Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Do you mean for example how Michael Shermer so eloquently eulogized Carl Sagan?
http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/a-wonderful-life/

Specifically:

So JiT is either disingenuous or horribly misinformed or perhaps unable to comprehend simple English. In sum, his is incorrect. He is wrong, not right, stacking straw in his imaginary barn. Silly.

Do you mean for example how Michael Shermer so eloquently eulogized Carl Sagan?
http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/a-wonderful-life/

Specifically:

So JiT is either disingenuous or horribly misinformed or perhaps unable to comprehend simple English. In sum, his is incorrect. He is wrong, not right, stacking straw in his imaginary barn. Silly.

I know skeptics hold Dr Shermer in high esteem. He is a born again Christian fundamentalist who evangelized for 7 years Christianity. Michael Shermer developed an early devotion and veneration of godly figureheads. His adulation of Carl Sagan is hardly surprising.

Dr Shermer was also a climate change skeptic and his embrace of scientific skepticism crystallized during his time as a cyclist, explaining, "I became a skeptic on Saturday, August 6, 1983, on the long climbing road to Loveland Pass, Colorado" after months of training."

So his road to skepticism was not science or critical thinking, it was cycling.

Why did Dr Shermer a skeptic, turn to a pot smoking scientist Carl Sagan who made science fiction and the search for extraterrestrial aliens a lifelong career, while under the influence of pot and at the same time promoted scientific skepticism? Dr Shermer possibly confused his past knowledge of spiritual euphoria with Carl Sagan's pot induced hallucination and credited him with a profound aura of transcendental and scientific overlapping of achievements.

But Dr Shermer is not a scientist. We have to turn to what scientists had to say about Carl Sagan’s achievements. Harold Urey a Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative . Sagan was not granted a tenure at Harvard and was denied membership at the National Academy of Sciences .

There are 2 skeptic writers William Poundstone and Keay Davidson. Both wrote biographies of Carl Sagan. Poundstone wrote about Sagan’s private life, his pot addiction and pot inspired works as well as how the skeptic community were split over mind altering drugs and skepticism. Davidson wrote mainly about Sagan’s obsession with extraterrestrial alien life, his naivety of their possible existence and why scientists should accept his failures to account for the improbability of alien life after spending 50 years searching for aliens without any success.

Carl Sagan's biographers reflects on his life.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pALOs8SIOMg
 
...
The validity of my conclusions should be judged by the credibility of my sourced material. The citations I provided are from reputable established sources. The materials were presented in a civil and friendly manner to encourage debate and active participation and that has been borne out by the number of skeptics who participated and the size the thread has grown.

I have raised legitimate issues about skeptics and little beyond my stated objectives was there a hidden motive or surreptitious intentions to offend anyone.

No, the validity of your conclusions should be judged by the content of your sourced material.
They are not necessarily the same, they most certainly do not appear to be in your case.

So, What is the reason for your rather strong dislike of skepticism again?
...
What is the reason for your rather strong dislike of skeptics or rather skepticism again?
You may have pointed it out already, in which case, could you please point me to it or perhaps state it again?
Thank you.
 
Once again with th elies about Dr Carl Sagan, exterestial life was jsut one of his avenues of research not his entire life work and certianly not the obsession you pretend it to be Jit.
 
From what I can gather, those of us who don't blindly, and credulously accept any ole' idea, and without any evidence, well that means our dopamine levels are somehow low.


No evidence for any such corrolation, of course...sounds more like an attempted, and rather lame, insult in my opinion.

The study that Dr Shermer referred to. Low dopamine - extreme skepticism, missing a lot of patterns, both real and illusion was used to explain "Paranormal beliefs linked to brain chemistry".

I have already explained.

It is quite normal to have the occasional doubt or to be uncertain at times.

But when the doubt persist and becomes instinctive and habitual it begins to define who you are ie. a skeptic.

Skeptic definition: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

I have provided links to research that suggest skepticism is not a product of science education or higher education. It is caused by low dopamine levels.

Low dopamine - extreme skepticism, missing a lot of patterns, both real and illusion (Dr. Shermer)

Skepticism definition: A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety. See Synonyms at uncertainty.

Skepticism is projected in a persons attitude, it reflects the persons psychological state of mind and much of it is determined by the individuals brain chemistry. Refer to all the researched links I posted to support the science behind the study.
 
The study that Dr Shermer referred to. Low dopamine - extreme skepticism, missing a lot of patterns, both real and illusion was used to explain "Paranormal beliefs linked to brain chemistry".

I have already explained.

It is quite normal to have the occasional doubt or to be uncertain at times.

But when the doubt persist and becomes instinctive and habitual it begins to define who you are ie. a skeptic.

Skeptic definition: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

I have provided links to research that suggest skepticism is not a product of science education or higher education. It is caused by low dopamine levels.

Low dopamine - extreme skepticism, missing a lot of patterns, both real and illusion (Dr. Shermer)

Skepticism definition: A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety. See Synonyms at uncertainty.

Skepticism is projected in a persons attitude, it reflects the persons psychological state of mind and much of it is determined by the individuals brain chemistry. Refer to all the researched links I posted to support the science behind the study.

How many times must the definition of scientific skepticism be repeated before it sinks in that your definition of the word skeptic is simply inappropriate in the context of this discussion. To quote the Wikipedia page for the umpteenth time:

Scientific skeptics attempt to evaluate claims based on verifiability and falsifiability and discourage accepting claims on faith or anecdotal evidence.

No one here is going to let you impose your false definition of what is meant by skeptical inquiry so why do you continue with a series of statements you must know are invalid?
 
How many times must the definition of scientific skepticism be repeated before it sinks in that your definition of the word skeptic is simply inappropriate in the context of this discussion. To quote the Wikipedia page for the umpteenth time:



No one here is going to let you impose your false definition of what is meant by skeptical inquiry so why do you continue with a series of statements you must know are invalid?

I have never tried to define 'scientific skepticism'. I have offered the definition for skepticism and skeptics taken from the free online dictionary. But I have never offered a definition for scientific skepticism.

There is no definition of scientific skepticism in the Oxford dictionary.

Wiki: uses the term to apply to scientists who are skeptics and therefore scientific skeptics. There is no general definition of scientific skepticism.

But skepticism and skeptics are found in all the dictionaries.
 
Wiki: uses the term to apply to scientists who are skeptics and therefore scientific skeptics. There is no general definition of scientific skepticism.

Yeah Wiki:

"Considering the rigor of the scientific method, science itself may simply be thought of as an organized form of skepticism. This does not mean that the scientific skeptic is necessarily a scientist who conducts live experiments (though this may be the case), but that the skeptic generally accepts claims that are in his/her view likely to be true based on testable hypotheses and critical thinking."

:-)
 
i have never tried to define 'scientific skepticism'. I have offered the definition for skepticism and skeptics taken from the free online dictionary. But i have never offered a definition for scientific skepticism.

There is no definition of scientific skepticism in the oxford dictionary.

Wiki: Uses the term to apply to scientists who are skeptics and therefore scientific skeptics. There is no general definition of scientific skepticism.

But skepticism and skeptics are found in all the dictionaries.

and then?
 
I have never tried to define 'scientific skepticism'. I have offered the definition for skepticism and skeptics taken from the free online dictionary. But I have never offered a definition for scientific skepticism.

There is no definition of scientific skepticism in the Oxford dictionary.

Wiki: uses the term to apply to scientists who are skeptics and therefore scientific skeptics. There is no general definition of scientific skepticism.

But skepticism and skeptics are found in all the dictionaries.


So what is your favorite flavor of woo, that you want skeptics to stay away from?
 
I have never tried to define 'scientific skepticism'. I have offered the definition for skepticism and skeptics taken from the free online dictionary. But I have never offered a definition for scientific skepticism.

There is no definition of scientific skepticism in the Oxford dictionary.

Wiki: uses the term to apply to scientists who are skeptics and therefore scientific skeptics. There is no general definition of scientific skepticism.

But skepticism and skeptics are found in all the dictionaries.

Merriam-Webster disagrees with you.
Wiki disagrees with you.
New World Encyclopedia disagrees with you.

I could go on, but enumerating the millions of search results would get tedious, especially when you could simply google them for yourself.
 
Richard Dawkins was asked. Why does evolution favor the believers over the skeptics by giving them a reproductive advantage because they disproportionately outnumber the skeptics? Is skepticism then unnatural and will through natural selection automatically reduce the skeptical population? Are skeptics performing unnatural acts that are detrimental to their propagation?

This is a core understanding of natural selection that traits that favor the survival of the species also provide the species a reproductive advantage.
 
Richard Dawkins was asked. Why does evolution favor the believers over the skeptics by giving them a reproductive advantage because they disproportionately outnumber the skeptics? Is skepticism then unnatural and will through natural selection automatically reduce the skeptical population? Are skeptics performing unnatural acts that are detrimental to their propagation?

Link or it never happened.
 
Link or it never happened.

Religious evolution

If brain function offers insight into how we experience religion, does it say anything about why we do? There is evidence that people with religious faith have longer, healthier lives. This hints at a survival benefit for religious people. Could we have evolved religious belief?

Prof Dawkins (who subscribes to evolution to explain human development) thinks there could be an evolutionary advantage, not to believing in god, but to having a brain with the capacity to believe in god. That such faith exists is a by-product of enhanced intelligence.

http://www.rexresearch.com/persinger/persinger.htm
 
Religious evolution

If brain function offers insight into how we experience religion, does it say anything about why we do? There is evidence that people with religious faith have longer, healthier lives. This hints at a survival benefit for religious people. Could we have evolved religious belief?

Prof Dawkins (who subscribes to evolution to explain human development) thinks there could be an evolutionary advantage, not to believing in god, but to having a brain with the capacity to believe in god. That such faith exists is a by-product of enhanced intelligence.

http://www.rexresearch.com/persinger/persinger.htm

I'm not playing this silly game with you.

Provide a link to something Dawkins wrote that supports your claims about what he thinks, or stand accused of mendacity.
 
Why does evolution favor the believers over the skeptics by giving them a reproductive advantage because they disproportionately outnumber the skeptics?

Claptrap!

It could be any number of reasons. Perhaps believers are told to go forth an multiply, so they do. Perhaps, as in some cases, contraception is frowned upon. Perhaps some believers haven't connected the dots between sex and pregnancy; as my dad used to say about certain large families.... "they haven't worked out what's causing it yet" :D
 
I'm not playing this silly game with you.

Provide a link to something Dawkins wrote that supports your claims about what he thinks, or stand accused of mendacity.

Dawkins was interviewed on BBC where he made those comments. This was after he agreed to be tested by Dr Persinger and have his temporal lobes stimulated.
 
Dawkins was interviewed on BBC where he made those comments. This was after he agreed to be tested by Dr Persinger and have his temporal lobes stimulated.

Link supporting your claims with Dawkins quotes or it never happened. I've seen you misrepresent facts too often in the past
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom