Mass shooting in small town Texas

You left out a NOT there.

Who is denying that? The problem is that the proposed solutions are not focused on people, but on the evil guns.

Do you not get that yet?

Universal background checks and registration are focused on the people that have already made it clear to society that they should not be trusted with guns. The "pro gun" lobby responds by invoking slippery slope arguments to keep gun ownership a secret from the regulators. Along with fighting to keep the private seller exemption from background check wide open.
 
The licensing approach for possession and purchase will help - it won't eliminate the problem, but it will help.

In Canada you need to present your license to purchase ammunition (or components), not just purchase a firearm. This alone can reduce the amount of illegal use, as it is harder to get ammo.

Now this only works if you set up a national system - if you rely on a state-by-state system it's not going to work as the resulting patchwork will defeat the intent. If Michigan imposes the restrictions and Wisconsin doesn't then all it takes to get around it is to go for a drive on your day off...

In the same way people accept that a safer society means that drivers on vehicles on public roads need licenses, they should probably accept that for a safer society people with firearms in public need to have displayed a minimum level of knowledge and training to have their firearms (sell it as the "well regulated" part of the 2A).
 
Why is there such an interest in Private Sales of firearms? I asked someone earlier to name an incident involving a firearm that was acquired via private sale illegally. He couldn't answer. That question is open for anyone to answer as I know of NONE.


Private sales account for a huge percentage of the firearms possessed and used illegally. These are extremely common for gang members who have legal restrictions against purchasing or possessing firearms.

If you want more information, look up "straw purchase". This is a practice whereby an individual who is not legally permitted to own or possess a firearm pays an individual who is permitted to do so to purchase a firearm on their behalf. In the case of gang members, these straw purchasers are typically family members or girlfriends.

Straw purchases are very often done with the collusion of unethical dealers, who are aware of the purchaser's nature, but are able to go through the minimum regulatory requirements and thereby maintain plausible deniability. I can't find the article, but a few years back I read about an FBI sting operation targeting the problem of straw purchases; and found that the overwhelming majority of legally purchased firearms diverted into criminals' hands came from a tiny minority, a dozen or two, of FFL dealers.
 
The answer is zero regulation on the purchase and possession of arms or armament, ever.

That does indeed seem to be the goal of the NRA and appears to be the current situation when it comes down to private sales.

I come from a country with an entirely different attitude towards firearms and firearms legislation and am therefore very uncomfortable with your suggestion. The idea that people who are unable to make informed decisions are allowed to buy and use firearms is an uncomfortable one. The idea that an angry drunk can walk into a gun shop and buy whatever they want no questions asked seems to run counter to maintaining public safety. Then again I see few politicians willing to put their heads above the parapet to argue for increased gun restrictions so maybe I just have to accept that it's another one of those cultural differences.
 
Private sales account for a huge percentage of the firearms possessed and used illegally. These are extremely common for gang members who have legal restrictions against purchasing or possessing firearms.

If you want more information, look up "straw purchase". This is a practice whereby an individual who is not legally permitted to own or possess a firearm pays an individual who is permitted to do so to purchase a firearm on their behalf. In the case of gang members, these straw purchasers are typically family members or girlfriends.

Straw purchases are very often done with the collusion of unethical dealers, who are aware of the purchaser's nature, but are able to go through the minimum regulatory requirements and thereby maintain plausible deniability. I can't find the article, but a few years back I read about an FBI sting operation targeting the problem of straw purchases; and found that the overwhelming majority of legally purchased firearms diverted into criminals' hands came from a tiny minority, a dozen or two, of FFL dealers.

I would not consider a straw purchase a "private sale", though.

Why go through an FFL when you can just buy a stolen gun on the street?

I think most criminals simply buy their handguns on the street illegally, and don't bother to try to get a relative to make it past the gun dealer and the NICS check.

In NC, all handgun transfers of any type have to involve some sort of permit. Either a concealed carry permit or a handgun purchase permit.
 
This is a tough one. I'm getting numb to the constant mass shootings. The answer to them seems to be 'Nothing can be done. Price of freedom'.

Things I'd like to see:
Registration of firearms. You are registered. Your car is registered. Register your damn guns. No, No one is going to come around and take them from you.

Registering them helps eliminate the straw purchase. You buy a gun, it's registered to you. If it ends up in the hands of someone else... there may well be questions. It may slow the spread of weapons towards those that shouldn't have them.

Licensing. You are licensed to drive? Some people may even require licenses to perform their profession. A license to show that you are familiar with the weapon, and how to use it.

Purchasing. Want a hunting rifle? Show your hunting license, have the background check done. Acquire rifle. Pistol? Show your carry permit, and the knowledge that you can operate it.

Want something.. more? That should require more intense training, and licensing. Want a damned tank? You can afford it? Go for it. Take a 2 month long course at your local army base, go through intense training, and you can have your tank.

Storage: When not in use, it should be strongly recommended to store your firearms in a strong lockable container. This is of course for the owners protection. people don't just leave their guns laying about when not in use, right?

Insurance: Strong recommendation for liability insurance. Again, for protection. Gun goes off and you injure someone? Insurance. Stolen, and used in a crime? Insurance.
 
I would not consider a straw purchase a "private sale", though.

Why go through an FFL when you can just buy a stolen gun on the street?

Because the stolen gun numbers are not enough to meet demand of course.
I think most criminals simply buy their handguns on the street illegally, and don't bother to try to get a relative to make it past the gun dealer and the NICS check.

The question is how did those guns move from the legal to the illegal market.

According to ATF studies stolen guns account for only 13% of the firearms there while, straw purchases account for 41%. So with that and the 27% from private sales you can get over half of the illegal guns out of the stream quickly.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3462834/
 
Violent video game is only one reason for some who do not realize they are fiction, but not the only one. Lack of proper parenting is another. There are other reasons, but I'll leave it to prolific pundits to delineate those.

so how would you regulate bad parenting?
 
so how would you regulate bad parenting?

You could start by fining the parents for misdemeanors committed by their offspring.

The fine could be fiscal or punitive, lets say attending X number hours of parenting class with the little **** in tow.
 
I would not consider a straw purchase a "private sale", though.


It amounts to the same thing. A private citizen who is legally allowed to purchase a firearm transferring that firearm to an individual who is not legally allowed to own one.

Why go through an FFL when you can just buy a stolen gun on the street?


Because it's often far easier and faster to buy via a straw purchase, especially for status firearms, than it is to steal or purchase a stolen firearm. And the risk is much lower. Especially when you're purchasing large volumes of firearms through a colluding dealer.

I think most criminals simply buy their handguns on the street illegally, and don't bother to try to get a relative to make it past the gun dealer and the NICS check.


As I noted, the FBI found that this was common practice for gangs. When tracking recovered firearms used in crimes, or which were found on the person of gang members, a huge number could be tracked back to straw purchases made through one of a very small number of licensed dealers.

In gang culture, firearms are just as much status symbols as they are tools of violence. Buying on the street is often limited to cheap, low-quality weapons that lack the status.

For low-level criminals and "lone gunman" types, the street is occasionally easier, but you're looking at a very high risk of being caught in a sting or reported by an informant (for both sellers and buyers), combined with low availability in most areas outside of major urban centers, and prices tend to be high. Importing from outside the US is another route, but mostly for hard-to-find, federally-restricted weapons that aren't typically available on the street or from licensed dealers. Costs and risks associated with that type of purchase are even higher.

For firearms that are not federally restricted, straw purchases are quick, easy, and often cheaper than street weapons; and can target specific weapons types that are popular for image or as status symbols. And, of course, the weapon will be newer and in better shape.

In NC, all handgun transfers of any type have to involve some sort of permit. Either a concealed carry permit or a handgun purchase permit.


That's true in very few states. In those cases, straw purchasers just go buy one at a dealer in the next state over.
 
Exactly what we need to do is get better at ignoring the whole issue.


I'm sure you will make a constructive, non-sarcastic argument one of these days, but I'm not waiting around for it any more. The Heat Death of the universe will surely arrive first.
 
Universal background checks and registration are focused on the people that have already made it clear to society that they should not be trusted with guns. The "pro gun" lobby responds by invoking slippery slope arguments to keep gun ownership a secret from the regulators. Along with fighting to keep the private seller exemption from background check wide open.

Where do you get this ******

Handgun carry permits were published in the Memphis Commercial Appeal 10 years ago that listed the name, address, and SSN of everyone in Shelby county, TN who had a carry permit.
 
Universal background checks and registration are focused on the people that have already made it clear to society that they should not be trusted with guns.
Actually those bkgd check laws target the law abiding almost exclusively. The law abiding person wanting to buy a gun submits personal information about themselves to the FFL to obtain the bkdg check and normally has to pay a fee so the dealer can facilitate the person's ability to exercise a civil right.

The criminal will avoid the FFL and the bkgd check to obtain a gun by other means. If the criminal is foolish enough to attempt to obtain a bkgd check after lying on form 4473, he or she is for the most part not going to be bothered by the police at all.

Along with fighting to keep the private seller exemption from background check wide open.
The US code has lots of exemptions for people like the military, police or government employees. There is no private seller exemption. While federal law requires an FFL to access NICS for a bkgd check, private sellers are prohibited. Too bad there isn't a way for me to access NICS.

Private sellers are allowed to use the BATFE to obtain a bkgd check and /or authorization to make/transfer/register certain firearms.
 
I guess actions speak louder than words. Despite all the opinion polls showing that the electorate support beefed-up gun laws (at least in the days following a tragedy like this), those gun laws are not beefed up - and in some cases are relaxed.

One way on look at this is that the American people are not sufficiently bothered about this to actually insist that their elected representatives take action. Perhaps gun control is pretty well down their list of priorities. The actual risk of being shot and injured or killed is still pretty low and if you have a lot of other things to worry about - finding and keeping a job, paying for healthcare, finding somewhere to live, paying off your debts - maybe a more remote concern like this takes a back seat.

Another way to look at it is that a minority of Americans (those who say that they don't want additional firearms control) are somehow holding the rest to ransom - sounds fanciful to me.

A third way to look at it is that even though a lot of people say that they support additional gun control, actually when it comes down to it they don't. It's something that sounds good said to an opinion pollster but in the voting booth maybe they're not so sure.

I'm sure that there are lots of other ways of looking at this but I tend to a mixture of 1 and 3 above.

So in your opinion the fact we are outgunned by the gun manufacturers who spend millions influencing legislators and public opinion means "American people are not sufficiently bothered about this to actually insist that their elected representatives take action?"

Right now we have an incompetent, dangerous POTUS, a GOP controlled Congress that wants to take away health care from millions, give tax breaks to millionaires and ignore for another decade rebuilding infrastructure and Russians that are using social media in a mass campaign to create discord. And that's in addition to the alt-right manipulating beliefs and the oil companies promoting global warming denial.

Yeah, the country's a mess. I'm just not as sure as you are that apathy is the underlying cause. Powerlessness, yes, apathy, not so much.
 
Last edited:
Actually those bkgd check laws target the law abiding almost exclusively. The law abiding person wanting to buy a gun submits personal information about themselves to the FFL to obtain the bkdg check and normally has to pay a fee so the dealer can facilitate the person's ability to exercise a civil right.

The criminal will avoid the FFL and the bkgd check to obtain a gun by other means. If the criminal is foolish enough to attempt to obtain a bkgd check after lying on form 4473, he or she is for the most part not going to be bothered by the police at all.

So why does this make such regulations fundamentally impossible to work well? The example of gun laws that work would seem to be NFA weapons, those almost never get into the hands of criminals at all. This is used as a defense of why we don't need to regulate them more but never seems to move to the idea that this is a proven effective means of regulating firearms.
 
I know, can you quote me saying that I though they were? I've been very clear about why I insist that mental illness plays a part in events such as these.



Yeah, and that will be a mental illness.


It's not helpful to describe a person's personality as a mental illness.

Illness implies an aberration from an equilibrium that causes the sufferer distress and to seek out treatment or help (or their relatives do). In addition, many mental illnesses are self-limiting. For example, depression.

Personality is something that is with you for life. It rarely causes distress. People with a psychopathic personality disorder almost never seek treatment. In any case, treatment is rarely effective. CBT can be applied to violent inmates, but who knows how effective this is, beyond the short term.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom