(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

So, you see we have achieved a consensus that is most important to my education and enlightenment, namely:

That folks here have the attitude or certainty even, that acupuncture effects cures to medical complaints.​
Do you have any evidence to support of your claim "that folks here have the attitude or certainty even, that acupuncture effects cures to medical complaints"? Please provide links to relevant posts, if you can.

You are suggesting that because Pragmatist has said that it is not the attitude of people here that acupuncture definitely does not work, then it must be the attitude of people here that it does. This is a false dilemma. There is a third possibility: that people think that the evidence is not yet good enough to make a definite conclusion one way or the other.
 
So, you see we have achieved a consensus that is most important to my education and enlightenment, namely:

That folks here have the attitude or certainty even, that acupuncture effects cures to medical complaints.​
Incidentally, why do you feel that this is so important? You stated in your OP that you want to find out the facts about acupuncture. Why is it so important to you to arrive at a conclusion as to peoples' belief? This will not have any effect on the facts.
 
Incidentally, why do you feel that this is so important? You stated in your OP that you want to find out the facts about acupuncture. Why is it so important to you to arrive at a conclusion as to peoples' belief? This will not have any effect on the facts.
Y.reg has always been more interested in the effects of "stirring the ants' nest" and in pseudo-Zen-master type outpourings than in any debate about acupuncture

Yuri
 
Okay, let's have a poll here.

Okay, guys -- but first let's all have a good laugh together: hahahahahaaaaaaaaa -- let's have a poll here. I don't know how to do one. So, you just tell me, folks here who are not happy with me, Yes or No, to this sentence:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

So, everyone here who have been reacting with me on acupuncture and more specifically here in my own thread, "Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture," imagine that you are shipwrecked in an island where the chieftain there wants to find out: whether you can see the big picture and and perceive the short statement.

He devised a test for all the passengers and crew by which he can eliminate those, who can't see the big picture and understand or formulate the short statement to convey the big picture.

He tells everyone to answer one by one, Yes or No, to the following sentence:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

But first he lets you people discuss among yourselves for one whole day what is the answer to give in order to save your lives, each one of you.

Then each one of you by raffle will approach him to tell him his answer, while the rest observe from afar and can't hear the answer.

The one telling the chieftain the answer he wants to hear will be allowed to live, while the one giving the wrong answer will immediately in full view of but not hearing distance, be dispatched to the next world, with a clean slash on the neck by his burly assistant swinging a massive machete.

Imagine you folks are the passengers and crew of the ship, what will your answer be, one by one?


Oh yes, I almost forgot, that chieftain was educated in the U.S.A., in seeing the big picture and saying the short statement.



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
How many times must you be explained this, Yrreg?

I'll try to paint you a picture, once again, using the 'big picture and short statement'.

First, your answer just can't be answered with yes or no. It's as simple as that.

Second, people here are sceptics. Sceptics want to see evidence before they make up their mind on things. All evidence (not anecdotal, but actual double blind tests on large groups) so far suggests that acupunture is either just as good, or just a bit better, than the placebo effect. In other words, you could just as well take a sugar pill.

If evidence to the contrary is presented, sceptics will change their minds.

Do you understand? Please answer yes or no :p
 
So, everyone here who have been reacting with me on acupuncture and more specifically here in my own thread, "Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture," imagine that you are shipwrecked in an island where the chieftain there wants to find out: whether you can see the big picture and and perceive the short statement.

He devised a test for all the passengers and crew by which he can eliminate those, who can't see the big picture and understand or formulate the short statement to convey the big picture.

He tells everyone to answer one by one, Yes or No, to the following sentence:
Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.


But first he lets you people discuss among yourselves for one whole day what is the answer to give in order to save your lives, each one of you.

Then each one of you by raffle will approach him to tell him his answer, while the rest observe from afar and can't hear the answer.

The one telling the chieftain the answer he wants to hear will be allowed to live, while the one giving the wrong answer will immediately in full view of but not hearing distance, be dispatched to the next world, with a clean slash on the neck by his burly assistant swinging a massive machete.

Imagine you folks are the passengers and crew of the ship, what will your answer be, one by one?


Oh yes, I almost forgot, that chieftain was educated in the U.S.A., in seeing the big picture and saying the short statement.

Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha
This may come as a bit of a surprise to you, but threats and ultimatums are not generally the best way to arrive at the truth. You're likely to just hear what people think you want to hear.

The Spanish Inquisition: how very Buddhist. :nope:
 
All evidence (not anecdotal, but actual double blind tests on large groups) so far suggests that acupunture is either just as good, or just a bit better, than the placebo effect. In other words, you could just as well take a sugar pill.
Or maybe that it's just a more convincing placebo than a sugar pill. Some placebos are more "effective" than others. Dummy treatments that look as if they're an actual physical intervention (e.g. sticking a needle into somebody) tend to invoke the placebo effect more strongly than, for example, pills.
 
yrreg said:
Imagine you folks are the passengers and crew of the ship, what will your answer be, one by one?
The village talks it over and realizes a leader willing to kill his own subjects if he does not hear what he wants regarding a logical fallacy is not fit to rule. Being educated in the west, the chieftan may or may not be smart enough to abdicate before the citizenry "have him replaced."

CT
[sharpening his virtual pitchfork ;) ]
 
The one telling the chieftain the answer he wants to hear will be allowed to live, while the one giving the wrong answer will immediately in full view of but not hearing distance, be dispatched to the next world, with a clean slash on the neck by his burly assistant swinging a massive machete.
You can kill people by e-mail... Cool

Sorry, did that one before.

Yuri
 
I know he's already been asked if he's stopped beating his wife, answer yes or no, I just felt like repeating it.

Rolfe.
 
Ryokan and Mojo, question can't be answered?

I have to look up your posts, but I am sure you expressed the view that the question: "Yes or No -- Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint," cannot be answered, owing to the need to examine every case ever past, present, and future, and to document them scientifically.

We are seemingly in a situation of ars longa vita brevis What do you say?


Ryokan, didn't you call me something, like worst skeptic ever?


I am looking for a way to raise the discourse to a higher level, like the character of evidence in medicine, which is not the same in generic view as the character of evidence in Buddhism?

What do you say, Ryokan and Mojo, can we raise the discourse to a higher level?


I seem to notice that there are posters here (don't ask me to name them, because that takes a lot of time and labor -- if you don't agree with me here; well, then don't agree) who might be afflicted with the disease of 'evidentiasis,' so that no evidence is ever appropriate and sufficient.


Anyway, good friends, Ryokan and Mojo, am I correct in my memory to have read in your posts somewhere that the question: "Yes or No -- Acupuncture has effected a cure in a medical complaint," cannot be answered in the circumstances of the real world; because we would have to examine -- as I already mentioned earlier here in this post -- every case past, present, and future of acupuncture intervention, and document every case scientifically (which science is an open-ended discipline where we have not yet had and never will ever have all the final definite answers to life and the universe).


I will think of a new thread on acupuncture where we can arrive at a more agreeable consensus or dissent, maybe some definite case of acupuncture intervention, and analyze placebo, anecdotal evidence, double-blind, chance event, etc.

In the meantime, rulers of nations and the United Nations also have to consider the billions who must do with non-evidenced based medicine, the kind perhaps definitively required by you two gentlemen -- even should you find yourselves in a remote village in Nepal where the only medicine practitioner is a traditional acupuncturist? and you are suffering from agonizing and incapacitating back pain, that you can't meditate at all with the traditional posture of meditation the Buddhist or the Yoga way, on your haunches.



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
I know he's already been asked if he's stopped beating his wife, answer yes or no, I just felt like repeating it.

Rolfe.

It's quite obvious that Yrreg is not here to answer questions, he's here to conduct monologues.

Although it's equally obvious that I haven't really learned that lesson yet :boxedin:
 
Ryokan, didn't you call me something, like worst skeptic ever?

An exaggeration, of course. I'm sure there are worse, but I haven't encountered anyone lately. Especially one who labels himself sceptic, and a super-sceptic at that ;)

I am looking for a way to raise the discourse to a higher level, like the character of evidence in medicine, which is not the same in generic view as the character of evidence in Buddhism?

What do you say, Ryokan and Mojo, can we raise the discourse to a higher level?

That would be great. We've been trying since post 2.


I seem to notice that there are posters here (don't ask me to name them, because that takes a lot of time and labor -- if you don't agree with me here; well, then don't agree) who might be afflicted with the disease of 'evidentiasis,' so that no evidence is ever appropriate and sufficient.

Yeah, we've heard this one before. But that's what sceptics do, we look at evidence before we make up our mind. And that evidence has to be solid. You should know this, being a super-sceptic.


I will think of a new thread on acupuncture where we can arrive at a more agreeable consensus or dissent, maybe some definite case of acupuncture intervention, and analyze placebo, anecdotal evidence, double-blind, chance event, etc.

If you're up for it, that'd be great!

In the meantime, rulers of nations and the United Nations also have to consider the billions who must do with non-evidenced based medicine, the kind perhaps definitively required by you two gentlemen -- even should you find yourselves in a remote village in Nepal where the only medicine practitioner is a traditional acupuncturist? and you are suffering from agonizing and incapacitating back pain, that you can't meditate at all with the traditional posture of meditation the Buddhist or the Yoga way, on your haunches.

Well, if I was in that situation, it probably wouldn't hurt trying. But I'd prefer to use my energy to get myself to a real doctor.

Should the rulers of nations and the UN also consider bleeding as a cheap alternate treatment for the poor and desperate? Or voodoo? Or prayer? Or should they spend all their efforts at getting real medicine to people, medicine that has been proven to work?
 
Last edited:
yrreg;1461975I have also read them [posts in the two threads on acupuncture said:
all and got the impression "that it is the common attitude of folks here:

However, good friend Pragmatist, if you have the opposite impression and even certainty "that it is not the common attitude of folks here, meaning:

Then I defer to your impression and even certainty, meaning I was wrong with my impression, that folks here have the common attitude that acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning I accept your sure conclusion from the posts in the two threads concerned, that acupuncture for the folks here has effected cures to medical complaints.

A skeptic wouldn't take anybody's word for it, he'd actually look at the evidence and make up his mind based on that evidence.

I didn't make any such conclusion as "that acupuncture for the folks here has effected cures to medical complaints", it's a classic logical fallacy on your part, the false dichotomy. On the remote possibility that you may genuinely not understand what logical fallacies are and that you are not simply being deliberately obnoxious, this web site: http://www.fallacyfiles.org/ will be extremely useful for you. In particular this page: http://www.fallacyfiles.org/eitheror.html (they call it the "false dilemma" fallacy).

yrreg said:
Well, I am so glad that the folks here, who have contributed to the two threads in question about acupuncture, do maintain that acupuncture has effected cures to medical complaints, as testified to by Pragmatist on his reading of the posts in these two threads: Any value in Acupuncture? and Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture.

I didn't author the first thread, Any Value to Acupuncture; but I authored the second thread, the present one here, precisely to ask about the Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture.

And honestly I am so glad, good friend Pragmatist, that you have succeeded to show me the most important fact, namely, that for the folks here:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.​

Since you are such a polite person, and since you now know that I didn't say anything of the sort, I'm sure you will be more than happy to apologise for lying about what I said, now that you (hopefully) understand your fallacy.

yrreg said:
So, we need not have to quarrel any further.

Who's quarreling? I asked you to present evidence to support your claims. You were unable to do so. That isn't quarrelling, that's skepticism.

yrreg said:
Now, perhaps we should give our attention and concentration to find out very deeply and extensively whatever evidence we can unearth for those cases where acupuncture does effect cures to medical complaints, keeping in mind all the caveats against placebo, spontaneous remission, chance, and of course making sure that our examinations are conducted in a double-blind manner where double-blind control is possible.

Okay?

Nobody's stopping you. Feel free to present evidence of the above.

yrreg said:
So, you see we have achieved a consensus that is most important to my education and enlightenment, namely:

That folks here have the attitude or certainty even, that acupuncture effects cures to medical complaints.​

As I said, there is no such concensus. I never said nor implied anything of the sort. But again, as you claim to be a polite and courteous person who is concerned with honesty, integrity and civility, I am quite confident that you will apologise for misrepresenting my statements in such a manner, because to do so is surely most uncivil, wouldn't you agree?
 
IRyokan, didn't you call me something, like worst skeptic ever?

Oh, that's awful, I agree, it's totally out of order and Ryokan should be soundly rebuked for making such a statement. Please let me do so.

Ryokan: This is really not acceptable, please desist from such behaviour in future, please stop calling Yrreg a skeptic... :mad:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom