Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

That definition of UFOs was taken from the Oxford dictionary.

No, it did not change his beliefs. He was just as determined to find them.

I think UFO was used in the early sighting because their were unidentifiable. But the public figured there had to be more to that because of the closed secrecy behind the Roswell UFO incident. Some of the eyewitness broke their silence and identified it as a alien spacecraft. The conspiracy is more about the coverup and not doubts about it being an alien spacecraft.

And the uncritical, unsophisticated, unsupported, credulous belief that "there really was a UFO" at Roswell, and that "the conspiracy is more about the coverup and not doubts about it being an alien spacecraft" is precisely the kind of thing Demon-Haunted World (which you really ought to read) was written to debunk.

Please explain how your claim that there has been a "conspiracy" and/or a"coverup" about "it being an alien spacecraft" demonstrate anything about Dr. Sagan's beliefs, or opinions...preferably without spin-doctoring and quote mining.
 
That definition of UFOs was taken from the Oxford dictionary.

No, it did not change his beliefs. He was just as determined to find them.

I think UFO was used in the early sighting because their were unidentifiable. But the public figured there had to be more to that because of the closed secrecy behind the Roswell UFO incident. Some of the eyewitness broke their silence and identified it as a alien spacecraft. The conspiracy is more about the coverup and not doubts about it being an alien spacecraft.


A UFO is an unidentified flying object, something with appears to be flying, appears to be an object, and which is not or has not been identified as a particular thing. If something has been identified as an alien craft, it is no longer unidentified. Once more: If we know what something is, it isn't a UFO.

And if you have objective evidence to support a claim that alien craft exist, take it to one of the appropriate threads which already exist for that discussion.
 
Not true. I do not have a life long obsession with UFOs, aliens or even ETI. I am not even a Ghost buster. I just try to see the treatable person behind the Skeptic and his or her Skepticism.
I try not to confuse entertainment with serious discourses.

Then why do you try to use Contact as evidence that Dr. Sagan was, as you have put it, a "snake-oil salesman"?

And where have you demonstrated your qualifications to identify anyone (much less your friend you are outing) as "treatable"? And where have you demonstrated your training in "treating" anyone so diagnosed?
 
I would have pointed to Greece if the Skeptic was from there. Sorry if you are offended. I was a Joe Cocker fan Mad Dogs and Englishmen album. He was ahead of his time. I wonder if he would have retitled the album to Mad Cows and Englishmen. I digress.

British Budget Adheres to Austerity While It Cuts the Top Tax Rate
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/22/b...cks-to-austerity-in-new-budget-plan.html?_r=0

No offence taken. What do you think of my green cow example of how scepticism works in the "field"?
 
I just try to see the treatable person behind the Skeptic and his or her Skepticism.
I try not to confuse entertainment with serious discourses.

Credentials?

(Of course on the anonymous interwebs one can claim pretty much anything)
 
It is beginning to look as if it is you, not Sagan, who believes we have been visited by alien spacecraft.

Leave Justin aloonee!

For the first time he had drawn back the curtain on what he thought, rather than what he thought other people thought. Gentle handling was called for :cool:

Now he's back in his shell.
 
To the claim I haven't encountered any Skeptics outside of Skeptic forums. There are more important things that affect you directly in the real world. Your job, customers, patients, transactions, interactions, trust and social encounters. You don't have Skeptics out there demanding citations or criticizing your beliefs. It is a live and let live attitude out there. All the nit pickers are cesspooling on Skeptic forums.

*snipped for the sake of brevity*


I get the impression that you are well intentioned. You seem to be arguing for something you have strong convictions for, and I respect that.

Unfortunately, you've painted a picture of skeptics with a rather broad brush and as a result you've sacrificed accuracy in favor of generalizations. Yes there are participants on skeptical forums who match with your descriptions, if not always, at least some of the time. That in itself does not mean that all skeptics match these descriptions and I contend that the vast majority do not.

As well intentioned as your crusade may be, it is unlikely to bear fruit because the misdirected war you've waged is on the wrong enemy. To truly have an impact of the sort you're hoping for will require far more diligence and specificity than you're currently employing. You'll need to target and dismantle the arguments of individuals instead of lackadaisically poisoning the well. In doing so you can expose the weakness of cynicism, which is what I think you really want to do.

Even then you've got a hard road ahead of you if you want to be effective. Do yourself a favor though, and don't create enemies where there were none in the first place. Who knows, you may even come to appreciate some of the skeptical perspectives offered by many participants on forums like these.

Cheers.
 
And how does that make you feel?

I think looking at the dates Roswell 1947 and around 1951 Carl Sagan at 17 talking about flying saucers and aliens makes me feel he made that connection. He developed an early obsession and tried to fulfill it by searching for them for the rest of his life.
By embellishing his Cosmos program with the possibility of finding ETI through the SETI project added the type of hype that sells books and movies and panders to the irrational beliefs in aliens.
 
Then why do you try to use Contact as evidence that Dr. Sagan was, as you have put it, a "snake-oil salesman"?

And where have you demonstrated your qualifications to identify anyone (much less your friend you are outing) as "treatable"? And where have you demonstrated your training in "treating" anyone so diagnosed?


Indeed. It continues to appear we're witnessing some lashing out due to an anger and resentment about being smacked down by skeptics sometime in the past.

Come on, justintime, what is it you believe, that skeptics don't believe, that makes you so angry at skeptics? Was your mother a skeptic when you were an infant? Did your father smoke a cigar? A bigger one than yours? Is there a point to any of your rambling aside from you hate skeptics so you want to hang around insulting them? You do realize that activity has gotten you banned from other forums, don't you?
 
I think looking at the dates Roswell 1947 and around 1951 Carl Sagan at 17 talking about flying saucers and aliens makes me feel he made that connection. He developed an early obsession and tried to fulfill it by searching for them for the rest of his life.
By embellishing his Cosmos program with the possibility of finding ETI through the SETI project added the type of hype that sells books and movies and panders to the irrational beliefs in aliens.

So, with no regard to basic priciple of etymology, you build an entire case against Dr. Sagan oin what you "feel" must be true?

You are continuing to use the word "obsession" without any justification.

Your continued, and increasingly desperate, attempts at calumniating Dr. Sagan for what you want to believe he believed, are noted.

Now: be so kind as to address your qualifications for diagnosing someone as "treatable".

Further, be so kind as to address your qualifications for providing approrpiate "treatment", assuming arguendo you could, in fact, make the diagnosis.

Further, be so kind as to address the issue of denigrating the person whose identity you claim to be trying to protect as part of any approved, or accepted, "treatment".
 
Indeed. It continues to appear we're witnessing some lashing out due to an anger and resentment about being smacked down by skeptics sometime in the past.

Come on, justintime, what is it you believe, that skeptics don't believe, that makes you so angry at skeptics? Was your mother a skeptic when you were an infant? Did your father smoke a cigar? A bigger one than yours? Is there a point to any of your rambling aside from you hate skeptics so you want to hang around insulting them? You do realize that activity has gotten you banned from other forums, don't you?

I see what you did there...
 
By embellishing his Cosmos program with the possibility of finding ETI through the SETI project added the type of hype that sells books and movies and panders to the irrational beliefs in aliens.

Why is belief that aliens might exist irrational?
 
Indeed. It continues to appear we're witnessing some lashing out due to an anger and resentment about being smacked down by skeptics sometime in the past.

Come on, justintime, what is it you believe, that skeptics don't believe, that makes you so angry at skeptics? Was your mother a skeptic when you were an infant? Did your father smoke a cigar? A bigger one than yours? Is there a point to any of your rambling aside from you hate skeptics so you want to hang around insulting them? You do realize that activity has gotten you banned from other forums, don't you?

I have been noticing the Education section is hardly drawing any interest. So I was right Skeptics are not for education.

I found the heaviest activity in the Paranormal section which included Carl Sagan and his obsession with aliens (this OP). So it is not only the Skeptic Carl Sagan who was obsessed with aliens. Most Skeptics here are just as obsessed with aliens.
I was not trying to make this an OP about aliens but about Carl Sagan as a Skeptic. But it appears one cannot separate Skeptics from their beliefs in aliens. :jaw-dropp
 
I think looking at the dates Roswell 1947 and around 1951 Carl Sagan at 17 talking about flying saucers and aliens makes me feel he made that connection. He developed an early obsession and tried to fulfill it by searching for them for the rest of his life.
By embellishing his Cosmos program with the possibility of finding ETI through the SETI project added the type of hype that sells books and movies and panders to the irrational beliefs in aliens.

You keep using this term as if it's a diagnosis; I don't think you can justify that. Your participation on in this thread and a few others, all concerning skepticism seems to suggest an agenda.

What is it?
 
I have been noticing the Education section is hardly drawing any interest. So I was right Skeptics are not for education.

I found the heaviest activity in the Paranormal section which included Carl Sagan and his obsession with aliens (this OP). So it is not only the Skeptic Carl Sagan who was obsessed with aliens. Most Skeptics here are just as obsessed with aliens.
I was not trying to make this an OP about aliens but about Carl Sagan as a Skeptic. But it appears one cannot separate Skeptics from their beliefs in aliens. :jaw-dropp

Is this some sort of undergrad project? Your language skills seem passable, maybe even skilled, though with more than a hint of pedant.

You don't have to capitalize skeptic by the way. Unless you're trying to make some sort of point; then, well, you haven't I'm afraid.

As to your shot about the Education forum, you do understand many here are in fact educators, don't you?
 
I have been noticing the Education section is hardly drawing any interest. So I was right Skeptics are not for education.

I found the heaviest activity in the Paranormal section which included Carl Sagan and his obsession with aliens (this OP). So it is not only the Skeptic Carl Sagan who was obsessed with aliens. Most Skeptics here are just as obsessed with aliens.
I was not trying to make this an OP about aliens but about Carl Sagan as a Skeptic. But it appears one cannot separate Skeptics from their beliefs in aliens. :jaw-dropp

Oh, and I thought you intended making an effort not to confuse entertainment with serious discourse. You appear unaware that the busiest forums here are those which attract the most entertaining (or merely persistent) contrarians. It's the nutcases who are uninterested in education.

In what way might aliens, if they exist, be paranormal?
 
Last edited:
I have been noticing the Education section is hardly drawing any interest. So I was right Skeptics are not for education.

I found the heaviest activity in the Paranormal section which included Carl Sagan and his obsession with aliens (this OP). So it is not only the Skeptic Carl Sagan who was obsessed with aliens. Most Skeptics here are just as obsessed with aliens.
I was not trying to make this an OP about aliens but about Carl Sagan as a Skeptic. But it appears one cannot separate Skeptics from their beliefs in aliens. :jaw-dropp


Ah, I see. You're just trolling to get banned. I would wish you luck in that endeavor, but it looks like you'll be successful regardless.
 
I think UFO was used in the early sighting because their were unidentifiable. But the public figured there had to be more to that because of the closed secrecy behind the Roswell UFO incident. Some of the eyewitness broke their silence and identified it as a alien spacecraft. The conspiracy is more about the coverup and not doubts about it being an alien spacecraft.

I think we may finally be getting somewhere.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom