Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Well, the actual line was building off of Jond's Firesign Theatre reference.

It's the name of an old Firesign Theatre album.

JiT -- does "this bus" mean JREF, skeptics, intellectuals, the whole world, or what?

If you listen to the album while hallucinating on pot, maybe you can tell me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lmWFrMq3qNY
 
Last edited:
Well, the actual line was building off of Jond's Firesign Theatre reference.

It's the name of an old Firesign Theatre album.

JiT -- does "this bus" mean JREF, skeptics, intellectuals, the whole world, or what?

If you listen to the album while hallucinating on pot, maybe you can tell me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lmWFrMq3qNY

Ahh, thank you great sage! I know what I will be doing for the next 40 minutes.
 
Well, the actual line was building off of Jond's Firesign Theatre reference.

It's the name of an old Firesign Theatre album.

JiT -- does "this bus" mean JREF, skeptics, intellectuals, the whole world, or what?

If you listen to the album while hallucinating on pot, maybe you can tell me.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lmWFrMq3qNY

I can't believe I missed the allusion.

I guess I can believe it, but I regret it.
 
what a wonderful word investigoogling

I wish I could, but sadly cannot claim credit for the term. I have no idea who might have coined it.

OK I googled it LOL

Investigoogling: A prolonged search into a particular topic in order to investigate different opinions and subject matter. First coined in 2006 by Karin Slaughter.

Investigoogling was first used in the Book - Indelible of Karin Slaughter's: Grant County Series of Novels in 2004.
Linky.
 
Last edited:
This thread is closed for clean up. As always, do not start other threads to discuss the same subject; you'll have to wait until a Moderator has time to clean this one up and reopen it.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
I tried to do justice to your OP BobR and would have preferred to have Carl Sagan as a separate thread. But I am honored you paid us a visit.
"I" paid "you" a visit. Ok then...

I invited myself to your OP. I just hope you see that as an intrusion rather than a hijack.
If I had seen it as an intrusion, I would have called it an intrusion.

I agree with you Carl Sagan held himself to a standard he could not live up to.
I have no opinion on the subject of Carl Sagan. Please don't put words in my mouth.
 
While the moderators are sorting out the confusion and at the same time suggestion my new thread is really a continuation of what was temporarily closed. The only way to continue the discussion was to post the same question I raised in my new OP here, so members can comment on it.

Should skeptics be ignored?

The Center for Inquiry thinks they should.
"Shunning and boycotting may be gaining acceptance in the atheist and skeptic communities. In particular, it appears they are being adopted as tactics against fellow atheists and skeptics."

And they even have a partial list of undesirables.

"In any event, the list of individuals that CFI has been advised not to have any dealings with is long. In no particular order it includes: Richard Dawkins, Lawrence Krauss, Ophelia Benson, Harriet Hall, Russell Blackford, Edwina Rogers, Rebecca Watson, PZ Myers, and Sharon Hill. I am sure I am forgetting several more. "
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/on_shunning_fellow_atheists_and_skeptics/

Climate Change skeptics are just as successful at being snubbed and ignored. Besides the IPCC ignoring the climate change skeptics, new labels are being applied to them.

NYT's Climate Change Reporter Dismisses 'Skeptical Skunks,' Assumes Problem 'Growing Worse'

"Broder wrote from Doha on the paper's Green blog December 6 calling two climate change skeptics who dared to crash the party "skeptical skunks."
http://newsbusters.org/blogs/clay-w...er-dismisses-skeptical-skunks-assumes-problem

The public are equally participating in ignoring skeptics attacks on pseudoscience and the paranormal. TV rating is soaring for shows on Bigfoot, psychics, ghost detectives and other strange sightings. That is a mass scale snub of skeptics both my media and public.

James Randi offered a million dollars for any psychic to prove their craft. He is going about largely ignored with no takers. Some even claim Mr Randi was more successful and popular when he was a magician than he is as a skeptic. Even the JREF site has more on Bigfoot and psychics than it has on any major breakthrough by the skeptic movement.

Are there any reasons for this push-back or backlash against skeptics.

I did some research on the subject and find no relationship between skeptic efforts and public rejection of their efforts. Skeptics assumptions that more skepticism will reduce the public's fascination with the paranormal/pseudoscience and even other unsupported beliefs are largely wrong.

Steven Novella highlights the problem with the skeptic movement.

"The skeptical movement is having some (charitably characterized) growing pains. It’s nothing new, actually. Ever since I have been involved in organized skepticism (about 17 years) we have been struggling with the exact same identity crisis, and from speaking with older skeptics it seems much longer than that.

What is the skeptical community all about? What are the limits, if any, of skeptical analysis? What should be our goals, and our main focus of attention? There is also an even deeper question – are we, in fact, a movement at all?"

http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/bigfoot-skeptics-new-atheists-politics-and-religion/
 
Even the JREF site has more on Bigfoot and psychics than it has on any major breakthrough by the skeptic movement.

I would posit that part of that is unlike Bigfoot and psychic message boards, the JREF forum has never banned a poster because of message content. If those folks would let skeptics into their forums, we'd have a helluva less bigfoot over here.
 
Should skeptics be ignored?

The Center for Inquiry thinks they should.
"Shunning and boycotting may be gaining acceptance in the atheist and skeptic communities. In particular, it appears they are being adopted as tactics against fellow atheists and skeptics."

And they even have a partial list of undesirables.

"In any event, the list of individuals that CFI has been advised not to have any dealings with is long. In no particular order it includes: Richard Dawkins, Lawrence Krauss, Ophelia Benson, Harriet Hall, Russell Blackford, Edwina Rogers, Rebecca Watson, PZ Myers, and Sharon Hill. I am sure I am forgetting several more. "
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/on_shunning_fellow_atheists_and_skeptics/

Did you read the following sentences he posted after those you quoted? I mean specifically this part:
This is advice which I decline to follow. Let me explain why.

CFI is an organization that has as part of its core mission the promotion of free inquiry. We try to fulfill that mission in several ways. One way is to campaign against government restrictions on speech, in particular, speech deemed intolerable because it offends the sensibilities of the religious. We also try to promote discussion of important issues, often by inviting speakers to events or conferences who have contrasting views.

You misunderstand his main point. Shunning isn't skepticism. Shunning is group behavior. Free inquiry is skepticism. Reread his post again.
 
Did you read the following sentences he posted after those you quoted? I mean specifically this part:


You misunderstand his main point. Shunning isn't skepticism. Shunning is group behavior. Free inquiry is skepticism. Reread his post again.

It is very clear the author is trying to defend the CFI by denying the politics behind the scenes. He does not deny there is a "To be shunned" list.

What is even more ironic is his own defense against accusations made against him for perpetuation discord.

"Jerry Coyne claimed that CFI had declared war on atheists. No, really. Moreover, he specifically mentioned me as someone who had gone out of his way to criticize CFI’s atheist supporters. "

"PZ Myers, who has raged against those alleged accommodationist “wankers” at CFI, stating that CFI stood for the “Church of Fatuous Incompetence.”

"Watson suggested that I was a person who, with respect to the controversy over feminism and harassment within the atheist/skeptic communities, “play[ed] the ‘both sides are wrong’ game, insinuating that ‘misogynist’ is just as bad an insult as ‘****.’

"Of course, there are persons who combine controversial opinions with outrageous, intolerable behavior or express their opinions in such a fashion that they do not allow for a meaningful exchange of views (e.g., their “views” consist largely of a string of racist epithets). Similarly, there are persons who repeatedly make demonstrably false claims, whose every word out of their mouths, including “and” and “the” (to paraphrase Mary McCarthy), are lies. Such persons would not be invited to speak at CFI events. "

Now who decides what is outrageous and who needs to be shunned? The CFI and they are put on the "To be Shunned" list.

What the author is trying to do is "damage control". CFI is tired of the wackos and skeptics and action it being taken to keep these speakers out. The title says it all. "On Shunning Fellow Atheists and Skeptics."

The link from which the quotes were taken.
http://www.centerforinquiry.net/blogs/entry/on_shunning_fellow_atheists_and_skeptics/
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There is indeed dissent in the skeptic community (if such a thing exists) mostly related to accusations of sexism.

Did you have some other, less obvious point?
 
Believe it or not, higher education is linked to a greater tendency to believe in ghosts and other paranormal phenomena, according to a new study.

Contrary to researchers' expectations, a poll of 439 college students found seniors and grad students were more likely than freshmen to believe in haunted houses, psychics, telepathy, channeling and a host of other questionable ideas.

http://www.livescience.com/564-higher-education-fuels-stronger-belief-ghosts.html#table

The above study suggests skeptics are both losing the battle against believers and people with higher education.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom