Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

you find a lot of highly educated people are members of religions too and beleive in omniscient super being.

That study shows nothing new.
 
you find a lot of highly educated people are members of religions too and beleive in omniscient super being.

That study shows nothing new.


I would say that more than anything else it's an indictment of the American educational system--as well as evidence that more emphasis needs to be placed on teaching science and the scientific method, across all disciplines. It certainly has nothing to do with a "battle" between skeptics and believers or those with higher education.
 
Nice. The Science-Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA) has announced that Carl Sagan has posthumously received the Solstice Award, given to the writers, living or dead, who have "consistently had a positive, transformative influence on the genre of science fiction and fantasy."

The story is here: http://www.sfwa.org/2013/03/2013-solstice-awards/

Throughout my research I have alluded to Carl Sagan’s pot induced flights into the twilight zone. When he could not produce evidence of alien existence he invented them as science fiction in his book Contact. From a star gazer he became an alien hunter. His obsession with aliens turned him into a space traveller, criss-crossing the billions and billions of stars in search of alien life. He managed all this without a Star Trek crew or spacecraft to assist him. He did it his way, alone with his ‘Bong” and galactic grade pot.

It is some consolation to skeptics, Carl Sagan's pot induced trips into the twilight zone was finally rewarded. His flights into fantasy finally caught the attention of the SFWA who posthumously awarded him the award along with GINJER BUCHANAN.

But note.
"The Solstice Awards were created to acknowledge individuals who have had a significant impact on the science fiction and fantasy landscape.”

The award does not shed any light on Carl Sagan's real scientific achievements or validates his scientific credentials. For that we have to turn to Harold Urey the Nobel Prize winner whose pioneering work on the chemical origins of life inspired Sagan's similar work correctly informed the relevant tenure committee that Sagan's scientific "achievements" were trivial and derivative.

Sagan was denied tenure at Harvard and refused membership to the National Academy of Sciences. But he did not disappoint the public’s fascination with science fiction and fantasy land. He pandered to them and was finally recognized for his contribution.

The SFWA correctly recognized Carl Sagan for what he was a science fiction writer and the fantasy landscape he glorified.
http://www.sfwa.org/2013/03/2013-solstice-awards/
 
And you once again ignore his contributions to NASA/JPL and his work at Cornell university among other things.
 
In my post #2396 I introduced an article from eSKEPTIC dated Wednesday, March 7th, 2012 based on a study done in 2002 by Walker, W. Richard; Hoekstra, Steven J.; Vogl, Rodney J.
Science Education Is No Guarantee of Skepticism
SOURCE Skeptic;2002, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p24
http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/12-03-07/#feature

In my post#2779 I introduced another survey which was published in the Skeptic Inquirer. The second survey was published in 2006.
Paranormal Beliefs: An Analysis of College Students by Bryan Farha and Gary Steward Jr.
Volume 30.1, January / February 2006
Feature

This study examines the paranormal beliefs of students along dimensions relating to age, area of study, and education level.
And the link I provided was: http://www.livescience.com/564-higher-education-fuels-stronger-belief-ghosts.html#table
How come higher education fuels stronger belief in ghosts?
Robert Roy Britt Date: 20 January 2006 Time: 03:06 AM ET

Please note these are two separate surveys done by different people as indicated by the different authors of the two surveys.
One is based on “Science Education Is No Guarantee of Skepticism” and the other “Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts.” The questions in the two surveys are also different.
What I was doing was drawing attention to the fact neither higher science education or higher education reduced the beliefs in pseudoscience or paranormal beliefs. Thus suggesting skeptics are losing the battle against believers, people of science and people with higher education.
 
A definition of skepticism would certainly be in order. The logical fallacy stuff is interesting, but the paranormal stuff is really, really boring.
 
In my post #2396 I introduced an article from eSKEPTIC dated Wednesday, March 7th, 2012 based on a study done in 2002 by Walker, W. Richard; Hoekstra, Steven J.; Vogl, Rodney J.
Science Education Is No Guarantee of Skepticism
SOURCE Skeptic;2002, Vol. 9 Issue 3, p24
http://www.skeptic.com/eskeptic/12-03-07/#feature
And you were shown how your interpretation was incorrect, and where the survey was flawed. The authors themselves stated that it was an informal survey of students, nothing more.

In my post#2779 I introduced another survey which was published in the Skeptic Inquirer. The second survey was published in 2006.
Paranormal Beliefs: An Analysis of College Students by Bryan Farha and Gary Steward Jr.
Volume 30.1, January / February 2006
Feature

This study examines the paranormal beliefs of students along dimensions relating to age, area of study, and education level.
That is not what the study set out to identify. You did not read the original study, just quoted an article which paraphrased it. See below.

And the link I provided was: http://www.livescience.com/564-higher-education-fuels-stronger-belief-ghosts.html#table
How come higher education fuels stronger belief in ghosts?
Robert Roy Britt Date: 20 January 2006 Time: 03:06 AM ET
You omitted the study itself, which states, in the very first line:
This experiment was designed to further previous research on
the relationship between media and social influence on beliefs in
the paranormal.
You obviously did not read the actual study. Why not?

Please note these are two separate surveys done by different people as indicated by the different authors of the two surveys.
One is based on “Science Education Is No Guarantee of Skepticism” and the other “Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts.” The questions in the two surveys are also different.
Both of which studies you have misrepresented.

What I was doing was drawing attention to the fact neither higher science education or higher education reduced the beliefs in pseudoscience or paranormal beliefs. Thus suggesting skeptics are losing the battle against believers, people of science and people with higher education.
No, what you were in fact doing was misrepresenting studies to support your baseless hypothesis.
 
A definition of skepticism would certainly be in order. The logical fallacy stuff is interesting, but the paranormal stuff is really, really boring.

Since JiT has not read the research he quotes, he likely does not realise that the "results" section of the paper says this:
The results did not support the researchers hypothesis and
therefore no interaction was found between the use of social
influence and video F (1,36) = 4.53, p = .505.
That was what the researchers set out to test, i.e. how media affects belief. Answer found is "No, it doesn't".

JiT is simply attempting to co-opt unrelated research to his unsupported thesis.
 
There appears to be some confusion regarding my post #2779.

The link I provided was an article that appeared in LiveScience written by Robert Roy Britt Titled "Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts."
http://www.livescience.com/564-higher-education-fuels-stronger-belief-ghosts.html#table

The author points to a survey done by Bryan Farha at Oklahoma City University and Gary Steward Jr. of the University of Central Oklahoma which appeared in the Skeptic Inquirer titled "Paranormal Beliefs: An Analysis of College Students by Bryan Farha and Gary Steward Jr. Volume 30.1, January / February 2006

"The survey was modeled after a nationwide Gallup Poll in 2001 that found younger Americans far more likely to believe in the paranormal than older respondents." It was a new survey and it concluded:

"Believe it or not, higher education is linked to a greater tendency to believe in ghosts and other paranormal phenomena, according to a new study.

Contrary to researchers' expectations, a poll of 439 college students found seniors and grad students were more likely than freshmen to believe in haunted houses, psychics, telepathy, channeling and a host of other questionable ideas. "

The study abaddon quoted is from "Effects of Social Influence and Persuasion Paranormal on Paranormal Beliefs which is a followup to answer questions raised in "Investigating the Relationship Between Exposure to Television Programs that Depict Paranormal, Phenomena and Beliefs in the Paranormal, Glenn G. Sparks and Will Miller.

As the titles suggest "The experiment was designed to further previous research on the relationship between media and social influence on beliefs in the paranormal"

And it concluded mass media (television,films or advertising) had no influence on the average college student's belief in the paranormal.

"The results did not support the researchers hypothesis and therefore no interaction was found between the use of social influence and video F (1,36) = 4.53, p = .505. "

Note again the articles I pointed to "Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts, Robert Roy Britt" and "Science Education is No Guarantee of Skepticism by Richard Walker, Steven J. Hoekstra, and Rodnet J. Vogl are not questioning the role of TV or social media.
What I was doing was drawing attention to the fact neither higher science education or higher education reduced the beliefs in pseudoscience or paranormal beliefs. Thus suggesting skeptics are losing the battle against believers, people of science and people with higher education.
 
There appears to be some confusion regarding my post #2779.

The link I provided was an article that appeared in LiveScience written by Robert Roy Britt Titled "Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts."
http://www.livescience.com/564-higher-education-fuels-stronger-belief-ghosts.html#table

The author points to a survey done by Bryan Farha at Oklahoma City University and Gary Steward Jr. of the University of Central Oklahoma which appeared in the Skeptic Inquirer titled "Paranormal Beliefs: An Analysis of College Students by Bryan Farha and Gary Steward Jr. Volume 30.1, January / February 2006

"The survey was modeled after a nationwide Gallup Poll in 2001 that found younger Americans far more likely to believe in the paranormal than older respondents." It was a new survey and it concluded:



The study abaddon quoted is from "Effects of Social Influence and Persuasion Paranormal on Paranormal Beliefs which is a followup to answer questions raised in "Investigating the Relationship Between Exposure to Television Programs that Depict Paranormal, Phenomena and Beliefs in the Paranormal, Glenn G. Sparks and Will Miller.

As the titles suggest "The experiment was designed to further previous research on the relationship between media and social influence on beliefs in the paranormal"

And it concluded mass media (television,films or advertising) had no influence on the average college student's belief in the paranormal.

"The results did not support the researchers hypothesis and therefore no interaction was found between the use of social influence and video F (1,36) = 4.53, p = .505. "

Note again the articles I pointed to "Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts, Robert Roy Britt" and "Science Education is No Guarantee of Skepticism by Richard Walker, Steven J. Hoekstra, and Rodnet J. Vogl are not questioning the role of TV or social media.
What I was doing was drawing attention to the fact neither higher science education or higher education reduced the beliefs in pseudoscience or paranormal beliefs. Thus suggesting skeptics are losing the battle against believers, people of science and people with higher education.

You still have not read Farha and Stewards study, have you?

Tell you what, I'll give you a quote for free...

Twenty-eight percent of college students reported belief in ESP compared to 50 percent in the 2001 Gallup Poll (22 percent difference).
IOW, the rate of belief among students is nearly half that in the general public.

Go read the actual study, not an article about the study.
 
Thus suggesting skeptics are losing the battle against believers, people of science and people with higher education.

Do you think believers in pseudoscience, the paranormal and the supernatural are in the same camp with scientists and people with higher education, and opposed to skeptics?
 
You still have not read Farha and Stewards study, have you?

Tell you what, I'll give you a quote for free...


IOW, the rate of belief among students is nearly half that in the general public.

Go read the actual study, not an article about the study.

The two quotes you provided:

abaddon wrote: You omitted the study itself, which states, in the very first line:
"This experiment was designed to further previous research on the relationship between media and social influence on beliefs in
the paranormal. "
abaddon wrote: Since JiT has not read the research he quotes, he likely does not realise that the "results" section of the paper says this:
"The results did not support the researchers hypothesis and therefore no interaction was found between the use of social influence and video F (1,36) = 4.53, p = .505. "
The two quotes you claim are from the the actual study are not the actual study but an article written by Jenna M Vallee in 2008 titled "Effects of Social Influence and Persuasion on Paranormal Beliefs. This was published 2 years after the the survey done by Bryan Farha at Oklahoma City University and Gary Steward Jr. of the University of Central Oklahoma which appeared in the Skeptic Inquirer in 2006.

What I was referring to was a survey done by Bryan Farha at Oklahoma City University and Gary Steward Jr. of the University of Central Oklahoma which appeared in the Skeptic Inquirer titled "Paranormal Beliefs: An Analysis of College Students by Bryan Farha and Gary Steward Jr. Volume 30.1, January / February 2006

The link I provided clear explains why the survey concluded "Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts.
http://www.livescience.com/564-higher-education-fuels-stronger-belief-ghosts.html#table

"In general college students checked the "Believe" box less than the general population surveyed by Gallup. But the lack of "Don't Believe" responses among college students was lower for six of the 13 categories: psychic or spiritual healing, haunted houses, demonic possession, ghosts, clairvoyance and witches. That means a higher percentage of college students put themselves in the "Not Sure" column on these topics."
"While 23 percent of college freshmen expressed a general belief in paranormal concepts—from astrology to communicating with the dead—31 percent of seniors did so and the figure jumped to 34 percent among graduate students."

"As people attain higher college-education levels, the likelihood of believing in paranormal dimensions increases," Farha and Steward write.
 
...
Should skeptics be ignored?

The Center for Inquiry thinks they should.
"Shunning and boycotting may be gaining acceptance in the atheist and skeptic communities. In particular, it appears they are being adopted as tactics against fellow atheists and skeptics."

And they even have a partial list of undesirables.

"In any event, the list of individuals that CFI has been advised not to have any dealings with is long. In no particular order it includes: Richard Dawkins, Lawrence Krauss, Ophelia Benson, Harriet Hall, Russell Blackford, Edwina Rogers, Rebecca Watson, PZ Myers, and Sharon Hill. I am sure I am forgetting several more. "
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/on_shunning_fellow_atheists_and_skeptics/ ...

That article does not state that the CFI has a list of people undesirable by the CFI, as you suggest.
It's a shun wish list of several others, who appear to want to impose there opinion of individuals on the CFI.
 
Do you think believers in pseudoscience, the paranormal and the supernatural are in the same camp with scientists and people with higher education, and opposed to skeptics?

I have pointed out the general public are increasingly showing a greater interest in the paranormal, pseudoscience and supernatural phenomena and TV ratings are soaring for shows on Bigfoot, psychics, ghost detectives and other strange sightings.

More Science education does not lead to an increase in skepticism but quite the opposite. "Science Education Is No Guarantee of Skepticism."

Now another survey suggests. "Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts."

All this suggest skeptics are the ones in a separate camp from scientists, believers and people with higher education. Their assumptions that science, education and critical thinking would reduce beliefs in pseudoscience, paranormal and supernatural phenomena are being proven wrong.

There are many studies explaining why humans want to believe in supernatural science, the paranormal etc. But very little research has been done on how skeptics are produced and why people become skeptics.
A study group in Australia stumbled on it by accident. It was discovered skeptics are produced in childhood. It is a lengthy video, but around the 10min point the study comes together.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ezEukr0zuo
 
...
There are many studies explaining why humans want to believe in supernatural science, the paranormal etc. But very little research has been done on how skeptics are produced and why people become skeptics.
A study group in Australia stumbled on it by accident. It was discovered skeptics are produced in childhood. It is a lengthy video, but around the 10min point the study comes together.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ezEukr0zuo
Hilite by Daylightstar
There's no study group stumbling on 'it', at all.

It's the individual in the video, a Steve from Sydney, claiming 'to have discovered a little treasure find on australian television'.

It concern an item on Australian television about kids with troubled backgrounds learning magic tricks and in the process gain confidence and improve their general performance as children.

The item is shown in the YouTube video and overlayed texts have been added (not by the television station ......) to conflate his apparent/obvious dislike of what he calls pseudo skeptics with the situations of troubled kids.

Sorry justintime, but you've been had by an irrationalist.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For those interested in reading the original survey mentioned in ""Higher Education Fuels Stronger Belief in Ghosts. can find it under:
http://www2.okcu.edu/petree/education/bryanfarha.aspx

Farha, B., & Steward, G. (2006). Paranormal beliefs: An analysis of college students Skeptical Inquirer, 30(1), 37-40.

How funny. You didn't link to the actual study, but to a huge list. I can only assume this was an attempt to add obscurity, since you could easily link to the actual study in your reply.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom