(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

Authorities in acupuncture

I just entered acupuncture into Google web search and it returned the following statistics (followed by the listing of 9,180,000 links):

Web Results 1 - 100 of about 9,180,000 for acupuncture [definition]. (0.13 seconds) ​

So, even at the risk of incurring the accusation of Argumentum ad Googlum, we can say that acupuncture commands the interest and attention of many people.

Would it be all right now to seek some authoritative statement about this subject, acupuncture; I mean we want to read something that is, shall we say, supposed to tell us what is good and what is bad to life and health from someone or some agency having the responsibility to tell us so.

Who or what in society is tasked to tell us when we are in a situation of need to know some authoritative statement about what is good or bad to our life preservation and our health maintenance, in the present context about acupuncture?

Would it be logical and sensible to look up government offices?

Then if we can't trust their statements, look up critiques of these statements.

But we have got to make sure that the government people and agencies we resort to belong to democratic regimes which uphold free inquiry and free speech in their citizenries.

I will now look up such government agencies and sources in English speaking countries, because I am literate in English, not because I don't trust governments of democratic countries with free inquiry and free speech, of peoples speaking German or Dutch or French or Spanish or Italian.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
Oh, I'm a glutton for punishment.

Yrreg, why do you think the best course is to seek authorities on whom to rely?

What would be your criteria regarding whom to accept as an authority? Surely, that they have reliable information as to whether acupuncture works or not. In that case, where will they have acquired that information? From looking at the results of properly-controlled trials, of course! Otherwise they are merely speculating, and have no authority.

So, understanding that, what purpose might it serve to seek such authorities? Having found a possible authority, the first thing one would be required to do would be to test his authority by examining the strength of the evidence on which he was relying. In other words, look at the reports of controlled trials, and decide whether you agreed with his assessment.

Why not just cut out the middle-man?

In fact there are a handful of publications which (at least at first sight) appear to satisfy the criteria of being properly-controlled studies which show a positive effect for acupuncture. If you had been searching seriously for information, rather than just googling randomly to fuel a rather pointless conversation, you would have found them by now.

As a little hint, I will mention post-operative nausea, and arthritis of the knee. Finding the relevant studies is left as an exercise for Yrreg.

Then we might look at the details, and examine whether in fact there might have been flaws in the studies, and even discuss the concept of statistical flukes.

After that, if we ever get that far, we might even introduce the concept of the requirement for replication.

On the other hand we could just talk aimlessly, without finding out anything. Guess which I think Yrreg is going to do?

Rolfe.
 
What would be your criteria regarding whom to accept as an authority?

I suspect the real answer is that someone who agrees with Yrreg is an "authority" and anyone who doesn't, isn't! :D

I don't see any need for a new thread on the same subject, can we have a mod ruling on whether this should be merged with the other, please?
 
I guess the fact that Yrreg appears to have abandoned this thread in favour of another identical one means that he does not intend to show evidence of his various claims in this one.

And I also note that given that Yrreg claims to be extremely concerned about civility and decent behaviour, it is somewhat telling that he doesn't see fit to apologise for misrepresenting what I, Mojo and others on here have posted. I guess we can take that as evidence of just how decent and civil Yrreg really is, or not.

...with emphasis on the not... :rolleyes:
 
UK Government approves of and provides free acupuncture.

Would it be all right now to seek some authoritative statement about this subject, acupuncture; I mean we want to read something that is, shall we say, supposed to tell us what is good and what is bad to life and health from someone or some agency having the responsibility to tell us so.

Who or what in society is tasked to tell us when we are in a situation of need to know some authoritative statement about what is good or bad to our life preservation and our health maintenance, in the present context about acupuncture?

Would it be logical and sensible to look up government offices?

Then if we can't trust their statements, look up critiques of these statements.

But we have got to make sure that the government people and agencies we resort to belong to democratic regimes which uphold free inquiry and free speech in their citizenries.

I will now look up such government agencies and sources in English speaking countries, because I am literate in English, not because I don't trust governments of democratic countries with free inquiry and free speech, of peoples speaking German or Dutch or French or Spanish or Italian.

I found the UK Government giving acupuncture free to UK citizens.

Is complementary therapy available on the NHS?
http://www.nhsdirect.nhs.uk/chq.asp?Classid=17&Articleid=911

Complementary therapy is gradually becoming more widely available on the NHS. At the moment, the kind of complementary treatment you can access depends somewhat on where you live in England. However, complementary therapies are being introduced in more healthcare settings, including hospitals, GP surgeries and community clinics. Ask your GP if you’re not sure what’s available in your area.

There are five NHS homeopathic hospitals in the UK. They are located in Bristol, Glasgow, Liverpool, London and Tunbridge Wells, Kent. Most hospital clinics offer some form of complementary therapy. Acupuncture is often used in pain clinics, and aromatherapy and massage may be used in the treatment of cancer. Osteopathy and chiropractic are commonly used to treat bone and joint problems such as back pain, often alongside physiotherapy and heat treatment.

Lots of GPs have completed further training in complementary therapies, and may be able to provide treatments such as acupuncture, homeopathy and osteopathy directly from the surgery. Other GP surgeries can refer you to complementary therapists in the area. If you contact a therapist yourself for private treatment, make sure they are fully qualified and an accredited member of the appropriate organisation, (for example, the British Acupuncture Council).

16/11/2005 13:28:45


What is the NHS or National Health Service in the United Kingdom?

History of the NHS
http://www.nhs.uk/england/aboutTheNHS/history/default.cmsx

The National Health Service or NHS as it is more commonly known, was set up on the 5th July 1948 to provide healthcare for all citizens, based on need, not the ability to pay.

The NHS is funded by the taxpayer and managed by the Department of Health, which sets overall policy on health issues. It is the responsibility of the Department of Health to provide health services to the general public through the NHS.

It was launched as a single organisation based around 14 regional hospital boards. This new NHS was originally split into three parts:

1. hospital services
2. family doctors, dentists, opticians and pharmacists
3. local authority health services, including community nursing and health visiting​

So, it is a fact in UK that the government approves of acupuncture and dispenses it freely to the citizens.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
So? We knew this. There are political reasons. This is not evidence of efficacy.

Rolfe.
 
I found the UK Government giving acupuncture free to UK citizens.




What is the NHS or National Health Service in the United Kingdom?



So, it is a fact in UK that the government approves of acupuncture and dispenses it freely to the citizens.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
The UK government supports homeopathy far more than it supports acupuncture, Does that therefore mean that homeopathy is more effective than acupuncture?
As Rolfe pointed out, the provision of CAM on the NHS is down to political, rather than medical, reasons. What's more, CAM treatments in the UK are specifically excluded of the requirement to prove themselves effective before being offered on the NHS.
Every new "conventional" treatment must be evaluated by the UK's National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE). For some reasons proponents of "CAM" do not seem to want their treatments to be examined as robustly as other treatments, and have strongly resisted calls for CAM treatments to be evaluated by NICE prior to their use by the NHS, perhaps you could offer an explanation as to why?
So please, Yrreg, answer the questions.
1)Does the fact that the UK government supports homeopathy more than acupuncture make homeopathy more effective than acupuncture? Yes/no .
2) Can you give a convincing reason why those that advocate CAM treatments, resist calls for those treatments to be proven effective?
 
British Medical Association on acupuncture

I am producing here the approval of acupuncture by the British Medical Association.

Acupuncture wins BMA approval - British Medical Association - News
British Medical Journal, July 1, 2000 by Mark Silvert
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0999/is_7252_321/ai_63713358

Acupuncture should become more widely available on the NHS and family doctors should be trained in some of its techniques, a BMA inquiry has concluded. The therapy has proved effective in treating back and dental pain, nausea and vomiting, and migraine, the BMA's Board of Science and Education has found after a two year study.

Acupuncture is one of the most frequently requested of the complementary therapies. Up to five million people may have consulted a therapist specialising in complementary or alternative medicine in the past year, the report says.
Welcoming the report, Dr Richard Halvorsen, a GP and press officer for the British Medical Acupuncture Society, said: "It indicates a complete change in the way that the medical establishment views complementary therapies." The study was commissioned in 1998 to "investigate the scientific basis and efficacy of acupuncture and the quality of training and standards of competence in its practitioners." It reviewed literature and current research on acupuncture and examined safety aspects, including adverse effects.

Complication rates associated with acupuncture are "relatively low," the study found. They generally fall into one of three categories: physical injuries, infections, and other adverse reactions. Many of the physical injuries could be avoided by ensuring that acupuncturists are fully trained in anatomy and physiology, with particular emphasis on teaching the location and depth of major organs. Inadequate or improper sterilisation techniques constitute a serious risk factor for infections, and this is recognised by professional acupuncture bodies and reflected in their codes of practice, states the report.
Transmission of infections can be avoided if all practitioners use only sterile disposable needles rather than reusable needles, which need sterilisation. Other adverse reactions include more minor events such as bleeding on withdrawal of the needle, bruising, and drowsiness. A survey of UK family doctors carried out as part of the study showed that nearly half had arranged acupuncture for patients and 58% had referred patients for some form of complementary or alternative medicine. The BMA is calling for a national register of all acupuncturists who are medically or non-medically qualified and for a national surveillance system to report adverse events.
Dr Vivian Nathanson, head of health policy at the BMA, said: "We need to see more high quality research into the effectiveness of acupuncture. Greater use of acupuncture would save the NHS millions of pounds each year." However, she added that a consensus needed to be built on the minimum standards of training required for all potential acupuncture practitioners.

The BMA hopes that the National Institute for Clinical Excellence will consider the value of acupuncture as a next step and produce guidance for the NHS.

It is a fact that the British Medical Association of doctors approves the use of acupuncture for medical complaints.

Readers who wish to read critiques adverse to the British government's approval and utilization of acupuncture for its citizens, and also the British Medical Association's approval and employment as well, can look up the posts of fellow forum members here contributing to this thread.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
 
I am producing here the approval of acupuncture by the British Medical Association.





It is a fact that the British Medical Association of doctors approves the use of acupuncture for medical complaints.

Readers who wish to read critiques adverse to the British government's approval and utilization of acupuncture for its citizens, and also the British Medical Association's approval and employment as well, can look up the posts of fellow forum members here contributing to this thread.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
putai26eo.gif
1)Does the fact that the UK government supports homeopathy more than acupuncture make homeopathy more effective than acupuncture? Yes/no . </p>2) Can you give a convincing reason why those that advocate CAM treatments, resist calls for those treatments to be proven effective?</p>
 
Their decision appears not be be based on any new evidence that it actually works but merely on the basis that it's safe and that lots of doctors say they want to either do it or learn about it.

This seems to have annoyed the other 50% who want an evidence based approach. See here for some discussions on the BMJ website:
http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/eletters/321/7252/11/b#8760

I'm hoping there is something to acupuncture but I want to see some proper evidence. It is lacking at the moment.

BTW, off topic - how did buddha get fat if he managed to free himself from earthly desires such as the the urge to eat more food than is needed?
 
The UK government supports homeopathy far more than it supports acupuncture, Does that therefore mean that homeopathy is more effective than acupuncture?
As Rolfe pointed out, the provision of CAM on the NHS is down to political, rather than medical, reasons. What's more, CAM treatments in the UK are specifically excluded of the requirement to prove themselves effective before being offered on the NHS.
Every new "conventional" treatment must be evaluated by the UK's National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE). For some reasons proponents of "CAM" do not seem to want their treatments to be examined as robustly as other treatments, and have strongly resisted calls for CAM treatments to be evaluated by NICE prior to their use by the NHS, perhaps you could offer an explanation as to why?
So please, Yrreg, answer the questions.
1)Does the fact that the UK government supports homeopathy more than acupuncture make homeopathy more effective than acupuncture? Yes/no .
2) Can you give a convincing reason why those that advocate CAM treatments, resist calls for those treatments to be proven effective?

Just to be nit-picking, NICE does not have to approve all new conventional treatments. In fact it doesn't `approve' anything, it only makes recommendations on cost-effectiveness, and issues practice guidelines. These functions are after drugs (if we are talking about drugs) get their marketing authorisation from the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA). NICE is not a regulatory body, its role is advisory only, but of course the health authorities are pretty much expected to follow its advice. However note that the advice is not adhered to by the letter, hence the `postcode' lotteries. The other key point is that NICE is reactive. It can't select treatments for appraisal of cost-effectiveness, it has to be asked, and requests are channelled through the Department for Health. Despite agreeing to the recommendations of the House of Lords Select Committee Report 2000, the government has persistently stonewalled requests to have any CAMs appraised, for as you say totally political reasons. I happen to know that NICE is very keen to look at CAM, but can't take the initiative. Part of the reason is its very limited funding, which has to be tightly targeted to treatments where there are big cost issues. Another problem is that the NHS does not track the cost of CAM so nobody knows how much is spent - thus it's easy to side-step questions about cost-effectiveness.
 
Just to be nit-picking.
Thanks for correcting me, that's one of the things I love about this place, there is always someone with detailed knowledge who is willing to share it. :)
Anyway, dispute my total misunderstanding of the position of NICE within the chain of healthcare choices within the NHS, my central points still stand, CAM is given an easy ride by the government and those that favour acupuncture as a viable treatment on eth NHS are resistant to an robust examination of it's efficacy and cost effectiveness by those most able to make this judgment,
 
Isn't it "NICE" the way Yrreg persistently ignores the advice to look for actual evidence, and goes trawling for biassed reports that say what he wants to hear?

Any progress on finding those papers I mentioned, Yrreg?

(I think he's got me on ignore.)

Rolfe.
 
A question for Rolfe, this is a safety concern of acupuncture that has recently been brought to my attention (by a comedy show, admittedly).

I'm addressing it to Rolfe in her capacity as a voodoo vet practitioner.

As I understand it, the principle of voodoo it to insert needles into a likeness of the victim in order to stimulate a (painful) response. My assumption is that the better the resemblence to the victim, the more likely the respose (possibly an increased magnitude, I'm not sure of the details).

What then, is the implication of acupuncture for someone who has an identical twin? Has research addressed this, or have there just been a number of mysterous injuries, maybe even fatalities, as a result of overlapping made up systems?

I think we need to be told.
 
Isn't it "NICE" the way Yrreg persistently ignores the advice to look for actual evidence, and goes trawling for biassed reports that say what he wants to hear?

Any progress on finding those papers I mentioned, Yrreg?

(I think he's got me on ignore.)

Rolfe.
I'm not sure how you tell if yrreg has you on "ignore" or not, he seems to prefer soliloquies to dialogs.
 
A question for Rolfe, this is a safety concern of acupuncture that has recently been brought to my attention (by a comedy show, admittedly).

I'm addressing it to Rolfe in her capacity as a voodoo vet practitioner.

As I understand it, the principle of voodoo it to insert needles into a likeness of the victim in order to stimulate a (painful) response. My assumption is that the better the resemblence to the victim, the more likely the respose (possibly an increased magnitude, I'm not sure of the details).

What then, is the implication of acupuncture for someone who has an identical twin? Has research addressed this, or have there just been a number of mysterous injuries, maybe even fatalities, as a result of overlapping made up systems?

I think we need to be told.
When Mrs brodski heard this (on "the now show") she immediately started looking up local acupuncturists, she doesn’t get on too well with her identical twin sister. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom