Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Well allowing that you are having some sort of short term memory problem...

It was demonstrated that the version you claimed to have in your possession had precisely the blank page you said it didn't. You also stated you didn't believe any paper book had blank pages and that was also comprehensively demonstrated to be wrong. Now you can carry on with this 'I did it deliberately' stance that never works and just further undermines your credibility or you could just concede the error and move on.

No one saw my copy of the book. The link I gave and several other links showed page 78 was not blank in the pdf version which is quite similar to one of my copies. Even between my copies the page numbering did not match. But that is hardly relevant when I said at the start I never read the book and certainly not the treeware version that is now being disputed.
 
Originally Posted by justintime

Let us not lose sight I said my copy did not have a blank page 78 nor did the link to pdf versions have page 78 as a blank page. There was no mention earlier of a treeware version also in circulation. It was recently brought to our attention.

Hard to keep your lies straight, isn't it. I told you way back I had 2 different printed editions.

Furthermore, you said you hadn't read your copy, then that your page 78 had a discussion about Sagan and Schermer disagreeing about whether the brain was hard-wired to believe in gods. Later you said your page 78 was about UFO sightings. later still you again said you hadn't read it.

Your credibililty is not a boomerang. If you throw it away, it's not coming back.
 
i have the first hard cover edition of demon Haunted World and a paperback version which I bought when Ihad thought I had lost my original copy
 
No one saw my copy of the book.
It is your claim that not even YOU saw it.

The link I gave and several other links showed page 78 was not blank in the pdf version which is quite similar to one of my copies.
The reason for this has been explained to you in this very thread, in detail. You just don't understand it/have reading comprehension issues, or else, are simply trolling.

Even between my copies the page numbering did not match.
Why would you have more than one copy of a book you have no intention of reading?

But that is hardly relevant when I said at the start I never read the book and certainly not the treeware version that is now being disputed.
It is very relevant. It means your idea may be dismissed, since you have not done the requisite research by your own admission.
 
I had several copies because I got them free.
From where? A good researcher specifies sources that can be verified.

When people heard of my research they got very supportive.
Who, exactly? A good researcher would specify those sources also, so that they could be independently verified.
Of course I refused most of them because I was not researching the books he wrote, I was researching the pot addict behind the public persona.
Yet you used Demon Haunted World as support for your weak idea even though you had not read it, and had no idea what was in it, treeware or not.

I was unable to find a blank page 78 in any of them because they were not the treeware version.
Poor research. Visit a library next time. That's what they are for.

If the debate is over a blank page 78 in a treeware version. I have no quarrel about that being true. I have no treeware version of the book to confirm or deny the blank page conspiracy.
Incorrect. This is about the credibility of your "research", or the blatant lack thereof.
But if it about What is a skeptic? and Was Carl Sagan really a skeptic?
Yup, he was. And?

There is only one persistent view across this thread and one logical conclusion.
At last, you are correct about something. However, I very much doubt you would be pleased if you realised what that persistent view was. Hint: It is not what you think it is.

My research accurately revealed the pot smoking scientist and his obsession with aliens.
Nope. Your posts revealed your lack of research.

I thank JREF for allowing me to publish my research material on this site which I found was "a place to discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal and science in a friendly and lively way." before some very insecure skeptics. But who am I to complain. :cool:
Posting on JREF is not the accepted kind of way of actually publishing research. You would know this if you had done a little research...Oh, wait.

And don't think your obsequiousness can conceal your insults.
 
Originally Posted by justintime

If the debate is over a blank page 78 in a treeware version. I have no quarrel about that being true. I have no treeware version of the book to confirm or deny the blank page conspiracy.


Oops! Busted again. Up-thread you identified your copy by an ISBN that corresponds to a printed edition from 1997.

You just can't keep your stories straight.
 
Originally Posted by justintime

There is only one persistent view across this thread and one logical conclusion.

By George, you may accidentally be correct for once.

There is a persistent view that what you try to pass-off as research is really just trolling, and that you are persistently disingenuous.
 
Oops! Busted again. Up-thread you identified your copy by an ISBN that corresponds to a printed edition from 1997.

You just can't keep your stories straight.

You are all confused. The ISBN number was the same as the pdf version. I was surprised you failed to notice it. :cool:
 
so what JiT the point still stands you ahve been caught lying but you have been all the way through this thread.

Now instead of traducing someone who has actually advanced our knowledge why not learn how to do real research and contribute something useful to the world?
 
I pretty much walked away from this thread (in case it's been lost in the noise, I'm the one who started it) once some moderator merged it into some self-pleasuring session for Ubertroll justintime, thereby allowing him to hijack it.

I saw some interesting answers (thank you), and some terrible ones, somewhere near the beginning of the thread. Ignoring any posts that reference Carl Sagan, any posts by Ubertroll justintime, and any responses thereto (including my own--gullible soul that I am, I took a little while before I became skeptical of his sincerity), I say the worst answer prize goes to StankApe. "knows poop when he smells it" is precisely what a skeptic is not. Consolation prize goes to Castro for his toadying seconding of this unintelligent reply.

As for the old saw "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence", I don't find that this defines what a skeptic is. It reminds me of Ross Perot's response when asked to comment on his ideas about foreign policy: "Let me tell you the circumstances under which I would go to war..." While I may agree with the principle, one need not restrict skepticism to extraordinary claims. (I still wonder how "extraordinary" is defined in this statement exactly.)

I find personally that I like arthwollipot's simple definition best.
 
I pretty much walked away from this thread (in case it's been lost in the noise, I'm the one who started it) once some moderator merged it into some self-pleasuring session for Ubertroll justintime, thereby allowing him to hijack it.

I saw some interesting answers (thank you), and some terrible ones, somewhere near the beginning of the thread. Ignoring any posts that reference Carl Sagan, any posts by Ubertroll justintime, and any responses thereto (including my own--gullible soul that I am, I took a little while before I became skeptical of his sincerity), I say the worst answer prize goes to StankApe. "knows poop when he smells it" is precisely what a skeptic is not. Consolation prize goes to Castro for his toadying seconding of this unintelligent reply.

As for the old saw "extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence", I don't find that this defines what a skeptic is. It reminds me of Ross Perot's response when asked to comment on his ideas about foreign policy: "Let me tell you the circumstances under which I would go to war..." While I may agree with the principle, one need not restrict skepticism to extraordinary claims. (I still wonder how "extraordinary" is defined in this statement exactly.)

I find personally that I like arthwollipot's simple definition best.

I tried to do justice to your OP BobR and would have preferred to have Carl Sagan as a separate thread. But I am honored you paid us a visit.

It has been a struggle. I was new to this site and brought forward some ideas I used on a similar OP on What is a skeptic?
Much of what I said originally have been moved to some holding area, so I am not sure if your comments reflect my true beginnings or intentions.

I believe there is a deep desire for skeptics to come to grips with an identity crisis they have been suffering for over 17 years according to Steven Novella. To have a watering hole they can be comfortable in and trust the only laughter they hear are from fellow skeptics, in short an echo chamber.

But there are intellectuals with no natural affiliations also looking for large watering holes and buffaloes to laugh at for no particular reason.

I invited myself to your OP. I just hope you see that as an intrusion rather than a hijack. With the freedoms we enjoy, such extreme measures are unnecessary. Promoting paranoia has been very expensive as have conspiracy theories.

Please feel free to comment. Much has been put into your OP and much will be extracted from it. It may not be what you intended but it sure looks like what people take pleasure in reading.

I agree with you Carl Sagan held himself to a standard he could not live up to. 'Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.' But we know he provided the extraordinary evidence pot smoking induced hallucination should be legalized. No alien has died from such enhanced human curiosity.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by justintime

You are all confused. The ISBN number was the same as the pdf version. I was surprised you failed to notice it.

The ISBN (not ISBN number) you gave for your copy was for a print edition from 1997. The only thing I'm confused about is why you keep telling such transparent falsehoods.
 
Last edited:
I remember a fellow student at University who used to carry around huge books on post modernist theory. Never read anything from them apart from the blurb and some reviews and then manage to ******** about what he had "read" from the book. He was pretty successful with this and it took the teachers almost a year before they caught on. Jit needs to take lessons from him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom