Moderated [Merged] What is a "skeptic"?/Was Carl Sagan a skeptic?

Originally Posted by justintime

Why can't skeptics get electronic copies like the rest of us and save some tress in the process?

Because we have been reading since before electronic copies were available. :D

You do know that there was a world of literate people before the advent of e-books, don't you?

That was a question. :facepalm
 
It is possible treeware versions have blank pages when the press runs out of tree barks. Why can't skeptics get electronic copies like the rest of us and save some tress in the process?
This is where you fail. One of the oldest books in my collection? "The Road To Nowhere" by Maurice Walsh. First published in 1934, my reprint? 1935. Show me your internet now, boy.

Maybe that is why everyone who had a treeware version of The Demon Haunted World had to stop at page 78. Just too much tree to carry around or ship.
Wrong again. My version of that tome is an E version. Stay on your spike.

ETA: Oooo, and right beside it, a 1905 edition of "The Scarlet Pimpernel".
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by justintime

Maybe this treeware version of The Demon Haunted World is a special version with blank pages starting from page 78. The blank pages are for skeptics to carefully tear out and roll them into joints and smoke them.

I spoke earlier about the comedy value of this thread. The above is not an example of such.

There's a difference between being outrageous and being clever.
 
Because we have been reading since before electronic copies were available. :D

You do know that there was a world of literate people before the advent of e-books, don't you?

That was a question. :facepalm

With so many avid treeware readers, one has to ask why so many skeptics devoted so many posts to a blank page 78 in The Demon Haunted World?
 
I spoke earlier about the comedy value of this thread. The above is not an example of such.

There's a difference between being outrageous and being clever.

Just trying to connect the dots between Carl Sagan's drug induced hallucinations and similar symptoms exhibited by his treeware reading fans and the purpose of the blank pages in his books. :cool:
 
Just trying to connect the dots between Carl Sagan's drug induced hallucinations and similar symptoms exhibited by his treeware reading fans and the purpose of the blank pages in his books. :cool:
Well, no, that is not what you are doing.

What you are, in fact, doing, is drawing imaginary dots, connecting them with imaginary lines, then jumping up and down, shouting "hey, everyone, look at my wonderful research".

It doesn't work that way. When you have extensively read Sagan's work, then you might have an opinion. Outright stating you have read nothing means your unfounded opinion may be dismissed without regard. Opinion without evidence may be dismissed without evidence, to paraphrase.
 
Because YOU made a big deal of it, and were proven wrong. Live with it.

Only skeptics are capable of making a big deal out of a blank page. It is there for all to see the many skeptics mesmerized by a blank page 78 in their treeware book and their many posts describing their rapture over a blank page filling several pages in this thread.
 
Originally Posted by justintime

With so many avid treeware readers, one has to ask why so many skeptics devoted so many posts to a blank page 78 in The Demon Haunted World?

Because you were caught in an outright lie. It's been amusing watching you stew in your own juices

How many posts do you think were merited by your outright lie about page 78, and why should we seriously consider anything you say after that?

Hmm?
 
Only skeptics are capable of making a big deal out of a blank page. It is there for all to see the many skeptics mesmerized by a blank page 78 in their treeware book and their many posts describing their rapture over a blank page filling several pages in this thread.
You made a big deal of it. You made an issue of it. Instead of gracefully conceding the point when it was pointed out to you that you were flat out wrong by those WHO HAD THE BOOK IN FRONT OF THEM, you perpetuated the stupid argument. When I pointed out why precisely an E version would omit the blanks, and explained the reasons, YOU, and YOU alone perpetuated the argument.

And YOU did it for one reason, and one reason alone. Your inability to admit you were plain flat out wrong. You went further and engaged in dishonesty to try and support that. It is all here in this very thread, so you cannot back out of it.
 
Originally Posted by justintime
Only skeptics are capable of making a big deal out of a blank page.

Actually, it was you who first made a big deal out of a blank page. You were then proven to be a bare-faced liar.

You know it. Everybody knows it. The record is here on this thread.

Please stop insulting our ability to read the English language, but do continue to entertain us with your dissimulation. :D
 
I might be considered a strategic genius for using a blank page out of a book as a diversionary tactic to draw the skeptics to debate a blank page, while I moved forward with the primary objective to show What is a skeptic and to raise the question Was Carl Sagan really a skeptic.
You expect anyone to really believe that you, the strategic genius :D somehow knew where a blank appeared in a book you never read? Seriously? You should apply for Randi's MDC.
Skeptic discreditors are well aware skeptics are attracted to shiny objects and bigfeet. But there are too many skeptics already snared by these traps and new ways had to be found to draw more seasoned skeptics, who have overcome some of their Pavlovian conditioning to shiny objects and bigfeet.
<snigger> Now you are trying to pretend you did it on purpose. That is a childs excuse for an argument. Sorry, it doesn't work that way.
I used my earlier success with the null hypothesis against skeptics and applied it here in the form of a blank page nullification and surprisingly it did nullify the skeptics who were drawn to a blank page.
You have achieved no success at all with your poorly thought out "arguments", your lack of any research and your general demeanor.

What was rather unexpected was the rush by skeptics to get treeware versions of the book I casually mentioned, The Demon Haunted World. I never read the book myself but since the topic included Carl Sagan I made the recommendation.
Lack of actual research noted.

Lo and behold the skeptics latched on to page 78 because it was BLANK in their treeware version and began to interact with it. How much of my strategy was a result of unintended consequences is hard to assess in this environment of hyperbole.
You were caught in a lie. Your poor to non-existent research was shown for what it is. You cannot not erase the record right here in this thread by suddenly announcing "I meant to do that". Live with it.

But I am sure the outcome will not be too different from AmyWilson's testimony.
What testimony?

First, that is an un-evidenced claim. Second, do you believe reading any book can actually reduce intelligence? Are you really that superstitious and gullible? If so, I have a bridge to sell you.
 
I have owned a copy of The Demon Haunted World as long as you have been able to read, so there was no rush to buy it. When you started glibly tossing-out page numbers to support your non-arguments, I was pretty sure I had you.


Glib:

Characterized by fluency of speech or writing that often suggests insincerity, superficiality, or a lack of concern.


Insincere:

Not sincere; hypocritical.

Superficial:

1. Of, affecting, or being on or near the surface: a superficial wound.
2. Concerned with or comprehending only what is apparent or obvious; shallow.
3. Apparent rather than actual or substantial: a superficial resemblance.
4. Trivial; insignificant: made only a few superficial changes in the manuscript.

:)
 
Only skeptics are capable of making a big deal out of a blank page. It is there for all to see the many skeptics mesmerized by a blank page 78 in their treeware book and their many posts describing their rapture over a blank page filling several pages in this thread.


You do understand how a thread like this works right? That people can go look at previous posts and see what was actually said? You made a claim, it was shot to pieces and rather than simply admit it you've indulged in these cheap shots at those who proved you wrong.
 
so erik van Danikan is creditable and Carl Sagan is not, now I know I am in a parallel universe
 
Let us not lose sight I said my copy did not have a blank page 78 nor did the link to pdf versions have page 78 as a blank page. There was no mention earlier of a treeware version also in circulation. It was recently brought to our attention.

So what was the claim I made that was shot down? :cool:

Well allowing that you are having some sort of short term memory problem...

It was demonstrated that the version you claimed to have in your possession had precisely the blank page you said it didn't. You also stated you didn't believe any paper book had blank pages and that was also comprehensively demonstrated to be wrong. Now you can carry on with this 'I did it deliberately' stance that never works and just further undermines your credibility or you could just concede the error and move on.
 
so erik van Danikan is creditable and Carl Sagan is not, now I know I am in a parallel universe

Both used ancient mythologies and literature in their books. erik van Danikan just postulated some theories but did not have childhood obsessions with aliens, Carl Sagan did. Both later became promoters of the SETI Research Association

"Däniken later became a co-founder of the Archaeology, Astronautics and SETI Research Association (AAS RA). " wiki.

Carl Sagan achieved more public popularity. His pot induced hallucinations took his alien theories to a full scale search for them.

There is no record Däniken was addicted to pot or advocated legalizing it. He is less known among skeptics for his skepticism because he did not have any nor suffered from hallucinations.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom