Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

We already know why cheese turn green. It is the mold that causes it to turn green. If you knew that and was less of a Skeptic. You might have ended checking her out for suspect mold instead of being directed to a dead cow.


What makes the mold green? And why do you hate chlorophyll?

Next time someone shows you a picture of udders, Be less skeptical.


Next time someone mentions a green cow, be more skeptical. And if you don't know how, you've come to the right place. Here at the JREF forums we specialize in teaching the uninformed, uneducated, skeptic haters. But of course it only works if they want it.
 
We already know why cheese turn green. It is the mold that causes it to turn green. If you knew that and was less of a Skeptic. You might have ended checking her out for suspect mold instead of being directed to a dead cow.

Next time someone shows you a picture of udders, Be less skeptical.

Third request...

Be so kind as to explain:

"It may be no more than a careless mistake on your part (formatting can be tricky) but the source you appear to be providing for the quote above
(The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749)
does not, in fact, contain the text you appear to be claiming that it does."
__________________
 
How many posts have you made in the last 3 years, Justitime?

I have been posting on Skeptic forums for little over a year starting (09/21/11).. I accidentally stumbled on one trying to locate a discussion on phenotypes ( Pink flamingos) to be exact . The link was pointed by someone who turned out to be a troll and I have been trying to rehabilitate him ever since.
I was on Dawkins early 2010. before I discovered the Skeptic forums. I am big on science.
 
justintime, I think that you would discover that you are vastly out of your league here. Your attempts at short shifting and semantics might work when you are arguing with a bunch of boobs on the basementtroglodytes.com forum, but on here, many of the people you will talk with are pros in the science, education, medical and legal professions (and those of us who are just regular blowhards are still rather clever) so, you think you are making points and looking smart.


You aren't


All you have succeeded in doing is making yourself look uneducated, angry,biased and carrying a grudge about Sagan and the concept of skepticism so large as to cloud any fair judgement.

In other words, your argument is worthless and based on conjecture shrouded in a personal animosity that negates any rational point you may have been trying to make (if one ever existed)

Now, if you would like to discuss these things like a grown up, we are all ears.
 
what are your credentials? because it doesn't appear as though you have any earthly idea what you are talking about in regards to anything...
 
I think looking at the dates Roswell 1947 and around 1951 Carl Sagan at 17 talking about flying saucers and aliens makes me feel he made that connection. He developed an early obsession and tried to fulfill it by searching for them for the rest of his life

You feel Sagan made the connection?
It is you who has made the connection.
I think it has been explained to you that simply repeating an assertion does not make it more real. The difference between what I think and what you think is that what I think is demonstrably true.
 
I have been posting on Skeptic forums for little over a year starting (09/21/11).. I accidentally stumbled on one trying to locate a discussion on phenotypes ( Pink flamingos) to be exact . The link was pointed by someone who turned out to be a troll and I have been trying to rehabilitate him ever since.
I was on Dawkins early 2010. before I discovered the Skeptic forums. I am big on science.

Fouurth request:

In post #66, you appear to be offering the following:

A skeptic forum is not the proper place to go to for facts. It is the place you go to when you have doubts about something and you are looking for other doubters. For example if you want to learn something about climate change or religion/god You go to a climate research/study site or a church to be with religious people.

Now having met more doubters that agree with you on a skeptic forum, you can either end your search and stop learning anything more about the subject or search for other doubts that doubters have to add to the list of doubts you have accumulated. You might then reach a saturation point full of only doubts and that is where the panic and fear creeps in.
Tragically, Skeptic brains 'emit fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought'

...and appear to be offering the following cite as its source:

The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749

It is possible that this merely represents no more than a careless mistake on your part (formatting can be tricky). However, that source does not, in fact, contain the text you appear to be claiming that it does.

I do not want a simple mistake to give you the appearance of intentional dishonesty on this forum.

Be so kind as to provide the actual source for the quote above.

Be so kind as to explain the purpose of the link above.

I eagerly anticipate your resolution of this issue.
 
Last edited:
Fouurth request:

In post #66, you appear to be offering the following:



...and appear to be offering the following cite as its source:



It is possible that this merely represents no more than a careless mistake on your part (formatting can be tricky). However, that source does not, in fact, contain the text you appear to be claiming that it does.

I do not want a simple mistake to give you the appearance of intentional dishonesty on this forum.

Be so kind as to provide the actual source for the quote above.

Be so kind as to explain the purpose of the link above.

I eagerly anticipate your resolution of this issue.

You have to understand the link and the function of the amygdala. It is obvious you did not read the link but tried a word search for a direct match.

I was looking for what the troll had to say about phenotypes and followed through with the link he provided. That is how I discovered Skeptic Forums are not the place to look for information.

You have to apply logic and not jump to conclusions.
 
I believe in the very real possibility that there is intelligent life in the Universe other than on Earth. If I were a scientist, I would definitely be an astronomer or astro-physicist, or whatever the the actual names are :D and I'm sure that I would have followed in Carl Sagan's mold -he's a hero of mine. He simply used the best science available to him to look for any real acceptable evidence that might be out there.

But this type of "belief" in the possibility of alien life doesn't mean that I think UFOs are aliens or that people have been abducted by aliens. When I was a kid, late teens early 20s, I may have believed that some of these stories were real. But as I grew up and got a little wiser and more mature, I began to see through them. There is no credible evidence available -and unexplained does not constitute evidence. Now that I understand the science a little better, I see that even if life does exist out there it's probably not going to be widespread or even anywhere close enough to us to make travel feasible given what we know about physics.

I understand the woos fascination with Sagan. If you have never read him or seen his show, Cosmos, then you might be fooled into thinking he was a mainstream scientist who believed in UFOs. Unfortunately for woodom, this is not the case.
 
justintime

There is probably no doubt that Sagan believed UFO's were extraterrestrial in origin when he was a young man. Hell, I thought that as well as a teenager, Chariots of the Gods, The Bermuda Triangle, Flight 19, etc were all "evidence" that aliens were here on earth. This all changed gradually as I grew up, and came to the realisation that "speculation" is not "evidence".

If Sagan still believed this in his 40's and 50's, then he had a strange way of showing it. For just one example, in an episode of Cosmos (04:Heaven and Hell) he had a golden opportunity to advance that belief when talking about what might have caused the Tunguska event, yet what does he say?

"Or maybe, other people have speculated, it was a spaceship of some unimaginably advanced extraterrestrial civilization in desperate mechanical trouble crashing in a remote region of an obscure planet. Well, if so, it's pretty startling that at the impact site there is not a piece, not the tiniest transistor of a crashed spacecraft."


If you have ever bothered to watch the series Cosmos all the way through from beginning to end (and somehow, I doubt it) you would pick up a theme which runs right through it, that science is about the evidence and the rigorous testing of theory with experimentation and research. He lambasts scientists who do not approach subjects with an open mind, e.g. the active suppression of the theories of Velikovsky, which while almost certainly wrong, were nevertheless his call to propose.



Unfortunately, CTs and woomeisters don't want close scrutiny and investigation by experiment, because they know that such investigation will reveal their beliefs and claims as a fraud. Its why, despite having a world full of people who claim psychic powers and abilities as mediums, NOT ONE has accepted the JREF Million Dollar challenge, because they know their fraud will be exposed... and they hate sceptics for that.
 
Last edited:
It's really simple, justintime. Being a skeptic isn't about what you believe or how much of your time you spend researching a particularly topic. It's about how you believe and how you spend your time researching a particular topic.

Carl Sagan believed that intelligent life probably exists out there somewhere but admitted that because of the immense size of the universe and our limited resources, no convincing physical evidence had been found during his lifetime.

He postulated a reasonable idea, explored it logically, and came to sound conclusions that weren't based on pseudoscience or fallacies. Therefore, he was a skeptic.
 
Last edited:
I believe in the very real possibility that there is intelligent life in the Universe other than on Earth. If I were a scientist, I would definitely be an astronomer or astro-physicist, or whatever the the actual names are :D and I'm sure that I would have followed in Carl Sagan's mold -he's a hero of mine. He simply used the best science available to him to look for any real acceptable evidence that might be out there.

But this type of "belief" in the possibility of alien life doesn't mean that I think UFOs are aliens or that people have been abducted by aliens. When I was a kid, late teens early 20s, I may have believed that some of these stories were real. But as I grew up and got a little wiser and more mature, I began to see through them. There is no credible evidence available -and unexplained does not constitute evidence. Now that I understand the science a little better, I see that even if life does exist out there it's probably not going to be widespread or even anywhere close enough to us to make travel feasible given what we know about physics.

I understand the woos fascination with Sagan. If you have never read him or seen his show, Cosmos, then you might be fooled into thinking he was a mainstream scientist who believed in UFOs. Unfortunately for woodom, this is not the case.

I would have looked for ETI if I was a scientist in the trained field. But I would not have done so if I were skeptical of their existence(did not believe). Carl Sagan was a Skeptic he denounced irrational beliefs.
1. What can be more irrational than looking for aliens without a spacecraft that could reach them.
2. What could be more irrational than assuming aliens could be contacted using radio telescope.
Sagan argued that thousands of technically advanced civilizations might be scattered across the galaxy. Some of these societies might be able to communicate with Earth via radio. The back-and-forth messaging might take centuries because of Albert Einstein’s speed limit on electromagnetic waves, but the participants felt the search for such signals was worthwhile anyway.
3, What can be more irrational than using a statistical probability equation with arbitrary assumptions to arrive at a probable number.
4. What could be more irrational than writing a book on alien contact when even the remotest possibility of finding any was never realized.
You have misplaced the woo.
 
Last edited:
You have to understand the link and the function of the amygdala. It is obvious you did not read the link but tried a word search for a direct match.


The article you linked to in no way supports your statement that "Skeptic brains 'emit fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought'."

And you took that last bit from a book on climate change that is not referring to "skeptic brains":

Author William Marsden explains in his recent book Fools Rule: Inside the failed politics of climate change (Alfred A. Knopf Canada) that the when the brain is confronted with tiny changes to familiar patterns, it “quickly emits fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought”.

http://www.straight.com/article-604...-incapable-recognizing-reality-climate-change
 
You have to understand the link and the function of the amygdala. It is obvious you did not read the link but tried a word search for a direct match.

I was looking for what the troll had to say about phenotypes and followed through with the link he provided. That is how I discovered Skeptic Forums are not the place to look for information.

You have to apply logic and not jump to conclusions.

I see. You are going to repeat your dodge of not standing behind what you post.

Follow:

Here is your original formatting, quoted directly form your post #66:

Quote:
A skeptic forum is not the proper place to go to for facts. It is the place you go to when you have doubts about something and you are looking for other doubters. For example if you want to learn something about climate change or religion/god You go to a climate research/study site or a church to be with religious people.

Now having met more doubters that agree with you on a skeptic forum, you can either end your search and stop learning anything more about the subject or search for other doubts that doubters have to add to the list of doubts you have accumulated. You might then reach a saturation point full of only doubts and that is where the panic and fear creeps in.
Tragically, Skeptic brains 'emit fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought'

The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749

It is a common convention of honest scholarship that, when one purports to quote material, one provides a source for the quote (to avoid, among other things: on the one hand, the charge of plagiarism, by demonstrating that the words quoted are, in fact, another's work; and on the other hand, the charge of quote-mining, that is, taking a snippet of text out of context in order to change the clear meaning intended by the actual offer).

Your formatting, above, appears to make the claim that the text from "A skeptic forum..." to "...rational thought." is, in fact, an actual direct, and unedited quote from "The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749".

The truth is that "The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749" does not, in fact, mention, even by colorable implication, "skeptic forums", the "agreement" among "doubters" on such fora, "accumulated doubt", "saturation points", or "fear signals" tragically emitted by "Skeptic brain' (sic)", that can "disrupt attempts at rational thought".

In fact, the article articulately discusses the role of the amygdala, with the rest of the limbic system, in conditioned rats in laboratory settings. There is an interesting, and useful, distinction suggested between the "feeling" of fear and the "emotion" of fear; there is also a brief paragraph on methods of "reducing fear and inhibiting the fear response".

In other words, the text you provided is not from the article you referenced.
The text you provided is not a description, precis, abstract, or development of the information in the article you cited.

Your pretense that I did not read, or understand, the citation is incorrect.
Your post, as formatted, looks dishonest.

Logically, there are several possibilities, among them being:
1. You made an honest formatting mistake, but tried to cover it up by pretending I was not applying "logic" (as per your habit of blaming the reader for reading what you say, not what you claim, you meant); or,
2. You posted a link to an article you did not understand, hoping that no one would check your source and notice that your quote is not, in fact, described, contained, reference, or implied, much less present verbatim, in the citation you provided; or,
3. You knowingly provided a citation to an article that does not in any way support the quote you presented as coming from that article.

I anticipate your explanation. Do be so good as to notice that simply repeating your accusation that I did not read, or understand, the article has been dealt with--the issue is not my comprehension, but your use or abuse of the way material is honestly and accurately quoted.
 
I would have looked for ETI if I was a scientist in the trained field. But I would not have done so if I were skeptical of their existence(did not believe). Carl Sagan was a Skeptic he denounced irrational beliefs.

Yes, he denounced irrational beliefs. Believing that life on other planets is possible is not irrational.

1. What can be more irrational than looking for aliens without a spacecraft that could reach them.

What's irrational about that?

2. What could be more irrational than assuming aliens could be contacted using radio telescope.

How is that irrational?

3, What can be more irrational than using a statistical probability equation with arbitrary assumptions to arrive at a probable number.

Sagan didn't do that.

4. What could be more irrational than writing a book on alien contact when even the remotest possibility of finding any was never realized.

Everyone who writes science fiction is irrational?
 
Justintime, please answer the following questions:

1. Why is it irrational to think that life may have evolved elsewhere in the universe?

2. Why is it irrational to investigate the possibility that some of that life might, like us, evolve to the point that it develops the technology to broadcast communications using radiation emissions?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom