(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

Just please answer that question or participate by reading but don't post -- unless and until you want to answer that question.
I don't think the question is worth answering. It's so simplistic that it demonstrates the questioner has a very incomplete understanding of the logic of evidence.

I'm just posting to assert my right to post in any thread I wish to post in, and demonstrate that I'm not subject to Yrreg's orders.

Rolfe.
 
Nice Try

If I may, I think you have not answered my original question, now put in an Yes or No formulation:

Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medicall complaint.​

Just, answer Yes or No.

Of course, this needs to be divided into two questions:

Yes or No: People receiving acupuncture treatment for a medical complaint have felt relief from their complaint
Answer: Yes. This is supported by many studies, in addition to the usual anecdotal evidence.

Yes or No: This relief was caused by the acupuncture treatment.
Answer: Difficult to tell for sure. Studies so far have clearly been showing "No".

That's why nobody is willing to answer only "Yes or No" to your question, it is actually a 2-part question with different answers for each part.
 
Now, let's sit back and see the reactions of people here.

Post of Ryokan Yesterday, 02:44 PM #39
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1457029&postcount=39
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1456766#post1455774

Yrreg: Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. Just answer Yes or No.

Ryokan: How can we answer this? It's impossible to know.
--------------

Dear good friend, Ryokan, you tell me that "it's impossible to know" whether to choose Proposition 1 (P-1) or Proposition 2 (P-2), as fact:

P-1: Yes: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint.
---------------

Please confirm if that is your mind.

[Ryokan:] Yes, the question is impossible to answer, and I can't choose either your preposition 1 or your preposition 2. To answer, I would have to review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind, and all those cases would have to be documented scientifically. If you don't see that the question is imposible to answer, you're the worst sceptic I've ever met.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1456766#post1455774

Yrreg, you probably won't answer this question, but what if I had used the same rhetoric on Buddhism in your critical to Buddhism threads? Would you have accepted it? -- Ryokan

Good friend Ryokan, I like to engage in that exercise with you described in your question above; please start a thread here in this forum and I will accommodate you. We will have a lot of fun.

You must think I'm an idiot. Do you really think I'm going to start a new thread looking for answers from you to specific questions, when you're not even answering the ones in this thread?
End of Post of Ryokan Yesterday, 02:44 PM #39
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1457029&postcount=39

=================================

To recapitulate:​
Yrreg: Yes or No: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. Just answer Yes or No.
Ryokan: How can we answer this? It's impossible to know.
Yrreg: Dear good friend, Ryokan, you tell me that "it's

impossible to know" whether to choose Proposition 1 (P-1) or Proposition 2 (P-2), as fact:

P-1: Yes: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint.

Please confirm if that is your mind.

Yes, the question is impossible to answer, and I can't choose either your preposition 1 or your preposition 2. To answer, I would have to review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind, and all those cases would have to be documented scientifically. If you don't see that the question is imposible to answer, you're the worst sceptic I've ever met.

======================


Dear Ryokan: first I am not engaging in semantic tricks or any kind of tricks here.

You say: "the question is impossible to answer, I can't choose either your preposition 1 or your preposition 2."[Because it's] "impossible to know" whether to choose Proposition 1 (P-1) or Proposition 2 (P-2), as fact:

P-1: Yes: Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint.
​

However, unless I am mistaken, the general conviction here is that the question can be answered and answered in the negative, namely:

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​

Isn't that what people are saying here, that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint?

So they believe that the question of the choice between P-1 or P-2 is possible to know, to answer; and they do know and do answer and that in the negative:

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​

In which negative choice obviously they have "reviewed every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind," and "have documented scientifically all those cases," QED.

All contrary to your conviction:

Ryokan:
Yes, the question is impossible to answer, and I can't choose either your preposition 1 or your preposition 2. To answer, I would have to review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind, and all those cases would have to be documented scientifically. If you don't see that the question is imposible to answer, you're the worst sceptic I've ever met.

---------------------

So, shall we wait and see how people react to your position, who maintain that:

(P-2) No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​

--------------------

About this other matter:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1456766#post1455774

Yrreg, you probably won't answer this question, but what if I had used the same rhetoric on Buddhism in your critical to Buddhism threads? Would you have accepted it? -- Ryokan

Good friend Ryokan, I like to engage in that exercise with you described in your question above; please start a thread here in this forum and I will accommodate you. We will have a lot of fun.

You must think I'm an idiot. Do you really think I'm going to start a new thread looking for answers from you to specific questions, when you're not even answering the ones in this thread?

Suppose you tell me what kind of topic on Buddhism you have in mind, and I will be to one to sponsor a thread on it, not you; would that be all right now? Then you can use the same rhetoric as I am using here, or any rhetoric you prefer.

--------------------

Back to acupuncture, I tend to agree with you that the question whether or not "Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint," is impossible to know, to answer: one way or the other.

And I tend to agree with you: because "To answer, I would have to review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind, and all those cases would have to be documented scientifically," which is impossible.

Let's sit back and wait to see how people react to this insight of ours; shall we, good friend Ryokan?


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
Back to acupuncture, I tend to agree with you that the question whether or not "Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint," is impossible to know, to answer: one way or the other.

And I tend to agree with you: because "To answer, I would have to review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind, and all those cases would have to be documented scientifically," which is impossible.
So I take it, then, that you do not claim to know of any case where acupuncture has effected a cure, because if you did you would just be able to point to it, rather than having to "review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind" in the hope of finding one.

However, as I and others have already pointed out to you, there is a simpler way to find out whether or not it works: controlled and blinded trials. There are researchers who are actually doing this. The published results are so far rather inconclusive, partly because of the difficulty in devising a convincing placebo, and, of course, a major problem for proponents of acupuncture was shown up by the study I cited above that strongly suggested that the theory behind acupuncture is bunk. I have no doubt the progress towards some sort of conclusion will eventually be made.
 
Ask Ryokan first.

So I take it, then, that you do not claim to know of any case where acupuncture has effected a cure, because if you did you would just be able to point to it, rather than having to "review every case of treatment by acupuncture in the history of mankind" in the hope of finding one.

However, as I and others have already pointed out to you, there is a simpler way to find out whether or not it works: controlled and blinded trials. There are researchers who are actually doing this. The published results are so far rather inconclusive, partly because of the difficulty in devising a convincing placebo, and, of course, a major problem for proponents of acupuncture was shown up by the study I cited above that strongly suggested that the theory behind acupuncture is bunk. I have no doubt the progress towards some sort of conclusion will eventually be made.

Ask Ryokan first, he is the one who says that it is impossible to know whether or not acupuncture has effected a cure in a medical complaint. because it would be necessary to have examined every instances of acupuncture and have it documented -- which according to him is impossible.

Actually I maintain an open mind and agree with him; but on the other hand, I am looking for at least one case of successful acupuncture that satisfies all the controls imposed upon it in order to pronounce that a cure did occur and it is due to the acupuncture intervention.

You are keen on evidence that can prove the efficacy of acupuncture, but I keep thinking of the evidence being sought by scientists who do examine the efficacy of acupuncture.

And I came upon this statement from Carl Sagan, namely, that absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

I think Rumsfeld resorted to that argument in re weapons of mass destruction in Ir ag. Hahahaha.

However, I think Carl Sagan has a very good point there, if I understand him correctly.

Here is an example I have thought up which I believe is very common with the quest for evidence.

There ar aerial plants which can survive and grow and reproduce in the air without support for food in soil and water -- apparently. Now, suppose that some people had never come across such plants, then the first time they encounter them, the keep looking for soil and water from the ground which should have gotten to the aerial plants by one way or another.

In this case they are looking for evidence of nutrients and water from the ground; so they are looking in the wrong direction.

Is that a good example of looking for evidence in the wrong or not productive directions. There are also cases of looking for evidence of the kinds already customarily looked for and not finding them, but there might be found evidence of the kinds not customarily being looked for.

About aerial plants, I might have to correct myself in regard to how they really get their nutrients and water.

I will get back to you as soon as I have done more reading about aerial plants.

Right now I have to get ready to leave for work.

Thanks Mojo for your interest.

Let's wait and see what Ryokan says about your post.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif


PS I have to go now, the wife is calling me to breakfast and if I don't report pronto, she will pick up everything and then no breakfast for me.
 
However, unless I am mistaken, the general conviction here is that the question can be answered and answered in the negative, namely:

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint.

Yes, you are either mistaken, or deliberately misrepresenting what has been said.

yrreg said:
Isn't that what people are saying here, that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint?

I would strongly suggest you go and learn some basic logic, as you constantly seem to fall into the same fallacies. No, that is not what people are saying here. What people are saying here is what they have actually said - which is that they have not seen any convincing evidence that shows acupuncture to be effective for anything, beyond possible placebo effect.

yrreg said:
So they believe that the question of the choice between P-1 or P-2 is possible to know, to answer; and they do know and do answer and that in the negative:

That doesn't follow, it is another logical fallacy based on your own misrepresentation of other's responses.
 
Yrreg specifically stated that acupuncture would be an "acceptable" course of treatment for those who had only limited resources for medicine, yet he can't seem to grasp the fact that those are the people who should be targeting their resources towards proven effective treatments. If you can only afford one treatment, you best pick the right one, if you've got money to waste playing pincushion, and still have enough to see a real doctor, then obviously your priorities will be slightly different.
All the studies I have seen on acupuncture show acupuncture to be, at best, only slightly better than placebo, nothing like the miraculous cures that many proponents claim, and certainly nowhere near as effective as conventional medicine for pain relief (which is the area which acupuncture shows most "promise" in).
 
Actually I maintain an open mind and agree with him; but on the other hand, I am looking for at least one case of successful acupuncture that satisfies all the controls imposed upon it in order to pronounce that a cure did occur and it is due to the acupuncture intervention.
You will not find such a case, for reasons that have already been explained. For a start, you would never be able to eliminate the possibility of spontaneous improvement unrelated to the treatment.

What you need to look at is controlled trials with a large enough sample size for a reliable conclusion to be drawn.

You are keen on evidence that can prove the efficacy of acupuncture, but I keep thinking of the evidence being sought by scientists who do examine the efficacy of acupuncture.
No, you don't. You keep harping on about your mythical N=1 anecdote of a successful cure. If you want to know what real scientists are doing to examine the efficacy of acupuncture, I suggest that you go on Pubmed and look for reports of properly controlled and blinded clinical trials.
 
A simple yes or no, then explain briefly.

Well, I guess I have to insist that you folks answer: yes or no, to this sentence:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​

then explain briefly.

Or say as Ryokan did, that it's impossible; and give your reasons why it's impossible, as Ryokan did.

We want to have the big picture in the short statement.


The way I see it, you bring in all kinds of concepts and explanations which diffuse and mess up the issue unnecessarily.


The more systematic course is to formulate as I have done the issue in a statement, as above, namely:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​



Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
Well, I guess I have to insist that you folks answer: yes or no, to this sentence:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​

You just don't get it. This is not really one premise, it is two.
1. People who use acupuncture feel relief.
2. The relief is not just from placebo, but actually caused by acupuncture.

Most people here agree with #1 and disagree with #2.
 
Well, I guess I have to insist that you folks answer: yes or no, to this sentence:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​

then explain briefly.

Or say as Ryokan did, that it's impossible; and give your reasons why it's impossible, as Ryokan did.

We want to have the big picture in the short statement.


The way I see it, you bring in all kinds of concepts and explanations which diffuse and mess up the issue unnecessarily.
The concept that has been introduced, of the placebo controlled blinded trial, is vitally important if you want to establish whether or not a treatment is effective. You take two sets of patients, give one set the treatment, and the other set a dummy treatment that they consider to be the real thing, then you look for differences in outcome between the two groups. As the only difference between them is that one was treated and the other wasn't, a difference in outcome between the two groups can be said with reasonable confidence to be the result of the treatment. This is the only way you will eliminate factors other than the treatment under consideration.
 
Taking a medical board exam, just answer yes or no.

Originally Posted by yrreg:

Well, I guess I have to insist that you folks answer: yes or no, to this sentence:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.
​

--------------------

You just don't get it. This is not really one premise, it is two.

1. People who use acupuncture feel relief.
2. The relief is not just from placebo, but actually caused by acupuncture.

Most people here agree with #1 and disagree with #2.

There have been people who failed to pass in board examinations because they cannot see the big picture and make the short statement.

Suppose you are taking a medical board examination and the questions are all to be answered with Yes or No, how would you answer the following question? and very important the scoring of the examination would be right answers minus wrong answers, meaning: if the right answers you obtain is 75 and the wrong answers you obtain is 25, and perfect score is 100, then your score for the examination is 50 -- this means if you really cannot answer, don't answer, just leave the Yes and No boxes empty.

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint. ​


--------------------

I want to tell you also that you have nonetheless contributed to further clarification of the issue.


Yrreg
 
That's the attitude, isn't it?

----------------
Originally Posted by yrreg :
However, unless I am mistaken, the general conviction here is that the question can be answered and answered in the negative, namely:

P-2: No: Acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint.
------------------
​

Yes, you are either mistaken, or deliberately misrepresenting what has been said.

----------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Isn't that what people are saying here, that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint?
----------------
​

I would strongly suggest you go and learn some basic logic, as you constantly seem to fall into the same fallacies. No, that is not what people are saying here. What people are saying here is what they have actually said - which is that they have not seen any convincing evidence that shows acupuncture to be effective for anything, beyond possible placebo effect.

-------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg :
So they believe that the question of the choice between P-1 or P-2 is possible to know, to answer; and they do know and do answer and that in the negative:
----------------
​

That doesn't follow, it is another logical fallacy based on your own misrepresentation of other's responses.

Would you require me to produce texts from the posters here and also from the mother thread authored by Paineroo,
to show you that it is the attitude of folks here "that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint?"

Or would you please yourself read the mother thread carefully and thoughtfully, "Any Value in Acupuncture?" and also more carefully and thoughtfully the posts in this present thread?


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
There have been people who failed to pass in board examinations because they cannot see the big picture and make the short statement.
If you think that the "big picture" can be expressed in a "short statement" for the topic being discussed here, please make your "short statement", and stop wasting time. You have said that you are "one guy in a hurry", after all.
 
Would you require me to produce texts from the posters here and also from the mother thread authored by Paineroo,
to show you that it is the attitude of folks here "that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint?"

Yes. Please show me the specific evidence in support of your claim that it is the attitude of folks here, "that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint."

Thank you. I await your production of that evidence.

yrreg said:
Or would you please yourself read the mother thread carefully and thoughtfully, "Any Value in Acupuncture?" and also more carefully and thoughtfully the posts in this present thread?

I have read them all. Have you by the way? Unfortunately I didn't see any evidence that supports the claim you have made above. Nor your original claim that acupuncture was "acceptable" therapy under certain conditions or in certain circumstances.

I'm sure you wouldn't want skeptics on here to think of you as someone who simply makes unsupported claims and then runs away or engages in evasive techniques to avoid presenting evidence in support of them, and so with that in mind I'm sure you'll be more than happy to back up your various claims with some solid evidence. Won't you...?
 
If you think that the "big picture" can be expressed in a "short statement" for the topic being discussed here, please make your "short statement", and stop wasting time. You have said that you are "one guy in a hurry", after all.

Hmm...let's see. So far the "short statement" has consisted of 45 posts by Yrreg in two threads (not to mention specifically starting this thread). And so far the evidence shown by Yrreg in support of his claims is precisely...wait a moment...let me count up all the items of evidence...uh...zero...?

I guess I'm somewhat skeptical of the efficacy of the "short statement" on the basis of the evidence thus far...
 
Exam?

There have been people who failed to pass in board examinations because they cannot see the big picture and make the short statement.

Suppose you are taking a medical board examination and the questions are all to be answered with Yes or No, how would you answer the following question? and very important the scoring of the examination would be right answers minus wrong answers, meaning: if the right answers you obtain is 75 and the wrong answers you obtain is 25, and perfect score is 100, then your score for the examination is 50 -- this means if you really cannot answer, don't answer, just leave the Yes and No boxes empty...

You obviously have no knowledge of what such examinations entail. Such a question would not be asked. The many posters that you have ignored have described the kind of study that would answer a real question, such as , "Does acupucture, as opposed to a placebo, show a statistically significant effect on a specific measurable medical condition in a well controlled double blind study."
 
Yrreg,

Please answer yes or no to the following question:
Do you still beat your spouse?

Answering within the guidelines leaves the impression that at least at one time you have beaten your spouse. There is nowhere on the test to even indicate you have no spouse.

This is not to say that such incorrect/meaningless/false choice questions cannot appear on an exam. A college buddy got no points on a question in which he was to calculate the height a particular fluid would be drawn up a tube by capillary action. He correctly pointed out that the fluid chosen would not be drawn up at all, rather than answer what the instructor wanted. Too bad - no points for being right.

You state you are here to have fun. Hopefully that is not intended to be at the expense of those honestly trying to help. Many are here to have fun as well. In addition, many are here to gain new knowledge, and not continue to flog the deceased equine of questions with logical fallacies.

CT
 
I will take your word for it...

--------------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Would you require me to produce texts from the posters here and also from the mother thread authored by Paineroo,


to show you that it is the attitude of folks here "that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint?"
-------------------------​

Yes. Please show me the specific evidence in support of your claim that it is the attitude of folks here, "that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint."

Thank you. I await your production of that evidence.

-----------------------------
Originally Posted by yrreg :
Or would you please yourself read the mother thread carefully and thoughtfully, "Any Value in Acupuncture?" and also more carefully and thoughtfully the posts in this present thread?
-----------------------------------------​

I have read them all. Have you by the way? Unfortunately I didn't see any evidence that supports the claim you have made above. Nor your original claim that acupuncture was "acceptable" therapy under certain conditions or in certain circumstances.

I'm sure you wouldn't want skeptics on here to think of you as someone who simply makes unsupported claims and then runs away or engages in evasive techniques to avoid presenting evidence in support of them, and so with that in mind I'm sure you'll be more than happy to back up your various claims with some solid evidence. Won't you...?
-------------------
I have read them [posts in the two threads on acupuncture] all. Have you by the way? Unfortunately I didn't see any evidence that supports the claim you have made above. -- Pragmatist
-------------------
​

I have also read them [posts in the two threads on acupuncture] all and got the impression "that it is the common attitude of folks here:

that acupuncture in fact has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has not led to any cure to any one case of a medical complaint.

However, good friend Pragmatist, if you have the opposite impression and even certainty "that it is not the common attitude of folks here, meaning:

that acupuncture in fact has effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning acupuncture has led to cures to cases of medical complaints.

Then I defer to your impression and even certainty, meaning I was wrong with my impression, that folks here have the common attitude that acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning I accept your sure conclusion from the posts in the two threads concerned, that acupuncture for the folks here has effected cures to medical complaints.

Well, I am so glad that the folks here, who have contributed to the two threads in question about acupuncture, do maintain that acupuncture has effected cures to medical complaints, as testified to by Pragmatist on his reading of the posts in these two threads: Any value in Acupuncture? and Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture.

I didn't author the first thread, Any Value to Acupuncture; but I authored the second thread, the present one here, precisely to ask about the Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture.

And honestly I am so glad, good friend Pragmatist, that you have succeeded to show me the most important fact, namely, that for the folks here:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.​

So, we need not have to quarrel any further.
-------------------

Now, perhaps we should give our attention and concentration to find out very deeply and extensively whatever evidence we can unearth for those cases where acupuncture does effect cures to medical complaints, keeping in mind all the caveats against placebo, spontaneous remission, chance, and of course making sure that our examinations are conducted in a double-blind manner where double-blind control is possible.


Okay?

-------------------

So, you see we have achieved a consensus that is most important to my education and enlightenment, namely:

That folks here have the attitude or certainty even, that acupuncture effects cures to medical complaints.​


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
-------------------
I have read them [posts in the two threads on acupuncture] all. Have you by the way? Unfortunately I didn't see any evidence that supports the claim you have made above. -- Pragmatist
-------------------
​
I have also read them [posts in the two threads on acupuncture] all and got the impression "that it is the common attitude of folks here:



However, good friend Pragmatist, if you have the opposite impression and even certainty "that it is not the common attitude of folks here, meaning:



Then I defer to your impression and even certainty, meaning I was wrong with my impression, that folks here have the common attitude that acupuncture has not effected a cure to a medical complaint, meaning I accept your sure conclusion from the posts in the two threads concerned, that acupuncture for the folks here has effected cures to medical complaints.

Well, I am so glad that the folks here, who have contributed to the two threads in question about acupuncture, do maintain that acupuncture has effected cures to medical complaints, as testified to by Pragmatist on his reading of the posts in these two threads: Any value in Acupuncture? and Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture.

I didn't author the first thread, Any Value to Acupuncture; but I authored the second thread, the present one here, precisely to ask about the Facts and Fictions in Acupuncture.

And honestly I am so glad, good friend Pragmatist, that you have succeeded to show me the most important fact, namely, that for the folks here:

Acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.​


So, we need not have to quarrel any further.
-------------------

Now, perhaps we should give our attention and concentration to find out very deeply and extensively whatever evidence we can unearth for those cases where acupuncture does effect cures to medical complaints, keeping in mind all the caveats against placebo, spontaneous remission, chance, and of course making sure that our examinations are conducted in a double-blind manner where double-blind control is possible.


Okay?

-------------------

So, you see we have achieved a consensus that is most important to my education and enlightenment, namely:
That folks here have the attitude or certainty even, that acupuncture effects cures to medical complaints.​

Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
sod it, this ignore thing is just too hard on me, Yrregs post seem to be like a sore I just can't stop picking at.
Anyway Yrreg I will answer your question.
I do not believe that acupuncture has ever cured any medical complaint. I am willing to change my mind on this if you can either1) show me one case where acupuncture ahs cured someone, where you can clearly demonstrate that their recovery was caused by the acupuncture, and not just coincidental spontaneous remission.
Failing that
2) Show me controlled experiments which show that patients using acupuncture (as opposed to a placebo) either where more likely to get better, or got better faster than the control groups.
Until this evidence is supplied I will keep with my underlying assumption that acupuncture has never cured anyone and does not work, just as, until I know there is evidence to the contrary, I assume that every other proposed "medical" treatment does not work, and has never cured anybody.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom