Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Justintime, could we have your thoughts on the following questions:

1. Why is it irrational to think that life may have evolved elsewhere in the universe?

2. Why is it irrational to investigate the possibility that some of that life might, like us, evolve to the point that it develops the technology to broadcast communications using radiation emissions?

It is the same reason Carl Sagan gave for people who thought Ghost were real or UFOs were real. They are irrational to believe in ghosts and UFOs because there is no evidence that they exist. Not that there is anything wrong looking for them but without evidence they cannot claim it is true.

Carl Sagan violated his own rules of scientific skepticism. He looked for ETI and found they do not exist. There is no proof of their existence. So he too started on an irrational belief in their existence.

Now you can say ETI have not been found yet. They might be found down the road. But so too can UFOs and Ghost. Who is to say after he fails to call others irrational.
 
René Descartes goes into a fish and chips shop and says to the man behind the counter "I'd like a cod and chips, please". "Certainly sir," replies the man, "would you like salt and vinegar?" René replies "I think not," and vanishes.
 
ahh, but in that article, they aren't referring to skeptics are they? No they are referring to people who deny AGM based on political and/or ideological reasons (or claim that AGW is promoted for those reasons) NOT because they have evaluated the scientific evidence and come to that conclusion.

So your attempt to pigeonhole skeptics has been smited. care to try again?

They are called climate change skeptics. They are skeptics.
 
Ahh but you are trying to apply the same rules of paranormal activity to the very simple concept of life existing on one of trillions of planets. The two are not compatible logically.
 
no, they claim they are skeptics, but just as i can claim I am Jesus Christ and dare you to prove I'm not, they aren't following the principles of skepticism and are actually deniers (in a similar vein as those people who claim the Holocaust didn't happen, yet with a lot less evil intent )
 
no, they claim they are skeptics, but just as i can claim I am Jesus Christ and dare you to prove I'm not, they aren't following the principles of skepticism and are actually deniers (in a similar vein as those people who claim the Holocaust didn't happen, yet with a lot less evil intent )

Beat me to it, and more accurately too.

Curses!
 
The amusing thing is the insinuation that we're somehow afraid of his intellectual prowess.

Not true. What it shows is someone pointed to climate change skeptics emitting fear signals. I reviewed his analysis and found it could be applied to other areas and sources of fear that Skeptics are exposed to. Someone might come after me and further broaden the scope. This is not an exhaustive list of all the fears Skeptics suffer from.
 
and you have no evidence to support your hypothesis (well none you have presented anyway) so you are using the scientific method rather poorly. and frankly, we are starting to grow weary with your silly,pointless banter and soon we will start smiting you.
 
Ahh but you are trying to apply the same rules of paranormal activity to the very simple concept of life existing on one of trillions of planets. The two are not compatible logically.


Logic has not made much of an appearance in justintime's posts.
 
They are cynics who call themselves skeptics.

I know I will get trouble for this (luckily, only from justin), but calling yourself a skeptic and then not accepting evidence is, well, not good skepticism.

At least you don`t have to worry about my analysis.
I first defined the Skeptic and then provided cause for his fears (doubts, uncertainty and insecurity) which built the case for panic and fear. For good measure I even located the seat of fear in the Skeptic brain.
 
Last edited:
At least you don`t have to worry about my analysis.
I first defined the Skeptic and then provided cause for his fears (doubts, uncertainty and insecurity) which built the case for panic and fear. For good measure I even located the seat of fear in the Skeptic brain.


No--you have made post after post of near-nonsense, refused to accept when you've been wrong and failed to present any evidence to support your "case".
 
I first defined the Skeptic and then provided cause for his fears (doubts, uncertainty and insecurity)[...]

Yes, you did make unfounded assumptions and sweeping generalisations. This is why you're not being taken seriously by anybody.

Of course, if you'd like to start saying something sensible, which you can provide evidence and reasoning for, people might start viewing your posts as something other than to laugh at.
 
It is the same reason Carl Sagan gave for people who thought Ghost were real or UFOs were real. They are irrational to believe in ghosts and UFOs because there is no evidence that they exist. Not that there is anything wrong looking for them but without evidence they cannot claim it is true.

Carl Sagan violated his own rules of scientific skepticism. He looked for ETI and found they do not exist. There is no proof of their existence. So he too started on an irrational belief in their existence.

Now you can say ETI have not been found yet. They might be found down the road. But so too can UFOs and Ghost. Who is to say after he fails to call others irrational.

One problem. There is life in the universe. We have incontrovertible proof of this. We've never had the slightest empirical evidence for the existence of an alien spacecraft or a ghost, but we know of a planet that is positively crawling with life. We also know that the elements that life is made up from are among the most abundant in the universe. We know that these elements make organic molecules that spontaneously arrange themselves into more complex arrangements. We know that the universe is teeming with the organic molecules that life as we know it is composed of. We also know that there are an unimaginably vast number of worlds in the universe. The Sloan Digital Sky Survey allows us to estimate that there are between 10 sextillion and 1 septillion stars in the observable universe. That's 10,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 to 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 stars! Each one likely to have at least several planets. So even if the odds of life evolving on any given planet are extremely low, there are a staggering number of chances of it happening. Even if the odds of any given star harboring life are a trillion to one, there could be ten billion to one trillion worlds with life in the universe.

Try to wrap your brain around a number like 1 septillion. If you had a lottery where the odds of winning with any individual ticket was 1 in a trillion, but you had 1 septillion tickets, you'd win the lottery about 1 trillion times over.

And remember, we do have proof that life exists in the universe.
 
Last edited:
I'm nominating your post Foster Zygote. It's concise, well written, to the point and will probably be completely ignored or hand waved away by you know who...
 
It is the same reason Carl Sagan gave for people who thought Ghost were real or UFOs were real. They are irrational to believe in ghosts and UFOs because there is no evidence that they exist. Not that there is anything wrong looking for them but without evidence they cannot claim it is true.

I see you misunderstood Foster Zygote's question. He asked what was irrational about believing extraterrestrial life may exist.

You are also making a false analogy. For life evolving on a planet, we have one example of it happening, so we know it's possible. For ghosts and alien spacecraft visiting the earth, we have zero examples.
 
Wow! That is incredibly wrong. Unless your mechanic is psychic, he can't "just know" all the time. There are any number of presented problems that will require the application of the fundamentals of the scientific method. My cousin is an ASE Master Mechanic who works for a Volvo dealership. If a car gets towed in with the problem, "will not start", there are hundreds of possible causes. He uses his experience to know what the most likely causes are, but then he forms an hypothesis and tests it by making an alteration to the element that he thinks might be the cause. If it has no effect and the car still won't start, he moves on to another likely system.

Foster Zygote you are disappointing me.
Let us try again.

Definition of Scientist: A person having expert knowledge of one or more sciences, especially a natural or physical science.

Scientific method : Mathematical and experimental techniques employed in the natural sciences.

Natural science definition:A branch of science that deals with the physical world, e.g., physics, chemistry, geology, and biology.

Is a mechanic a scientist. I don`t think so by that definition.
 
That's one of the dumbest things i have ever seen, and YOU SIR ARE NOMINATED FOR A STUNDIE!! congrats!
 
You don't seem to understand that the scientific method is exactly what a mechanic uses (and also peer review)

I shall demonstrate

Person A brings in a car that's making a wobbling noise, the mechanic asks questions to determine an initial system diagnosis (what part of the car can he eliminate from his "source" options) (this is akin to eliminating the possible variables in a science experiment)

He then fires up the car, drives it himself so as to familiarize himself to the "sound" the person has relayed to him. Then he uses his experience and knowledge to isolate and recognize the problem then make the repairs. (just like a scientist who wants to know why something is the way it is,isolate the 'something" study it's behavior, introduce a variable, observe the results)

He may also, consult other mechanics before making the repairs to verify that his diagnosis is accurate (peer review) and thus doesn't waste time chasing worthless data down the rabbit hole.

Then the customer returns, drives the car, notices the sound is gone. Is relayed the information of the cause (like a study is relayed in a journal) and happily pays and goes home.

The 2nd stage of review is the aftermath of the repair, if the "science" was practiced properly, the repair should solve the issue and the sound should not reoccur, if it does come back , then the initial stage can be said to have been "proven false" and further review of the information by the original mechanic is required. (this is like what happens when you publish a paper, the initial peer review merely states that the data was gathered in a verifiable and repeatable manner. The science community at large will get to work and give the final "grade" on the paper based on how often it is cited by others and also if any further papers are published refuting the original claim)

so mechanics use the scientific method. I use it everyday when doing baseball analysis. I'm not a 'pro scientist" but I MUST follow the scientific method if I want my statistical analysis to have any value.

Baseball analysis is using a branch of mathematics. Statistics, probability etc. Scientific method also used some of that. But that is just a part of the scientific method. Just like marketing and population projections all use mathematics and other techniques that were developed for the natural sciences. But they are not natural science and they are not scientific methods.
 
LOL, YES THEY ARE!

dude, seriously, you should just stop, you clearly have no idea what you are talking about.


unless you care to list some of the unnatural sciences for us to consider?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom