Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Hominini, but whatever.





No, they weren't hunting with tools. There's a debate as to whether they were hunting at all, but tools used specifically for hunting were still some way off.





There is no evidence that early hominini "took on" their predators. They certainly did not feed on them. Their meat diet was composed mostly of deer and smaller animals.





Well, your last statement was untrue, so this is meaningless. In any case, do you have any evidence whatsoever that animals that hunt have a sense of self or even have great intelligence? I am now including sharks, spiders, tuna and bears.





There is no evidence that religious or mystical belief predates self-awareness. In fact, the absolute earliest any expert has ever put mysitical belief is 300,000 years ago. The fact that you acknowledge self-awareness in hominini 2 million years ago means that you've refuted your own point.





Why does just one innate trait put humans over the top? Why not a whole suite of innate traits? What about: increased dexterity; bipedalism; increased vocalization; increased general wariness; longer periods of infanthood; etc.?





Not even logical enough to be wrong.
Humans hunted for meat 2 million years ago
http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/2012/sep/23/human-hunting-evolution-2million-years

Homo-erectus was around for over 2 million years and already has a well developed sense of self and group and were very skilled hunters. The Homo erectus set of attributes and skills enabled them to be very successful in Darwinian survival.
The awareness of self and group suggest some type of social hierarchy or order such as leader and followers and some sort of moral authority or morality by example. Those are the building blocks of religion and as most religions go there is a deity somewhere in there.

We know belief in god is innate in humans and must have always been a part of human evolution to be innate(hardwired). Religion too has always been with humans and found in every culture. It is the pathology of disbelief and skepticism that is under researched.
 
Skeptics are outnumbered by believers so the evolutionary advantage is quite obviously with the believers. But what is less clear is why skeptics work against their own self interest by denying what even evolutionary biologist like Dawkins acknowledges, beliefs are what gives believers Darwinian survival value and why the evolutionary advantage has been conferred on them.
I'm prepared to accept that superstitious belief may once have provided some selective advantage - it's a pretty basic response (pidgeons show it), and there are some reasonable sounding, if speculative, arguments for it.

Even some skeptics I know (me too!) show some superstitious behaviours (touch wood, commentator's curse, etc). But more complex structured superstitious belief systems are less reflexive or intuitive, require more conscious participation, and are more open to reasoned critique.

For evolutionary reasons, behavioural traits in populations generally have a (often 'normally') distributed range, e.g. passive to aggressive, risk-averse to risk-taking, followers to leaders, selfish to altruistic, religious to atheist, zealous to apathetic, credulous to skeptical, etc., so one should not be surprised to find skeptics denying superstitious belief systems.

Regardless of the possible evolutionary advantages superstitious belief systems may once have had, it seems to me that what's lacking is any evidence that they have any selective advantages in contemporary societies. Like a grumbling appendix they seem to have outlived their usefulness and have a potential for causing trouble.
 
Originally Posted by dlorde View Post
What's the argument here - if humans have an innate tendency to believe in gods then gods must be real?


I'm equally puzzled. Even if belief in God does (or did in the past) confer an evolutionary advantage, that wouldn't make the existence of God any more likely. It would, however, explain why so many people are predisposed to believe in a God, even if no such entity exists.

Man has an innate curiosity/tendency to search for the origin of the life and the Universe and we know life and the Universe exists and that is why the curiosity and tendency also exist in humans.

So mans innate belief in god by that same logic god must exist or why have that wired in his brain.

Research that found even Atheist secretly believe in god.
http://www.salon.com/2013/04/27/do_atheists_secretly_believe_in_god_partner/

It is time scientist focused on the pathology of disbelief and skeptics in particular. Now that Atheist have been exposed.
 
Man has an innate curiosity/tendency to search for the origin of the life and the Universe and we know life and the Universe exists and that is why the curiosity and tendency also exist in humans.

So mans innate belief in god by that same logic god must exist or why have that wired in his brain.
Something that people are predisposed to be curious about exists, therefore anything which people are predisposed to believe in exists? Are you serious?

It is time scientist focused on the pathology of disbelief and skeptics in particular. Now that Atheist have been exposed.
People believed that the earth was flat for thousands of years, because that's what their common sense (the way their brains were wired) told them. According to your logic, that mean that everyone alive today who doesn't believe the earth is flat is suffering from some sort of pathological problem which should be investigated by scientists. Have you any idea how ridiculous you sound?
 
Man has an innate curiosity/tendency to search for the origin of the life and the Universe and we know life and the Universe exists and that is why the curiosity and tendency also exist in humans.

So mans innate belief in god by that same logic god must exist or why have that wired in his brain.


You should probably stop using the word logic when trying to make a point if you don't really understand what it means.
 
Man has an innate curiosity/tendency to search for the origin of the life and the Universe and we know life and the Universe exists and that is why the curiosity and tendency also exist in humans.

So mans innate belief in god by that same logic god must exist or why have that wired in his brain.

Research that found even Atheist secretly believe in god.
http://www.salon.com/2013/04/27/do_atheists_secretly_believe_in_god_partner/

It is time scientist focused on the pathology of disbelief and skeptics in particular. Now that Atheist have been exposed.

Excerpt from your quoted article:

“There are at least four potential explanations for these findings,” Lindeman and her colleagues write. The simplest and most provocative is that “atheists’ explicit beliefs may differ from the implicit reactions that exist outside of conscious awareness.”

But other possibilities are equally plausible. Atheists “may have found using the word God stressful because others, possibly their friends and family, do take God seriously,” they note. Alternatively, they may have found the idea of God “absurd or aversive,” leading to the heightened emotional response.

Finally, the researchers note, “although atheists did not currently believe in God, they may have been influenced by their own previous beliefs.” They point to research from 2006 that found three-quarters of American atheists were once believers.

Perhaps the emotional response measured in this study is an echo of that previous belief. If so, it suggests that even for committed non-believers, it’s difficult to totally erase the idea of God from one’s psyche.

So it doesn't actually say what you want it to say. This appears to be a running theme in articles you quote.
 
Excerpt from your quoted article:



So it doesn't actually say what you want it to say. This appears to be a running theme in articles you quote.

From your own pick of quotes it answers the question. Do Atheists secretly believe in God?

Perhaps the emotional response measured in this study is an echo of that previous belief. If so, it suggests that even for committed non-believers, it’s difficult to totally erase the idea of God from one’s psyche.

1. Atheists find it difficult to totally erase the idea of God from their psyche.

2. The other quotes you used provide a cause and effect to explain Atheist's ambivalence that they were believers once and can never totally erase the idea of God from their psyches.

3. If they still have God in their minds because they cannot totally erase God from their psyches then they are guilty of secretly believing.

4. Just like you cannot be a little pregnant you cannot be a little believer because you have a little bit of God still lodged in you.

And that would apply to skeptics as well. If you think you have a little doubt, or a big doubt or any doubt. Then it is only a doubt and not a total rejection.

But if it is a total rejection then you are an atheist and that brings us back to the research that finds Atheists secretly believe in god.
 
I was actually asking the question. If there was any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics like there is about belief in god and religion conferring an evolutionary advantage on the believers.

So no, what I typed instead is not a quote from Dawkins.
"There is nothing in any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics. "

Link or it never happened.
 
From your own pick of quotes it answers the question. Do Atheists secretly believe in God?



1. Atheists find it difficult to totally erase the idea of God from their psyche.

2. The other quotes you used provide a cause and effect to explain Atheist's ambivalence that they were believers once and can never totally erase the idea of God from their psyches.

3. If they still have God in their minds because they cannot totally erase God from their psyches then they are guilty of secretly believing.

4. Just like you cannot be a little pregnant you cannot be a little believer because you have a little bit of God still lodged in you.

And that would apply to skeptics as well. If you think you have a little doubt, or a big doubt or any doubt. Then it is only a doubt and not a total rejection.

But if it is a total rejection then you are an atheist and that brings us back to the research that finds Atheists secretly believe in god.
Nope. Four possibilities were offered, and you have cherry picked only one.

And even the one you picked, you have chosen to misinterpret. I am an atheist, yet likely I would have an emotional response to those god based/biased questions. That emotional response would be "Oh no, not this irritating superstitious nonsense again. Will you please stop annoying me with this crock".
 
But if it is a total rejection then you are an atheist and that brings us back to the research that finds Atheists secretly believe in god.


Why do so many theists think they can tell atheists what they believe?

Justintime, we've heard all that nonsense before. And it's still nonsense.

I don't believe in God, not one little tiny bit, not openly nor secretly.

Why are you threatened by that?
 
Just my 2 cents. Convincing others to believe in a god would definitely be an evolutionary advantage. Time and time again, religious leaders have used their direct line to god to get more than their fair share of virgins and other comely women. Hell, some of those leaders may eventually believe the crap they spout.
 
Why do so many theists think they can tell atheists what they believe?

Justintime, we've heard all that nonsense before. And it's still nonsense.

I don't believe in God, not one little tiny bit, not openly nor secretly.

Why are you threatened by that?

Are you saying the research is nonsense? What you believe is your prerogative. I am as part of my research on skeptics presenting scientific data on the nature of skepticism and atheism and its evolutionary standing.
1. There is a chemical imbalance, low dopamine levels that cause extreme skepticism in skeptics.

2. Richard Dawkins an evolutionary biologist acknowledges natural selection confers an evolutionary advantage on believers over skeptics and anything that is so wide spread (religion) must have a Darwinian survival value or it wouldn't be there.

3. Now another research that highlights what Atheist say about their atheism is not necessarily what they believe inside because their monitored brain activity shows a much stronger emotional reaction when God is mentioned.

4. Here is another study that supports Dr Shermer's position that religion and god are innate in humans and that humans are wired to believe in god.

In conclusion, religious ideas appear as less seman-tically anomalous for the human cognitive system than other types of world-knowledge violations. This
seems to be an constitutional feature of certain ideas, which is even present when they are not embedded in a meaningful context. The present study highlights the importance of determining the evolutionary reasons why certain ideas are more acceptable to the human cognitive system than others and, thus, for their cultural success.

http://pendientedemigracion.ucm.es/info/neurosci/docs/PSNS_A_641228_O_SACRED.PDF
 
Nope. Four possibilities were offered, and you have cherry picked only one.

And even the one you picked, you have chosen to misinterpret. I am an atheist, yet likely I would have an emotional response to those god based/biased questions. That emotional response would be "Oh no, not this irritating superstitious nonsense again. Will you please stop annoying me with this crock".

You appear to have misread the research article.
Here is what the article said about the type of questions that raised strong emotional arousal in Atheists.

1. “The results imply that atheists’ attitudes toward God are ambivalent, in that their explicit beliefs conflict with their affective response,

2. This suggests that taunting God made the atheists more upset than they were letting on (even to themselves).

3. Of course, perhaps it wasn’t the presence of God, but rather the subject matter of the statements (such as the death of their parents) that caused the atheists’ emotional arousal.


4. The results: The atheists showed greater emotional arousal when reading the God-related statements than while reading the otherwise nearly identical sentences that omitted the almighty.

5. To the researchers, this indicates that “even atheists have difficulty daring God to harm themselves and their loved ones.

6. If so, it suggests that even for committed non-believers, it’s difficult to totally erase the idea of God from one’s psyche.

It is clear your own strong emotional arousal is quite different from the controlled research. Maybe it is because the subjects in the experiment were Atheists and you are a skeptic.
 
Just my 2 cents. Convincing others to believe in a god would definitely be an evolutionary advantage. Time and time again, religious leaders have used their direct line to god to get more than their fair share of virgins and other comely women. Hell, some of those leaders may eventually believe the crap they spout.

Isn't that the same thing as saying believers created for themselves an evolutionary reproductive advantage?
 
In most cases applying a label logical fallacy to a position is a sign of laziness, an attempt to abruptly end the discussion and more often than not the label is incorrectly applied.

The use of argumentum abusi fallacia is something of an argument by assertion, in which an attempt is made to refute an argument simply by citing the name of a fallacy, without any further explanation of why.

This is often a result of falling into skeptical jargon, or just discovering that there are terms not just to describe that someone is wrong but why they’re wrong. So, thanks to convenience and in an effort to show off this new-found knowledge – and, hey, some of it’s in Latin! – someone might be very keen to drop the name of a formal or informal fallacy into conversation. However, just because you can reduce why someone is wrong to a single, fancy name, doesn’t mean the names of fallacies can be thrown around at will and automatically be correct. Arguments need to be demonstrated as being fallacious, and usually this is possible without using any Latin at all.
 
You appear to have misread the research article.
Here is what the article said about the type of questions that raised strong emotional arousal in Atheists.

1. “The results imply that atheists’ attitudes toward God are ambivalent, in that their explicit beliefs conflict with their affective response,
Wrong. Read it again.

2. This suggests that taunting God made the atheists more upset than they were letting on (even to themselves).
Wrong. Read it again.

3. Of course, perhaps it wasn’t the presence of God, but rather the subject matter of the statements (such as the death of their parents) that caused the atheists’ emotional arousal.
Ya think?


4. The results: The atheists showed greater emotional arousal when reading the God-related statements than while reading the otherwise nearly identical sentences that omitted the almighty.
Yup. Because atheists in general find it irritating when iron age superstitions are trotted out. I know I do. It is all superstitious, iron age nonsense, and I am tired of hearing it.

5. To the researchers, this indicates that “even atheists have difficulty daring God to harm themselves and their loved ones.
Wrong. Read it again.

6. If so, it suggests that even for committed non-believers, it’s difficult to totally erase the idea of God from one’s psyche.
Wrong. I have no god. End of story.

It is clear your own strong emotional arousal is quite different from the controlled research. Maybe it is because the subjects in the experiment were Atheists and you are a skeptic.
Wrong. I am an atheist. There is no such thing as a god or gods.
 
In most cases applying a label logical fallacy to a position is a sign of laziness, an attempt to abruptly end the discussion and more often than not the label is incorrectly applied.

Most cases? Isn't that a hasty generalization (aka Fallacy of Insufficient Statistics, Fallacy of Insufficient Sample, Leaping to A Conclusion, Hasty Induction*)?

"People also commonly commit Hasty Generalizations because of laziness or sloppiness. It is very easy to simply leap to a conclusion and much harder to gather an adequate sample and draw a justified conclusion."*

So was this a justified conclusion based on an adequate sample, or just an opinion from some blogger?

*http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/hasty-generalization.html

RayG
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom