Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

There are two options here, jit hasn't read anything by Sagan or he has read him and has the same problems with reading that Kevin Klein's character has in Fish Called Wanda. I think someone had mentioned this earlier in this thread.
 
I remember a fellow student at University who used to carry around huge books on post modernist theory. Never read anything from them apart from the blurb and some reviews and then manage to ******** about what he had "read" from the book. He was pretty successful with this and it took the teachers almost a year before they caught on.


Given the nature of most postmodernist writings, I'm amazed that they could tell the difference.
 
Not as mod:

You guys do realize that you're acting like fundies when someone challenges the literal truth of the Bible, don't you? Someone comes in here and says "Maybe Carl Sagan wasn't so great" and everyone goes nuts because OMG SOMEONE INSULTED SAGAN!!!!eleventy!

So, to extend the religious analogy to its logical conclusion, just ask yourselves, "What would Carl do?" and deport yourselves accordingly.
 
Not as mod:

You guys do realize that you're acting like fundies when someone challenges the literal truth of the Bible, don't you? Someone comes in here and says "Maybe Carl Sagan wasn't so great" and everyone goes nuts because OMG SOMEONE INSULTED SAGAN!!!!eleventy!

So, to extend the religious analogy to its logical conclusion, just ask yourselves, "What would Carl do?" and deport yourselves accordingly.

Funny, but not really true. There hasn't been a challenge of Sagan's ideas. The simile isn't apt. For most of us, this has been an exercise in talking to a troll, without posting kittens or recipes like the old days.
 
Not as mod:

You guys do realize that you're acting like fundies when someone challenges the literal truth of the Bible, don't you? Someone comes in here and says "Maybe Carl Sagan wasn't so great" and everyone goes nuts because OMG SOMEONE INSULTED SAGAN!!!!eleventy!

So, to extend the religious analogy to its logical conclusion, just ask yourselves, "What would Carl do?" and deport yourselves accordingly.

Nope...not at all. the basic issue is that jit made some statements on Carl Sagan's motivation and even put forward his own version of what Sagan actually thought based on a misreading (now that I come to think of it...a non-reading) of Sagan's works.
 
Not as mod:

You guys do realize that you're acting like fundies when someone challenges the literal truth of the Bible, don't you? Someone comes in here and says "Maybe Carl Sagan wasn't so great" and everyone goes nuts because OMG SOMEONE INSULTED SAGAN!!!!eleventy!

So, to extend the religious analogy to its logical conclusion, just ask yourselves, "What would Carl do?" and deport yourselves accordingly.

He is saying that Carl Sagan was addicted to pot and suffered drug induced hallucinations. He also says that reading Sagan's works will make you stupid. That is all bollocks. If he had actually read any of Carl Sagan's works and had some genuine criticism, that would be a different matter. The religious analogy does not work, none of us consider Sagan to be a god.
 
Last edited:
He is saying that Carl Sagan was addicted to pot and suffered drug induced hallucinations. He also says that reading Sagan's works will make you stupid. That is all bollocks. If he had actually read any of Carl Sagan's works and had some genuine criticism, that would be a different matter. The religious analogy does not work, none of us consider Sagan to be a god.

that is right he had faults he was only human after all but what JiT is attempting is nothing short of character assination.
 
I see my point sailed over your heads. Dr. Sagan's work speaks for itself; he doesn't NEED any defending. Apply critical thinking to jit's assertions, and draw your own conclusions. Dr. Sagan wouldn't have wasted five minutes on jit; I submit that the forum ought to do the same.
 
I see my point sailed over your heads. Dr. Sagan's work speaks for itself; he doesn't NEED any defending. Apply critical thinking to jit's assertions, and draw your own conclusions. Dr. Sagan wouldn't have wasted five minutes on jit; I submit that the forum ought to do the same.
Your answer is "Body of work". He has prior form. He is lurching from forum to forum presenting the same unfounded idea. If rebuttals were not presented here, then JiT would be crowing about how he "Silenced his critics at JREF" on the very next forum he victimises with his drivel.

At some point, someone has to take a stand against this kind of nonsense.
 
Not as mod:

You guys do realize that you're acting like fundies when someone challenges the literal truth of the Bible, don't you? Someone comes in here and says "Maybe Carl Sagan wasn't so great" and everyone goes nuts because OMG SOMEONE INSULTED SAGAN!!!!eleventy!

So, to extend the religious analogy to its logical conclusion, just ask yourselves, "What would Carl do?" and deport yourselves accordingly.

I have never come across a moderator I liked. But you have profoundly changed that. Most moderators are pack leaders and when the pack goes rabid the moderator to stay ahead of the pack clears the intellectual brick wall.
But most do it by removing the intellectual.

You are the first moderator to recognize the pack has been rabid for a while and appealed to higher authority to help the situation. '"What would Carl do?'

Appealing to skeptics to apply critical thinking or a more rational approach would have been expected on a skeptic forum. But are they skeptics or just very insecure individuals.

I commend you for asking the members to take up the challenge. The is little denying Carl Sagan popularized science and was a popular public face to millions.
But he was a very controversial figure who on one hand down played alien encounters but on the other hand encouraged alien encounters of the extraterrestrial kind. The normal reaction would have been to ask. What was he smoking? It appears he was smoking something. Galactic grade pot.

That fact alone would not have made him the central focus of my research. But a obsessive compulsive pot smoking alien hunter with a questionable streak of scientific skepticism was just too hard to resist especially when I knew more about what skeptics would do(react)? than I did about Carl Sagan.

To be fair to the readers I admitted at the start I never read any of his books. That was to give the skeptics something to chew on while I surveyed the field and scope. The bone I threw consumed the rabid crowd. They began to debate a blank page 78 and I was free to focus on the man behind the public persona. A man who pursued his childhood impressions and was captured by the notion of extraterrestrial intelligent life.

As much as he demanded extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence to satisfy his scientific skepticism. He also prepared an alibi for his own escape into the twilight zone with the conviction 'absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.' Who says you can't have it both ways. Not if you are a skeptic. When the science doesn't work there is innate faith to fall back on. The belief in aliens carried Carl Sagan through his adult years enhanced by his pot addiction.

We all need a little help to get by. Carl Sagan was no different. We all need to exercise a little skepticism to keep us in check. He believed as a scientist he was already adequately skeptical.

The most encouraging announcement came from calebprime. He wrote: "We're all insecure bozos on this bus." presumably all set to leave town.

The not so encouraging announcement came from you. "I see my point sailed over your heads."

I openly declared there is no cure for insecurity only frequent bus excursions to destination 'X' can reduce the overcrowding on skeptic forums.
 
Last edited:
Not as mod:

You guys do realize that you're acting like fundies when someone challenges the literal truth of the Bible, don't you? Someone comes in here and says "Maybe Carl Sagan wasn't so great" and everyone goes nuts because OMG SOMEONE INSULTED SAGAN!!!!eleventy!

So, to extend the religious analogy to its logical conclusion, just ask yourselves, "What would Carl do?" and deport yourselves accordingly.

I have never come across a moderator I liked. But you have profoundly changed that. Most moderators are pack leaders and when the pack goes rabid the moderator to stay ahead of the pack clears the intellectual brick wall.
But most do it by removing the intellectual.

You are the first moderator to recognize the pack has been rabid for a while and appealed to higher authority to help the situation. '"What would Carl do?'

Appealing to skeptics to apply critical thinking or a more rational approach would have been expected on a skeptic forum. But are they skeptics or just very insecure individuals.

I commend you for asking the members to take up the challenge. The is little denying Carl Sagan popularized science and was a popular public face to millions.
But he was a very controversial figure who on one hand down played alien encounters but on the other hand encouraged alien encounters of the extraterrestrial kind. The normal reaction would have been to ask. What was he smoking? It appears he was smoking something. Galactic grade pot.

That fact alone would not have made him the central focus of my research. But a obsessive compulsive smoking alien hunter with a questionable streak of scientific skepticism was just too hard to resist especially when I knew more about what skeptics would do(react)? than I did about Carl Sagan.

To be fair to the readers I admitted at the start I never read any of his books. That was to give the skeptics something to chew on while I surveyed the field and scope. The bone I threw consumed the rabid crowd. They began to debate a blank page 78 and I was free to focus on the man behind the public persona. A man who pursued his childhood impressions and was captured by the notion of extraterrestrial intelligent life.

As much as he demanded extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence to satisfy his scientific skepticism. He also prepared an alibi for his own escape into the twilight zone with the conviction 'absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.' Who says you can't have it both ways. Not if you are a skeptic. When the science doesn't work there is innate faith to fall back on. The belief in aliens carried Carl Sagan through his adult years enhanced by his pot addiction.

We all need a little help to get by. Carl Sagan was no different. We all need to exercise a little skepticism to keep us in check. He believed as a scientist he was already adequately skeptical.

The most encouraging announcement came from calebprime. He wrote: "We're all insecure bozos on this bus." presumably all set to leave town.

The not so encouraging announcement came from you. "I see my point sailed over your heads."

I openly declared there is no cure for insecurity only frequent bus excursions to destination 'X' can reduce the overcrowding on skeptic forums.

See what you did.
 
I see my point sailed over your heads. Dr. Sagan's work speaks for itself; he doesn't NEED any defending. Apply critical thinking to jit's assertions, and draw your own conclusions. Dr. Sagan wouldn't have wasted five minutes on jit; I submit that the forum ought to do the same.

We did, posted accordingly, you disagree.


If the forum is just going to ignore this kind of poster then it might as well not exist. In fact if Randi had applied your principle the forum would not exist.
 
I have never come across a moderator I liked. But you have profoundly changed that. Most moderators are pack leaders and when the pack goes rabid the moderator to stay ahead of the pack clears the intellectual brick wall.
Moderators are also members, and are entitled to have an opinion of their own, just like any other member. So what?

But most do it by removing the intellectual.
Tempting to respond, but it would violate the MA, and you want that.

You are the first moderator to recognize the pack has been rabid for a while and appealed to higher authority to help the situation. '"What would Carl do?'
Hyperbole, and wishful thinking.

Appealing to skeptics to apply critical thinking or a more rational approach would have been expected on a skeptic forum. But are they skeptics or just very insecure individuals.
We are applying critical thinking to your idea. It is not our fault if you don't like it much.

I commend you for asking the members to take up the challenge. The is little denying Carl Sagan popularized science and was a popular public face to millions.
But he was a very controversial figure who on one hand down played alien encounters but on the other hand encouraged alien encounters of the extraterrestrial kind. The normal reaction would have been to ask. What was he smoking? It appears he was smoking something. Galactic grade pot.
Again with the Sagan/pot obsession.

That fact alone would not have made him the central focus of my research.
You are oscillating again. On the one hand you try to claim Sagan was incidental to your "research". Now, Sagan is central to your research. Make your mind up. You did no research.
But a obsessive compulsive smoking alien hunter with a questionable streak of scientific skepticism was just too hard to resist especially when I knew more about what skeptics would do(react)? than I did about Carl Sagan.
Project much? It is YOU who is obsessed. I have read and enjoyed some, but not all, of Sagan's work. What of it? Am I now a brainwashed follower of a "guru"? Nope. Has my IQ decreased? Nope.

To be fair to the readers I admitted at the start I never read any of his books.
Once again, you admit to doing no research.
That was to give the skeptics something to chew on while I surveyed the field and scope. The bone I threw consumed the rabid crowd.
Nope. That meant that all here were free to dismiss your unsupported opinion, which happened in short order. Once again, you didn't like it much.

They began to debate a blank page 78 and I was free to focus on the man behind the public persona.
Nope. You introduced that malarkey, and once again, you didn't like it much when you were caught out, and furthermore, you tried several dishonest arguments to extract yourself from that, all the way down to the childish "I meant to do that" position.

A man who pursued his childhood impressions and was captured by the notion of extraterrestrial intelligent life.
What's wrong with that?

As much as he demanded extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence to satisfy his scientific skepticism. He also prepared an alibi for his own escape into the twilight zone with the conviction 'absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.' Who says you can't have it both ways. Not if you are a skeptic. When the science doesn't work there is innate faith to fall back on. The belief in aliens carried Carl Sagan through his adult years enhanced by his pot addiction.
"extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence" Seems self evident to me. What's your problem?
'absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.' Seems self evident to me. What's your problem?
We all need a little help to get by. Carl Sagan was no different. We all need to exercise a little skepticism to keep us in check. He believed as a scientist he was already adequately skeptical.
And what "help" do you have to get by? Is it anti-evolutionism? biblical fundamentalism? superstition? I know you believe all these. The internet never forgets.

The most encouraging announcement came from calebprime. He wrote: "We're all insecure bozos on this bus." presumably all set to leave town.
Reading for comprehension fail. That was parody. You missed it.

The not so encouraging announcement came from you. "I see my point sailed over your heads."
All points sail over your head.
I openly declared there is no cure for insecurity only frequent bus excursions to destination 'X' can reduce the overcrowding on skeptic forums.
And it must be true, because you declared it. Evidence is irrelevant.
 
Not as mod:

You guys do realize that you're acting like fundies when someone challenges the literal truth of the Bible, don't you? Someone comes in here and says "Maybe Carl Sagan wasn't so great" and everyone goes nuts because OMG SOMEONE INSULTED SAGAN!!!!eleventy!

So, to extend the religious analogy to its logical conclusion, just ask yourselves, "What would Carl do?" and deport yourselves accordingly.

He has frequently and deliberately posted misrepresentations of the facts. There might be lurkers here taken-in by such tactics if we were to remain silent.
 
fonzsharkjump300x300x.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom