Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Dawkns was interviewed on the BBC and made his comments. Do you not trust the BBC. Can you point to one instance where I misrepresented the facts?

Here is the BBC interview:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/horizon/2003/godonbrain.shtml
That is not an interview with Dawkins, it is an article about a TV program exploring brain function in the presence of magnetic fields. Dawkins happened to participate as a test subject, and passed a remark that was pure speculation on his part. Furthermore, it is not even a quote, it is a paraphrased sentence in the body of the main article.

You simply cherry picked one sentence from the entire article and misrepresented it here. You were unable to post the BBC link at first because you originally found it on the rexresearch crackpot site, dealing with such topics as the Aether, alchemy, perpetual motion machines, and such bunk. Their disclaimer is a whole lot of fun.

rexresearch.com is powered by a patent-pending proprietary biodegradable carbon-neutral meta-mixture of Orgone, Phlogiston, ortho-Magnetism, Aether, and Zero-Point Energy ... rexresearch.com is Certified Matrix-Free, and contains no Advertisements, Subliminal Suggestions, Lies, Propaganda, Statistics, Typographical Errros or Animal Products, and Deposits no Cookies, Spyware, Worms, Viruses, Prions, Mycoplasms, or Chemtrails... rexresearch.com is Composed of 141.064% Recycled Organic Photons (Active Ingredient: +0% Ozone... Inert Ingredients: -110% US Constitution & Amendments).
The pathetic insufferable Macho Jockwad cowering behind rexresearch.com is inordinately Proud to be in full sniveling, snitching, simpering, groveling, cowering, whimpering, whining, wimpy, obsequious, obedient, knee-jerk, boot-licking, cross-bearing, flag-waving, butt-kissing, back-stabbing, choad-suqing, poopy-pants, whole-hearted, self-serving, morally bankrupt, willfully ignorant, dumbed-down, dim-witted, shameless, enslaved, impotent, craven, mindless, fawning, soulless, foolish, idiotic, stupidic, brainwashed, legal, psychopathic, nationally suicidal, incorporated prostituting Compliance with the Divine Patriot Acts I, II and III, the Imperial Military Commissions Act, the Holy Federal Quisling Act, the Sacred Enabling Act of 2008, &c...

You also neglected to mention that this occurred in 2003, ten years ago, and that subsequent attempts to replicate Persingers experiments failed miserably.
 
What is the evolutionary advantage of religious belief?

Following a talk about his book The God Delusion, for the University of Liverpool in February 2008, biologist Richard Dawkins was asked the following question:

Religion is widespread at least historically, perhaps universal, and human specific. My question to you is do you think religion or religious belief evolved in humans and if so did it confer an evolutionary advantage?

Dawkins' response is here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=nYwWZ9QTNLE
 
What is the evolutionary advantage of religious belief?

Following a talk about his book The God Delusion, for the University of Liverpool in February 2008, biologist Richard Dawkins was asked the following question:

Religion is widespread at least historically, perhaps universal, and human specific. My question to you is do you think religion or religious belief evolved in humans and if so did it confer an evolutionary advantage?

Dawkins' response is here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=nYwWZ9QTNLE

First, this belongs in a separate thread.

Human belief in supernatural agencies appears to be a byproduct of our ability to attribute agency to others. The ability to realize that others have minds like ours, and thus modify our own behavior in order to anticipate and influence others' behavior, was so strongly selected for in our evolution due to its critical importance to our survival strategy, that humans instinctively look for agency in anything that is a factor in our survival. Thus, forces of nature were addressed as though they were agencies that might be anticipated or influenced if we could just figure out what they wanted. This was the primitive origin of the gods.

So yes, religion did evolve, but as an emergent property of another characteristic which conferred the actual evolutionary advantage.
 
First, this belongs in a separate thread.

Human belief in supernatural agencies appears to be a byproduct of our ability to attribute agency to others. The ability to realize that others have minds like ours, and thus modify our own behavior in order to anticipate and influence others' behavior, was so strongly selected for in our evolution due to its critical importance to our survival strategy, that humans instinctively look for agency in anything that is a factor in our survival. Thus, forces of nature were addressed as though they were agencies that might be anticipated or influenced if we could just figure out what they wanted. This was the primitive origin of the gods.

So yes, religion did evolve, but as an emergent property of another characteristic which conferred the actual evolutionary advantage.

Belief in god is innate in humans.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304198004575172233981688208.html

If belief in god is innate than how can it also be a byproduct.
Innate definition: Inborn, natural.

Religion is a byproduct of a belief in god which is innate in humans. Applying your logic: So religion did evolve, but as an emergent property of a belief in god which conferred the actual evolutionary advantage.

Dawkins thinks there could be an evolutionary advantage, not to believing in god, but to having a brain with the capacity to believe in god. That such faith exists is a by-product of enhanced intelligence. But belief in god is innate and not just the capacity to believe in god. So Dawkins is playing some semantics here with a nuanced reply.

There is nothing in any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics.

Dawkins further argues that because religious truths cannot be questioned, their very nature encourages religions to spread like "mind viruses". In such a conception, it is necessary that the individuals who are unable to question their beliefs are more biologically fit than individuals who are capable of questioning their beliefs. Thus, it could be concluded that sacred scriptures or oral traditions created a behavioral pattern that elevated biological fitness for believing individuals. Individuals who were capable of challenging such beliefs, even if the beliefs were enormously improbable, became rarer and rarer in the population. (wiki)
 
First, this belongs in a separate thread.

Human belief in supernatural agencies appears to be a byproduct of our ability to attribute agency to others. The ability to realize that others have minds like ours, and thus modify our own behavior in order to anticipate and influence others' behavior, was so strongly selected for in our evolution due to its critical importance to our survival strategy, that humans instinctively look for agency in anything that is a factor in our survival. Thus, forces of nature were addressed as though they were agencies that might be anticipated or influenced if we could just figure out what they wanted. This was the primitive origin of the gods.

So yes, religion did evolve, but as an emergent property of another characteristic which conferred the actual evolutionary advantage.

So it belongs in a similar category to optical illusions - a characteristic of the way our eyesight evolved to let us see what's there, which occasionally causes us to see things that aren't really there.
 
I agree completely. That's why people go around eating whatever mushrooms they happen to find.

All I am doing is citing quotes from Dawkins an evolutionary biologist an atheist who thinks he is practicing science when he is actually building a case for god and religion.

The same approach I took with a skeptic scientist Carl Sagan, who thought he was practicing scientific skepticism when all he was doing was getting high on pot, raising his dopamine levels and compulsively searching for extraterrestrial intelligent aliens in total skeptical disbelief.
 
What's the argument here - if humans have an innate tendency to believe in gods then gods must be real?

Really?

Monsters under the bed too?
 
All I am doing is citing quotes from Dawkins an evolutionary biologist an atheist who thinks he is practicing science when he is actually building a case for god and religion.


Really? So were you quoting Dawkins when you wrote this:


There is nothing in any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics.


Is this a Dawkins quote or are these your words?
 
Really? So were you quoting Dawkins when you wrote this:


​


Is this a Dawkins quote or are these your words?

I was actually asking the question. If there was any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics like there is about belief in god and religion conferring an evolutionary advantage on the believers.

So no, what I typed instead is not a quote from Dawkins.
"There is nothing in any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics. "
 
I was actually asking the question. If there was any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics like there is about belief in god and religion conferring an evolutionary advantage on the believers.


So, when you said you were quoting from Dawkins, you weren't quoting from Dawkins, and when you made a statement, you were actually asking a question. Got it.

Well, in answer to your question, there's a fairly vast survey of literature that demonstrates that wariness, testing and skepticism confer a distinct evolutionary advantage. I already gave you one example - our species' extreme aversion to eating foods we know nothing about. (source)

Hey, here's an article where actual scientists find that general wariness confers an evolutionary advantage.

That was two minutes of my time.
 
Belief in god is innate in humans.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702304198004575172233981688208.html

If belief in god is innate than how can it also be a byproduct.
Innate definition: Inborn, natural.

Actually, research indicates that beleif in,and attribution of, agency where there is no agent is a characteristic of human thinking. You may have missed that whole thread.

The fact that there are so very, very many different 'gods' in which credulous humans believe indicates that the statement, "belief in 'god' is innate" is, at best inadequate; charitably, simply wrong; likely, dishonest.

Also, you really ought to learn that, if you wish to be taken seriously, you ought to give cites for your argumenti ad lexica.

Religion is a byproduct of a belief in god which is innate in humans.

Suppose, just for a refreshing change of pace, you provide evidence for this claim? You know, a citation? Something other than You Tube?

Applying your logic: So religion did evolve, but as an emergent property of a belief in god which conferred the actual evolutionary advantage.

Dawkins thinks there could be an evolutionary advantage, not to believing in god, but to having a brain with the capacity to believe in god. That such faith exists is a by-product of enhanced intelligence. But belief in god is innate and not just the capacity to believe in god.

Suppose, just for a refreshing change of pace, you provide evidence for this claim? You know, a citation? Something other than You Tube?

So Dawkins is playing some semantics here with a nuanced reply.

There is nothing in any literature that points to skepticism conferring an evolutionary advantage on a group of skeptics.

Dawkins further argues that because religious truths cannot be questioned, their very nature encourages religions to spread like "mind viruses". In such a conception, it is necessary that the individuals who are unable to question their beliefs are more biologically fit than individuals who are capable of questioning their beliefs.

Suppose, just for a refreshing change of pace, you provide evidence for this claim? You know, a citation? Something other than You Tube?

Thus, it could be concluded that sacred scriptures or oral traditions created a behavioral pattern that elevated biological fitness for believing individuals. Individuals who were capable of challenging such beliefs, even if the beliefs were enormously improbable, became rarer and rarer in the population. (wiki)
 
What's the argument here - if humans have an innate tendency to believe in gods then gods must be real?
I'm equally puzzled. Even if belief in God does (or did in the past) confer an evolutionary advantage, that wouldn't make the existence of God any more likely. It would, however, explain why so many people are predisposed to believe in a God, even if no such entity exists.
 
So, when you said you were quoting from Dawkins, you weren't quoting from Dawkins, and when you made a statement, you were actually asking a question. Got it.

Well, in answer to your question, there's a fairly vast survey of literature that demonstrates that wariness, testing and skepticism confer a distinct evolutionary advantage. I already gave you one example - our species' extreme aversion to eating foods we know nothing about. (source)

Hey, here's an article where actual scientists find that general wariness confers an evolutionary advantage.

That was two minutes of my time.

I think the study answers a broader question. To deal with general wariness our common ancestors took to the trees and thus avoided multiple predator types. But that would limit accessibility to only trees and hence an evolutionary disadvantage.

The act of faith and belief in god aided by the notion of a more purposeful life than living like monkeys/arboreal tree dwelling cause humans to descent from trees and stand up (bipedalism) to their predators thus giving humans an evolutionary advantage. We because hunters and gatherers and dedicated our time to devotion and gratitude for that evolutionary advantage. Religion is the byproduct of this belief in god which became innate in humans as we continued to evolve to conquer our fears, general wariness and predators.

So why is skepticism and skeptics still among us? We ask that of monkeys too. Why are monkeys still with us if we evolved from primates?
I have my theories laid out in my Unified Theory of Evolution.
 
IThe act of faith and belief in god aided by the notion of a more purposeful life than living like monkeys/arboreal tree dwelling cause humans to descent from trees and stand up (bipedalism) to their predators thus giving humans an evolutionary advantage.


I don't think you read the study a hundred percent correctly. It didn't even deal with humans.

Nor is there any evidence that "coming down from the trees" required an act of faith. It was most likely an act of hunger - a need to find food. Nor did our ancestors "stand up to their predators." They stood up to see over the tall grass so that they could more effectively run away from predators.

Also, I just don't see Australopithecus worrying about having a "more purposeful life." They were subsistence creatures.

The rise of religious thinking cannot be traced with certainty farther back than about 50,000 years. That was 1 to 2 million years after our ancestors "came down from the trees." The oldest religious type of behavior, disputed among experts, might be 300,000 years ago. That was still over a million years after we left the "trees."

It would appear that you might require further education on evolution before attempting to draw any meaningful conclusions.
 
I don't think you read the study a hundred percent correctly. It didn't even deal with humans.

Nor is there any evidence that "coming down from the trees" required an act of faith. It was most likely an act of hunger - a need to find food. Nor did our ancestors "stand up to their predators." They stood up to see over the tall grass so that they could more effectively run away from predators.

Also, I just don't see Australopithecus worrying about having a "more purposeful life." They were subsistence creatures.

The rise of religious thinking cannot be traced with certainty farther back than about 50,000 years. That was 1 to 2 million years after our ancestors "came down from the trees." The oldest religious type of behavior, disputed among experts, might be 300,000 years ago. That was still over a million years after we left the "trees."

It would appear that you might require further education on evolution before attempting to draw any meaningful conclusions.

You provided a link on predation and predators. Humans were hunting with tools over 2 million years ago. In order for them to take on their predators they had to have some sense of self, intelligence and assurance that they could overcome their predators.

Primitive man developed early this sens of self, confidence because of a brain that had the capacity to believe in god which gave them an edge over their primates and other animals.

It was more than just survival skills. There are animals better suited for survival than humans in the wild. But they lack this innate trait which gave humans an edge. This innate trait manifested into religious beliefs (a byproduct).

Skeptics are outnumbered by believers so the evolutionary advantage is quite obviously with the believers. But what is less clear is why skeptics work against their own self interest by denying what even evolutionary biologist like Dawkins acknowledges, beliefs are what gives believers Darwinian survival value and why the evolutionary advantage has been conferred on them.
 


Hominini, but whatever.


were hunting with tools over 2 million years ago.


No, they weren't hunting with tools. There's a debate as to whether they were hunting at all, but tools used specifically for hunting were still some way off.


In order for them to take on their predators


There is no evidence that early hominini "took on" their predators. They certainly did not feed on them. Their meat diet was composed mostly of deer and smaller animals.


they had to have some sense of self, intelligence and assurance that they could overcome their predators.


Well, your last statement was untrue, so this is meaningless. In any case, do you have any evidence whatsoever that animals that hunt have a sense of self or even have great intelligence? I am now including sharks, spiders, tuna and bears.


Primitive man developed early this sens of self, confidence because of a brain that had the capacity to believe in god which gave them an edge over their primates and other animals.


There is no evidence that religious or mystical belief predates self-awareness. In fact, the absolute earliest any expert has ever put mysitical belief is 300,000 years ago. The fact that you acknowledge self-awareness in hominini 2 million years ago means that you've refuted your own point.


It was more than just survival skills. There are animals better suited for survival than humans in the wild. But they lack this innate trait which gave humans an edge. This innate trait manifested into religious beliefs (a byproduct).


Why does just one innate trait put humans over the top? Why not a whole suite of innate traits? What about: increased dexterity; bipedalism; increased vocalization; increased general wariness; longer periods of infanthood; etc.?


Skeptics are outnumbered by believers so the evolutionary advantage is quite obviously with the believers.


Not even logical enough to be wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom