justintime
Banned
- Joined
- Dec 3, 2012
- Messages
- 1,260
Do you mean for example how Michael Shermer so eloquently eulogized Carl Sagan?
http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/a-wonderful-life/
Specifically:
So JiT is either disingenuous or horribly misinformed or perhaps unable to comprehend simple English. In sum, his is incorrect. He is wrong, not right, stacking straw in his imaginary barn. Silly.
Do you mean for example how Michael Shermer so eloquently eulogized Carl Sagan?
http://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/a-wonderful-life/
Specifically:
So JiT is either disingenuous or horribly misinformed or perhaps unable to comprehend simple English. In sum, his is incorrect. He is wrong, not right, stacking straw in his imaginary barn. Silly.
I know skeptics hold Dr Shermer in high esteem. He is a born again Christian fundamentalist who evangelized for 7 years Christianity. Michael Shermer developed an early devotion and veneration of godly figureheads. His adulation of Carl Sagan is hardly surprising.
Dr Shermer was also a climate change skeptic and his embrace of scientific skepticism crystallized during his time as a cyclist, explaining, "I became a skeptic on Saturday, August 6, 1983, on the long climbing road to Loveland Pass, Colorado" after months of training."
So his road to skepticism was not science or critical thinking, it was cycling.
Why did Dr Shermer a skeptic, turn to a pot smoking scientist Carl Sagan who made science fiction and the search for extraterrestrial aliens a lifelong career, while under the influence of pot and at the same time promoted scientific skepticism? Dr Shermer possibly confused his past knowledge of spiritual euphoria with Carl Sagan's pot induced hallucination and credited him with a profound aura of transcendental and scientific overlapping of achievements.
But Dr Shermer is not a scientist. We have to turn to what scientists had to say about Carl Sagan’s achievements. Harold Urey a Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative . Sagan was not granted a tenure at Harvard and was denied membership at the National Academy of Sciences .
There are 2 skeptic writers William Poundstone and Keay Davidson. Both wrote biographies of Carl Sagan. Poundstone wrote about Sagan’s private life, his pot addiction and pot inspired works as well as how the skeptic community were split over mind altering drugs and skepticism. Davidson wrote mainly about Sagan’s obsession with extraterrestrial alien life, his naivety of their possible existence and why scientists should accept his failures to account for the improbability of alien life after spending 50 years searching for aliens without any success.
Carl Sagan's biographers reflects on his life.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pALOs8SIOMg