Mass shooting in small town Texas

What ever satisfies your obsession. Very probable I am of Scottish heritage like you and we have over come worse problems than this. Rest assured this will be over come. It's shame that most of our politicians think like you do that getting rid of guns will solve all problems. Maybe they'll get a clue some day apparently like you have...

Where did I say getting rid of the guns will solve the problem? The answer is no where. There are plenty of countries with tons of guns and no problems like the USA.

My solution has been a universal adoption of a system like the Texas CCW permit system. The only people allowed a gun have to have a permit. Anyone in possession of a gun without a permit is committing a crime. Sales of any type can only be between permit holders. You can have any gun and any amount of guns you want. Each state administers its own permits and keeps records of who is a permit holder.

But, even that simple solution which is hardly restrictive and it is is compliant with the second as it accepts well regulated with no restriction on guns, is beyond the USA. I say that because even the deaths of children by children has not been enough to galvanise a general agreement on action to keep guns away from unsuitable people.

Hence, the realistic solution is a coping strategy where you learn to live with your disability.
 
You can't just go buy a handgun in the next state over unless you know a resident of that state to make your straw purchase for you. And now you are trafficking across state lines.

Rifles are virtually unused in crime when compared to handguns.

If I pass a background check in NC, I still can't buy a handgun in Virginia. The background check should be valid in all 50 states.

Nationalizing firearms laws is not exactly something the gun industry wants.
 
So he's got mental health issues on his record as well?

The stated reasons seem odd, he was bringing guns onto base to shoot his superiors. Not at all clear why that was treated as a psychiatric instead of criminal issue.
 
Looks like Kelley escaped from a secure mental health unit, according to this report from The Washington Post:

Wait, he got caught escaping, smuggling some weapons in and "attempting to carry out death threats" and what, the military just treated that like no big deal? The news says he did time for the assault crimes, but was that other stuff ignored or something? I've never served but I'd have guessed that those were pretty serious offenses. If he only got a BCD I shudder to think what he'd have had to do to get a dishonorable discharge.
 
Wait, he got caught escaping, smuggling some weapons in and "attempting to carry out death threats" and what, the military just treated that like no big deal? The news says he did time for the assault crimes, but was that other stuff ignored or something? I've never served but I'd have guessed that those were pretty serious offenses. If he only got a BCD I shudder to think what he'd have had to do to get a dishonorable discharge.

He fractured his child's skull...he should have still been in confinement...
 
Not what I was saying at all. Registering and bkgd checks are not the entire answer. The bkgd check was run on the prep in the church shooting; no good since his previous bad deeds were not reported. Had he known the police would be knocking on his door if he even tried to buy a gun from an FFL, chances are he would not have bothered going to the dealer at all.

All the laws in the world don't mean a damn unless the authorities are willing to enforce them. Even the feds are willing to look the other way during straw purchases at times.
I know you don't intend this, but this suggests that all transfers of guns should include background checks. Obviously, it wouldn't have stopped this shooter, but it might stop others.

Note that I'm not advocating that all gun transfers require background checks. I'm just pointing out an apparent consequence of your argument. This guy, had the system worked, would likely have bought guns some other way, right?
 
It needs to be done better. I'm all for bkgd checks; for transfers, paid for by the state. But not every time a person holds a gun that doesn't belong to them like it is in WA right now. Reduce the tax on transfers, taxing a civil right is bogus. Require the police to enforce the laws we have; bragging about stopping a felon from attempting to buy a gun at an FFL is stupid if we just let him continue to search for a gun elsewhere.
Oh, I apologize. You do seem to be in favor of background checks for private transfers. I was mistaken about your position.
 
Looks like another situation of an individual who gave off all the signs and nothing was done.
 
NPR was reporting several hours ago that the feds were looking into why the Air Force messed up notifying the org. that keeps the assault(etc.) records that mean no gun if you have that record.
 
The problem with this logic is, where do you draw the line? Are all criminals 'mentally ill' ipso facto the old Communist State view?

Should we label shoplifters 'mentally ill'. Illegal parking...? Fare dodging? Kleptomania?

I hate to sound cynical, but oftentimes, people do horrible things for no particular reason other than plain nastiness. Or because they can.

If you are asking my opinion, which holds no weight, I've been very clear about where the line is in this thread.
 
"You Americans"? Seems there are quite a few broad brush painters in this thread.

It's certainly a broad brush, but when we're talking about mass shootings which are endemic in America and this one in particular, then it's staying well within the lines.

Feel free to self identify if you think that it will help.
 
Originally Posted by Kestrel
Universal background checks and registration are focused on the people that have already made it clear to society that they should not be trusted with guns.

Actually those bkgd check laws target the law abiding almost exclusively. The law abiding person wanting to buy a gun submits personal information about themselves to the FFL to obtain the bkdg check and normally has to pay a fee so the dealer can facilitate the person's ability to exercise a civil right.

The criminal will avoid the FFL and the bkgd check to obtain a gun by other means. If the criminal is foolish enough to attempt to obtain a bkgd check after lying on form 4473, he or she is for the most part not going to be bothered by the police at all.


The US code has lots of exemptions for people like the military, police or government employees. There is no private seller exemption. While federal law requires an FFL to access NICS for a bkgd check, private sellers are prohibited. Too bad there isn't a way for me to access NICS.

Private sellers are allowed to use the BATFE to obtain a bkgd check and /or authorization to make/transfer/register certain firearms.


Yep those are the people who "should not be trusted with guns" Which is why gun limitation laws are targeted 90% toward their guns.
 
Wow! I just discovered that this idgit was a Security Policeman in the AF. I sure hope they took away his weapon when all of his issues surfaced. How in he hell he avoided a dishonorable discharge is beyond my comprehension.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom