Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

It may be no more than a careless mistake on your part (formatting can be tricky) but the source you appear to be providing for the quote above
(The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749)
does not, in fact, contain the text you appear to be claiming that it does.

Be so kind as to amend your error, or explain your claim.

X2

Though I like the disclaimer in your link J'Time: " . . . not intended to be authoritative . . ."

No ****.
 
Carl Sagan said:
Or take UFOS, the contention that beings in spaceships from other worlds are visiting us all the time. I find that a thrilling idea. It's at least a break from the ordinary. I've spent a fair amount of time in my scientific life working on the issue of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Think how much effort I could save if those guys are coming here.


Where in this quote does Carl Sagan say that he believes even one report that ETs have visited earth?
 
Given your posting history, and your demonstrated tendency to distort what Dr. Sagan actually said, be so kind as to provide your source for the idea that Dr. Sagan equated SETI with UFO sightings.

It's a quote mine.

"Or take UFOs, the contention that beings in spaceships from other worlds are visiting us all the time. I find that a thrilling idea. It’s at least a break from the ordinary. I’ve spent a fair amount of time in my scientific life working on the issue of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Think how much effort I could save if those guys are coming here. But when we recognize some emotional vulnerability regarding a claim, that is exactly where we have to make the firmest efforts at skeptical scrutiny. That is where we can be had."

Source.
 
If you understand the scientific method you pretty well grasp scientific skepticism.

From the responses it is obvious none of the participants are philosophy majors and unfortunately Skeptics lack an understanding of Epistemology. Discussion on solipsism, empiricism and rationalism require an understanding of their philosophical roots.

Kurtz has popularized scientific skepticism and critical thinking about claims of the paranormal.

Hurtz was not a scientist. He implored Skeptics to apply scientific method. In short scientific skepticism is for non scientific people.
Now how practical is it for a non scientific person to apply scientific method.
1. In America less than 5% of the working population make a living as engineers and scientist. So if you separate the scientist from engineers the percentage of the population actually making a living applying the scientific method is even smaller. How practical is that?

2. Scientific method requires a proficiency in the field of study. One cannot claim to know the scientific method and based on just this knowledge apply for a job as a research scientist.

Definition of scientific method Oxford dictionary.
1. a method of procedure that has characterized natural science since the 17th century, consisting in systematic observation, measurement, and experiment, and the formulation, testing, and modification of hypotheses:

In short, only the professionals can apply scientific method. Only the professionals can tackle complex phenomena for verifiability. The scientific method is beyond the scope of the average Skeptic.

Why then do Skeptic Forums promote the criticism of things not well understood; how they appear awkward, are marginalized and often found rather unhelpful.
 
Last edited:
Even Carl Sagan knew people associated UFOs with alien spacecraft and wished they were real.
What is your point?

Who wouldn't want to be a professional dragon racing jockey, or have a cool superpower and be one of the X-Men? Saying "It would be cool to have psychic powers" doesn't mean I think Sylvia Browne is any less full of crap. Sagan admitting that it would be exciting should aliens actually be visiting the Earth is hardly remarkable. Not long ago, one of the bigfoot believers on this forum asked skeptics what their reaction would be if such a creature were ever proved to be real. The overwhelming response was that they would be delighted if a new species were discovered.
 
Skepticism appears to match the definition of insecurity.
Compare.

Skepticism: 1. A doubting or questioning attitude or state of mind; dubiety synonyms with uncertainty.

Insecurity definition: 1. Not sure or certain; doubtful:

That is what I said in the OP. What is a Skeptic?

Why they might not be Skeptics but just very insecure individuals.



You start with one definition of insecurity - lack of certainty - which might be applied to skepticism if you mean it in the context of reserving judgement on objective facts for want of evidence.

But then you conflate this with quite another definition - emotional insecurity - to imply skeptical = weak and fearful.

Even compared to the rest of this thread this is staggeringly feeble wordplay. It's not big and it's not clever.
 
From the responses it is obvious none of the participants are philosophy majors and unfortunately Skeptics lack an understanding of Epistemology. Discussion on solipsism, empiricism and rationalism require an understanding of their philosophical roots.

Kurtz has popularized scientific skepticism and critical thinking about claims of the paranormal.

Hurtz was not a scientist. He implored Skeptics to apply scientific method. In short scientific skepticism is for non scientific people.
Now how practical is it for a non scientific person to apply scientific method.
1. In America less than 5% of the working population make a living as engineers and scientist. So if you separate the scientist from engineers the percentage of the population actually making a living applying the scientific method is even smaller. How practical is that?

2. Scientific method requires a proficiency in the field of study. One cannot claim to know the scientific method and based on just this knowledge apply for a job as a research scientist.

Definition of scientific method Oxford dictionary.
1. a method of procedure that has characterized natural science since the 17th century, consisting in systematic observation, measurement, and experiment, and the formulation, testing, and modification of hypotheses: In short, only the professionals can apply scientific method. Only the professionals can tackle complex phenomena for verifiability. The scientific method is beyond the scope of the average Skeptic.

Why then do Skeptic Forums promote the criticism of things not well understood; how they appear awkward, are marginalized and often found rather unhelpful.

1. At no point does the highlighted text imply , or make, any claim about limiting a scientific method to "professionals"...be so kind as to explain why you think it does.

2. As to your claim that "the scientific method is betond the scope of the average Skeptic" I taught high school science for 13 years. Most of my 9th graders understood scientific methodology, and the role of skeptical thought (particularly in its reliance upon evidence) in scientific inquiry, far better than you have demonstrated you do, by the third week of class...

3. Perhaps the reason you find skeptics "unhelpful" is your adversarial (and demonstrably dishonest) approach, demonstrated through several nyms and sockpuppets on several fora. Consider applying a scientific method, and testing your hypothesis that, for instance, "skeptic brains emit fear signals". A good starting point might be evidence of what a "fear signal" is, and corroborating evidence that any brain can, in fact, be demonstrated to emit such a thing. I would be interested in what evidence you could present to support this repeated calumny.
 
I think you're thinking of Greece.

Happy to treat your ignorance from the comfort of my English village. :)

I would have pointed to Greece if the Skeptic was from there. Sorry if you are offended. I was a Joe Cocker fan Mad Dogs and Englishmen album. He was ahead of his time. I wonder if he would have retitled the album to Mad Cows and Englishmen. I digress.

British Budget Adheres to Austerity While It Cuts the Top Tax Rate
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/22/b...cks-to-austerity-in-new-budget-plan.html?_r=0
 
From the responses it is obvious none of the participants are philosophy majors and unfortunately Skeptics lack an understanding of Epistemology.

I can see that you are conflating the idea of reserving judgement on matters of fact for want of good evidence with the idea of abandoning any attempt to reach any conclusion on anything.

Right now I am reserving judgement on whether you are a philosophy student, annoyed by recent threads here criticizing philosophy and determined to show us all how much cleverer a fellow you are than those meanie critics.
 
I would have pointed to Greece if the Skeptic was from there. Sorry if you are offended. I was a Joe Cocker fan Mad Dogs and Englishmen album. He was ahead of his time. I wonder if he would have retitled the album to Mad Cows and Englishmen. I digress.

Be so kind as to explain:

"It may be no more than a careless mistake on your part (formatting can be tricky) but the source you appear to be providing for the quote above
(The Role of the Amygdala in Fear and Panic.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/exchange/node/1749)
does not, in fact, contain the text you appear to be claiming that it does."
 
Yes, because that's a much more interesting story to tell. I'm not sure I would go see a movie called "Invasion of the barely recognizeable balloons from New Mexico"

On second thought, I totally would.

That is a silly definition. It already disregards certain kinds of explanations for an unexplained observation, and includes the (by this very definition unfounded) opinion of some unnamed persons.
What's wrong with "Unidentified Flying Object?"
It perfectly sums up the whole thing.

If so, what of it? In what way would it not be awesome if alien spacecraft were actually visiting us?
It hasn't affected his belief if they were alien spacecraft or not.

"I don't know" is a perfectly acceptable thing to say.

That definition of UFOs was taken from the Oxford dictionary.

No, it did not change his beliefs. He was just as determined to find them.

I think UFO was used in the early sighting because their were unidentifiable. But the public figured there had to be more to that because of the closed secrecy behind the Roswell UFO incident. Some of the eyewitness broke their silence and identified it as a alien spacecraft. The conspiracy is more about the coverup and not doubts about it being an alien spacecraft.
 
~~~
I think UFO was used in the early sighting because their were unidentifiable. But the public figured there had to be more to that because of the closed secrecy behind the Roswell UFO incident. Some of the eyewitness broke their silence and identified it as a alien spacecraft. The conspiracy is more about the coverup and not doubts about it being an alien spacecraft.

And how does that make you feel?
 
That definition of UFOs was taken from the Oxford dictionary.

No, it did not change his beliefs. He was just as determined to find them.

I think UFO was used in the early sighting because their were unidentifiable. But the public figured there had to be more to that because of the closed secrecy behind the Roswell UFO incident. Some of the eyewitness broke their silence and identified it as a alien spacecraft. The conspiracy is more about the coverup and not doubts about it being an alien spacecraft.

Oh for crissake, just drop the other shoe already?

"I believe in X because Y. And you self-described skeptics aren't lettered enough to evaluate Y."
 
It is beginning to look as if it is you, not Sagan, who believes we have been visited by alien spacecraft.

Not true. I do not have a life long obsession with UFOs, aliens or even ETI. I am not even a Ghost buster. I just try to see the treatable person behind the Skeptic and his or her Skepticism.
I try not to confuse entertainment with serious discourses.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom