Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

And if you had read Cosmos and watched the tv series of that name you would relaly know what his views were before projecting what you have decided what his views were.
 
I have been noticing the Education section is hardly drawing any interest. So I was right Skeptics are not for education.

I found the heaviest activity in the Paranormal section which included Carl Sagan and his obsession with aliens (this OP). So it is not only the Skeptic Carl Sagan who was obsessed with aliens. Most Skeptics here are just as obsessed with aliens.
I was not trying to make this an OP about aliens but about Carl Sagan as a Skeptic. But it appears one cannot separate Skeptics from their beliefs in aliens. :jaw-dropp

You are probably a bit too self-absorbed to realize that you are addressing a group that includes many educators. Your gratuitous attempted insult is, however, par for your course.

You cannot refer to Dr. Sagan without trying to pretend that he was a dishonest snake-oil salesman pandering to the credulous about his (as you put it) "obsession" with "UFOs and aliens". In what way have you demonstrated (remember: you made the claim, it is up to you to provide evidence) that "one cannot separate Skeptics (sic) from their beliefs in aliens"?

ETA: I see Resume beat me to it.

ETA: here is your OP: "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, particularly in claims that are far fetched or that violate physical laws.Carl Sagan did not need extraordinary evidence to spend his adult life searching for ETI (aliens). He just followed his early obsessions with flying saucers and aliens to fuel his scientific curiosity and a rather weak statistical probability based on arbitrary assumptions, hardly scientific by any definition or even scientifically skeptical."
With such an opening gambit, it is not disingenuous to claim that you didn't want this thread to be "about" aliens? Particularly since most of the mentions of "aliens" in the thread are rebuttals of your OP, and your fixation on Dr. Sagan's presumed "obsession"?
 
Last edited:
Einstein was obsessed with finding a Unified Theory of Everything
Newton was obsessed with Alchemy
Edison was obsessed with electricity.

Obsession with finding the truth (or a fiction) does not detract from the real work one does, nor does it prevent real findings.
In fact, obsession with something can be positive or negative--but it quite often leads to discovering things never before imagined...
 
Not true. I do not have a life long obsession with UFOs, aliens or even ETI. I am not even a Ghost buster. I just try to see the treatable person behind the Skeptic and his or her Skepticism.
I try not to confuse entertainment with serious discourses.

And by "treatment" you mean, what, helping them overcome their skepticism so that they can be credulous, not subjecting unusual claims to careful scrutiny and stupidly accepting wild stories about flying saucers and alien abductions, miracle elixirs, and psychic mediums?
 
...irrational beliefs in aliens.

It's very simple: Carl Sagan did not have a belief in aliens. He (and many, many other scientist who agree with him) had a thorough knowledge of chemistry, biology and astronomy that led them to realize that there is a very real probability that life is not unique to the Earth. With this possibility in mind, they decided to conduct a survey using the only method available. Most felt it was a long shot that they would detect any signals, but given the low cost of listening, it was worth doing. They did not start with "We are certain that we will hear from alien civilizations". They started with "I wonder if there could be alien civilizations broadcasting radio signals? Well let's listen and see if we hear anything".

Please answer the following questions:

1. Why is it irrational to think that life may have evolved elsewhere in the universe?

2. Why is it irrational to investigate the possibility that some of that life might, like us, evolve to the point that it develops the technology to broadcast communications using radiation emissions?
 
Einstein was obsessed with finding a Unified Theory of Everything
Newton was obsessed with Alchemy
Edison was obsessed with electricity.

Obsession with finding the truth (or a fiction) does not detract from the real work one does, nor does it prevent real findings.
In fact, obsession with something can be positive or negative--but it quite often leads to discovering things never before imagined...

By all accounts, Sagan was also "obsessed" with basketball and convincing the world of the utter foolishness, and grave danger of our own extinction, posed by the building of nuclear weapons.
 
I have been noticing the Education section is hardly drawing any interest. So I was right Skeptics are not for education.


You've made several serious errors of logic in those lone two sentences.

1. You're conflating two different meanings of the word "Education". The "Education" section of this forum is for the discussion of skeptical topics generally related to the schooling of children. You then pretend that "Education" actually means any and all efforts to inform anyone about skepticism.

2. You have concluded that the topics discussed by the membership of this forum correlate to the real-world actions of those individuals.

3. You have concluded that the membership of this forum represents the body of people who are skeptics.

4. You have concluded that the amount of discussion on an internet chat board is a reliable way of determining what people are "for" or "against."
 
ludicrous

So you prefer complete credulity? If someone offers you a miracle cure for only $100,000, you will immediately scrape together the cash and fork it over, because applying cautious scrutiny to the veracity of this claim would be "ludicrous"?

That explains a lot.
 
No offence taken. What do you think of my green cow example of how scepticism works in the "field"?

We already know why cheese turn green. It is the mold that causes it to turn green. If you knew that and was less of a Skeptic. You might have ended checking her out for suspect mold instead of being directed to a dead cow.

Next time someone shows you a picture of udders, Be less skeptical.
 
I can cure that for you retail

ludicrous

I have a cure for that, send $100.00 to Snake Oil Inc., Sunnyvale, Calif and a bottle of our patented, FDA Certified Medicine will be promptly mailed to you.
 
From the responses it is obvious none of the participants are philosophy majors and unfortunately Skeptics lack an understanding of Epistemology. Discussion on solipsism, empiricism and rationalism require an understanding of their philosophical roots.

Kurtz has popularized scientific skepticism and critical thinking about claims of the paranormal.

Hurtz was not a scientist. He implored Skeptics to apply scientific method. In short scientific skepticism is for non scientific people.
Now how practical is it for a non scientific person to apply scientific method.
1. In America less than 5% of the working population make a living as engineers and scientist. So if you separate the scientist from engineers the percentage of the population actually making a living applying the scientific method is even smaller. How practical is that?

2. Scientific method requires a proficiency in the field of study. One cannot claim to know the scientific method and based on just this knowledge apply for a job as a research scientist.

Definition of scientific method Oxford dictionary.
1. a method of procedure that has characterized natural science since the 17th century, consisting in systematic observation, measurement, and experiment, and the formulation, testing, and modification of hypotheses:

In short, only the professionals can apply scientific method. Only the professionals can tackle complex phenomena for verifiability. The scientific method is beyond the scope of the average Skeptic.

Why then do Skeptic Forums promote the criticism of things not well understood; how they appear awkward, are marginalized and often found rather unhelpful.

That's about what I figured...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom