(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

I seem to notice that there are posters here (don't ask me to name them, because that takes a lot of time and labor -- if you don't agree with me here; well, then don't agree) who might be afflicted with the disease of 'evidentiasis,' so that no evidence is ever appropriate and sufficient.

Permit me an observation of my own. There is at least one poster here (don't ask me to name him, because that takes a lot of time and labor -- if you don't agree with me here; well, then don't agree) who might be afflicted with the disease of "lackofevidentiasis", so that no evidence is ever presented for his claims. :)
 
The Spanish Inquisition: how very Buddhist. :nope:

Oh, Yrreg is not a Buddhist. I'm sure he'd be most insulted to be called a Buddhist (not to mention what the Buddhists might think of it). Yrreg's opinions are not at all influenced by Buddhist ideas. I'm sure that Yrreg's opinions are his own, and since he thinks so highly of himself, I think you could almost call them his "Opus Dei".
 
Let's not be unrealistic, okay?

----------------
Originally Posted by yrreg :
In the meantime, rulers of nations and the United Nations also have to consider the billions who must do with non-evidenced based medicine, the kind perhaps definitively required by you two gentlemen -- even should you find yourselves in a remote village in Nepal where the only medicine practitioner is a traditional acupuncturist? and you are suffering from agonizing and incapacitating back pain, that you can't meditate at all with the traditional posture of meditation the Buddhist or the Yoga way, on your haunches.
-----------------​

Well, if I was in that situation, it probably wouldn't hurt trying. But I'd prefer to use my energy to get myself to a real doctor.

Should the rulers of nations and the UN also consider bleeding as a cheap alternate treatment for the poor and desperate? Or voodoo? Or prayer? Or should they spend all their efforts at getting real medicine to people, medicine that has been proven to work?

I think, if you don't mind, that's not being realistic, comparing acupuncture to bleeding and voodoo, for even in the poorest nations today governments don't sanction bleeding or voodoo as cures for medical complaints. I presume you are being exorbitant with your analogies.

Even in the US and in your country and in every first world land, acupuncture is allowed, and there are doctors of conventional scientific training and successful practice who also do acupuncture, and endorse it -- just as they do with meditation, which you also seek to prove to be evidence-based.

Now, if you were in a remote monastery in Nepal and you can command a helicopter, then you can get to a medical practitioner who does conventional scientific medicine, but I can't imagine the natives having access to such medical personnel and facilities.

--------------------

After all these posts, I am still waiting for more people to come out like you have done, to say that it is impossible to answer yes or no to the question: Acupuncture has effected a cure for a medical complaint.

I seem to have seen Mojo also saying so, but that slip of light seems to have been closeted by his conditioned mind of the kind like Brodski's, insisting that the the question settled definitively already in the negative.

Remember Rumsfeld's defense: Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence; I am sure Rumsfeld got that from Carl Sagan.

Yrreg
 
I am sure you expressed the view that the question: "Yes or No -- Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint," cannot be answered, owing to the need to examine every case ever past, present, and future, and to document them scientifically.
Incorrect.

The view has been expressed that your question can never be answered for any one specific case because of the impossibility of ever excluding coincidental recovery. In any one individual isolated case.

The matter can only be fruitfully addressed statistically, by attempting to ascertain if a group of people treated with real acupuncture fares significantly better overall than a comparable group of people who only thought they'd been treated with real acupuncture. Note the word significantly. Which has connotations regarding the size of the groups, and the way or ways in which the outcomes are measured.

The problem of figuring out how to fool the second group into believing they've had real acupuncture becomes the main consideration, and is the confounder in most of the studies. However, this does not mean that transcendental meditation on a single case to try to divine whether a causal relationship exists is a superior approach.

Rolfe.
 
What is coincidental recovery?

Coincidental recovery, that is one concept that maybe you can explain to the education of less learned and perceptive souls here.

It is recovery, isn't it? in the present context, owing to some connection with acupuncture?

Then secondly it is coincidental.

I would welcome your explanation of coincidental, as in a recovery that is coincidental, understanding: owiig to some connection with acupuncture.

Yrreg
 
... should you find yourselves in a remote village in Nepal where the only medicine practitioner is a traditional acupuncturist? and you are suffering from agonizing and incapacitating back pain, that you can't meditate at all with the traditional posture of meditation the Buddhist or the Yoga way, on your haunches.
Yeah, reaaly. I would trust some quack who doesn't get the concept of "sterile needles" to stick germs, viruses and other contaminants into my imaginary meridians.
I got more advanced training in the Boys Scouts and am much more qualified to treat myself.
But for you, go ahead. Fester.
 
I think, if you don't mind, that's not being realistic, comparing acupuncture to bleeding and voodoo, for even in the poorest nations today governments don't sanction bleeding or voodoo as cures for medical complaints. I presume you are being exorbitant with your analogies.

You presume wrong.

From a 2003 article here: http://www.wehaitians.com/july 2003 news and analysis this month.html

The Catholic Church in the 1940's waged a campaign to eradicate Voodoo. Although unsuccessful, the religion was driven underground for years and disparaged by foreigners as a hodge-podge of beliefs.

In April, however, the Haitian government officially sanctioned it, allowing priests for the first time to legally perform marriages.

Many Voodoo practitioners have been wary of the step, fearful it was taken to woo them to the government of President Jean-Bertrand Aristide, whose popularity is waning with hard times.

"Here we pray to everybody. Some pray to St. James, others to Ogou," said Jean Joseph, 45, a farmer who made the pilgrimage but prayed at the town's Catholic church. "You serve God or the Devil as you like."

Not far from the church where Joseph and other others prayed, men and women stripped down to their shorts, and plunged into a shallow mud basin. They emerged in a trance and said they were transformed.

"When I come out of the basin, I tremble. I feel the might of Ogou, who empowers me all year long," said Voodoo priest Harvey Dorvil, 31.

Around the basin, Voodoo priests, priestesses, and witchdoctors congregate, on the lookout for patients, whose ills they claim they can cure with spells and herbal remedies.

And bloodletting is not only supported by the US government, it's FDA approved...http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/2004/504_leech.html :)

O.K. I'm kidding with the latter - but I believe that bloodletting is still officially sanctioned as an "alternative" therapy in Bhutan, Malaysia and Mongolia at least, and possibly even in Islamic countries under Sharia law.

yrreg said:
Now, if you were in a remote monastery in Nepal and you can command a helicopter, then you can get to a medical practitioner who does conventional scientific medicine, but I can't imagine the natives having access to such medical personnel and facilities.

That's a perfectly valid point. But it still doesn't imply that "traditional remedies" that have no established basis in evidence are actually efficacious for what they claim to do. Nor does it address the possible additional harm a quack "remedy" may cause...
 
Coincidental recovery, that is one concept that maybe you can explain to the education of less learned and perceptive souls here.

It is recovery, isn't it? in the present context, owing to some connection with acupuncture?

Then secondly it is coincidental.

I would welcome your explanation of coincidental, as in a recovery that is coincidental, understanding: owiig to some connection with acupuncture.

Yrreg
No. Coincidence means that there is no cause and effect relationship. So there is no connection in a causal sense between recovery and sticking with needles. No connection. Get it?
 
Coincidental recovery, that is a good idea for a thread.

No. Coincidence means that there is no cause and effect relationship. So there is no connection in a causal sense between recovery and sticking with needles. No connection. Get it?

Well, I was telling Ryokan that I would like to think of a thread on acupuncture that is of a higher level of discourse. Maybe "coincidental recovery and acupuncture" can be a good thread for a higher level of discourse.

-----------------

About Buddhism, no I am no Buddhist, but I do pray with Buddhists and pray to Buddha even, it is very humanly comfortable.

But I took up exchanging views about Buddhism with the Buddhists here, because I thought and still think that they are not critical enough for being skeptics.

Ryokan calls himself here Resident Buddhist, so I call myself Resident Buddhist Critic, out of a naughty whim to call his attention and the attention of his fellow Buddists here.

So also I take up a posture of being sympathetic to acupuncture, to get some reactions from people here who seem to be on auto mode frantically aroused in hostile temper against any so much as a sneeze friendly to acupuncture.

You call that a troll? Maybe I deserve that name; but remember if you ask the authorities here they might just tell you that calling people a troll because they incite discussions is not really what a troll is genuinely about except in a pejorative sense.

In fact, trolls are no longer looked upon with taboo; because if not for trolls people could continue to pursue their secure attitudes with absolute certainty that they possess the final, definitive, and complete knowledge and wisdom of science.


Yes, I am here for fun; and if the authorities should scrutinize my posts they might oust me right away, or continue to extend the welcome mat to me.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
Well, I was telling Ryokan that I would like to think of a thread on acupuncture that is of a higher level of discourse. Maybe "coincidental recovery and acupuncture" can be a good thread for a higher level of discourse...
You don't seem to be hacking it at this level, why aspire to fail at higher levels too?
You know, little steps for little feet.
 
But I took up exchanging views about Buddhism with the Buddhists here, because I thought and still think that they are not critical enough for being skeptics.

Ryokan calls himself here Resident Buddhist, so I call myself Resident Buddhist Critic, out of a naughty whim to call his attention and the attention of his fellow Buddists here.

So also I take up a posture of being sympathetic to acupuncture, to get some reactions from people here who seem to be on auto mode frantically aroused in hostile temper against any so much as a sneeze friendly to acupuncture.

You call that a troll? Maybe I deserve that name; but remember if you ask the authorities here they might just tell you that calling people a troll because they incite discussions is not really what a troll is genuinely about except in a pejorative sense.

In fact, trolls are no longer looked upon with taboo; because if not for trolls people could continue to pursue their secure attitudes with absolute certainty that they possess the final, definitive, and complete knowledge and wisdom of science.

Yes, I am here for fun; and if the authorities should scrutinize my posts they might oust me right away, or continue to extend the welcome mat to me.

There are many definitions of "troll", but the basic idea is someone who is trying to evoke reactions from people, usually in a dishonest way. It also refers to people who try to use others to play their "games" or as subjects for their "experiments" and who claim that they are being reactionary just for fun. Does that ring any bells?

Here is one of the better troll definition pages: http://www.themartialist.com/pecom/fieldguidetotrolls.htm

The Contrarian Troll. A sophisticated breed, Contrarian Trolls frequent boards whose predominant opinions are contrary to their own. A forum dominated by those who support firearms and knife rights, for example, will invariably be visited by Contrarian Trolls espousing their beliefs in the benefits of gun control. It is important to distinguish between dissenters and actual Contrarian Trolls, however; the Contrarian is not categorized as a troll because of his or her dissenting opinions, but due to the manner in which he or she behaves:

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number One: The most important indicator of a poster's Contrarian Troll status is his constant use of subtle and not-so-subtle insults, a technique intended to make people angry. Contrarians will resist the urge to be insulting at first, but as their post count increases, they become more and more abusive of those with whom they disagree. Most often they initiate the insults in the course of what has been a civil, if heated, debate to that point.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Two: Constant references to the forum membership as monolithic. "You guys are all just [descriptor]." "You're a lynch mob." "You all just want to ridicule anyone who disagrees with you."

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Three: Intellectual dishonesty. This is only a mild indicator that is not limited to trolls, but Contrarians display it to a high degree. They will lie about things they've said, pull posts out of context in a manner that changes their meanings significantly, and generally ignore any points for which they have no ready answers.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Four: Accusing the accusers. When confronted with their trolling, trolls immediately respond that it is the accusers who are trolls (see Natural Predators below). Often the Contrarian will single out his most vocal opponent and claim that while he can respect his other opponents, this one in particular is beneath his notice.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Five: Attempts to condescend. Pursued by Troll Bashers (see Natural Predators below), the Contrarian will seek refuge in condescending remarks that repeatedly scorn his or her critics as beneath notice – all the while continuing to respond to them.

– Contrarian Warning Sign Number Six: One distinctive mark of Contrarian Trolls is that every thread in which they dissent quickly devolves into a debate about who is trolling whom. In the course of such a debate the Contrarian will display many of the other Warning Signs mentioned above.

Contrarian warning sign behaviors may be shared by other breeds.

or

The Sophist Troll. Sophist Trolls, or "philotrolls," fancy themselves Enlightened Philosophers or Learned Experts of the highest order. Often well educated, Philotrolls are capable of speaking intelligently on a number of topics, and when the spirit moves them they can be worthwhile forum participants. Unfortunately, Sophist Trolls are an extremely hostile and intolerant species.

When confronted by opinions with which they do not agree – particularly when they do not see any means of successfully arguing their contrary views – Sophists resort (repeatedly) to a variety of intellectually dishonest tactics. Most often, this is characterized by an overly snide, condescending, patronizing attitude. Philotrolls consider anyone with whom they do not agree to be "immature," and are fond of quoting that old saw that "A little knowledge is a dangerous thing."

When cornered they are quick to resort to personal attacks. A philotroll's bag of rhetorical tricks includes a variety of transparent ploys, such as willfully misinterpreting the opponent's words, committing Straw Man fallacies, accusing his or her opponents of engaging in the very tactics used by the philotroll, and so forth.

When engaging in their sophistry, philotrolls are among the most hypocritical and aggravating of trollkind.

or

The Affected Profundity Troll. A mutant subspecies of Sophist Trolls, Affected Profundity Trolls post endless pages of pretentious drivel that is intended to appear wise, but which generally makes little sense (if any). Affected Profundity Trolls enjoy asking themselves questions, sometimes answering them and sometimes leaving them hanging, for they believe this looks intelligent and lends an aura of mystery to their incoherent ramblings. Affected Profundity Trolls aspire to become Sophist Trolls, but lack the intelligence necessary to make the leap.

Although I must admit I am rather partial to this description from: http://www.jayallen.org/journey/2004/05/from_troll_to_doppelganger

There are some people in this world we find annoying. There are others who we find distasteful. There are still others who we find repugnant.

Beyond that, there is the troll.

Not the fairy tale type of troll mind you. Those at least have a touch of culture and class, albeit trollish class. No, we're talking an internet troll.

Trolls are as old as the internet. For those who are lucky enough to have never run across one, they are little people who seem to have nothing better to do than argue ceaselessly and illogically about the topic at hand. They will do anything to engage anyone in their abyss of words for it is the only attention they really ever receive. Because of this, trolls are usually very bitter and angry and have little self-respect.

They also have very small genitals which doesn't help matters...

:D
 
I have to look up your posts, but I am sure you expressed the view that the question: "Yes or No -- Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint," cannot be answered, owing to the need to examine every case ever past, present, and future, and to document them scientifically.
If you look up my posts, you will find that I did not say this. I said that your approach of trying to find a single case where acupuncture had effected a cure would not work because it would not eliminate the possibility of the patient's recovery being entirely unrelated to the treatment. I also suggested an alternative approach, one that is used by real scientists to evaluate the efficacy of medical treatments: the double blind placebo controlled trial. Researchers are currently investigating acupuncture in DBPC trials, but the published evidence is so far inconclusive. It appears that sticking needles into people has some sort of effect, but it is still possible that the difference between control and treatment groups is because of inadequate blinding (it is difficult to devise a convincing placebo for sticking needles into someone). There is also the trial linked to above which found that it doesn't matter where the needles are stuck, which again suggests that the action is nonspecific (placebo?) and certainly suggests that the theory of "meridians" etc. behind acupuncture is bunk.

The question cannot be answered in specific terms (i.e. for a single specific case) because you would never be able to eliminate extraneous causes for recovery, and cannot currently be answered in general terms (i.e. the question "does acupuncture work?") because the evidence from reliable trials is not yet good enough.
 
Anyway, good friends, Ryokan and Mojo...
And don't call me "friend." I have standards, and I certainly don't consider people who attempt to misrepresent me (as you have on more than one occasion) to be "friends".
 
Coincidental recovery, that is one concept that maybe you can explain to the education of less learned and perceptive souls here.

It is recovery, isn't it? in the present context, owing to some connection with acupuncture?

Then secondly it is coincidental.

I would welcome your explanation of coincidental, as in a recovery that is coincidental, understanding: owiig to some connection with acupuncture.
No, it means not connected with the teatment. Go read a dictionary.

The fact that one event happened after another does not mean that the first event caused the second. I can translate your logical fallacy into latin if you want.
 
"Bloodletting" is still a valuable therapy for hemochromatosis - the bodies inability to regulate iron in the blood. It just happens to be done in a manner we call "giving blood" as opposed to slicing a vein and letting it dribble into a bowl.

My co-worker has to go bleed weekly until his iron levels come down. Then he can do so only a few times a year... for the rest of his life. And sadly, the blood is considered useless for donation. I think there is another JREF thread about that.

CT
 
Coincidental recovery, that is one concept that maybe you can explain to the education of less learned and perceptive souls here.

It is recovery, isn't it? in the present context, owing to some connection with acupuncture?

Then secondly it is coincidental.

I would welcome your explanation of coincidental, as in a recovery that is coincidental, understanding: owiig to some connection with acupuncture.

Yrreg
This is really very simple. Suppose you catch a cold. You will not suffer from it forever, even if you do nothing it will go away. So, if you choose to take some treatment, acupuncture or anything else, and your cold goes away, can you say that the treatment cured your cold?

The only way you can tell whether a treatment influences the course of a cold is to take two groups of people, all of whom have colds, and give one half of the group the treatment you want to test. You let the other half believe they're getting the treatment, but actually they aren't. You measure how long it takes every patient to get better. Some will get better more quckly than others. Only by comparing the two groups and seeing whether the half who had the real treatment did objectively better than the half who only thought they were getting the treatment, can you tell whether the treatment itself actually influenced the outcome.

A cold is an easy one because we know they always get better. But what about conditions that only sometimes get better on their own? In this case it is even more important to know what's going on, by doing such a study. Otherwise you get to the stage of claiming every recovery as a success or the treatment, when it may be that these people would have got better anyway.
I would welcome your explanation of coincidental, as in a recovery that is coincidental, understanding: owiig to some connection with acupuncture.
This sounds as if you are perhaps wanting to have it both ways. I have heard some homoeopaths claim that if a patient gets better while they were being treated with homoeopathy, then that is unarguably a "cure" to be credited to homoeopathy. Even if it is only someone with a cold which has run its normal course. They totally reject the logic that if a comparable group of people who didn't get the treatment recover on average just as often or just as frequently as the treated group, this indicates that the treatment is in fact doing nothing.

This is very good for business. You simply acquire patients who have illnesses that will get better, or might get better, and when they get better, you claim a cure. Is it honest? In what way can you claim a cure if in fact a patient in the untreated group has exactly the same probability of recovering as a patient who is treated?

Rolfe.
 
Facts and Figures in Acupuncture 2: pros and cons

The earlier thread started by me has become too emotional.

So I have decided to start a new thread with the same title but calling it "Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture 2: pros and cons," i.e., of acupuncture.

As before I will try to concentrate on the big picture and draft the short statement in regard to acupuncture.

Where is my sympathy?

First and foremost for the facts, then trying to understand the fictions.

As I proceed I might have to change my orientation and approach.

In the previous thread, the oppositions and objections to acupuncture were to my impression overwhelmingly emotional, although there were mentions of placebo, chance event, spontaneous remissions, coincidental recovery, double-blind studies, etc., which are what I might call literal instances of academic attitude.

As before I will try to maintain an academic orientation and approach in the present thread, but not without humor; for I believe that in humor there is more possibility and probability to seeing the better picture and truer one in every issue, than without.

Even though posters here might not be happy with me, yet I believe that acupuncture, the Facts and Fictions 2: pros and cons, can be a very useful discussion for members of this forum who sincerely want to know the facts and fictions, and specially visitors, for their own education and adoption or rejection of acupuncture in their personal health and medical concerns.

Please proceed to next post for a tentative idea of how to find the facts in acupuncture.



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
In the previous thread, the oppositions and objections to acupuncture were to my impression overwhelmingly emotional, although there were mentions of placebo, chance event, spontaneous remissions, coincidental recovery, double-blind studies, etc., which are what I might call literal instances of academic attitude.

I'm not sure what your issue was with the previous thread. Although I didn't participate, I just read it (well, skimmed it), and it was a reasonably good explanations of some of the necessary confounds in any study of proposed medical treatments. Nothing about "coincidental recovery," for example, applies strictly to acupuncture -- it must be taken into account in any halfway-competent analysis of any new treatment method.

Suppose, for example, that I claim that a particular chronic disease -- let's say, ulcers -- can be treated by a novel course of antibiotics. So to test this, I wll give a group of some patients this treatment and a group of other patients a placebo (or another, recognized, treatment).

Now we know that not everyone will respond to treatment in the same way. So rather than focusing on individual cases, I'll look at the group average. If, on average, the experimental groups gets better quicker, then I know that, in fact, ulcers can be successfully treated with antibiotics.

As it happens, this isn't a hypothetical situation at all. It actually happened in the 1980s, and it's resulted in a breakthrough in ulcer treatment.

Now, if you want to claim that, for example, acupuncture can also treat ulcers, we can do the same type of experiment. Unfortunately, the experiments that have been tried on acupuncture have been uniformly negative....
 
I think Yrreg is just too tied in knots by the drubbing he was getting in the other thread, and has moved to this one in the hope of wiping away all the posts that demonstrated just how clearly he wasn't thinking.

Oh well, the homoeopaths do exactly the same thing.

Badly Shaved Monkey had an interesting report about a physiotherapy treatment that was being recommended purely on genuinely-believed anecdotal evidence. The problem was that the range of recovery times for the injury in question was fairly wide, and while the average might be a month, some patients were better in two weeks even if nothing was done. What was happening was that whenever a patient who was receiving the physiotherapy was one of those with a short recovery, lights went on in people's brains, and the belief that the treatment was effective was reinforced. It took a properly controlled study to show that the range of recovery times was the same whether the patients were treated or not. If you were going to recover in two weeks, you would. Physiotherapy or none.

Yrreg seems to want to look for the two-week recoveries where acupuncture was used, and steadfastly refuse to consider that there might be just as many two-week recoveries in patients not treated with acupuncture.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom