(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

So, according to you in your own words:

Originally Posted by Mojo:
It is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment [acupuncture ] works for a single case [cure].


Or you really wanted to state that:

It is not possible (...) that a treatment [acupuncture] works for a single case [cure]. [Removing the phrase "to demonstrate"]

Please be more specific.
I mean what I said. Note that I included the words "to demonstrate" in that sentence, and that I did not include the word "acupuncture". It is not possible to demonstrate that any treatment works by looking at a single case. If you're just looking at a single case, it is always possible that any observed improvement is caused by something other than the treatment being considered, or that the patient would simply have got better anyway. Go back and read the rest of the post, and take care to read all the words, not just selected words that you think bolster your case.
 
Last night I had a headache, and read some Japanese comics before I went to bed. And when I woke up, the headache was gone! True story!

Japanese comics heal headaches!

I know this is just a single case, and entirely anecdotal, but that's enough, isn't it?
 
Oh dear. I suspect that yrreg will shortly be starting a thread called "Facts and fictions in Japanese comics".
 
Last night I had a headache, and read some Japanese comics before I went to bed. And when I woke up, the headache was gone! True story!
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. :)
 
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. :)

Is one at least one successful Japanese comic treatment fact, or all are fictions?

Why just ask for only one successful Japanese comic treatment? Because the adversaries of Japanese comics as a headache cure insist with all certainty that in all these decades of Japanese comic reading, there has not been accomplished one genuine truly medically authentic successful cure of headache.

-------

Well, what do you guys say here, who are adamant with complete and absolute certainty that Japanese comics have not produced in all the decades of its practice one successful headache cure, that can hurdle all the criteria of a successful treatment as demanded by today's conventional scientific medicine?

Just please answer that question or participate by reading but don't post -- unless and until you want to answer that question.
 
Last edited:
Why just ask for only one successful Japanese comic treatment? Because the adversaries of Japanese comics as a headache cure insist with all certainty that in all these decades of Japanese comic reading, there has not been accomplished one genuine truly medically authentic successful cure of headache.
Emotional responses such as this are inhibiting of a clearer mode of discussiveness, clouding of the creative facility as you might think they are.
I am here and you are here and we are all together. Don't shoot the messenger, there's no Art in that.
[Goo goo ga joob]

Yuri
 
Just a simple Yes or No.

Yrreg said:
So, according to you in your own words:

Originally Posted by Mojo :
It is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment [acupuncture ] works for a single case [cure].​

Or you really wanted to state that:

It is not possible (...) that a treatment [acupuncture] works for a single case [cure]. [Removing the phrase "to demonstrate"]​

Please be more specific.

Thanks for your reply.

Mojo said:
I mean what I said. Note that I included the words "to demonstrate" in that sentence, and that I did not include the word "acupuncture". It is not possible to demonstrate that any treatment works by looking at a single case. If you're just looking at a single case, it is always possible that any observed improvement is caused by something other than the treatment being considered, or that the patient would simply have got better anyway. Go back and read the rest of the post, and take care to read all the words, not just selected words that you think bolster your case.

If I may, do you think that you are disposed to answer these two questions below with an yes or no answer?

---------------
1. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.

Yes means: In regard to acupuncture, yes, it is possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.

No means: In regard to acupuncture, no, it is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.​
2. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible that a treatment works for a single case.

Yes means: In regard to acupuncture, yes, it is possible that a treatment works for a single case.

No means: In regard to acupuncture, no, it is not possible that a treatment works for a single case.​
---------------------

In all events, thanks for your continued interest.



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
Emotional responses such as this are inhibiting of a clearer mode of discussiveness, clouding of the creative facility as you might think they are.
I am here and you are here and we are all together. Don't shoot the messenger, there's no Art in that.
[Goo goo ga joob]

Yuri
:dl:
 
1. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.
Read and understand the post you were replying to, and you'll know my position on this.

2. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible that a treatment works for a single case.
It's not a question of whether it is possible, but of whether there is evidence that it actually works. At the moment there is evidence that sticking needles into people has an effect on them, but the evidence that the specific effects claimed for acupuncture are anything more than placebo is not good.

A particular problem for the theory of acupuncture, of course, is the absence of the structure of "meridians" on which it is said to rely. The theory arose at a time in which dissection of human bodies was not allowed in China, so people just guessed about what might lie below the skin. And guessed wrongly.
 
A simple Yes or No -- call 2.

Thanks for your reply.



If I may, do you think that you are disposed to answer these two questions below with an yes or no answer?

---------------
1. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.

Yes means: In regard to acupuncture, yes, it is possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.

No means: In regard to acupuncture, no, it is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.​
2. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible that a treatment works for a single case.

Yes means: In regard to acupuncture, yes, it is possible that a treatment works for a single case.

No means: In regard to acupuncture, no, it is not possible that a treatment works for a single case.​
---------------------

In all events, thanks for your continued interest.

If I may, I think you have not answered my original question, now put in an Yes or No formulation:

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medicall complaint.​

Just, answer Yes or No.


And also please just answer Yes or No to the two questions in the quote box.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medicall complaint.​

Just, answer Yes or No.

How can we answer this? It's impossible to know.

All we have a re the numerous scientific researchs into acupuncture, and they all conclude that there is nothing in acupuncture beyond the placebo effect.


And also please just answer Yes or No to the two questions in the quote box.

Ditto for those questions.

Yrreg, you probably won't answer this question, but what if I had used the same rhetoric on Buddhism in your critical to Buddhism threads? Would you have accepted it?
 
Last edited:
If I may, I think you have not answered my original question, now put in an Yes or No formulation:

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medicall complaint.​

Just, answer Yes or No.
I don't know: the evidence is not good enough to make a definitive statement one way or the other. There is certainly not enough evidence to conclude that it works. There are published studies that suggest that sticking needles into people has some sort of effect, but there is no strong evidence supporting acupuncture's specific claims to be more than a placebo effect. While there are some studies that appear to support it, there may be problems with the blinding (it is difficult to produce a convincing placebo for sticking a needle into somebody), and there was a study published last year in which it was found that it didn't matter where the needles were stuck (the "sham acupuncture" involved sticking the needles in points other than acupuncture points: see here), suggesting strongly that all the stuff about meridians and acupuncture points is nonsense.

As I have already said, the mere fact that someone's condition has improved after they received a treatment does not mean that the treatment caused the improvement.
 
Step by step, okay?

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

Just answer Yes or No.
How can we answer this? It's impossible to know.

All we have are the numerous scientific researchs into acupuncture, and they all conclude that there is nothing in acupuncture beyond the placebo effect.
------------------
And also please just answer Yes or No to the two questions in the quote box.

Ditto for those questions.
-----------------

Yrreg, you probably won't answer this question, but what if I had used the same rhetoric on Buddhism in your critical to Buddhism threads? Would you have accepted it?

Yrreg: Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. Just answer Yes or No.

Ryokan: How can we answer this? It's impossible to know.​
--------------

Dear good friend, Ryokan, you tell me that "it's impossible to know" whether to choose Preposition 1 (P-1) or Proposition 2 (P-2), as fact:

P-1: Yes: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint.
​

---------------

Please confirm if that is your mind.

-------------------

Yrreg, you probably won't answer this question, but what if I had used the same rhetoric on Buddhism in your critical to Buddhism threads? Would you have accepted it? -- Ryokan​

Good friend Ryokan, I like to engage in that exercise with you described in your question above; please start a thread here in this forum and I will accommodate you. We will have a lot of fun.

---------------------

Remember everyone here, I don't know about you guys but I am here for the fun.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
Let's see how Ryokan answers my preceding post.

Originally Posted by yrreg:

Thanks for your reply.

If I may, do you think that you are disposed to answer these two questions below with an yes or no answer?

---------------

1. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.

Yes means: In regard to acupuncture, yes, it is possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.

No means: In regard to acupuncture, no, it is not possible to demonstrate that a treatment works for a single case.
2. In regard to acupuncture, Yes or No: It is possible that a treatment works for a single case.

Yes means: In regard to acupuncture, yes, it is possible that a treatment works for a single case.

No means: In regard to acupuncture, no, it is not possible that a treatment works for a single case.​
---------------------

In all events, thanks for your continued interest.

If I may, I think you have not answered my original question, now put in an Yes or No formulation:

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medicall complaint.

Just answer Yes or No.​

And also please just answer Yes or No to the two questions in the quote box.

-----------------

I don't know: the evidence is not good enough to make a definitive statement one way or the other. There is certainly not enough evidence to conclude that it works. There are published studies that suggest that sticking needles into people has some sort of effect, but there is no strong evidence supporting acupuncture's specific claims to be more than a placebo effect. While there are some studies that appear to support it, there may be problems with the blinding (it is difficult to produce a convincing placebo for sticking a needle into somebody), and there was a study published last year in which it was found that it didn't matter where the needles were stuck (the "sham acupuncture" involved sticking the needles in points other than acupuncture points: see here), suggesting strongly that all the stuff about meridians and acupuncture points is nonsense.

As I have already said, the mere fact that someone's condition has improved after they received a treatment does not mean that the treatment caused the improvement.

Thanks, Mojo, for your continued interest in this thread.

Let's see the answer of Ryokan to my preceding post.

Best regards.

Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
The big picture in the short statement.

Originally Posted by yrreg :
Thanks, Mojo, for your continued interest in this thread.

Let's see the answer of Ryokan to my preceding post.
​

-----------------

Don't you want to respond to what I've posted?

Mojo, thanks for your continued interest in this thread.

I am working on the big picture in the short statement about facts and fictions in acupuncture.

I might get somewhere or might get nowwhere or even expose myself to be an ignorant bumpkin, but the fun is in the trying.

So, again:

Thanks, Mojo, for your continued interest in this thread.

Let's see the answer of Ryokan to my preceding post. --

Originally Posted by yrreg

​


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
I think maybe what some of these people are trying to tell you is that sure, it's great you want to get facts about accupuncture, but you're going about it in entirely the wrong fashion. You don't get facts and/or proof from anecdotal evidence, as Ryokan pointed out fairly well, as did others. Your first outline of how to accomplish your fact finding goals immediately dooms it to failure because it's set up to fit your personal views already. It doesn't follow scientific method. Then, when people point that out, you get wrapped up in semantics and make it impossible to continue.

You've also provided nothing as far as evidence or proof to even warrant *starting* this discussion, considering that there has been evidence presented stating that it *isn't* a valid form of medical treatment. Until you can dispute those claims or provide evidence to the contrary (evidence, not anecdotes), you don't seem to have much ground to stand on.

Or I'm way off base. Just the way it seems to me.
 
Yrreg: Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. Just answer Yes or No.

Ryokan: How can we answer this? It's impossible to know.​
--------------

Dear good friend, Ryokan, you tell me that "it's impossible to know" whether to choose Preposition 1 (P-1) or Proposition 2 (P-2), as fact:

P-1: Yes: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint.
​

---------------

Please confirm if that is your mind.

Yes, the question is impossible to answer, and I can't choose either your preposition 1 or your preposition 2. To answer, I would have to review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind, and all those cases would have to be documented scientifically. If you don't see that the question is imposible to answer, you're the worst sceptic I've ever met.

Yrreg, you probably won't answer this question, but what if I had used the same rhetoric on Buddhism in your critical to Buddhism threads? Would you have accepted it? -- Ryokan​

Good friend Ryokan, I like to engage in that exercise with you described in your question above; please start a thread here in this forum and I will accommodate you. We will have a lot of fun.

You must think I'm an idiot. Do you really think I'm going to start a new thread looking for answers from you to specific questions, when you're not even answering the ones in this thread?
 
Yes, the question is impossible to answer, and I can't choose either your preposition 1 or your preposition 2. To answer, I would have to review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind, and all those cases would have to be documented scientifically.
Actually, if you're looking at individual cases, the problem wouldn't be resolved by proper documentation. Even if an individual patient improves after receiving a particular treatment, you cannot conclude that the treatment caused the improvement. To draw any solid conclusions about a treatment's effectiveness you have to eliminate other factors such as spontaneous improvement, and you cannot do this by looking at anecdotal evidence. You have to conduct controlled trials. This is why yrreg's approach of looking at individual cases is nonsense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom