Mass shooting in small town Texas

So in your opinion the fact we are outgunned by the gun manufacturers who spend millions influencing legislators and public opinion means "American people are not sufficiently bothered about this to actually insist that their elected representatives take action?"

Right now we have an incompetent, dangerous POTUS, a GOP controlled Congress that wants to take away health care from millions, give tax breaks to millionaires and ignore for another decade rebuilding infrastructure and Russians that are using social media in a mass campaign to create discord. And that's in addition to the alt-right manipulating beliefs and the oil companies promoting global warming denial.

Yeah, the country's a mess. I'm just not as sure as you are that apathy is the underlying cause. Powerlessness, yes, apathy, not so much.

We are america the land of gun care and health control. Just think of how many of these people wounded in this attack will go bankrupt from their medical bills. As it should be, they should have planned to be shot at anytime, failure to do so is down right unamerican.
 
I'm sorry, I can't see any point in this exchange if you persistently refuse to acknowledge that to shoot 26 people is linked to some form of mental illness unless I diagnose exactly what his condition was.

This isn't a case of extraordinary evidence.

The problem with this logic is, where do you draw the line? Are all criminals 'mentally ill' ipso facto the old Communist State view?

Should we label shoplifters 'mentally ill'. Illegal parking...? Fare dodging? Kleptomania?

I hate to sound cynical, but oftentimes, people do horrible things for no particular reason other than plain nastiness. Or because they can.
 
So why does this make such regulations fundamentally impossible to work well?
I wasn't suggesting that the laws worked or not. I was pointing out that the bkgd check law is targeting only law abiding persons for the most part like most gun control laws do.

The example of gun laws that work would seem to be NFA weapons, those almost never get into the hands of criminals at all.
I think the main reason NFA firearms are rarely used in crime is that they're relatively rare compared to other guns. The rationale behind the CLEO signature (eliminated by the Obama administration last year) and the $200 tax back in 1934 (>$3000 in 2015 dollars) was to stop sales to the little people.

This is used as a defense of why we don't need to regulate them more but never seems to move to the idea that this is a proven effective means of regulating firearms.
If we put all guns into the NFA registry, then only NFA guns and contraband guns would be associated with crime. There would still be guns everywhere, legal or not.
 
I'm sorry you feel that nothing can be done and I'm disappointed that you think that some omnipotent being controls events such as these.

Lets see what I said about "nothing to be done".

I've highlighted my very general advice to you Americans. I'm not in any position to help you any further. I feel that it's a good place to start looking at what can be done.

"You Americans"? Seems there are quite a few broad brush painters in this thread.
 
Like I said, it's perfectly clear where I'm coming from. I have no need to diagnose an individual who murdered 26 men woman and children in cold blood with a specific illness just to indulge you in the contortions you're going to pull for absolutely no good end other than to argue across each other.

I think he was mentally ill, let that be the end of it. You can scrabble for a more specific diagnosis if it gives you a deeper understanding. Like I said I'm quite happy to wallow in my ignorance.




The guy was mad, mental, crazy, out of his *********** tree. He remorselessly killed these people without pause or warning. He planned, in advance, to enter the church and kill as many as he could without warning and was only stopped by an armed civilian. He fired indiscriminately and without compunction into the congregation not caring who his victims were. He watched his bullets entering the bodies of men,women and children and will have seen the chunks of body parts dislodged as they exited, he moved from victim to victim with cold intent. I can't begin to tell you what the illness that caused him to act in such a way might be called.

First and foremost, his motive was domestic violence. We know this because he assaulted his wife and stepson so badly, he was court-martialled and discharged.

All the signs suggest that he went to that church to mow down his ex-in-laws, an extension of his belief his wife is his property and his right to dictate and control her life.

Are wife-beaters 'mentally ill', because if so, there are an awful lot of them in our society?

What makes domestic violence perpetrators predominantly male? Is domestic violence a 'male mental illness'?

Or is it something else all together?
 
I wasn't suggesting that the laws worked or not. I was pointing out that the bkgd check law is targeting only law abiding persons for the most part like most gun control laws do.

Which is why I would want it tied to registering firearms, so that the last legal owner is easy to determine. And knowing who is straw purchasing guns trivial.

If we put all guns into the NFA registry, then only NFA guns and contraband guns would be associated with crime. There would still be guns everywhere, legal or not.

Yep nothing can be done, laws fundamentally can't work, any examples from other nations don't matter because america is unique and frankly violent and we like it that way. Hell we have knocked columbine off the top 10 mass shootings, that is a serious accomplishment. Makes you proud to be an american.
 
Yep nothing can be done,...
Not what I was saying at all. Registering and bkgd checks are not the entire answer. The bkgd check was run on the prep in the church shooting; no good since his previous bad deeds were not reported. Had he known the police would be knocking on his door if he even tried to buy a gun from an FFL, chances are he would not have bothered going to the dealer at all.

All the laws in the world don't mean a damn unless the authorities are willing to enforce them. Even the feds are willing to look the other way during straw purchases at times.
 
Not what I was saying at all. Registering and bkgd checks are not the entire answer. The bkgd check was run on the prep in the church shooting; no good since his previous bad deeds were not reported. Had he known the police would be knocking on his door if he even tried to buy a gun from an FFL, chances are he would not have bothered going to the dealer at all.

All the laws in the world don't mean a damn unless the authorities are willing to enforce them. Even the feds are willing to look the other way during straw purchases at times.

And this just sounds like more reasons that there is simply nothing that can be done. Which is true as it stand now nothing can be done about these shootings.
 
How to Reduce Shootings

Gun enthusiasts often protest: Cars kill about as many people as guns, and we don’t ban them! No, but automobiles are actually a model for the public health approach I’m suggesting.

We don’t ban cars, but we work hard to regulate them – and limit access to them – so as to reduce the death toll they cause. This has been spectacularly successful, reducing the death rate per 100 million miles driven by 95 percent since 1921.


If you’re wondering how we managed to crank out all these charts and data in the immediate aftermath of the Texas shooting, here’s the secret: We didn’t. We spent weeks gathering the information and preparing the charts, because we knew that there would be a tragedy like this one to make it all relevant.

That’s the blunt, damning truth: Sunday’s horror was 100 percent predictable. After each such incident, we mourn the deaths and sympathize with the victims, but we do nothing fundamental to reduce our vulnerability.
 
Which is why I would want it tied to registering firearms, so that the last legal owner is easy to determine. And knowing who is straw purchasing guns trivial.



Yep nothing can be done, laws fundamentally can't work, any examples from other nations don't matter because america is unique and frankly violent and we like it that way. Hell we have knocked columbine off the top 10 mass shootings, that is a serious accomplishment. Makes you proud to be an american.

Have you ever made an argument that wasn't a blatant straw man?
 
And this just sounds like more reasons that there is simply nothing that can be done. Which is true as it stand now nothing can be done about these shootings.
It needs to be done better. I'm all for bkgd checks; for transfers, paid for by the state. But not every time a person holds a gun that doesn't belong to them like it is in WA right now. Reduce the tax on transfers, taxing a civil right is bogus. Require the police to enforce the laws we have; bragging about stopping a felon from attempting to buy a gun at an FFL is stupid if we just let him continue to search for a gun elsewhere.
 
Last edited:
Why would a handgun require a carry permit and not a long gun?

*shrug* I'm just tossing ideas. I was thinking more conceal carry. I also cannot think of much in the way of a reason why someone would want to walk around in public with a long gun.
 
It needs to be done better. I'm all for bkgd checks; for transfers, paid for by the state. But not every time a person holds a gun that doesn't belong to them like it is in WA right now. Reduce the tax on transfers, taxing a civil right is bogus. Require the police to enforce the laws we have; bragging about stopping a felon from attempting to buy a gun at an FFL is stupid if we just let him continue to search for a gun elsewhere.

How do you suggest any of that be done, prosecutors discretion and all that, which you seem to like when say it gets cops trying to violate peoples rights not charged with the crimes they committed, and just fired for unlawfully detaining a nurse.

Everytime someone holds it, but what about letting it out of your possession? Where is the limit between I lent him the gun so I didn't need a background check and ignore the extra money in my walled?

Registering firearms and holding the owner some degree of legally accountable for what happens with the gun seems a good way.
 
Looks like Kelley escaped from a secure mental health unit, according to this report from The Washington Post:

NEW BRAUNFELS, Tex. — The gunman who opened fire in a church outside San Antonio, killing at least 26 people, escaped from a mental health facility in 2012 after he was caught sneaking guns onto an Air Force base and “attempting to carry out death threats” made against military superiors, according to a police report.

The report said officers with the El Paso, Tex., police were dispatched to a bus terminal after Devin P. Kelley‘s escape from a behavioral facility about seven miles away in New Mexico. Officers wrote they were told Kelley, who intended to take a bus out of the state, “was a danger to himself and others” at the time and noted that he “was also facing military criminal charges.”

This incident occurred the same year that Kelley was court-martialed.
 
How do you suggest any of that be done, prosecutors discretion and all that, which you seem to like when say it gets cops trying to violate peoples rights not charged with the crimes they committed, and just fired for unlawfully detaining a nurse.
Lying on form 4473 is pretty much a written confession. No nurse required.

Everytime someone holds it, but what about letting it out of your possession? Where is the limit between I lent him the gun so I didn't need a background check and ignore the extra money in my walled?
As long as I control the gun (watch the person I'm letting shoot it) I should be okay. But WA law seems to be written to protect gun rental counters, not guys like me at the local range or in the woods.

Registering firearms and holding the owner some degree of legally accountable for what happens with the gun seems a good way.
Something I agree with.
 
It amounts to the same thing. A private citizen who is legally allowed to purchase a firearm transferring that firearm to an individual who is not legally allowed to own one.




Because it's often far easier and faster to buy via a straw purchase, especially for status firearms, than it is to steal or purchase a stolen firearm. And the risk is much lower. Especially when you're purchasing large volumes of firearms through a colluding dealer.




As I noted, the FBI found that this was common practice for gangs. When tracking recovered firearms used in crimes, or which were found on the person of gang members, a huge number could be tracked back to straw purchases made through one of a very small number of licensed dealers.

In gang culture, firearms are just as much status symbols as they are tools of violence. Buying on the street is often limited to cheap, low-quality weapons that lack the status.

For low-level criminals and "lone gunman" types, the street is occasionally easier, but you're looking at a very high risk of being caught in a sting or reported by an informant (for both sellers and buyers), combined with low availability in most areas outside of major urban centers, and prices tend to be high. Importing from outside the US is another route, but mostly for hard-to-find, federally-restricted weapons that aren't typically available on the street or from licensed dealers. Costs and risks associated with that type of purchase are even higher.

For firearms that are not federally restricted, straw purchases are quick, easy, and often cheaper than street weapons; and can target specific weapons types that are popular for image or as status symbols. And, of course, the weapon will be newer and in better shape.




That's true in very few states. In those cases, straw purchasers just go buy one at a dealer in the next state over.

You can't just go buy a handgun in the next state over unless you know a resident of that state to make your straw purchase for you. And now you are trafficking across state lines.

Rifles are virtually unused in crime when compared to handguns.

If I pass a background check in NC, I still can't buy a handgun in Virginia. The background check should be valid in all 50 states.

Why does it seem like these hypothetical gang members can buy a handgun far easier than I can, when my greatest crime on record is a single speeding ticket? Why do I think that it will get more difficult for me, but stay the same for the gang members?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom