(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

I too have researched the efficacy of acupuncture on the web. I have gone to the following sites: British Medical Journal, The Cleveland Clinic, JAMA, NCAM, NIH, WHO, Pubmed, and The Mayo Clinic.

Each of these sites has something positive to say about acupuncture in various capacities. However, not one tackles the issue behind the issue. And you all know what that is: the existence of the ever so ellusive (delusive ?) qi/chi energy. Not one of the sites scientifically states that the functioning principle of acupuncture (qi/chi energy) is a scientific/medical fact. And until some type of empirical evidence for qi/chi is found, the credibility for acupuncture will always be in question.

Then again, maybe all the positive things about acupuncture may give the idea/reality of qi/chi energy a boost in the credibility and authenticity department. Then again maybe not.

Either way, the existence of qi/chi energy seems to be the debate--not the efficacy of acupuncture as a viable and credible mode of health and healing.
 
So, even at the risk of incurring the accusation of Argumentum ad Googlum, we can say that acupuncture commands the interest and attention of many people.

Why does this matter?
 
History of Acupuncture in the US

I have been reading about the history of acupuncture in the US.

I think the following texts from www.emedicinehealth.com might be useful for people who are interested to know briefly the major steps taken by the US Government in regard to the practice of 'medical' acupuncture and its patronage by the US public.

Medical Acupuncture: History http://www.emedicinehealth.com/articles/11678-2.asp

In the United States, accounts of acupuncture began to appear in the medical literature in the mid-1800s. In fact, Sir William Osler included a section on the use of acupuncture for the treatment of "lumbago and sciatica" in his respected textbook The Principles and Practice of Medicine from 1892 through its final edition in 1947. The 1901 edition of Gray's Anatomy included this statement: "The sciatic nerve has been acupunctured for the relief of sciatica."

A turning point in the introduction of acupuncture in the United States came in 1971. James Reston, a reporter for The New York Times, was in Beijing to report on a ping-pong match between China and the United States. While there, he developed acute appendicitis and required an emergency appendectomy. The report of his firsthand experience with acupuncture for the management of his post-operative pain was published on the front page of The New York Times. This sparked an intense interest in acupuncture by the public. Several months later, a report favorable to acupuncture was published in the Journal of the American Medical Association.
In 1987, a major step forward in the acceptance of acupuncture by Western Medicine occurred with the founding of the American Academy of Medical Acupuncture. The AAMA became the sole physician-based acupuncture society in North America.

It is estimated that, by 1991, 8,000 nonphysicians and 1,500 physicians were practicing acupuncture in the United States. An article, published in the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine in 1993 by David Eisenberg, MD, and colleagues reported that $14 billion were spent by Americans in 1990 on "alternative therapies." It was becoming apparent that the public was embracing complementary medicine.

In 1992 the Office of Alternative Medicine was created within the National Institutes of Health. In 1997, the office convened a Consensus Development Conference that resulted in the publication of a Consensus Statement affirming the benefit of acupuncture for certain medical conditions. These conditions included post-operative and chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting, post-operative dental pain, substance addiction, stroke rehabilitation, headaches, menstrual cramps, tennis elbow, fibromyalgia, osteoarthritis, low back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, and asthma.
A significant development in the acceptance of acupuncture in the United States occurred in 1996, when the US Food and Drug Administration reclassified acupuncture needles from the Class III, or "investigational" category that they had been in, to Class IIb, the category that means "safe, effective, but with special restrictions."

In 1998, the Office of Alternative Medicine was expanded to become the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine.

Another first in Medical Acupuncture occurred in April of 2000, with the establishment of the American Board of Medical Acupuncture. The board offered its first certifying examination for physicians in October 2000, allowing physicians the opportunity to demonstrate proof of proficiency in the specialty of medical acupuncture. Physicians who pass the ABMA certifying examination are referred to as Diplomates of the American Board of Medical Acupuncture (DABMA) and are considered board certified in medical acupuncture.

What is the www.emedicinehealth.com?

About Us
http://www.emedicinehealth.com/common/about_us-1.asp

Overview: Launched in 1996, www.eMedicine.com comprises the largest and most current Clinical Knowledge Base available to physicians and other healthcare professionals. eMedicine's subscription site for institutions is www.iMedicine.com. Nearly 10,000 physician authors and editors contribute to the eMedicine Clinical Knowledge Base, which contains articles on 7,000 diseases and disorders. The evidence-based content, updated regularly, provides the latest practice guidelines in 59 medical specialties. eMedicine's professional content undergoes 4 levels of physician peer review plus an additional review by a PharmD prior to publication.

And here is what it says about medicine which I find most useful to anyone who is interested in knowing the pros and cons of a particular medical practice.
http://www.emedicinehealth.com/articles/11678-2.asp

Medicine is a constantly changing science, and clearly established therapies are not always available for every condition. New research findings necessitate continual changes in drug and treatment therapies. The authors, editors, and publisher of this journal have used reasonable efforts to provide up-to-date, accurate information that is within generally accepted medical standards at the time of publication. However, as medical science is ever evolving, and human error is always possible, the authors, editors, and publisher (or any other involved party) do not guarantee total accuracy or comprehensiveness of the information in this article, nor are they responsible for omissions, errors, or the results of using this information. The reader should confirm the accuracy of the information in this article from other sources. In particular, all drug doses, indications, and contraindications should be confirmed in package inserts. FULL DISCLAIMER

Readers who wish to know the critiques against acupuncture can read the posts contributed by fellow members of this forum in this thread, and also earlier threads on acupuncture; and they can use the search function to look up other materials here on acupuncture.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif
 
Acupuncture approved by US government

I am starting another thread on acupuncture, with the same title but accompanied with a different subtitle, namely: "Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture 3: the facts and the explanations."

I will just here post the document from the US government approving the use of acupuncture for medical complaints. I had wanted to also produce here the authorities of other English speaking countries like Australia, Canada, South Africa, New Zealand, Ireland, but the authorities of the UK and the USA are sufficient for the purpose of showing that acupuncture is an approved treatment for medical complaints.

--------------------

Here is the most complete yet concise text giving Americans the authority of the US Department of Health on its approval of acupuncture, through its daughter agency, the National Institutes of Health.


http://consensus.nih.gov/1997/1997Ac...ure107html.htm

Acupuncture
National Institutes of Health
Consensus Development Conference Statement
November 3-5, 1997

NIH Consensus statements and State-of-the-Science statements (formerly known as technology assessment statements) are prepared by a nonadvocate, non-Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) panels, based on (1) presentations by investigators working in areas relevant to the consensus questions during a 2-day public session; (2) questions and statements from conference attendees during open discussion periods that are part of the public session; and (3) closed deliberations by the panel during the remainder of the second day and morning of the third. This statement is an independent report of the panel and is not a policy statement of the NIH or the Federal Government.

<snip>

Conclusions.
Acupuncture as a therapeutic intervention is widely practiced in the United States. While there have been many studies of its potential usefulness, many of these studies provide equivocal results because of design, sample size, and other factors. The issue is further complicated by inherent difficulties in the use of appropriate controls, such as placebos and sham acupuncture groups. However, promising results have emerged, for example, showing efficacy of acupuncture in adult postoperative and chemotherapy nausea and vomiting and in postoperative dental pain. There are other situations such as addiction, stroke rehabilitation, headache, menstrual cramps, tennis elbow, fibromyalgia, myofascial pain, osteoarthritis, low back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, and asthma, in which acupuncture may be useful as an adjunct treatment or an acceptable alternative or be included in a comprehensive management program. Further research is likely to uncover additional areas where acupuncture interventions will be useful.


(Here follows the complete text and lists of panel of experts.)

The next two posts are abridged reproductions of the Consensus statement, for the convenience of readers who want to know the official stand of the US health and medical authorities.

Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am starting another thread on acupuncture, with the same title but accompanied with a different subtitle, namely: "Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture 3: the facts and the explanations."
I guess the second one didn't work out either...
 
Rest of the Consensus Statement on Acupuncture (abridged) 1

Please read the complete text in http://consensus.nih.gov/1997/1997Ac...ure107html.htm
with abundant bibliography and online links.

Introduction
Acupuncture is a component of the health care system of China that can be traced back for at least 2,500 years.

(etc. etc. etc.)

Acupuncture describes a family of procedures involving stimulation of anatomical locations on the skin by a variety of techniques. There are a variety of approaches to diagnosis and treatment in American acupuncture that incorporate medical traditions from China, Japan, Korea, and other countries. The most studied mechanism of stimulation of acupuncture points employs penetration of the skin by thin, solid, metallic needles, which are manipulated manually or by electrical stimulation. The majority of comments in this report are based on data that came from such studies. Stimulation of these areas by moxibustion, pressure, heat, and lasers is used in acupuncture practice, but because of the paucity of studies, these techniques are more difficult to evaluate.

See next post for the remainder of the text (abridged).


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Rest of the Consensus Statement on Acupuncture (abridged) 2

Here is the remainder of the consensus report by the NIH on the US government approval of acupuncture. Please read the complete text in http://consensus.nih.gov/1997/1997Ac...ure107html.htm
with abundant bibliography and online links.

3. What Is Known About the Biological Effects of Acupuncture That Helps Us Understand How It Works?

Many studies in animals and humans have demonstrated that acupuncture can cause multiple biological responses. These responses can occur locally, i.e., at or close to the site of application, or at a distance, mediated mainly by sensory neurons to many structures within the central nervous system. This can lead to activation of pathways affecting various physiological systems in the brain as well as in the periphery. A focus of attention has been the role of endogenous opioids in acupuncture analgesia. Considerable evidence supports the claim that opioid peptides are released during acupuncture and that the analgesic effects of acupuncture are at least partially explained by their actions. That opioid antagonists such as naloxone reverse the analgesic effects of acupuncture further strengthens this hypothesis.

For readers who want to know about the adverse critiques voiced against the report of the NIH on US government approval of acupuncture, they can read the posts of fellow contributors to this topic, acupuncture, here in the JREF forum. Use the search function of the forum to locate pertinent messages.


I am starting a new thread on acupuncture, "Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture 3: the facts and the explanations."

Please join me there.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif

yrreg, this post and the others above are in violation of Rule 4. Do not post copyrighted material in this manner again.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture 3: the facts and the explanations

Previously I had been exchanging views with posters here on acupuncture from my stock knowledge of acupuncture. Now I will bring in materials from societies and peoples who have studied acupuncture to find out the facts and the fictions and the explanations in acupuncture.

---------------

Earlier discussions led me to address one simple question to posters here, namely:

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.​

My purpose was to elicit an agreement that in fact there have been successful cures from acupuncture to medical complaints.

Posters who are adverse to acupuncture however do not seem to be inclined to see the fact, namely, that acupuncture at least has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

I was insisting on the big picture and the short statement, and to my stock knowledge, I answer that question with an Yes; however, if we would be meticulously insistent on science as an open ended discipline and the scientific method as one which can never be satisfied with our observations and verification and/or falsification of more observations, then it would be impossible to answer Yes or No; because we really cannot have studied all the cases of acupuncture treatment past, present, and future, and have done all the observations and verification or falsification of all ever observations done and to be done yet.

Nonetheless, for the present state and stage of science and to the limits of present human resources, we can say that acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint, without unnecessarily bringing in all kinds of qualifications and reservations, to hedge our answer Yes or No.


Posters adverse to acupuncture point out that they have not seen any evidence in support of acupuncture that is scientifically valid.

I was waiting to see if any poster would care to bring in the evidence of a testimonial character and documentary at that, from governmental authorities; but they seem to have missed that kind of evidence from government authorities, testifying namely that acupuncture is in fact effective in some medical complaints and can be safely utilized with the ordinary safeguard exercised by prudent consumers of any medical product and service.

What they are concerned about in regard to testimonial evidence is that it can be purely what is called anecdotal evidence.

Testimonial evidence is not anecdote. In regard to successful acupuncture treatments it is given by MD's who treated patients successfully and from these patients themselves.


So, I guess we will have to ask again the simple question:

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.​

Meaning, Yes or No: it is a fact that there has been at least one successful cure by acupuncture to a medical complaint.

Yes means: Yes, it is a fact that there has been at least one successful cure by acupuncture to a medical complaint.

No means: No, it is not a fact that there has been at least one successful cure by acupuncture to a medical complaint.

​



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif
 
Earlier discussions led me to address one simple question to posters here, namely:

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.​

My purpose was to elicit an agreement that in fact there have been successful cures from acupuncture to medical complaints.

Posters who are adverse to acupuncture however do not seem to be inclined to see the fact, namely, that acupuncture at least has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

And this fact -- and the determined adversity -- should have given you a clue. Especially when the adversity is continually explained to you.

The basic problem is that it's not possible, even theoretically, to determine exactly what "effected" a cure in a medical situation. People often get better all by themselves -- and there's no way of knowing in any individual situation, whether the person got better "all by themselves" at the same time they were taking any particular course of treatment, or whether the treatment had a causal effect.

However, you can make these kind of causal statements (with appropriate caution) when you've got a large enough clinical sample. However, when subjected to this kind of large-scale clinical trial, acupuncture has never shown any effectiveness at all.

I was insisting on the big picture and the short statement, and to my stock knowledge, I answer that question with an Yes

And in answering it, you are flying in the teeth of all the available clinical evidence. In short, you're welcome to answer the question however you like -- but if you answer it with a Yes, you're answering it wrongly.

Nonetheless, for the present state and stage of science and to the limits of present human resources, we can say that acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint,

No, we can't.


Posters adverse to acupuncture point out that they have not seen any evidence in support of acupuncture that is scientifically valid.

... and you have not presented any such evidence.

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.​

Given the current state of clinical evidence? No. Any scientifically reliable evidence you can present to the contrary will, of course, be considered. But I suspect you have no more of this than you had the other two times you asked this question.
 
Yrreg,

Since you asked folks to join you here, I will repond to your last post in the second portion of this hyrda thread here. I can't really tell what you are claiming about the NIH and accupuncture.

1) The closest thing to a positive effect discussed was in the areas of reduction of pain and nausea. The "big picture," as you like to put it, seems to be that more study is needed because nothing was definitive. The panels do not appear to claim that anything was proved.

2) You continue to hint that accupuncture affects "cures." Nowhere in the NIH statements does it say anything about cure of a medical condition. Reduction in pain and nausea, whether or not borne out in the further study recommended, are not a cure of a disease.

3) Since there is no evidence of any of your primary claims in the NIH statements, why even post it? Are you simply attempting to argue by authority?

I am hoping you are going to attempt some concluding statement (as opposed to yet another thread). But since you have provided no evidence of anything, I am hard pressed to see what conclusion about accupuncture could be logically drawn from your posts.

CT

Help beat blood cancers: tinyurl.com/fyrfm
 
I've merged the three "Facts and fictions in acupuncture" threads into one to help keep all the various arguments and the counter-arguments together.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Previously I had been exchanging views with posters here on acupuncture from my stock knowledge of acupuncture. Now I will bring in materials from societies and peoples who have studied acupuncture to find out the facts and the fictions and the explanations in acupuncture.
I have not so far seen any evidence that you have any "stock knowledge of acupuncture". All you seem to have done so far, apart from cutting and pasting stuff from websites that you seem to feel have some sort of authority, is to advance the approach of looking for anecdotal evidence, and to repeatedly ask an unaswerable question despite repeated explanations as to why it is unanswerable without considerable qualification.

Could you please state, in your own words backed up with links to any available evidence, why you think acupuncture is an acceptable treatment option?
 
Last edited:
Acupuncture and Medical Intervention

My knowledge and acquaintance of acupuncture is what I might call stock, meaning not from devoted and concentrated self-study on the subject, but from casual reading, casual thinking and casual observations. You might call it a man in the street knowledge and acquaintance.

It is from such a background that I gave my very first opinion expressed in the thread of Paineroo, "Any value in acupuncture?"

[Post #18 in thread by Paineroo: "Any value in acupuncture?" (reproduced from posts #9 and #14).]
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Acupuncture is an acceptable option for dealing with medical complaints, if you don't have enough money for treatment and medication in conventional scientific medicine, or if conventional scientific medicine has given up on you.

[ etc. etc. etc. etc. ]

Please proceed outside this quote box for specific invitations from yours truly for your calmly considered reactions.
---------------------------

[Kindly give careful attention to phrases in bold.]

----------------
[First published in posts #9 and $14 of thread, "Any value in acupuncture?"]

1. Acupuncture is an acceptable option for dealing with medical complaints, if you don't have enough money for treatment and medication in conventional scientific medicine, or if conventional scientific medicine has given up on you.

-----------------

2. I might be wrong with this suspicion, but if you make a survey of medical complaints treated by acupuncture and treated by conventional scientific medicine, you might just find that the number of successful cases and lasting duration of the successful treatments are quantitatively the same.

3. This rough study means you get people who are treated with acupuncture and people treated with conventional scientific medicine, on the same diseases or medical complaints.
Is this a valid approach for a study? Never tried that; as I said, it is just my almost arbitrary suspicion.

4. Actually I have seen Chinese doctors using their Chinese medical procedures, with herbs or concoctions made directly from herbs, heal patients in cases where conventional scientific medicine has given up.

5. And they cost in most instances less than 20% or even less of what scientific medical practitioners will cost you, with all kinds of drugs, procedures, and equipment expenses and hospitalization. (Addendum: the sky is the limit in professional fees, unless you enjoy socialized medicine.)

6. I said that if you don't have enough money for conventional scientific medicine or this kind of medicine has given up on you, you can and might profitably try acupuncture, and I will add also Chinese medical practitioners working with herbs and drugs directly sourced from herbs, including natural components from organic and mineral origins.

7. I will also add that if you want to experiment because you are not in an urgent medical situation, try the Chinese medical practitioners, you might just save a bundle of money and get the successful lasting treatment for your medical problem.

8. I would like to ask people here whether there are scientific studies of successful treatments done by Chinese doctors in patients given up by conventional scientific medicine.

9. I think that is a good approach for a study: round up people who had been treated successfully by Chinese doctors, who had been earlier given up by medical practitioners of conventional scientific medicine, and find out why the Chinese doctors succeeded where conventional scientific doctors had given up. In this manner conventional scientific medicine stands to gain new knowledge in medicine.

10. Allow me to point out that Chinese medicine is not to be equated with what people might think to consist in gestures and in orations executed by religious medicine men, maybe called tribal healers, who would treat sick people by appeals to invisible agents called spirits.

------------------

For my part I am searching the net for reliable accounts of people given up by doctors of conventional scientific medicine, but healed and still alive and healthy today, by Chinese medical practitioners using their traditional methods, and with herbs or concoctions made from materials of organic and mineral origins.


[Please remain calm and keep to rational mood with your reactions.]

If the authorities here in this JREF forum allow, I would like to go into the aspect of medical intervention in acupuncture.

It is an absorbing inquiry, to find out what is the intervention in acupuncture which can be described as medical and to what medical end it can and even has contributed to.

For example, acupuncture has been attributed to be the intervention that leads to pain relief in a patient. I want to find out the medical condition of pain in a person, and the character of the intervention from acupuncture, and whether this intervention can be credited in any way to the relief of pain, and whether without the intervention the pain could be relieved in the patient, in the same circumstantial aspects as it is attributed to have been relieved with the intervention of acupuncture.


At present I am reading up on what exactly is a medical complaint.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif
 
Acupuncture as an event

With the indulgence of the authorities here...

On 16th February 2006 at 09:16 AM in that thread from yours truly on Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture," post #1 (see annex below), I thought of doing a study of acupuncture from the standpoint of events, namely, before acupuncture, during acupuncture, and after acupuncture.

The purpose was to find out for my own personal enlightenment if indeed there is a beneficial effect in event after, and to determine if event after exhibits a beneficial effect, what could be the responsible ingredient in event during acupuncture, that could account for the beneficial condition in event after.

Of course for some people, and I could be mistaken as regards some people for there could be no people at all (it being all in my mind), nothing absolutely of any beneficial character happens in event after, as studies after studies they maintain of evidence have established irreversibly.

However if I may assume that reports of beneficial effects from acupuncture are genuinely factual, then if I could with the permission of authorities here, I like to continue or resume my study of acupuncture from event before, event during, and event after.

So, if I may proceed, again presuming on the allowance of the authorities here...


I have already a very rough approach to this study.

1. Get some current news reports of people who are so relieved to have their medical complaints finally answered successfully with acupuncture.

2. Divide their treatment history into three phases:

---- a. condition prior to acupuncture,
---- b. event of acupuncture treatment,
---- c. condition post acupuncture.​
3. Seek the factors whatever they be that might be in any way the intervening component in the treatment event that changes the condition prior to acupuncture to the beneficent condition post.​
In step 3 we want to imagine everything imaginable of however negligible connection to the complaint and however unimaginable causality with the healing of the patient.

What are all these possible components, conditions, circumstances, incidental details during the treatment period, that might have an efficacious link in any manner and degree with the successful outcome of the treatment?

Things like for example the weather, or even the body odor of the acupuncturist. Yes, laugh, but we are not going to forgo any of the categories of being in the investigation.

So, first task is to gather some successful accounts of acupuncture treatment done specially by certified practicing MD's who also go into acupuncture as a complementary skill.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Butai.
putai26eo.gif


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

ANNEX

[16th February 2006, 09:16 AM Facts and fictions in acupuncture post 1]

We want to find the facts and locate the fictions in acupuncture.

Facts are independent of man's mind, fictions are in the mind of man and enacted outside.

Why bother to find the facts and the fictions in acupuncture? Perhaps in the process we will realize for a categorical certainty that it is all fictions, or realize that it is both facts and fictions, as in almost everything in man's endeavors.

If we should find out that acupuncture is all fictions, then that is a very good step forward in the advancement of medical knowledge, saving time and trouble and labor to thousands who do take recourse in acupuncture, and give testimonies of their deliverance from bodily pain and discomfort and dysfunction, otherwise not susceptible to successful treatment and medication through conventional scientific medicine.

If on the other hand we should find out at least that there are facts beneficial at that, then we will absolutely also contribute to the advancement of medical knowledge for the relief of suffering -- which is the eternal concern of Buddhists: for Buddhists here, that is one great solution to your quest, so no need to spend time and patience and torture in meditation.

It is a win win exercise, the search for the facts and the fictions in acupuncture.

----------------

I have already a very rough approach to this study.

1. Get some current news reports of people who are so relieved to have their medical complaints finally answered successfully with acupuncture.

2. Divide their treatment history into three phases:

---- a. condition prior to acupuncture,
---- b. event of acupuncture treatment,
---- c. condition post acupuncture.​
3. Seek the factors whatever they be that might be in any way the intervening component in the treatment event that changes the condition prior to acupuncture to the beneficent condition post.​
In step 3 we want to imagine everything imaginable of however negligible connection to the complaint and however unimaginable causality with the healing of the patient.

What are all these possible components, conditions, circumstances, incidental details during the treatment period, that might have an efficacious link in any manner and degree with the successful outcome of the treatment?

Things like for example the weather, or even the body odor of the acupuncturist. Yes, laugh, but we are not going to forgo any of the categories of being in the investigation.

So, first task is to gather some successful accounts of acupuncture treatment done specially by certified practicing MD's who also go into acupuncture as a complementary skill.


Please stay posted, and remember we will change the approach as we proceed when modifications of perspectives and strategies are dictated for the sake of making the exercise more promising and easier and quicker, and of course more easy to apprehend on the part of non-partisan observers.
 
I have merged another one of yrreg's acupuncture threads into this one. We do not need another thread re-stating what is already stated here.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Expert testimony from a doctor scientist researcher

I have merged another one of yrreg's acupuncture threads into this one. We do not need another thread re-stating what is already stated here.
__________________

I am the Lizard Queen

If I didn't have inner peace, I'd completely go psycho on all you guys, all the time. -- Carl Carlson

There's no "I" in team, but there's a "Me" in mediocre.

Smart is sexy.

Thanks, Lisa. You are my kind of skeptic.


I would like to present here an expert testimony from a doctor scientist researcher in re beneficial medical effect of acupuncture.


Abstract

Annual Review of Medicine
Vol. 51: 49-63 (Volume publication date February 2000)
(doi:10.1146/annurev.med.51.1.49)


Acupuncture: An Evidence-Based Review of the Clinical Literature

David J. Mayer*
Department of Anesthesiology, Medical College of Virginia, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia, 23298–0337, ; email: [email protected]


This chapter reviews the experimental literature on the effects of acupuncture treatment. The review covers the 14 medical conditions for which the National Institutes of Health Acupuncture Consensus Development Panel (NIHCDP) concluded that acupuncture either is effective (2 conditions) or may be useful (12 conditions). My conclusions partially support those of the NIHCDP. There is evidence that acupuncture is effective for the treatment of postoperative and chemotherapy induced nausea and vomiting. Also, some data indicate that acupuncture may be useful for headache, low back pain, alcohol dependence, and paralysis resulting from stroke (4 of the 12 conditions for which the NIHCDP found that acupuncture may be useful). For most of the remaining conditions, there is little evidence that acupuncture is either effective or ineffective. It is recommended that workers in the field design double blind, sham controlled trials using adequate acupuncture treatment regimens, with specific hypotheses, and sample sizes sufficient to allow both positive and negative conclusions.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif
 
Point blank: Yes or No: Acupuncutre has effected a cure to a medical complaint?

On the basis of the research and conclusion made by David J. Meyer:

There is evidence that acupuncture is effective for the treatment of postoperative and chemotherapy induced nausea and vomiting. Also, some data indicate that acupuncture may be useful for headache, low back pain, alcohol dependence, and paralysis resulting from stroke (4 of the 12 conditions for which the NIHCDP found that acupuncture may be useful).

If I were to ask him point blank, to answer Yes or No, to the following question:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint?​

What do people here think he would answer in one word, choosing Yes or No.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
twobudes5rb.gif
 
If I were to ask him point blank, to answer Yes or No, to the following question:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint?​

What do people here think he would answer in one word, choosing Yes or No.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha
Haven't you done this riff already?

If you're not sure, try scrolling back up the thread.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom