Interesting definition. Certainly not accurate, by any stretch, but interesting. For example, those firemen that publish in peer-reviewed journals--would you call THEM scientists? They've got knowledge of paleontology equal to that of the guy who's writing that volume of the Treatise, but they're not professionals and you've already said that non-profesionals are excluded from being scientists.justintime said:Let us try again.
Definition of Scientist: A person having expert knowledge of one or more sciences, especially a natural or physical science.
Employed by, but not limited to. Geology uses compasses. Does that mean cartographers are incapable of using them? You're confusing the tools with the institutions--a critical failure for someone who is attempting to school us on epistemology.Scientific method : Mathematical and experimental techniques employed in the natural sciences.
As an aside, are you aware of how dictionaries define words? I think you really aught to look that up sometime. It'd be extraordinarily educational for you.
This illustrates another problem with argument by definition: definitions aren't typically complete. For example, your definition is extremely vague, to the point where I could honestly include carpentry and farming as natural sciences.natural science definition:A branch of science that deals with the physical world, e.g., physics, chemistry, geology, and biology.
You ONLY think in definitions, so the last three words here are redundant. Also, you're ignoring the fact that none of us have argued that a mechanic is a scientist. Rather, we've argued that they use the scientific method. I'm not an engineer, but I've used blueprints. My father's not a geologist, but he's used geotechnical studies. The SM is a tool, nothing more--and anyone who's ever owned a home can tell you that one tool can have many, many uses.Is a mechanic a scientist. I don`t think so by that definition.
Of course, I doubt you'll even read that. You're locked into your world-view, it seems.