Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

How funny. You didn't link to the actual study, but to a huge list. I can only assume this was an attempt to add obscurity, since you could easily link to the actual study in your reply.

Actually, the link to the description of that study appears on the linked page.
The closing sentence of justintime's last post contains the text of a list item in the linked page.
Part of that list item (the text: "Paranormal beliefs: An analysis of college students") in the linked page is the link to the description of that study.
 
My research deals with the question. What is a skeptic? and tries to answer what are the causes for skepticism, doubts, uncertainty and insecurity in skeptics.

From a published study "Science Education is No Guarantee of Skepticism."
http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/12-03-07/#feature
We know science education does not increase skepticism as skeptics have assumed.

Another survey suggest Higher Education leads to stronger belief in ghosts.
http://www.livescience.com/564-higher-education-fuels-stronger-belief-ghosts.html

Now we have a study that links body chemistry (levels of dopamine) as causal factors in peoples beliefs in the paranormal and skepticism.

Peter Brugger's study was mentioned in LiveScience "Paranormal beliefs linked to brain chemistry"
http://www.newscientist.com/article/...chemistry.html

Dr Micheal Shermer quoted his study at A TED meeting.
http://godwillbegod.com/blog/beyond-belief/sunday-ted-skepticism-associated-learning

"Dopamine (a neurotransmitter in the brain related to controlling reward and pleasure functions) appears to be associated with patternicity. Shermer suggests a scale can be used with dopamine levels that relates to individual behaviour (about 9:30):

Low Dopamine – extreme skepticism, missing a lot of patterns, both real and illusion

Medium Dopamine – flourishing creativity, ability to recognize and evaluate patterns

High Dopamine – potential madness, see patterns everywhere and unable to filter the illusion from the real."

Therefore. lower levels of dopamine leads to extreme skepticism. We now have a genetic/brain chemistry cause for skepticism.

Skepticism is defined as "A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety. See Synonyms at uncertainty."

It is a psychological state of mind brought about by low levels of dopamine.
 
I have applied the proper word "research" to my work.

Research definition: The systematic investigation into and study of materials and sources in order to establish facts and reach new conclusions.

I have studied materials and sources and systematically presented my investigations, supported my conclusions with established facts and reached new conclusions.
1. The road to scientific skepticism is not science it is cycling. (post #2540)

""Michael Shermer is a prominent atheist and skeptic who has done as much as anyone to make the modern skeptic movement what it is today. "

So skeptics owe it to Dr Shermer and not Carl Sagan as the architect of the modern skeptic movement for what it is today.

Did he arrive at this junction through critical thinking as most skeptics believe they can?

"Shermer's embrace of scientific skepticism crystallized during his time as a cyclist, explaining, "I became a skeptic on Saturday, August 6, 1983, on the long climbing road to Loveland Pass, Colorado" after months of training under the guidance of a "nutritionist" with an unaccredited Ph.D. After years of practicing acupuncture, chiropractic, massage therapy, negative ions, rolfing, pyramid power, fundamentalist Christianity, and "a host of weird things" (with the exception of drugs) to improve his life and training, Shermer stopped rationalizing the failure of these practices. Shermer would later produce several documentaries on cycling."
The road to scientific skepticism is not science it is cycling.

2. Carl Sagan was a habitual cannabis user, a pot addict. Pot induces psychoses, hallucination and known to cause a temporary increase in dopamine levels.
How Does Marijuana Affect Dopamine?
http://www.truthonpot.com/2012/12/04/how-does-marijuana-affect-dopamine/

It is important to note a decrease in dopamine has been observed during cannabis withdrawal as well.

This explains why Carl Sagan was scientifically skeptical at times about alien encounters and also simultaneously a believer in extraterrestrial alien existence. It was the fluctuation of dopamine levels in his system that determined where he stood and the amount of pot he smoked at any given instance. I discovered a correlation between the two and provided research material to back my observations.
 
Here is another article drawing the distinction between left and right brain hemisphere biases.

Skeptics and Left Brain Pitfalls
http://weilerpsiblog.wordpress.com/2013/02/10/skeptics-and-left-brain-pitfalls/

It is further back by " Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience "
Dopamine, Paranormal Belief, and the Detection of Meaningful Stimuli

"Dopamine (DA) is suggested to improve perceptual and cognitive decisions by increasing the signal-to-noise ratio. Somewhat paradoxically, a hyperdopaminergia (arguably more accentuated in the right hemisphere) has also been implied in the genesis of unusual experiences such as hallucinations and paranormal thought. To test these opposing assumptions, we used two lateralized decision tasks, one with lexical (tapping left-hemisphere functions), the other with facial stimuli (tapping right-hemisphere functions). "
http://www.mitpressjournals.org/doi/full/10.1162/jocn.2009.21313

If skeptics are not produced in early childhood as an Australian study suggests.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ezEukr0zuo

Then adult skeptics are products of low dopamine or psychological anomalies such as partial disassociation between the left brain and right brain.

It is not as simple as Michel de Montaigne simple request to skeptics to ask. What do I know? But that skeptics should also be observing which half of their brain responds and monitoring their dopamine level accordingly.
 
In my post #212 I provided information on. The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic and why Skeptic brains 'emit fear signals that can disrupt attempts at rational thought'

http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749

It was a very technical paper and rather advanced for the average reader. I was quite elated when I came across a user friendly version explaining how stimulating the amygdala produced positive results in skeptics.

A cure for pseudoskeptics was produced by the same speaker who also produced the video on How skeptics are produced in childhood that I linked to several posts ago.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lKuVoSNljF8
 
Five of the last eleven posts have been your own, more if we count deleted posts. A total of three people have written you back, two if you don't count the moderator. To whom are you addressing your posts?
 
Again I must ask Justintime why is it you appear to believe skepticism, at its most basic the weighing up of evidence for a claim and drawing a conclusion based on it, is a bad thing or indeed as you appear to imply in this thread a mental dysfunction?
 
Again I must ask Justintime why is it you appear to believe skepticism, at its most basic the weighing up of evidence for a claim and drawing a conclusion based on it, is a bad thing or indeed as you appear to imply in this thread a mental dysfunction?

It is quite normal to have the occasional doubt or to be uncertain at times.

But when the doubt persist and becomes instinctive and habitual it begins to define who you are ie. a skeptic.

Skeptic definition: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

I have provided links to research that suggest skepticism is not a product of science education or higher education. It is caused by low dopamine levels.

Low dopamine - extreme skepticism (Dr. Shermer)

Skepticism definition: A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety. See Synonyms at uncertainty.

Skepticism is projected in a persons attitude, it reflects the persons psychological state of mind and much of it is determined by the individuals brain chemistry. Refer to all the researched links I posted to support the science behind the study.
 
So which is it? Paranormal beliefs have risen over the last 30 years or peaked 30 years ago?

It peaked some 30 years ago and skeptic organizations like CSICOP tried to deal with it, but failed miserably. Failure to mount a credible challenge has resulted in a rise in paranormal beliefs setting new records, causing people to doubt the skeptic movements ability to function as a check against the paranormal and fringe science.

A drop by 25% in attendance at the annual TAM 2012 and a threat by the women's group to boycott future TAM meetings are signs of divisions withing the Skeptic Movement.
Paul Kurtz wrote recently that the“steady decline in the reading of magazines … has eroded the financial base of the Skeptical Inquirer; and we do not see any easy solution to the deficit gap that increasingly imperils our survival. With fewer skeptics reading today and the institutions for higher education and sciences promoting less skepticism is compounding the problem for skeptic organizations.

Skeptics raging on the internet with displaced priorities have done little to endear them to the public. Skeptics are largely ignored by the public and even shunned by fellow skeptics and atheists. New lows are predicted for the skeptic movement even as new peaks are anticipated for paranormal beliefs.

Some blame the demise on the lack of charismatic skeptic leaders. The loss of Carl Sagan is viewed with extreme nostalgia by the skeptic community. They miss the leadership of this pot smoking scientist alien hunter who eloquently spoke against pseudoscience even as he steered skeptics towards beliefs in extraterrestrial alien existence and amateur radio so they could join in the effort to listen for extraterrestrial advanced civilizations.

Skeptics have been listening for 50 years for that faithful moment and 30 years to CSICOP. Is there any wonder why they are now raging on the internet against any held beliefs?
 
It is quite normal to have the occasional doubt or to be uncertain at times.

But when the doubt persist and becomes instinctive and habitual it begins to define who you are ie. a skeptic.

Skeptic definition: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

I have provided links to research that suggest skepticism is not a product of science education or higher education. It is caused by low dopamine levels.

Low dopamine - extreme skepticism (Dr. Shermer)

Skepticism definition: A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety. See Synonyms at uncertainty.

Skepticism is projected in a persons attitude, it reflects the persons psychological state of mind and much of it is determined by the individuals brain chemistry. Refer to all the researched links I posted to support the science behind the study.

If you say so Justintime. However, it doesn't appear all too convincing since your conclusions are not substantiated by the links you provided.

Simply attaching your favorite conclusion to a story doesn't make your conclusion valid. If you'd want to make a good case for your idea you'd really have to put in more (and better) effort.

What is the reason for your rather strong dislike of skeptics or rather skepticism again?
You may have pointed it out already, in which case, could you please point me to it or perhaps state it again?
Thank you.
 
It is quite normal to have the occasional doubt or to be uncertain at times.

But when the doubt persist and becomes instinctive and habitual it begins to define who you are ie. a skeptic.

Skeptic definition: One who instinctively or habitually doubts, questions, or disagrees with assertions or generally accepted conclusions.

I have provided links to research that suggest skepticism is not a product of science education or higher education. It is caused by low dopamine levels.

Low dopamine - extreme skepticism (Dr. Shermer)

Skepticism definition: A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety. See Synonyms at uncertainty.

Skepticism is projected in a persons attitude, it reflects the persons psychological state of mind and much of it is determined by the individuals brain chemistry. Refer to all the researched links I posted to support the science behind the study.

So you answer to my question is to present a completely different definition of skepticism than the one I outlined, which is that of scientific or rational skepticism, and is the one that is commonly used on this board? Is it simply that you have issues with reading comprehension or is it simply that you being deliberately disingenuous?

To remind you yet again by quoting the wiki page:

Scientific skeptics attempt to evaluate claims based on verifiability and falsifiability and discourage accepting claims on faith or anecdotal evidence.

And to be clear you don't need a science degree to adopt such an approach when faced with extraordinary claims. You will find no one here who if you tell them; 'I have a shed in my garden' won't simply take that at face value. On the other hand if you state 'there's a unicorn in my shed' then people will expect some concrete evidence.

So please no more evasion; answer the question I asked and not the one you made up.
 
If you say so Justintime. However, it doesn't appear all too convincing since your conclusions are not substantiated by the links you provided.

Simply attaching your favorite conclusion to a story doesn't make your conclusion valid. If you'd want to make a good case for your idea you'd really have to put in more (and better) effort.

What is the reason for your rather strong dislike of skeptics or rather skepticism again?
You may have pointed it out already, in which case, could you please point me to it or perhaps state it again?
Thank you.

Even after producing volumes of climate change research, skeptics are still skeptical about climate change. Is there any wonder why skeptics are largely ignored by the public and even shunned by fellow skeptics and atheist?

The many research studies I have referenced are published in Skeptic magazines by skeptics designed to educate skeptics by showing them scientists have found correlation between their skepticism and causal factors such as low dopamine levels, education, science literacy, early childhood experiences, insecurity and differences in brain chemistry. It is the most comprehensive material on. What is a Skeptic? Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Skepticism is not a qualification that qualifies a skeptic to reject claims, even scientific claims. It is their instinctive or habitually doubts, questions, or disagreement with assertions or generally accepted conclusions that precludes them from accepting facts they are uncomfortable with or are unable to find meaningful patterns in both meaningful and meaningless noise, a cognitive function call patternicity.

Dr Shermer said "Low Dopamine – extreme skepticism, missing a lot of patterns, both real and illusion." Peter Brugger pioneered the study. "Dopamine, Paranormal Belief, and the Detection of Meaningful Stimuli."

JREF is a skeptic forum and one would assume skeptics here would be interested in what scientists and research reveals about their condition and why they are different. Not bad or good, just different.

The validity of my conclusions should be judged by the credibility of my sourced material. The citations I provided are from reputable established sources. The materials were presented in a civil and friendly manner to encourage debate and active participation and that has been borne out by the number of skeptics who participated and the size the thread has grown.

I have raised legitimate issues about skeptics and little beyond my stated objectives was there a hidden motive or surreptitious intentions to offend anyone.

Do no post in other threads in order to by-pass this threads Moderated status.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Locknar
 
Last edited by a moderator:
...could you please point me to it or perhaps state it again?
Thank you.

From what I can gather, those of us who don't blindly, and credulously accept any ole' idea, and without any evidence, well that means our dopamine levels are somehow low.


No evidence for any such corrolation, of course...sounds more like an attempted, and rather lame, insult in my opinion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom