't seem to understand that the scientific method is exactly what a mechanic uses (and also peer review)

I shall demonstrate

Person A brings in a car that's making a wobbling noise, the mechanic asks questions to determine an initial system diagnosis (what part of the car can he eliminate from his "source" options) (this is akin to eliminating the possible variables in a science experiment)

He then fires up the car, drives it himself so as to familiarize himself to the "sound" the person has relayed to him. Then he uses his experience and knowledge to isolate and recognize the problem then make the repairs. (just like a scientist who wants to know why something is the way it is,isolate the 'something" study it's behavior, introduce a variable, observe the results)

He may also, consult other mechanics before making the repairs to verify that his diagnosis is accurate (peer review) and thus doesn't waste time chasing worthless data down the rabbit hole.

Then the customer returns, drives the car, notices the sound is gone. Is relayed the information of the cause (like a study is relayed in a journal) and happily pays and goes home.

The 2nd stage of review is the aftermath of the repair, if the "science" was practiced properly, the repair should solve the issue and the sound should not reoccur, if it does come back , then the initial stage can be said to have been "proven false" and further review of the information by the original mechanic is required. (this is like what happens when you publish a paper, the initial peer review merely states that the data was gathered in a verifiable and repeatable manner. The science community at large will get to work and give the final "grade" on the paper based on how often it is cited by others and also if any further papers are published refuting the original claim)

so mechanics use the scientific method. I use it everyday when doing baseball analysis. I'm not a 'pro scientist" but I MUST follow the scientific method if I want my statistical analysis to have any value.
 
Last edited:
I have never seen a mechanic apply scientific method. He knows what is wrong and without even thinking fixes it. He relies on his knowledge and experience. Unlike a scientist who has to build a hypothesis and verify with frequent test if his hypothesis is correct at the same time following some strict guidelines so the results can be repeated.

Wow! That is incredibly wrong. Unless your mechanic is psychic, he can't "just know" all the time. There are any number of presented problems that will require the application of the fundamentals of the scientific method. My cousin is an ASE Master Mechanic who works for a Volvo dealership. If a car gets towed in with the problem, "will not start", there are hundreds of possible causes. He uses his experience to know what the most likely causes are, but then he forms an hypothesis and tests it by making an alteration to the element that he thinks might be the cause. If it has no effect and the car still won't start, he moves on to another likely system.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom